The Best Outdoor Wedding Venues in Shoreview, MN

The Best Outdoor Wedding Venues in Shoreview, MN

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads?


110 Wedding Venues in Shoreview, MN

Outdoor
Clear
Quick responder
Hope Glen Farm 
  • Up to 280 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $1,500

In 1910, President Taft signed the bill to establish Glacier National Park as the country’s 10th national park. Mr. Healy was given a plumbing contractor for the train depot here in St. Paul, where he met Samuel Bartlett, the architect of many of the railroad depots and Glacier National Park Lodge. Healy then commissioned Bartlett to renovate and enlarge the house. In 1914, the farm was sold to John Healy, the owner of Healy Plumbing and Heating Company of St. Paul. Mr. Healy’s company became closely tied to the Great Northern Railroad, as it provided the heating and plumbing for many of the train depots that were being built around the country at that time. The farm was named Hope Glen Farm, the name of John Healy’s mother’s maiden name of Hope, and the house settles in a Glen, thus Hope Glen.

Delta Hotels by Marriott Minneapolis Northeast 

5.0

Minneapolis, MN
  • Up to 350 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor

Our chic, newly renovated hotel offers two ballrooms and seven event spaces, on-site catering with customizable menus, audio-visual professionals, and experienced wedding planners. Plan your rehearsal dinner, getting ready suites, ceremony, reception, and Sunday brunch all under one roof! While we handle the logistics of your event, you and your guests can enjoy the amenities that matter most to you; spacious guest rooms with ultra-comfortable beds, complimentary parking, a 24-hour fitness center, an indoor saltwater pool, and complimentary Wi-Fi everywhere in the hotel. Visit our onsite restaurant, Twin Cities 400 Tavern, for a true taste of Minnesota. We offer a full bar with selections from a range of Minnesota breweries and distilleries, a menu filled with locally sourced ingredients, a sunny solarium, seasonal patio, and private dining room. Receive one complimentary night for the couple and a $50 restaurant gift card when you book 30 rooms per night at our group rate.

It was wonderful working with Delta Hotel making their ball room even more stunning with floral. I look forward to doing more weddings with them and know that their team will take great care in communication, selecting details, and executing your special day for each one of their Brides and Grooms.
Myra Patterson, 2 years ago
Quick responder
Sociable Cider Werks 

5.0

Minneapolis, MN
  • Up to 70 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $1,000

Located in the heart of Northeast Minneapolis, Sociable Cider Werks is a vibrant production brewery and taproom offering a unique setting for private events. Known for our lively atmosphere, regular live music, and spacious outdoor patio, we have something for everyone to enjoy. Our two private event spaces each feature a dedicated bar and a team of staff to ensure your event runs smoothly. With a rotating selection of house-made ciders, beers, seltzers, and non-alcoholic options on tap, there’s always something to please your guests. You can choose to book catering from our onsite food truck, or you're welcome to bring in your own outside catering. Additionally, feel free to bring your own DJ or live music to enhance the atmosphere of your event.

We had our rehearsal dinner at Sociable Cider Werks and it was the best decision we could have made! Everything about the venue was perfect. The space was the exact size and look we were hoping for. The cider was delicious as was the food from So&So's. We had so many amazing comments fro our guests about the food and cider. On top of it all Sociable has the BEST operations manager who was on top of every detail. Olivia truly made our day special. She was so organized and friendly and accommodating, our rehearsal dinner truly would not have been possible without her!
Nora, 4 months ago
Quick responder
Quincy Hall 

5.0

Minneapolis, MN
  • Up to 600 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $4,000
  • Offer

Located in the fast growing NE Minneapolis Arts District, Quincy Hall is a historic event center that hosts weddings, non profit, corporate and other large social occasions. This expansive property can host a ceremonies onsite, cocktail hours (inside and outside options!) and a seated dinner for up to 600, Here you will discover a vibrant neighborhood filled with many local attractions such as craft breweries, fun restaurants, galleries, beautiful photo opportunities and more.

