The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Brooklyn, NY

The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Brooklyn, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


34 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in Brooklyn, NY

Up to $158
Quick responder
Big Day, Small Budget Cakes 

5.0

Brooklyn, NY
  • Starts at $140

With Big Day, Small Budget Cakes every couple can have a cake that brings cheer and warmth to their big day without sacrificing beauty, flavor, or your entire savings. Based in Brooklyn, New York, you’ll be working directly with me, Allie, on creating the best cake for your budget. Whether it’s a simple cake for 25 guests or a large four-tier cake with embellishments, I have affordable options for you. You’re in good hands! I’ve baked and decorated cakes for over 10 years, and I’m still hooked! I began my journey training at ICE in New York City and worked at celebrated bakeries, including The Chocolate Room, Balthazar, and Billy’s Bakery.

I recently requested a cake from Allie to celebrate my 40th birthday, and she seriously delivered a masterpiece. I gave her some creative freedom and she came up with the perfect cake: a combo of cardamom, dulce de leche, and Phantom of the Opera. I have never eaten anything so delicious. Words cannot express my appreciation for this beautiful cake . Thank you!!
Kristen H., 4 months ago
GemHidden gem
Four & Twenty Blackbirds 

5.0

Brooklyn, NY
  • Starts at $42 per serving

Four & Twenty Blackbirds is a pie bakery founded in Brooklyn in 2009 by sisters and pie makers Melissa Elsen and Emily Elsen. We make beautiful handmade pies, using seasonal and fresh ingredients sourced from local orchards.

We ordered pies for our wedding, and it was perfect. It was a last minute order and they accommodated our crazy request. The team got back to me so quickly, and, everything arrived on schedule. Of course, the pies were delicious!
Sarah L., 5 years ago
Baked 

5.0

Brooklyn, NY

    Baked is many things. We are a classic American bakery and cafe with locations in Brooklyn and Tokyo. We are also a full-fledged lab of sorts, creating better baking mixes and delicious granola. Finally, we are absolute dessert enthusiasts (and cookbook authors) – perhaps even obsessives. We eat a lot of cake and cookies. Everyone should get a little Baked on their wedding day. Baked Weddings is a natural extension of our bakery and philosophy — fun, delicious, modern, and beautiful. Our Wedding design team is immensely talented, and this gallery represents a sampling of some of their latest work.

    My husband's aunt was supposed to bake the cake for our wedding, until ~6 weeks before when she made the decision that coming was too risky (COVID). So with a short runway we had to find a solution, and of course, we hadn't budgeted for this! So I reached out to at least a dozen bakeries and am so happy I found Baked. They got us in for a tasting really quickly and were so nice. They not only didn't pressure us to upsell, but helped us talk through what it would look like and the cost savings to get 3 separate cakes and put them on pedestals instead of a stacked cake. I honestly couldn't believe it, I was so sure that since we had so little time we were going to be targets, and instead Baked swooped in, saved the day, and made the whole experience just lovely. And of course, the cake was delicious!
    Amanda P., 4 years ago
    TrendlineTrending
    Lucy's Confections 

    5.0

    Brooklyn, NY
    • Starts at $48

    We create custom shortbread cookies and fluffy marshmallows printed with your photo, monogram, or design. A fun and memorable favor for weddings, rehearsal dinners, or anniversaries. Because love should be celebrated in every detail (and every bite). The sweetest way to share something special.

    Lucy's Confections was an absolute pleasure to work with for our anniversary marshmallows. From the very beginning, they were incredibly responsive, replying to all of our inquiries within 2 hours. This made the planning process so smooth and stress-free. When it came to the quality of their work, we were blown away - the printed marshmallows they created for us were truly amazing, with vibrant colors and sharp details. Despite a last-minute time crunch, they delivered our order right on time. The printing quality was fantastic, and our guests raved about how unique and delicious the marshmallows were. We're so grateful to Lucy's Confections for helping make our special day even sweeter!
    Mike, 2 months ago
    The Chocolate Room 

    5.0

    Brooklyn, NY
    • Starts at $50

    Jon Payson and Naomi Josepher moved to NYC in the early Nineties. Together, they enjoyed seeking out phenomenal desserts all around the city. When they moved to Park Slope, Brooklyn in 2003, they noticed a need for a dessert café on quickly changing Fifth Avenue. After reading an inspirational book on chocolate, they decided to create a café specializing in high-end chocolate, extraordinary desserts, handmade ice creams, dessert wines and beers from all over the world, as well as superb coffee. They opened in January 2005 and is currently serving the Cobble Hill neighborhood of Brooklyn.

