The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in East Orange, NJ

The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in East Orange, NJ

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


70 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in East Orange, NJ

Quick responder
Big Day, Small Budget Cakes 

5.0

  • Starts at $140
  • Serves East Orange, NJ

With Big Day, Small Budget Cakes every couple can have a cake that brings cheer and warmth to their big day without sacrificing beauty, flavor, or your entire savings. Based in Brooklyn, New York, you’ll be working directly with me, Allie, on creating the best cake for your budget. Whether it’s a simple cake for 25 guests or a large four-tier cake with embellishments, I have affordable options for you. You’re in good hands! I’ve baked and decorated cakes for over 10 years, and I’m still hooked! I began my journey training at ICE in New York City and worked at celebrated bakeries, including The Chocolate Room, Balthazar, and Billy’s Bakery.

Awarded Best of Zola
Working with Big Day, Small Budget Cakes was an absolute delight. Allie, the owner, was communicative, caring, timely, and responsible throughout the entire process. Her passion for baking shines through in the delicious, beautiful, and perfectly individualized cake she created for our wedding. The cake was even more stunning than we had anticipated, and all of our guests raved about how moist and flavorful it was. Allie clearly understands how important your wedding day is, and she takes her craft seriously to ensure an exceptional experience. Her prices are almost too low for the level of care and quality she provides. We are so grateful to have found Big Day, Small Budget Cakes and would highly recommend them to any couple looking for a truly special wedding cake. In addition, as an LGBTQ couple we always found it comforting when we knew in advance that a vendor was LGBTQ friendly. Allie is absolutely supportive of all weddings.
Daryn, a year ago
GemHidden gem
David's Custom Cakes 

5.0

  • Starts at $5 per serving
  • Serves East Orange, NJ

David’s Custom Cakes is a specialty cake shop that will make your cake dreams come true! We will help you to design a beautiful, delicious work of art that will be the centerpiece of your event. Our experienced decorators specialize in buttercream and fondant designs and can create a stunning and creative cake that will suit your vision.

David's Custom Cakes was a fantastic choice for our wedding cake. From the initial tasting to the final product, their communication was always on point, responding promptly to emails and calls with thoughtful answers to our questions. The cake itself was simply amazing - beautifully decorated and incredibly delicious. Our guests raved about the flavors and unique design. For the quality, creativity, and service, the value was outstanding. David worked closely with us to bring our vision to life with a gorgeous multi-tier cake that perfectly suited our wedding aesthetic. The cake was truly a highlight of our special day and we can't recommend David's Custom Cakes highly enough!
Jasmine B., a year ago
Quick responder
My Daughter's Cakes 

5.0

  • Starts at $850
  • Serves East Orange, NJ
  • Offer

My Daughter's Cakes was founded in 2009 based on my desire to elevate the wedding cake experience for couples and their families. Our belief is that a wedding cake should be the most beautiful and delicious centerpiece of your reception, an artistic expression that plays an important role with your main meal. A long-remembered ‘wow factor’ for the eyes and taste buds for you and your guests.

Awarded Best of Zola
I am so glad that I booked My Daughter's Cakes for my wedding. The cake they created looked absolutely stunning and tasted delicious. The owner was incredibly helpful in working with me to pick the perfect icing and cake flavors that complemented each other beautifully. She was very responsive to all of my questions and requests throughout the process, making the cake selection and ordering experience stress-free. I would highly recommend My Daughter's Cakes to any couple looking for a talented, professional, and personable wedding cake vendor.
Diane E., a year ago
TrendlineTrending
Joeycakes Custom Cakes & Confections 

5.0

  • Starts at $750
  • Serves East Orange, NJ

Hi there! I’m Joey, the owner and cake artist behind Joeycakes Custom Cakes & Confections. First off, congratulations on your engagement! Planning a wedding is such an exciting adventure, and I’m honored to play a part in creating sweet memories for your big day. My journey into the world of cakes began with a love for baking that I nurtured into a career by attending culinary school, where I graduated in 2023. It was there that I discovered my passion for cake decorating. I quickly fell in love with the process of turning simple ingredients into edible works of art that not only taste amazing but also tell a story—your story.