Quincy Hall was an incredible venue for our wedding! We had around 200 guests for our September wedding and it felt simultaneously spacious and cozy. The QH team was very responsive and helped with planning every step of the way. They were also super accommodating and helped fine ways for us to meet out budget while still getting the experience we were looking for. The venue and surrounding area had a number of spots for stunning, industrial vibe photos and we couldn't be happier with the look and feel for our day. Our food was also outstanding. We knew the food at Crave would be delicious, but we received so many compliments from guests about their meals. They have some of the most reasonable prices on the market and the catering staff were super professional and polished. Overall, we had a great experience and would highly recommend Quincy Hall!
Marissa B., 18 days ago
Quick responder
Heritage Center Of Brooklyn Center 
Brooklyn Center, MN
  • Up to 600 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Outdoor
  • Starts at $5,000

From the moment you set foot on our historic grounds, you’re sure to fall in love with the Heritage Center. Once a country estate, now a charming venue located near the outskirts of downtown Minneapolis, the Heritage Center maintains red barn exteriors, gorgeous courtyards and paired with modern interior event spaces. There are many indoor event spaces to choose from to create your perfect wedding. Our experienced sales team will help you navigate our rooms based on your guest count and what you're looking for as a couple. Each room is unique but all maintain the rustic charm you can come to know throughout our venue.

Quick responder
The Haralson Room at Minneapolis Cider Co. 

5.0

Minneapolis, MN
  • Up to 160 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $3,750

Named after the iconic apple from the University of Minnesota, the Haralson Room is a perfect place hosting groups ranging in size from 50 to 300+ guests. A beautiful combination of modern and industrial design guarantees a memorable experience for you and your guests. Nestled in Minneapolis' oldest neighborhood, our spacious taproom features incredible craft cider, one-of-a-kind cocktails, delicious food, and indoor pickleball courts.

The Haralson Room was the perfect spot for our wedding reception. The staff was flexible and accommodating. We were able to set up early and layout the space just as we hoped. Went off without a hitch! Easy, affordable, and our guests loved it. Would happily recommend to anyone looking for a hip spot to host any style event.
Laura P., 3 years ago
TrendlineTrending
The Sinclair on Grand 

5.0

Minneapolis, MN
  • Up to 200 guests
  • Raw space
  • Indoor & outdoor

The Sinclair on Grand is Northeast Minneapolis Gem. Tucked back it offers a private setting near the heart of the city. Built in 1905, this building is located in the heart of Northeast Minneapolis. This event space has a great industrial vibe with some beautiful rustic elements added in to make this a perfect space to hold all types of celebrations! We offer a very raw industrial space with massive beams and high ceilings. With an outdoor ceremony space and patio, you are able to have your city wedding with a secluded feel. Our mission with The Sinclair on Grand is to provide people with exceptional hospitality, a unique and flexible space, where people from all walks of life can host the wedding that they envision! If you are interested in setting up a tour, send us an email!

The Sinclair on Grand is effortlessly cool and romantic, which were exactly the vibes we were going for with our Minneapolis wedding of 200 people. To achieve this feeling of effortlessness, Adam and Christina and their team worked so hard for us and we highly recommend also hiring them as your planners. They are worth every penny. The venue is gorgeous without having to spend a fortune on decorations, and the space flows beautifully for a fun, easy, uncomplicated event. With a massive garage door that floods the space with air and light, to an adorable and versatile patio area where we had Solo Stove bonfires crackling into the night, it was just what we were envisioning. Parking is easy-breezy, and a bunch of our family got cute Airbnbs nearby to enjoy the weekend in Northeast Minneapolis. Only note is to know you'll need to rent a bathroom trailer if your wedding is more than 100 (?) people, but they set up at the Sinclair all the time and it couldn't have been easier. We LOVE the Sinclair on Grand and can't recommend it enough.
Tara N., 7 months ago
GemHidden gem
Broken Clock Brewing Cooperative 

5.0

Minneapolis, MN
  • Up to 140 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $340

At Broken Clock Brewing, we firmly believe that our brew cooperative is more significant than just crafting a great beer. We aim to make a positive impact by uplifting our community, encouraging enthusiasm, and promoting teamwork. Our cooperative puts community needs first, prioritizing them over profit.

