The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Garnerville, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


48 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in Garnerville, NY

Quick responder
Brent Bakes 
Rating: 5.0 (8 reviews)
  • Starts at $900
  • Serves Garnerville, NY

Woman-owned small business. Carol, the baker behind Brent Bakes, loves baking and creating wedding cakes that is perfect for the big day! Brent Bakes specializes in uniquely flavored and equally stunning sweets. We custom make delicious cakes, cupcakes, and so much more!

Awarded Best of Zola
It was an amazing experience working with Carol and BrentBakes for our wedding. We are incredibly grateful we got to work with such a talented artist and baker! Her flavors are unique and delicious and it meant a lot to us to be able incorporate filipino flavors! The whole process was seamless and Carol was always responsive and gave great advice and recommendations. She puts her all into everything she bakes, any occasion, big or small. We can't wait to order more just to enjoy for ourselves or family and friends!
Krystle, a year ago
Quick responder
Vici Design 
Rating: 5.0 (6 reviews)
  • Serves Garnerville, NY

At Vici Design, we believe your wedding cake should be more than just a dessert. It's a reflection of your unique love story, a centerpiece that adds a touch of elegance and sweetness to your celebration.

Awarded Best of Zola
Vici Design was an absolute pleasure to work with for our wedding cake. From our initial consultation, their communication was quick, friendly, and professional. Victoria was very open-minded to our ideas, including our unique game theme wedding. Vici Design worked closely with us to bring our dream cake to life, asking thoughtful questions to ensure every detail was perfect. The final product was not only visually stunning and creative, but also incredibly delicious. We received so many compliments from our guests and the venue staff on the high quality and fun design of our cake. Victoria truly went above and beyond to make our special day even more memorable.
Gladys S., a year ago
Quick responder
Hudson Sugar By Sam 
Rating: 5.0 (5 reviews)
  • Starts at $350
  • Serves Garnerville, NY

Hudson Sugar by sam is an independent, woman-owned baking company, specializing in custom wedding cakes and desserts. Only the best ingredients are used and each cake is made fresh to your specifications

Awarded Best of Zola
We had the pleasure of working with Stephanie for our wedding cake, and we couldn't be happier with the experience! From the moment we first reached out via email to picking up cake samples at her studio, everything was smooth and easy. Stephanie was incredibly responsive, professional, and truly a joy to work with. She was more than accommodating with our request to have two different flavors in two layers of the cake, and we were thrilled with the result! Both flavors were absolutely delicious, and our guests couldn't stop talking about how wonderful the cake was. We are so grateful to Stephanie for adding such a sweet touch to our special day and making it even more memorable. Highly recommend her to anyone looking for a talented, thoughtful, and dedicated cake vendor!
Peihan, 10 months ago
GemHidden gem
The Bombón Shop 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Starts at $75
  • Serves Garnerville, NY

I am a registered and insured cottage baker from the Hudson Valley Middletown NY area and I would love to be part of your special celebration. My intuitive creations ranges from macaron, macaron towers, decorated sugar cookies, small bite size dessert such as cupcakes, petit fours, cakes shooters, brownies, cookies, cookie cups, push pop desserts and cookie sandwiches. I collaborate closely with your event coordinator to ensure a cohesive theme and to decorate the treats accordingly. While we do not typically decorate the tables. For rental stands or displays for the desserts cab be at a nominal fee if the venue does not supply them.

I had the absolute pleasure of working with The Bombon Shop for a very special event honoring my two grandmothers, and I couldn’t be happier with the experience. From the very beginning, Karina was an incredible partner, she was thoughtful, creative, and a fantastic communicator. She truly listened to my vision and brought it to life with such care and elegance. Every detail of the cookies were stunning and filled with meaning. It’s rare to find someone who can so beautifully blend design with sentiment, but Karina did just that. Her dedication and artistry helped make the celebration feel even more special and heartfelt. Highly, highly recommend The Bombon Shop to anyone looking for something custom, beautiful, and made with love. Thank you again, Karina, for helping me honor my grandmas in such a meaningful way!
Nirmala, a year ago
Quick responder
Maxine's Catering/Bittersweet Bakers 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Serves Garnerville, NY

Maxine's Catering/Bittersweet Bakers has been providing the Hudson Valley and surrounding areas with beautiful cakes and delicious desserts for over 25 years. Designing a wedding cake is an important part of a your wedding. We work intimately with each couple to create a custom designed cake using the highest quality seasonal ingredients. We specialize in gluten free, dairy free, and vegan options.