Joeycakes Custom Cakes & Confections was a pleasure to work with for our wedding. From the start, their communication was thorough, efficient, and responsive, making the cake design process easy and fun. Joey went above and beyond to deliver and set up the cake, which turned out absolutely gorgeous and delicious. The quality of their work is truly meticulous, and the final product was a stunning centerpiece for our special day. We couldn't have been happier with Joeycakes and highly recommend them to any couple planning their wedding.
Bill M., a year ago
GemHidden gem
Victoria's Cake 

5.0

  • Starts at $270
  • Serves East Orange, NJ

After graduating from interior design school and becoming a self-taught pastry chef, Victoria set out to unite her two passions: baking and design. Her vision was to create a Parisian-inspired boutique bakery where everyone feels at home.

Victoria's Cake was a pleasure to work with for our wedding. As helpful professionals, they were always quick to respond to our requests and guide us through the process of designing our dream cake. Despite having a very specific vision in mind, their talented team of artists outdid themselves, creating a stunning cake that was a true work of art. The end result was worth every penny - our guests raved about not just the beautiful design, but the incredible taste as well. We can't thank Victoria's Cake enough for helping make our special day even more magical.
Camille, 10 days ago
Quick responder
Elm Chocolates 

5.0

  • Starts at $5
  • Serves East Orange, NJ

We are a husband and wife team of pastry chefs who made our own chocolate favors for our wedding and got such good feedback. We offer handcrafted chocolates for favors, gifts and dessert displays. We have a background in fine dining restaurants and high end bakeries. We love the craft of making chocolates and bringing them to couples for their events.

Elm Chocolates was the most special finishing touch to our wedding day! From the moment we first reached out, their communication style was easy, professional, and made us feel so valued. They custom designed every single chocolate for our wedding, and we met with them in person for a detailed design meeting where they brought our vision to life. The quality of their work is truly one of a kind - they are so uniquely talented and every bite was absolutely delicious. We fell in love with their creations and plan to use them for our anniversary and all other special events in our lives. Elm Chocolates was the perfect addition to our wedding day, and we cannot recommend them highly enough!
Erika & R., 10 months ago
GemHidden gem
Mother Fudgers LLC 

5.0

  • Starts at $180
  • Serves East Orange, NJ

Mother Fudgers prides itself on making bite-sized fudge in a variety of flavors!... all served with a cheeky attitude! We've got typical flavors such as chocolate, vanilla, cookies & cream, and artisanal flavors such as birthday cake, lemon vanilla, and ube!

I used to think "Whatever, fudge is fudge, it's all the same to me" until I had Mother Fudgers fudge! Their creative seasonal flavors along with old standbys like walnut fudge make then stand out in a fudged-up world of mediocre confections. My favorites are strawberry, lemon (OMG lemon YES lemon get it trust me) and of course basic walnut fudge. Oh, and cookies and cream. Oh, and peanut butter. I could go on, but I think you get the idea. Is the name a bit...different? Yep. and THAT is a selling point for me! Fudging yeah!
Leslie B., 7 months ago
Quick responder
Tasty Glam Treats 

5.0

  • Starts at $2
  • Serves East Orange, NJ

Welcome to Tasty Glam Treats! As treat maker, I am truly passionate about adding a touch of sweetness and elegance to life's most special moments. Creating these treats is more than just a business for me—it's a therapeutic and joyful experience. I absolutely love the process of bringing creative ideas to life, from selecting the perfect colors and ribbons to ensuring every treat is as beautiful as it is delicious. It's truly a labor of love, and nothing brings me more joy than seeing the smiles on my clients' faces. Although I haven't had my business for as long as others I am dedicated to providing top-notch service for my customers.

I place my ordered and customer service was great! I love the way you can place your order and you get your treats in a timely manner. The treats are so good! I will definitely be ordering from Tastyglamtreats in the very near future. Thanks again!!!
Wanda C., 6 months ago
GemHidden gem
Toasty Polvo 

5.0

  • Starts at $250
  • Serves East Orange, NJ

Hi, I’m MJ, founder of Toasty Polvo—where we reimagine and elevate Filipino polvoron for modern celebrations. Made with browned butter and crafted in small batches in Union, NJ, our rich, crumbly shortbread bites add a nostalgic yet elevated touch to your event. Perfect for wedding favors, dessert tables, or welcome bags, each piece brings comfort, culture, and joy. Women-owned and rooted in tradition, Toasty Polvo is proud to offer custom options to make your day even more special—one buttery bite at a time.