    It was a no brainer to get the layer cake for our wedding. As brooklyn natives and chocolate lovers we frequent the chocolate room. Needless to say, the cake was to die for and really the talk of the show. We’ve gone back multiple times since the wedding for a slice!
    Michelle M., 2 years ago
    Sugar Couture 

    5.0

    Brooklyn, NY

      Dreamers. Artists. Detail Obsessives. Chefs. Storytellers…. Sugar Couture has been delighting clients with their custom cakes and confections for more than a decade. We are collaborators and look for every opportunity to tell our client’s unique stories through our singular eye. We strive to make our wedding cakes and celebration cakes memorable long past the last sweet bite. Our extensive portfolio is made up of some of Sugar Couture’s previous work to help inspire you, but everything that comes from this creative company is completely custom, made just for you. No detail is missed and flavor is always top priority.

      SugarCouture creates truly inspired works of sugar art. Fun, cute and beautiful! Can’t recommend them enough.
      Pola Rosehip, 5 years ago
      Nepita 

      5.0

      • Serves Brooklyn, NY

      Hello everyone, my name is Terence and I am the owner of Nepita! I have always been passionate about sharing a culinary moment with strangers. Being trained and having worked in Michelin starred restaurants, I learned how to make all sorts of frozen confections. That shaped me in creating Nepita, an artisan ice cream pop up shop offering flavors inspired by the Mediterranean!

      Nepita is incredible. Not only is the taste amazing but talking to the owner, you realize how much commitment he has to the craft. He told me about how part of his flavors for the ice cream came from a hike he did in Corsica where he started picking some natural flowers in the mountain and saw how he could use them in ice cream. Talk about true authenticity. Definitely buying from Nepita again.
      Sebastien D., 9 months ago
      Ebakes Cakes 

      5.0

      • Starts at $8
      • Serves Brooklyn, NY

      Hello, my name is Erica and I'm the owner of Ebakes Cakes. I make custom cakes, cupcakes, and treats for all occasions. I've been baking for 4 years, and I absolutely love it. My passion for baking began making my kids birthday cake. I fell in love! Every cake is created with love. Whether your event is big or small we provide a luxury experience. Thank you for trusting me. I look forward to bringing your vision to life and creating magic.

      Hiring Erica and Ebakes Cakes for our wedding was one of the best decisions we made. From the moment we first spoke, her communication was extremely fast and she felt like family - so warm and friendly. I was so confident in her abilities, which was a huge relief during wedding planning. Erica worked closely with us on our budget and vision, and the end result was a cake that looked even better than the inspiration photo I had shared. The chocolate cake itself was the best I've ever had, and the flowers on top were absolutely stunning. Erica's expertise and reliability made the cake process so easy and stress-free. I feel truly blessed. Hire Erica ! She will work with your budget!!!
      Cassidy L., 3 months ago
      Quick responder
      Charmaine’s Cake Boutique 

      5.0

      • Starts at $70
      • Serves Brooklyn, NY
      • Offer

      Hi, name is Charmaine and I’ve been a passionate baker since 2016. What started as a hobby and a side job throughout college, later turned into my career. I’m a self-taught baker who has always enjoyed art and baking. So, what better way to make desserts look just as good as they taste? In 2023, I opened my storefront in Staten Island, NY and it’s been great! I strive to make all of my customers and couples happy and I look forward to hearing how much everyone enjoyed the cake. And remember, a cake is not just dessert, but it’s also the centerpiece at your wedding that you’ll never forget!

      Charmaine makes the BEST cakes, hands down! No event is too big or too small for her. I’ve been ordering from her for the past two years for everything. Her cakes are not only delicious but always beautifully made. And don’t even get me started on her treats, they’re absolutely to die for! Make sure you catch her specials when she posts them because they sell out fast. On top of all that, her customer service is unmatched. Always friendly, responsive, and reliable. Highly recommend!
      Ajene J., 4 months ago
      Quick responder
      Sweet Kee's Candies & Gifts 

      5.0

      • Starts at $150
      • Serves Brooklyn, NY

      Sweet Kee's is a one-of-a-kind Hudson Valley, New York wedding favors & gifts business, servicing couples throughout New York State. We offer handcrafted, artisanal treats, including a variety of classic & specialty hard candies & lollipops that are perfect as candy or dessert table options, as gifts and favors. We also offer premium beverage infusion kits that allow your guests to create their own craft drink experience. Just add wine, liquor, or non-alcoholic beverages. Our other specialty food novelties include hot cocoa jars, small-batch fruit jams, and edible peppermint shot glasses. Shipping is available throughout New York State.