Awarded Best of Zola
Rented out the event space for our reception and it was amazing. The room is a really cool vinyl record lounge and outdoor patio. We were allowed to bring in vinyl to be played or they had hundreds of albums on the shelf to choose from. Price was very reasonable, we had a view of downtown and the river. We were allowed to customize things the way we wanted and could bring in our own food vendor. The staff was beyond gracious and helpful leading up to and on the day of the event.
J&S, a year ago
Dellwood Country Club 

5.0

Dellwood, MN
  • Up to 280 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $5,000

Everything you have always dreamed of, in a comfortable and gracious setting. We offer more than your typical wedding venue with access to excellent amenities specific to hosting your wedding event. Indoor and outdoor ceremony options with complementary Bridal Suite allow for the ease of your entire day being at one location. Our Clubhouse boasts a casual elegance and is conveniently located, just 20 minutes from downtown St. Paul and Minneapolis and right outside White Bear Lake & Stillwater. We gladly welcome outside events and emphasize membership is not required to host an event at the Club!

From the moment we booked Dellwood Country Club for our wedding, their communication was prompt, clear, and professional. The venue itself is spacious, beautiful, and has a warm, inviting atmosphere that made all of our guests feel right at home. The team at Dellwood went above and beyond to personalize our day and make it truly special. They were extremely accommodating, ensuring that all of our guests' requests were met with ease. We couldn't have asked for a better venue to celebrate our marriage - Dellwood Country Club exceeded our expectations in every way.
Alex L., 2 months ago
Quick responder
The Riverside At Minneapolis Event Centers 
Minneapolis, MN
  • Up to 300 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $11,000

Located on The Mississippi River with Walking distance to the Historic Stone Arch Bridge. Exposed Brick Walls Event Space, High Ceilings, Plenty of Natural Lights, Custom Made Fiber optic Chandelier with Stunning Views of the City attached to an urban outdoor patio surrounded by lush greenery. Elegant Bridal and Groom Suites included. Minneapolis Event Centers offers "one stop shop" services for Ceremony and Wedding Receptions. We also offer Decor, Florals, Hotel access, Entertainment Services and more. We include complimentary wedding planning services and access to unlimited resources with a very experienced wedding team. Schedule a tour with us to meet ur weddings team, learn more about what we have to offer, and answer any questions you might have while you are trying to locate the best venue for your wedding day!

Quick responder
The View At Minneapolis Event Centers 
Minneapolis, MN
  • Up to 300 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $11,000

A view of the Mississippi River with Walking distance to the Historic Stone Arch Bridge. Large Exclusive Outdoor Urban cobblestone patio for outdoor ceremonies and Cocktail Reception. Exposed Brick Walls, Original Hardwood floor and Wood Beams Event Space creates an industrial-chic atmosphere. Elegant Bridal and Groom Suites included. Minneapolis Event Centers offers a"one stop shop" services for Ceremony and Wedding Receptions. We also offer Decor, Florals, Hotel access, Entertainment Services Etc. We include complimentary wedding planning services and access to unlimited resources with a very experienced wedding team. We are proud to be leading the industry with transparent and all inclusive pricing. At the venue tours we can provide you with detailed estimate on the complete cost of your wedding. We hold your hand throughout the whole process and work tirelessly on providing a 5 Star Service and an effortless planning experience.

Quick responder
Campus Club At The University Of Minnesota 

5.0

Minneapolis, MN
  • Up to 250 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor

The Campus Club at the University of Minnesota is a ballroom venue for couples’ weddings in the Minneapolis, Minnesota area. This historic, city venue is a private location for couples to host their weddings, with floor-to-ceiling views of the surrounding city from high above it. There is also a rooftop ceremony location. Couples will find this venue on the University of Minnesota’s campus, just a 10-minute drive from the Stone Arch Bridge up the river.