Toasty Polvo was an absolute delight to work with for our wedding desserts. From the very first interaction, they were communicative, kind, and flexible in accommodating our requests. The quality of their work was exceptional - the desserts were not only delicious, but beautifully presented as well. They truly went above and beyond to ensure our wedding day was special, providing amazing treats - both infused and not-infused - that were the extra piece that made our celebration complete. Couldn't recommend Toasty Polvo more highly!
Kate, 9 months ago
GemHidden gem
Butter Babe 

5.0

  • Starts at $60
  • Serves East Orange, NJ

Butter Babe creates custom decorated sugar cookies for all occasions. We specialize in matching themes for anything from birthdays to bridal shower favors to custom cookie wedding seat place settings!

Awarded Best of Zola
My girlfriend ordered from Butter Babe customer sugar cookies as a surprise for my bridal shower, and WOW! My shower was in June and I still get messages and comments from my friends and family on how amazing they were. Not only were they beautiful to look at, but the cookies themselves tasted absolutely amazing. Each cookie was individually wrapped with a custom sticker that matched the theme of my shower, Butter Babe went above and beyond. I would recommend Butter Babe to anyone looking for a show stopping dessert at any gathering.
Alyssa M., 2 years ago
GemHidden gem
Lori's Mixing Bowl 

5.0

  • Starts at $70
  • Serves East Orange, NJ

We specialize in cakes and other sweets. Whether you are looking for a cake, a dessert table, or dessert favors we do it all! All of our desserts are made from scratch with the highest quality of ingredients.

We recently had our wedding cake and wedding favors made by Lori’s mixing bowl and could not have loved our experience more. Lori was extremely easy to work with. She was very responsive and went above and beyond helping us understand how much cake and cookies we needed based on our guest count. The delivered product not only looked exactly like our inspiration photos but tasted incredible. We got SEVERAL compliments from proclaimed “not cake people” who said this cake was different! The cake was moist and the buttercream was not too sweet like most often are. Lori took extra precaution in sealing our 240 cookies as we had to do an earlier pick up and did not plan to give them out until the end of the reception. The cookies stayed fresh and delicious as a result! I’d highly recommend Lori’s mixing bowl to others looking for a crowd pleaser at an upcoming event
Ryan A., a year ago
Quick responder
Tasty Treats And Fancy Sweets 

5.0

  • Starts at $6
  • Serves East Orange, NJ
  • Offer

Coming from an Italian family, I inherited the baking genes. I started making cheesecakes 15 years ago. It started out as a challenge to see if I could do it, and once I mastered that, I decided to expand into different flavors. I brought cheesecakes to family functions and my mom would always say that they were "too rich" or "too much". I changed to making them into bars so she could have a smaller piece and it wouldn't be too much. Once I found mini cheesecake pans, my life was made! After being encouraged by my friends and family to start my own business, I took the leap and did it. 6 years later, I am still enjoying it.

Love the selection of mini desserts from Tasty Treats and Fancy Sweets!! Super cute. They are perfect for weddings or events. I also love to support woman owned, local businesses.
Nikkolette, 5 years ago
Everything Just Baked 

5.0

  • Starts at $8
  • Serves East Orange, NJ

I started Everything Just Baked because I no longer wanted to choose between a beautiful cake or a delicious cake! With Everything Just Baked we take pride in having both a masterpiece on the outside and inside. We specialize in custom cakes and would love to create a piece of art you will remember for the rest of your life!

