Custodi Caterers

Catering services pricing

Food starts at $20 per person and bar services at $8 per person.

About Custodi Caterers

Christopher Lucas

Chef / Owner

Christopher grew up in Nutley and proudly called it his home until he went off to pursue his culinary aspirations at Johnson & Wales. While at Johnson & Wales, Chris returned home to Nutley to work at Custodi Caterers in order to support himself throughout his education. Fortunately, Chris found immediate employment cooking up a diverse array of food at Custodi. Chris was offered the opportunity to buy the business twenty-two years ago and continues to be the proud owner. Whether its for a school, business, cocktail party, wedding, you name it, Chris is hands on and treats every event as if its his own.

Quality is at the center of everything we do. From a phone call, selection of ingredients, to the delectable food we serve, we always promise quality. We are honored to be a part of a couple's wedding. We put our absolute everything in honoring your special day. Chris will schedule a tasting to give you a flavorful introduction to his menu. Most importantly, Chris will walk you through every step of the way throughout selection of dishes to the main event. We pride ourselves in a tradition that never goes out of style, quality.



  • Bartenders
  • Cleanup and breakdown
  • Consultations and tastings - complimentary
  • Delivery and setup
  • Rental coordination - directly invoice couple
  • Rental coordination - does not invoice couple
  • Serving staff


  • American
  • Italian

Dietary accommodations

  • Gluten-free
  • Vegetarian

Meal types

  • Buffet
  • Dessert service
  • Food stations
  • Passed appetizers
  • Seated meal
  • Stationary appetizers

Beverage services

  • Bartending
  • Beverage servingware rentals
  • Mixers/non-alcoholic options

Extra costs

  • Bartender services
  • Gratuity


Write a review

5.0 out of 5

1 review

Write a review
  • Wonderful Experience!

    Verified review
    AmandaNov 15, 2023

    Custodi Caterers did an amazing job for our wedding. They catered our whole wedding gluten free and went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect. The food was delicious, the staff were smiling and super attentive and they even helped with setting up our decorations. I would choose them again for any event we would need catered. They were wonderful!