We had an unforgettable wedding at the University of Minnesota Campus Club in February. We had about 6 months to plan our wedding and working with the staff at the Campus Club made the planning process more fun than anything! They had great taste and suggestions for the wedding, responded quickly to questions, and were so kind. We were also allowed to have our dog at the ceremony! It made the planning process streamlined because we could have the ceremony, dinner, food, and the dance floor all in one place. The venue already had so much character that one doesn't need a lot of extra decorations (and extra work). The space is so large that it does not feel crowded to have the entire wedding at this location. What drew us to this location were the stunning views of Minneapolis, the incredible food options (the guests could not stop talking about the steak!), and the multiple options you had for room choices. We rented out the West Wing and the bar area, which proved to be a great option for guests to mingle after the ceremony and before dinner. With amazing views, delectable food, and a beautiful venue it made our wedding a perfect day!
Daniel & J., 4 years ago
Quick responder
Nicollet Island Pavilion 
Minneapolis, MN
  • Up to 700 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $17,000

Nestled in the heart of Minneapolis, MN, Nicollet Island Pavilion stands as a historic treasure and one of the Twin Cities’ most sought-after wedding venues. This award-winning location offers a tranquil and picturesque setting for celebrations of all kinds. With its breathtaking facilities, top-notch service, and stunning views of the Minneapolis skyline, Nicollet Island Pavilion provides the perfect backdrop for every moment of your special day, from the ceremony to the unforgettable reception. Perched on the banks of the Mississippi River, Nicollet Island Pavilion boasts a storied history and a rustic, industrial charm.

Quick responder
A'BULAE 

5.0

Saint Paul, MN
  • Up to 465 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $3,995

A'BULAE is a SoHo-style event site that provides unparalleled views of the city from floor-to-ceiling windows. The space is a classic international building with a distinct euro-contemporary style that incorporates Italian design. The intimate yet dramatic modular space combines rich and raw design elements that offer contrast and are reflective of Manhattan's SoHo environment. With an on-site parking garage, rooftop deck for ceremonies and social hours, expansive views of the capitol and bluffs, this is one of Minnesota's most sought-after event sites. It's unmatched in every aspect.

I've photographed numerous weddings at this loft style venue. It has great views day and night! The staff has their stuff together and make it easy to be here. It's a quick walk to Mears Park, which is a beautiful spot with some greenery to take photos.
Keighla Anderson, 7 months ago
Quick responder
Summit Manor 

5.0

St. Paul, MN
  • Up to 150 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $3,500

This dignified stone mansion provides a gracious inviting atmosphere for the wedding reception in Saint Paul you and your guests will always remember. A courteous staff relieves you of all responsibility so you can enjoy the day with your guests. The unique mansion style wedding venue in Saint Paul is the perfect location for those who want something different for their special day. Summit Manor is an elegant yet comfortable setting with beautiful grounds for you and your guests to enjoy. A complete reception service including the use of the Mansion, catering, linens, silver service, dance floor, beautiful grounds, speakeasy style bar facilities... everything you will need for your perfect day. We also love short notice and small weddings. *** We Love Micro Weddings***

This charming and historic manor is a delight to experience. We have provided entertainment at Summit Manor many times over the years and it continues to be one of our favorite venues to perform at. Such a warm and inviting atmosphere to enjoy the company of family and friends. David and the staff at Summit Manor are incredible to work with. They will take great care of you and will ensure that every detail is handled perfectly.
Scott, 4 years ago
Quick responder
Minnesota Boat Club on Raspberry Island 
Saint Paul, MN
  • Up to 170 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $8,500

Minnesota Boat Club, located on the picturesque shores of the Mississippi River in Saint Paul, MN, offers a charming and historic venue for your intimate wedding celebration. As one of Minnesota's oldest athletic institutions, this yacht club is steeped in tradition and surrounded by natural beauty, making it an unforgettable setting for your special day. The venue features an outdoor ceremony space with stunning views of downtown Saint Paul's skyline and the tranquil river, providing a breathtaking backdrop. It accommodates up to 170 guests, with two outdoor verandas enhancing the ambiance. The Boat Club combines historic charm with modern amenities, offering a stylish indoor space for dining and dancing. Their dedicated team ensures a seamless experience, from planning to day-of coordination. Partnered with Mintahoe Catering & Events, the venue offers exceptional cuisine, tailored to your tastes.