Justin was an absolute pleasure to work with! From the first email, to the tasting, to the designing, to the final product! Our wedding cake was absolutely perfect and it was incredible to see the vision in my head come to life. From the colors, to the flowers, to the flavors, it was everything we dreamed of! We chose cannoli cream, strawberries and cream, and chocolate chip deluxe. Our guests kept raving about how delicious it was! We cannot wait to have an excuse to order a cake from Justin again!
Sara C., a year ago
The Dessert Ladies 

5.0

  • Serves East Orange, NJ

We specialize in Custom Dessert Bar Displays and 100% Customizable Celebration Cakes. Dessert Ladies Events! From a masterpiece cake centerpiece, perfectly complimented by our coordinating bite sized desserts like our Signature Bien Tree Sculptures, to fully decorating the event space to create a transformative experience for your guests or employees, and even staffing for your special occasion to create a seamless party experience! Our full service, one stop shopping, Dessert Table displays can be customized for every theme and event including, anniversary milestones, promotional parties, open house features, weddings, showers and more!

Working with dessert ladies was so seamless! They are amazing and everyone raved about our wedding cake!
Marianna S., 2 years ago
Chocolate Carousel 

4.7

  • Serves East Orange, NJ

Chocolate Carousel is a family owned and operated bakery and dessert shop located in Wall, NJ. We are proud to partner with some of the finest wedding venues and caterers in the state. Chocolate Carousel is widely known as a leader in the wedding industry having received numerous local and national awards for its work and philanthropy. Chocolate Carousel is known for its beautiful cake creations, creative design concepts, exceptional customer service and quality of product. Chocolate Carousel also offers, custom cookies, favors, groom’s cakes and many more desserts for your shower, rehearsal dinner, wedding and more!

Our wedding cake was so delicious! So many compliments. The decor was also stunning!
Lauren S., 8 months ago
Quick responder
Cupcake Chromatography LLC 

5.0

  • Starts at $300
  • Serves East Orange, NJ

Our cake lab specializes in Pocono Wedding Cakes! We create beautiful, customized luxury desserts that will have your wedding guests raving over each bite. We combine our love of science, food, and the creative arts, using these passions to produce amazing masterpieces bursting with unique flavors that are sure to be a hit on your big day. We offer an extensive list of flavors!

Awarded Best of Zola
My husband is all things football obsessed!!! It was only fitting that I surprised him with a grooms cake fitting of his second obsession! A whole football field with a Tom Brady jersey!!! Nadia at Cupcake Chrom was a delight to work with and captured every single detail! The cake itself was in hubby's favorite - carrot cake and was soooooo moist and delicious! He ate that entire cake by himself over the next few weeks after our wedding! You won't be disappointed! Everything ur heart desires is here - one stop shop!
Tiffany, 3 years ago
Quick responder
PETITE FLEUR CAKE 

5.0

  • Starts at $700
  • Serves East Orange, NJ

Petite Fleur Cake specializes in buttercream and sugar flower cakes. We are committed to treats that impress both the sight and the bite. To make your event extraordinary, we are only committed to using the finest quality ingredients. We are looking forward to serving you.

Awarded Best of Zola
Karen from Petite Fleur Cake is an excellent cake designer who combines an elevated creative conceptualization with high-quality ingredients for her delicious cakes and desserts. I'm a wedding planner and designer and always have a great pleasure welcoming her to the team of creative vendors selected to work with couples who value style, creativity, and beautifully curated experiences. What I love the most about working with Karen is her intentional attitude towards each cake she creates. She also has a strong sense of teamwork, which leads to amazing collaborations. She will go further and beyond to listen to what your vision is and surprise you with incredible, gorgeous, and delicious cakes. Her approach to using the finest and highest quality ingredients is always present in each of her cakes. I strongly recommend Petite Fleur Cake for your event and can guarantee you will be beyond excited about working with Karen.
Carol G., a year ago
TrendlineTrending
Ebakes Cakes 

5.0

  • Starts at $8
  • Serves East Orange, NJ

Hello, my name is Erica and I'm the owner of Ebakes Cakes. I make custom cakes, cupcakes, and treats for all occasions. I've been baking for 4 years, and I absolutely love it. My passion for baking began making my kids birthday cake. I fell in love! Every cake is created with love. Whether your event is big or small we provide a luxury experience. Thank you for trusting me. I look forward to bringing your vision to life and creating magic.

Ebakes cake is hands down one of the greatest cakes I had! She made each layer a different flavor, and each flavor had a filling that complemented each other so well. I had wedding guess coming up for seconds and by the time I saw the entire cake was gone by the end of the wedding!
Saudia A., a year ago