      Not only are the products delicious, they come artfully packaged which makes them highly giftable. Can’t wait for my next order!
      Beth, 10 months ago
      Quick responder
      Don Cannoli, LLC 

      5.0

      • Starts at $12
      • Serves Brooklyn, NY

      Premium cannoli, hand-piped by The Don himself! We make cannoli you can't refuse, featuring handmade shells imported from Sicily and fresh cannoli cream prepared for the day of your event. Our lavish cannoli concierge service is perfect for weddings, backyard birthdays, holiday parties, corporate events, and more!

      We had Don Cannoli at my sister’s gender reveal party, and let’s just say…all the attention was on “The Don”! He showed up with blue and pink sprinkles and made delicious cannolis for everyone. The vibe was on point! Highly recommend!
      Daniela, 3 months ago
      Quick responder
      Empire Cake 

      5.0

      • Serves Brooklyn, NY

      Our custom-designed cakes range from traditional tiered wedding cakes to one-of-a-kind creations. Everything served at Empire Cake is made fresh daily on the premises using the finest ingredients, including fresh butter and cream from quality local producers, pure whole vanilla beans, Belgian chocolate, and fresh seasonal produce from the Union Square Greenmarket. Our cake consultants can help you build your dream cake for any of life’s celebrations, large or small.

      Awarded Best of Zola
      Empire Cake was a delicious addition to our wedding day! We went with Raspberry Lemon- it was so yummy, and we kept the design beautifully simplistic so it would be the perfect backdrop to add fresh flowers from our florist. The Empire team so helpful and communicative throughout the planning process. Shout out to Bonnie, who was our main point of contact. Highly recommend Empire for any of your cake needs!
      Sydney D., a year ago
      GemHidden gem
      Heritage Bread Pudding 

      5.0

      • Starts at $120
      • Serves Brooklyn, NY

      Heritage Bread Pudding is a Latina-owned company born in the World’s Borough - offering a spin on a beloved Puerto Rican classic made from whole ingredients, locally sourced bread, and stories passed down through generations.

      This bread pudding is amazing! Every bite left me wanting more! The creator is a doll. She went above and beyond in her customer service. An overall positive experience. Will definitely be coming back for more.
      Carmen B., a month ago
      Quick responder
      Tasty Glam Treats 

      5.0

      • Starts at $40
      • Serves Brooklyn, NY

      Welcome to Tasty Glam Treats! As treat maker, I am truly passionate about adding a touch of sweetness and elegance to life's most special moments. Creating these treats is more than just a business for me—it's a therapeutic and joyful experience. I absolutely love the process of bringing creative ideas to life, from selecting the perfect colors and ribbons to ensuring every treat is as beautiful as it is delicious. It's truly a labor of love, and nothing brings me more joy than seeing the smiles on my clients' faces. Although I haven't had my business for as long as others I am dedicated to providing top-notch service for my customers.

      I place my ordered and customer service was great! I love the way you can place your order and you get your treats in a timely manner. The treats are so good! I will definitely be ordering from Tastyglamtreats in the very near future. Thanks again!!!
      Wanda C., 3 months ago
      Quick responder
      Chai Chief 

      5.0

      • Starts at $100
      • Serves Brooklyn, NY
      • Offer

      We create moments never forgotten. The spirit of being together must be celebrated, the joy and authenticity of creating experiences for the most magical people in your life is what drives our mission.

      Chai Chief was a fantastic vendor to work with for our wedding. Their communication was very responsive and direct, which made the planning process smooth and stress-free. The quality of their work was amazing - the dessert setup was absolutely beautiful and our guests raved about the delicious tea and desserts. The team was timely with the setup, and everything looked perfect. I would highly recommend Chai Chief and would use them again for any future events.
      Tyiebah, a year ago
      GemHidden gem
      The Evercake 

      5.0

      • Starts at $9
      • Serves Brooklyn, NY

      The Evercake concept started as I was ordering flowers online while skimming Pinterest for my toddler's birthday cake. I wanted a beautiful cake that I could add to a cart and have delivered. Why didn't this exist? A few months later, The Evercake was born. We are different in that we are strictly buttercream based (no overworked fondant here). Our recipes are tried and true, slightly less sweet, and with designs aimed to be worthy of your celebrations. We don't have a traditional storefront with overhead to worry about it, which means we don't have to mark up our cakes to account for this.