Wicked Wort 

5.0

Robbinsdale, MN
  • Up to 600 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $3,000

Wicked Wort Brewing Company is a family owned brewery located in Robbinsdale Minnesota. Established in 2014, with a 10 Barrel system providing 10 deliciously malted craft beers at all times. We are a STRICTLY 21+ VENUE that provides live entertainment on occasion. Dog friendly patio!

I can't say enough great things about Wicked Wort. When we got engaged, we didn't give our venue a second thought. The inside of the brewery is so cool and unique, it made for some amazing photos. The day of, I didn't have to think about anything, they were all so great at taking care of what needed to be done. The best thing about having our wedding here? It was working with family. There wasn't a bunch of people running around who we didn't know- it was the same faces we had met with and planned with. Steve and Tracy are about the best business owners/runners, and having their family involved makes it even cooler. I look back on our photos and think about they day with so much joy- the pictures are as unique as the day was- and that's how it should be :) We wouldn't have changed a thing of how our big day went- and I will keep recommending Wicked Wort forever. Thank you all so much for everything and for making us feel like part of the family.
BriAnna & M., 2 years ago
Quick responder
The Van Dusen Mansion 

5.0

Minneapolis, MN
  • Up to 200 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor

Are you looking for something truly unique ? A progressive-style event offers a festive evening where guests journey through ever changing scenery in four distinct and unique areas of the meticulous restored mansion. Each area is more striking then the last. Your guests will be awed with its splendor and be engaged throughout the day with your progressive styled event, exclusivly at the Van Dusen Mansion.

Awarded Best of Zola
The Van Dusen Mansion is absolutely stunning and was perfect for our fall wedding, the colors and mood were everything we could have asked for. From the over all castle feel of the grounds to the secret garden vibe of the courtyard, it was all absolutely beautiful. The Van Dusen Mansion's team was a great help throughout the planning process, with helpful emails, and super friendly staff that were always available to answer questions when they came up. If you are looking for an absolutely breathtaking venue with staff dedicated to helping make your day perfect this is the place for your wedding!
Katherine S., a year ago
TrendlineTrending
Minneapolis Institute of Art 

5.0

Minneapolis, MN
  • Up to 350 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $750

At the Minneapolis Institute of Art, we take pride in delivering a sophisticated, modern twist on events in a classic, convenient setting. Day or night, grand or intimate, private events at Mia showcase the fine art of entertaining with unparalleled service and attention to detail. At Mia we have an extensive list of caterers to choose from who will work with you to curate the perfect menu for your event. Contact us today to start planning your event!

Not only is the museum known for its rich history and art collections, but its events team is incredible. Their team of expert event leads have helped my clients create their perfect day with ease and grace. Every person we worked with (from Sales Directors to day-of managers) were professional, energetic and kind. They are so diligent in making sure there are no hiccups for my clients weddings during their events. The energy we feel from the staff walking in on my clients wedding days are so joyous. We are all so incredibly happy with this historic, beautiful venue. The venue is stunning and Mia's team genuinely cares about each clients special day!
Nicole Hillman, 4 years ago
TrendlineTrending
Glass House 

5.0

Minneapolis, MN
  • Up to 250 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $5,000

Glass House is a unique event space in the North Loop of Minneapolis located inside the facility of Hennepin Made, a local company founded in 2011 drawing on traditional glassblowing techniques to craft hand-blown accents that blur the line between everyday object and modern art. The space’s original concrete floors, cinderblock walls, and steel beam construction have been re ned and accentuated by modern elements to create a beautiful backdrop that blends past and present. Our building at 147 Holden Street was constructed in 1955 as a glass warehouse and mirror manufacturing plant for the Ford McNutt Company. Hennepin Made acquired the property in 2016 from Brinn Glass in order to expand their operations and grow their vision to connect people through craft. Thus, Parallel Cafe + Holden Room were created.

