Big Day, Small Budget Cakes

Price per serving

Starts at $5 per person.

About Big Day, Small Budget Cakes

Big Day, Small Budget Cakes

Cake Creator

With Big Day, Small Budget Cakes every couple can have a cake that brings cheer and warmth to their big day without sacrificing beauty, flavor, or your entire savings. Based in Brooklyn, New York, you’ll be working directly with me, Allie, on creating the best cake for your budget. Whether it’s a simple cake for 25 guests or a large four-tier cake with embellishments, I have affordable options for you. You’re in good hands! I’ve baked and decorated cakes for over 10 years, and I’m still hooked! I began my journey training at ICE in New York City and worked at celebrated bakeries, including The Chocolate Room, Balthazar, and Billy’s Bakery.

Weddings are expensive! In my small way, I’d like to help be part of the solution. Folks can turn to Big Day, Small Budget Cakes for beautiful, high-quality celebration cakes at reasonable prices. While I can keep costs down when others can't, what I don’t do is sacrifice quality. I make every cake with the same ingredients and care that I do for my family and friends.

Services

Dessert types

  • Cakes

Decor options

  • Fruit topping
  • Live flowers

Services offered

  • Consultations
  • Delivery
  • Tastings

Dietary accommodations

  • Vegan

Reviews

Write a review

5.0 out of 5

8 reviews

Write a review

  • Delicious and gorgeous wedding cake!

    •Verified review
    •Emily•Jun 20

    We knew Allie is an amazing baker and had a unique request for her to ship a wedding cake to Maine! She figured out all the details for shipping, and listened to what we were looking for in a cake. The cake arrived perfectly, was absolutely beautiful and just as we imagined, and was also DELICIOUS. Everyone raved about how great the cake looked and tasted! Hire Allie, she is amazing!!

  • The Cake Made the Day!

    •Verified review
    •Jeff•Jun 5, 2025

    Big Day, Small Budget Cakes was an absolute delight to work with for our baby shower. From the moment we first reached out, Allie was professional, engaged, caring, thoughtful, and highly responsive. The quality of their work was superb - the cakes they created were a step above, delicious, and worth every penny. Allie went above and beyond, carefully packaging the cakes so they arrived at our event ready to serve. Every single one of our guests could not stop gushing about the spectacular desserts she made with such care. She listened closely to our dietary restrictions and still managed to create a cake that was delicious for all without any compromise. I will definitely be ordering from Big Day, Small Budget Cakes again for our son's first birthday party - I know Allie will make a cake for him and our guests that will not be forgotten!

  • Incredible Cakes, Incredible Everything

    •Verified review
    •Briana V.•Apr 3, 2025

    I am incredibly grateful to Big Day, Small Budget Cakes for making our wedding so special. Words cannot fully express the care, thoughtfulness, and, of course, the deliciousness of the baked goods. Allie, the owner, took the time to personalize our wedding cake and desserts to reflect our personalities, interests, and desired style. Her seamless communication made the entire process, from coordination to delivery, effortless. We highly recommend Big Day, Small Budget Cakes for any wedding or special occasion.

  • Wonderful and talented baker

    •Verified review
    •Kristen H.•Mar 27, 2025

    While Allie hasn’t done a wedding cake for me, I have known her for a long time and enjoyed her baking on several occasions. She is an extremely talented and creative baker. She is also a wonderful human being who is incredibly easy to talk to. As a self-professed cake fanatic, I can safely say that she made the best peanut butter cake ever for my birthday. If you value cake as much as I do, please reach out to Allie!

Explore other vendors serving Brooklyn, NY

Complete your dream team

Other cakes & desserts in Brooklyn

Other wedding services nearby