      We were thrilled with the wedding cake and desserts from The Evercake. From the very beginning, they were quick to reply to our messages and easy to communicate with, which made the process of selecting and customizing our cake a breeze. On the day of the wedding, the cake was absolutely beautiful and looked perfect in our photos. But most importantly, it tasted amazing! Our guests raved about how delicious the cake and desserts were. The Evercake team truly helped make our special day even more perfect.
      Emily M., 7 months ago
      Everything Just Baked 

      5.0

      • Starts at $8
      • Serves Brooklyn, NY

      I started Everything Just Baked because I no longer wanted to choose between a beautiful cake or a delicious cake! With Everything Just Baked we take pride in having both a masterpiece on the outside and inside. We specialize in custom cakes and would love to create a piece of art you will remember for the rest of your life!

      Justin was an absolute pleasure to work with! From the first email, to the tasting, to the designing, to the final product! Our wedding cake was absolutely perfect and it was incredible to see the vision in my head come to life. From the colors, to the flowers, to the flavors, it was everything we dreamed of! We chose cannoli cream, strawberries and cream, and chocolate chip deluxe. Our guests kept raving about how delicious it was! We cannot wait to have an excuse to order a cake from Justin again!
      Sara C., a year ago
      Quick responder
      Sweet Cup Bows 
      • Starts at $30
      • Serves Brooklyn, NY

      At Sweet Cup Bows, we craft one-of-a-kind tea and dessert experiences designed to bring joy, beauty, and a touch of whimsy to your special day. What started as a love for elegant desserts and floral-themed milk teas has blossomed into a curated cafe-to-go concept that couples and guests truly remember. We’re passionate about creating aesthetic, flavorful moments—because we believe dessert and tea should feel as special as the celebration itself. Each cup is handmade with care, styled with hand tied bows, delicate details, and designed to be as delightful as it is delicious.

      Splurge Bakery 

      5.0

      • Serves Brooklyn, NY for additional fees

      Our clients love the fact that we offer both delicious and beautiful cakes specific to their dreams. We can create a special cake and beautiful customs desserts for favors or dessert table. We can ship cookies, some of our desserts, and favors too!

      Splurge wow'd our entire wedding with a truly outstanding cake. Our caterer said she's NEVER seen every crumb of a cake eaten before, with people coming back for more! It may have been the most delicious thing I ate on my wedding day and we are so grateful. Our wedding cake had three layers, two gluten and one gluten-free. Two were the same amazing banana cake with fresh banana slices with cream cheese frosting, and another layer had chocolate fudge.
      Brandon I., 23 days ago
      GemHidden gem
      Royal Bakeria by Arisha 

      4.6

      • Starts at $40
      • Serves Brooklyn, NY

      Hello! I’m a professionally trained pastry chef who runs a cake and confections company in Brooklyn NY called Royal Bakeria. I have over 8 years of experience in the Baking and pastry/ culinary industry and a degree holder in Baking and Pastry Arts. I love that I get to bring joy and be apart of all my clients special events through my skills and talent. I am looking forward to working with you to make that a reality for your event also! - Chef Arisha

      I worked with Chef Arisha on an wedding reception that I brought her along to do the wedding cake and dessert menu. I received great feedback on the items she prepared. She was super alert, and is a great communicator. It was a great time working along with her and I plan on using her services more in the future.
      Rhonda’s Spicy Kitchen, 2 years ago
      Mini Melanie 

      5.0

      Brooklyn, NY

        Mini Melanie was founded in 2015 by sisters Melanie and Diana Moss. Melanie grew up baking with their grandmother, and her hobby steadily grew into an obsession. While attending Northwestern University, Melanie studied in Paris and was Sous Chef at Cours de Cuisine atelier. She later attended the Institute of Culinary Education and honed her craft in the Michelin-starred kitchens of Babbo and Blue Hill at Stone Barns, where she was Pastry Sous Chef. Melanie’s desserts have been recognized in the 2016 New York City Michelin guide, and in 2018, Melanie became Champion of a special-themed chocolate competition on Food Network’s CHOPPED.