Admittedly, I was very picky about the details I wanted for my wedding cake. I found portions of past cakes that Maxine had made and frankensteined together my dream creation. Maxine was very patient and helpful during this design process and nailed my vision. It was beautiful and delicious! She even worked with my florist to add some accents. She was also the only person in the area I could find willing to deliver, which was a huge plus for me (who wants the stress of a dropped cake on their wedding day?).
Mya T., a year ago
TrendlineTrending
The Cannoli cart 
  • Starts at $400
  • Serves Garnerville, NY

Indulge your guests with our mobile cannoli cart, featuring freshly piped cannoli and a variety toppings to choose from! For a more interactive experience, our walking cannoli or gelato/sorbet station allows our staff to bring the joy of freshly filled cannoli or gelato right to the dance floor or anywhere, throughout your event. I'm Lauren, a mom to 2 & a proud third-generation Italian-American with deep roots in Sicily & a heart full of memories from my childhood kitchen making pasta dishes, cannoli & other traditional desserts. I love to bring the flavors of Sicily to you & your guests. For more about me and my business check my website!

Quick responder
Sugar Crystles 
Rating: 5.0 (22 reviews)
  • Starts at $4
  • Serves Garnerville, NY

Sugar Crystles is a wedding confectionery company in New Milford, CT. This budding bakery is owned and run by me, Crystle, and I am industry professional with years of cake-making in my repertoire. Using my skills, I do my best to craft stunning wedding cakes and delectable desserts that will have you and your guests wanting more. I create a variety of desserts and cakes for any special occasion with various techniques. From icing-covered sugar cookies to a variety of desserts for a buffet, I do it all. I also specialize in gluten and dairy free. I will cater to any flavor or design of your choice. Cake tastings are also available

Awarded Best of Zola
I sent Crystal this photo and I was a bit nervous at first about how they'd be able to make this happen but honestly I am so happy with how this came out it really was absolutely beautiful. I wasn't able to meet her in person with everything going on but she dropped it off for us on time and my coordinator was great in getting everything set up and presented. A few blueberries fell off during handling but considering how detailed and intricate the cake was I am so beyond thrilled at how this came out. I really don't often ask for perfection but with how this came out it's really right up there being perfect. If I find any better photos I will absolutely update this post with them. The venue itself was an absolute disaster but it was great having all those excessive blueberries everywhere it really made a mess and watching them clean it all up later was just fantastic. I'm not even sure if it's on their regular menu but I asked them to do a lemon cake with a blueberry compote inside (I have no idea what that means but my now wife had me asking for that) and the flavors and taste of the cake were just beyond extraordinary. They also made and brought a smaller mint chocolate cake to accommodate some allergies we had in the family and one bite my breath was smelling good all night! Thank you so much for everything I will definitely have you guys doing more in the future!
Andrew T., 2 years ago
Quick responder
The Gingersnap Bakery 
Rating: 4.8 (9 reviews)
  • Serves Garnerville, NY

The Gingersnap bakery is located in the business district of the village of Phoenix. We specialize in custom cakes and pastries. We love creating unique sweets that reflect the happiness of your celebration. We can pull inspiration from your wedding design elements as well as you as a couple!

Awarded Best of Zola
The Gingersnap Bakery was an absolute delight to work with for our wedding cake and desserts. Their communication was easy, quick, and reliable throughout the entire process. The quality of their work was simply gorgeous, delicious, and perfect. They made the wedding cake of our dreams, and all of the cake samples we had were so yummy it was hard to decide on just one flavor. We are so grateful to the Gingersnap team for helping make our special day even sweeter.
Madison R., a year ago
Quick responder
Rosebloom Cakes 
Rating: 5.0 (7 reviews)
  • Starts at $250
  • Serves Garnerville, NY

I'm a former costume designer and fashion historian with a PhD in English literature, now using my love of art, craft, and design to create one-of-a-kind custom wedding cakes! I make delicious, colorful cakes in traditional and modern flavor combinations, topped with handcrafted sugar flowers. I use only the highest-quality ingredients and always emphasize both design and taste. I would love to work with you to make your cake one of the most memorable and beautiful parts of your wedding!

Awarded Best of Zola
Abigail was so amazing to work with from start to finish. My husband and I usually aren’t big cake lovers but this cake was the exception. We gave her some ideas for flavors and what we usually gravitate towards and she made our cake into three tiers with two different flavor combinations that were out of this world. She also worked with us on the design to make sure it was exactly what we wanted. The sugar flowers matched our wedding flowers perfectly and our guests couldn’t believe they weren’t real. Everyone raved about how delicious it was and we were able to save the top tier for ourselves. Couldn’t recommend her enough!
Alanna S., 10 months ago
Quick responder
Por Suerte 
Rating: 5.0 (6 reviews)
  • Starts at $36
  • Serves Garnerville, NY

We make sweet AND savory fortune cookies that are fully customizable in every way. From the color and flavor, to the fortunes on the inside, these aren't your typical takeout afterthought. Think porcini mushroom with truffle salt, espresso, tutti frutti, and so many more flavors. We can also create a custom flavor just for you. We also stuff our cookies like cannolis, make fortune cookie ice cream sandwiches, and have different sized-cookies to really make a statement. We're based in Napa, CA but ship Nationwide and to Puerto Rico!