The team at Glass House was a pleasure to work with for our wedding. Their communication was timely and they were highly accountable, ensuring a smooth planning process. The venue itself is absolutely beautiful, with an aesthetic that perfectly fit our vision. They were also flexible in the required minimum charges, layout and flow of our smaller guest count. The transition between rooms went seamlessly, and the bar service was well-organized. While the staff may have been a bit too casual, and it was unclear who our dedicated day-of contact and security were, overall Glass House provided excellent value and contributed greatly to making our special day a huge success.
Emily B., 14 days ago
Quick responder
Majestic Oaks Club 

5.0

Ham Lake, MN
  • Up to 400 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $3,000

View our club grounds and plan your next special event. From our picturesque setting just 20 minutes north of downtown Minneapolis to our renowned amenities and impeccable service, Majestic Oaks Golf Club offers an unequaled locale for extraordinary weddings. Let our friendly, experienced wedding specialists create a one-of-a-kind wedding that complements your personal style, fits within your budget, and leaves you and your guests with memories to last a lifetime. When you’re ready, we’d be honored to show you in person!

We had our wedding here and it was PERFECT!! The Majestic Oaks team is absolutely amazing and so helpful!! They are there for you every step of the way and want to make sure your day absolutely perfect! Stop looking and book your event here!!
Katelyn, 5 months ago
Quick responder
FIVE Event Center 

5.0

Minneapolis, MN
  • Up to 200 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $2,500

Step into the charm of the late 1800s with a modern twist at FIVE Event Center, housed in the iconic former Minneapolis Fifth Precinct. Imagine celebrating your special day in a space where New York-inspired contemporary design meets rich, vibrant textures. You’ve found your perfect match, so why not find the perfect backdrop for your wedding day? FIVE Event Center is the stylish, romantic venue that turns your dream celebration into a stunning reality.

This venue is gorgeous and spacious, having the perks of an indoor venue space with lots of natural light. Robyn and her team were a delight to work with and really helped us bring our vision for the space together and collaborated effortlessly with the rest of our vendors. I highly recommend this venue to other couples!
Emy Van Z., 6 months ago

Location flexible? Discover venues near Shoreview, MN

About wedding venues in Shoreview, MN

How much do wedding venues typically cost in Shoreview, MN?

The cost of a wedding venue varies widely by location, number of guests, and many other details of the wedding package. Shoreview, MN offers a range of options that can fit most budgets. All-inclusive packages start at $1,500 and average $4,000.

What types of venues can I find in Shoreview, MN?

Shoreview offers a wide range of venues, including Ballroom, Historic estate and Urban.

What are some of the best wedding and reception venues available in Shoreview, MN?

Some of the most popular venues in this area include A'BULAE, Summit Manor and Landmark Center. But just like finding "the one," finding the perfect wedding venue takes time and a little bit of magic. Start by envisioning your dream wedding - the ambiance, style, and location. Then, explore our extensive collection of carefully curated wedding venues. Our marketplace provides detailed information, stunning photos, and real couples' reviews to help you make an informed decision. Trust your instincts, and when you find that venue that gives you butterflies, you'll know it's the one.

What questions should I ask when booking a venue in Shoreview, MN?

It all depends on what you're looking for, but you may want to consider things like whether the venue has an on-site bridal suite (77% in Shoreview do) or whether the venue provides an event coordinator (77% in Shoreview do!).

Additionally, some venues work with certain caterers and require a minimum food and beverage spend in addition to the space rentals. Others might have a recommended list of preferred caterers that they'd like you to work with.

Can the venues in Shoreview, MN accommodate both small and large weddings?

Of course! Small wedding venues in Shoreview, MN can host intimate parties while large venues can accommodate up to 700. The average venue in Shoreview can seat 150 guests.

What amenities do the reception venues in Shoreview, MN offer?

The venues in Shoreview, MN are known for the exceptional suite of services and amenities offered to couples and their wedding parties. The most common services provided are Bar services, Wheelchair accessible and Event staff. Some venues even offer Transportation!

What types of wedding venues are in Shoreview, MN?

What other Shoreview vendors will I need?

What other wedding venues are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?