        Not only are the treats from Mini Melanie incredibly delicious, but the team goes above & beyond to make sure every detail is taken care of. From clear/on-time communication to customization, our favors turned out amazing! We've continued to use the team for so many other occasions and would recommend them to everyone. Enjoy - you will not be disappointed!
        Sara and Z., 5 years ago
        The Black Cake Company 

        5.0

        Brooklyn, NY
        • Starts at $35

        The Black Cake Company was founded in 1987 by Angela Price. A native of Barbados, Angela wanted to share the rich cultural heritage surrounding traditional black cake from the Caribbean region across North America. 35 years later, The Black Cake Company is still a mail-order company that ships the best Black Cakes and Rum Cakes worldwide.

        My husband and I had mini black cakes as our wedding favors and we and all the guests loved it! I personally don't like favors that get tucked into a corner and forgotten so this was a great treat for guests to take with them (although I later saw that my aunt ate the cake and kept the box it came in in her display case). The packaging was beautiful and fit well with the wedding decor, as guests took a box (or two) as they left at different times. Also, communication with The Black Cake Company was great. Probably the least stressful of the entire wedding planning process. I highly highly recommend.
        Jessica, 4 years ago
        GemHidden gem
        Pasticceria Bruno 

        5.0

        • Starts at $8
        • Serves Brooklyn, NY

        Bruno's Bakery is a family owned business since 1981. Chef Biagio & Chef Joseph Settepani take pride in making every dessert, cake, sweet or baked good an unforgettable treat. The team at Bruno's love meeting with new & ongoing clients in making every milestone a sweet one to remember. We congratulate you in this special journey in your life!

        This bakery was great for us.. Fina took the time to work with us, offer us a cake tasting, and made sure everything was prepared to perfection. Very happy we chose this bakery for our big day.
        Mellissa & M., 4 years ago
        Sweet Jules Treats 

        5.0

        • Starts at $90
        • Serves Brooklyn, NY

        Julia Lentini, owner of Sweet Jules Treats, creates custom works of desserts and cakes for all special occasions. Our highest priority is that your desserts taste just as wonderful as they look, using the highest quality ingredients. I decided to take my passion for baking to the next level by creating my own baking business. Turning my passion into a full time business has been such a blessing for me and I am loving every part of it. Overall, I cannot thank my customers enough for the support they give and the love they give through each and every text, call or message. Each and every event is treated like my own!

        Jules was so accommodating and was willing to work with us on our Golf themed engagement party. She made the cutest cupcakes and a beautiful small cake topper that everyone thoroughly enjoyed at the party. THANK YOU JULES!
        Kristina H., 3 years ago
        Pip & Bits 

        5.0

        • Serves Brooklyn, NY

        Pip n Bits is a custom bakery based in Astoria, NYC. Every cake we create is unique and created especially for you. Our cakes not only taste amazing, but we believe they are also a focal point for your special event. Only the finest ingredients go into everything we create. Pip n Bits specializes in beautiful cakes for weddings, birthdays, showers, and all special events. Drop us a line and let's get your order started!

        I don't think I can really explain how incredible Laura's cakes are!! I am a baker and have a huge sweet tooth, so the cake for our wedding was really important to me. We tried samples from 4 bakers in total, and NOTHING compared to Laura's cakes! If you want amazing, moist, flavorful cakes, and not just mouthfuls of sugar, you gotta go with Pip & Bits. They were all so good, we couldn't pick just one cake! So we had a two tier cake with two flavor combos (chocolate with ganache and peanut butter frosting and vanilla with raspberry jam and speculoos frosting), and two different flavors of cake pops (cardamom cake with espresso frosting and lemon cake with jam and lemon/salted honey frosting)! The cake pops disappeared so fast, they were such a fan favorite, I don't even have a picture of them yet! The cake itself looked beautiful, exactly what I wanted, and our guests are still talking about what flavor they got to try and how good it was. Laura was also so sweet to work with, and really open to making changes and customizations, so that we had exactly what we wanted! I only wish we could have had more! I see a first anniversary order from Laura in our future...
        Abbey S., 2 years ago

        Location flexible? Discover cakes & desserts near Brooklyn, NY

        About wedding cakes & desserts in Brooklyn, NY

        What other Brooklyn vendors will I need?

        What other wedding services are nearby?