I ordered Por Suerte cookies as a gift for my pre-wedding parties (bridal shower) and they were a hit! The variety of flavors offered a great opportunity to have something for guests of all tastes. And it hadn’t been done before, which was fun for me. I loved working the vendor - incredibly professional, communicative, and thoughtful. Highly recommend!!!
Ana F., a month ago
Quick responder
My Daughter's Cakes 
Rating: 5.0 (5 reviews)
  • Starts at $850
  • Serves Garnerville, NY
  • Offer

My Daughter's Cakes was founded in 2009 based on my desire to elevate the wedding cake experience for couples and their families. Our belief is that a wedding cake should be the most beautiful and delicious centerpiece of your reception, an artistic expression that plays an important role with your main meal. A long-remembered ‘wow factor’ for the eyes and taste buds for you and your guests.

Awarded Best of Zola
My Daughter's Cakes provided excellent communication throughout the process of ordering our wedding cake. The cake they delivered was absolutely beautiful and delicious - exactly what we had envisioned. They made sure to deliver the cake on time, which was a huge relief on our busy wedding day. Overall, we were thrilled with the quality of their work and the value they provided. We wanted to take a moment to thank Denise, for the beautiful and delicious cake. Everyone liked it! Thank you -Angie and Mike.
Angie L., 10 months ago
Quick responder
Sweet Kee's Candies & Gifts 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Starts at $150
  • Serves Garnerville, NY

Sweet Kee's is a one-of-a-kind Hudson Valley, New York wedding favors & gifts business, servicing couples throughout New York State. We offer handcrafted, artisanal treats, including a variety of classic & specialty hard candies & lollipops that are perfect as candy or dessert table options, as gifts and favors. We also offer premium beverage infusion kits that allow your guests to create their own craft drink experience. Just add wine, liquor, or non-alcoholic beverages. Our other specialty food novelties include hot cocoa jars, small-batch fruit jams, and edible peppermint shot glasses. Shipping is available throughout New York State.

Awarded Best of Zola
Sweet Kee's was an absolute delight to work with! From our first interaction, she was professional, prompt, and incredibly helpful during communications. The lollipops were simply stunning and beautifully crafted. These were the most delicious, unique flavors we've ever tasted. In fact, I can say with confidence that these are the best lollipops I've ever had the pleasure of enjoying!! Thanks so much!
Kiana, 2 years ago
GemHidden gem
Cake Hero 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves Garnerville, NY

Based in Brooklyn, self taught sugar artist Melissa Torres knows that there’s nothing like a gorgeous and delicious treat to take your party to the next level! With a commitment to using organic, fair trade ingredients, Cake Hero confections are beautiful and delicious delights that you can feel good about. Your purchase of a Cake Hero cake means that together, we are a force for good in our business and purchasing practices. We extend this way of thinking to our packaging, and use recycled boxes and paper whenever possible. Melissa’s unique take on cake has caught the eye of Vogue, New York Magazine, and many stylish events in NYC & beyond.

While there are many cakes to choose from, we couldn't have been happier with ours from Cake Hero. Naturally, Melissa is a sweetheart (she can probably make one, too) and a pleasure to work with. She's bright, punctual, easy to communicate with, and has an acute attention to detail. Melissa makes sure you will not have to worry about the cake on your big day. From our first conversation to delivery, she had it covered. We could not have been happier with our wedding cake, and have the sugar cherry blossoms displayed on our bookshelf as a daily reminder of our love for each other, and the sweet leftovers in the freezer. We HIGHLY recommend working with Melissa to make your wedding cake dreams come true!!!!
Julia and M., 6 years ago
TrendlineTrending
Common Meadows Creamery 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Starts at $750
  • Serves Garnerville, NY

Common Meadows is a family-owned creamery. Our products are made in Brooklyn using thoughtful and local ingredients. We are committed to creating quality products that stand the test of time. We partner with local New York State farms, as well as other small farms globally, such as Hattori Farms, who make the matcha we use in our gelato. We offer a well rounded assortment of gelato in seasonal, rotating flavors. All flavors are available in dairy and vegan varieties.

Awarded Best of Zola
Common Meadows Creamery was a wonderful addition to our wedding day. Their communication throughout the planning process was timely, professional, and friendly. On the day of, their team delivered a truly inspired gelato selection - our guests were blown away by the delicious gelato flavors they provided instead of a traditional wedding cake. The quality and taste of their work exceeded our expectations, and we felt we received great value for the price. We couldn't have been happier with Common Meadows Creamery and highly recommend them to any couple looking for a unique and delicious dessert option for their special day.
Jeff C., 2 years ago
Quick responder
Little Treats and Cakes by Janna, LLC 
Rating: 5.0 (7 reviews)
  • Starts at $180
  • Serves Garnerville, NY for additional fees

Little Treats and Cakes by Janna specializes in wedding cakes and specialty cakes for all occasions. Our commitment is to create an original piece of edible art, that it’s not only beautiful but also very delicious. We not only offer cakes but also a variety of treats for your event like custom cupcakes, sugar cookies, and a full dessert menu which is created to match the theme and design of your event for an unforgettable sweets table. We also offer guest edible favors. At Little Treats and Cakes by Janna we also offer gluten free, dairy free and vegan options if you have dietary restrictions.

Awarded Best of Zola
We were delighted with Little Treats and Cakes by Janna, LLC for our wedding cake! Janna was so easy to work with - quick to respond, flexible, and really made sure she understood what we wanted. The final cake not only tasted delicious with moist layers and perfect buttercream frosting, but it was gorgeously decorated just as I envisioned. Janna delivered it on time the day of our wedding and made sure everything was perfect before she left. We couldn't recommend Janna highly enough for wedding cakes - her excellent communication, attention to detail, and talent resulted in the perfect sweet ending to our special day!
Emily I., 2 years ago
TrendlineTrending
Sweet Buckets 
Rating: 5.0 (5 reviews)
  • Starts at $300
  • Serves Garnerville, NY for additional fees

We began as a concession company providing cotton candy at sporting events. In the fall of 2021, we extended our brand by starting our own manufacturing plant. Sweet Buckets was born as an option for customers and businesses to purchase Cotton Candy and Gourmet popcorns direct from our company.

Awarded Best of Zola
We had our wedding reception at a brewery and wanted some easy to eat sweet and salty snacks. These popcorn flavors were delicious, they sent us flavors to try before we decided. We chose 4 flavors and they shipped them right to our house. The popcorn buckets had our cute custom labels which they designed for us and looked PERFECT! We had tons of compliments on the popcorn. We ordered plenty and people were grabbing them to take home at the end of the night. A perfect snack after a few beers. Theu were very fast with the samples and the order too!
Lyndsey C., 2 years ago
TrendlineTrending
BakerBitesCo 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Starts at $200
  • Serves Garnerville, NY for additional fees

Ready to impress your guests with our unique tasty treat? BakerBitesCo offers single serve fudge bites with customized labels to fit your perfect day. Wedding favors, bridesmaids gifts, wedding party gifts, etc. these can be used in any way to fit your needs. WHY YOU'LL LOVE US -We offer delicious unique seasonal flavors -We ship anywhere in the US -We can send a sampler box so you can taste all our flavors and pick your favorites. -Budget friendly at only $2/piece -Prepackaged, making our dessert ideal during COVID -We give a meal to a hungry child with every order We can't wait to make your day even more spectacular!

Best fudge I’ve ever had and the flavor varieties are amazing! I love that I can customize them for any occasion!
Linda, 6 years ago
GemHidden gem
Canela Bakeshop 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Starts at $8 per serving
  • Serves Garnerville, NY

Canela Bakeshop is a boutique custom wedding cake bakery, and are particularly drawn to creating designs with a unique artistic flair. We specialize in buttercream work, and can accommodate custom flavor requests and some dietary restrictions. We work one cake at a time, meaning your beautiful custom creation is the only thing on our mind!

Full disclosure - we were sold on Canela bakery once we saw her name as our beautiful maltipoo puppy is named Canela But once we saw her work and tasted her cake, it was obvious that she is a force to be reckoned with. We had a tasting with her prior to our big day and the cake was exceptional. It was moist with great consistency and the frosting was divine. And her aesthetic is absolutely spectacular. We had Canela bakery provide us a beautiful lemon flavored cake for our pre-wedding Mehndi henna party and it was a huge hit. Then the three tiered cake we had for our wedding was the best tasting wedding cake we have ever eaten (and many, many guests agreed!) It was a almond cake with cherry filling with pink champagne frosting. My mouth waters just writing this review. Canela bakery is exceptional and we recommend it to anyone and everyone!
Lindsay & P., 6 years ago
TrendlineTrending
Sara Victoria Cake Design 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Serves Garnerville, NY

Sara Victoria Cake Design was born from a genuine love of baking and art; stemming from childhood. After Graduating from the Institute of Culinary Education, Sara has worked with both classically trained artists and some of the best sugar artists in the industry which has helped build her signature style. Each piece isn't just a cake but a piece of edible art, elegant and unexpected. She has been featured on the food network on several occasions and won the Big Bake! Forever sculpting figures and working on new sugar flowers, watching each sketch come to life is a joy that never gets old.

Sara is so talented with her array of flavors, fillings, and designs! She was very receptive and created the cake of our wedding dreams
Katelyn, 3 years ago