Mama Stortinis Catering

Catering services pricing

Food starts at $20 per person.

Minimum spend

$3,000 total

About Mama Stortinis Catering

Mama Stortini's Catering

Since 1993, Mama Stortini's has been serious about great food, tasty drinks, and sharing it with folks who love the feeling of a homemade meal. Mama Stortini's Catering takes this concept with them wherever they go, so that any celebration is crafted with love, and it shows.

As a full-service catering company, we are able to supply our clients with linens (all color/texture types available), china, flatware, glassware, and other rental items. We provide bartending services, as well as fully staff every event- whether it is in our Fireside Room (Puyallup Location) or an offsite location of your choice, to be sure that you, your guests, and your venue of choice are cared for.

Best of Zola 2026

Services

Services

  • Bartenders
  • Cleanup and breakdown
  • Consultations and tastings - complimentary
  • Delivery and setup
  • Rental coordination - directly invoice couple
  • Serving staff

Cuisines

  • American
  • BBQ
  • Fusion
  • Hawaiian
  • Italian
  • Mexican
  • Southern

Dietary accommodations

  • Dairy-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Vegan
  • Vegetarian

Meal types

  • Breakfast/brunch
  • Buffet
  • Dessert service
  • Family-style meal
  • Food stations
  • Passed appetizers
  • Seated meal
  • Stationary appetizers
  • Wedding cake service

Beverage services

  • Bartending
  • Beverage servingware rentals
  • Mixers/non-alcoholic options
  • Provides liquor license

Drink types

  • Beer
  • Coffee service
  • Liquor
  • Non-alcoholic
  • Signature cocktails
  • Wine

Reviews

Write a review
Rating: 5.0

5.0 out of 5

5 reviews

  • JC

    Jadyn C.

    Rating: 5
    •Jun 27, 2026

    Best vendor we have worked with!

    Mama Sortinis was top notch catering. The communication from start to finish was excellent, Julie was incredibly easy to work with and she made sure we were well taken care of throughout the process. The food was of course delicious and our guests raved about the chicken picada and wild rice pilaf! The wait staff was timely, respectful and proactive - we never had to ask for anything to be done. They made sure to box up special to go meals for my wife and I and even made sure to box up some cake for us! 10/10 we would highly recommend Mama Sortinis catering for any event!

    Elise Manaea•Jun 28, 2026

    Thank you so much Jadyn for your 5-star review and for saying the kindest words about Julie and our staff! We are so thankful for your business and wish you both many years of happiness and joy! :)

  • MR

    Mike R.

    Rating: 5
    •Mar 19, 2025

    Fantastic Catering Experience

    Mama Stortinis Catering was an absolute pleasure to work with for our wedding. From the very first interaction, their communication was open, honest, and proactively helpful in guiding us through the catering process. On the day of the event, they arrived promptly and set up their stations with a wonderfully presented spread of crowd-pleasing dishes. The food was plentiful and delicious, and we felt their pricing was realistic for the high-quality service and presentation. It was clear Mama Stortinis treated our wedding like a true partnership with the venue, and we could tell they genuinely cared about the overall success of our special day.

  • SB

    S. B.

    Rating: 5
    •Mar 15, 2025

    Worth Every Penny!

    Thank you Stortinis for your professionalism and quality of catering for our daughter’s wedding! The staff were attentive and kind while taking care of our guests. The food was delicious as we knew it would be! We look forward to our next event and cause for celebration to be spent at Stortinis in the future!

  • MH

    Mikayla H.

    Rating: 5
    •Mar 14, 2025

    Wedding Planner

    From the moment Our client's book with Mama Stortinis Catering for their wedding, their communication was clear and transparent, putting all minds at ease throughout the entire planning process. The team was attentive, dependable, efficient, and truly committed to ensuring the special day was a success. They constantly went above and beyond, taking care of every detail from set up, to tear down. We loved working with Mama Stortinis and cannot recommend them highly enough - their exceptional service, and delicious food make each event truly unforgettable. BOOK THEM NOW

  • H

    Heidi

    Rating: 5
    •Mar 14, 2025

    Sales and Event Coordinator

    Mama Stortinis Catering was a pleasure to work with for our wedding. They had a friendly and personable communication style that put us at ease throughout the planning process. Their team was thorough and efficient, ensuring every detail was taken care of. On the day of the wedding, it was raining and their entire staff was outside drying off the chairs so our guests would have a comfortable and dry experience. We were so impressed by their dedication and attention to creating a seamless event. Mama Stortinis Catering exceeded our expectations and we highly recommend them to any couple planning their wedding.

Preferred vendors of Mama Stortinis Catering

Quick responder
Venue
Legacy Farms
Rating: 5.0 (2 reviews)
Buckley, WA
Starts at $6,500
Quick responder
Venue
Evergreen Meadows
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
Snoqualmie, WA
Starts at $4,000
Planner
Homan Weddings & Events
Rating: 5.0 (5 reviews)
Puyallup, WA
Starts at $1,350
Quick responder
Florist
Loveleigh Blooms
Rating: 5.0 (13 reviews)
Tacoma, WA
Starts at $3,500
Yes, we offer complimentary tastings for you and a guest at our Puyallup location. Booked clients may come back for additional tastings for a small fee.
As many times as needed! You are welcome to make an appointment with the catering team to meet in office or arrange an over-the-phone meeting to go over final details prior to your event date. Any meetings to take place at your venue will need approval/availability through the Catering Department's General Manager.
ABSOLUTELY! We can work with your color scheme and overall aesthetic to curate the perfect rental package of linens, china, flatware, glassware, and centerpiece options.
To provide the best service and quality in product as possible, our niche is within 2-hours driving distance from the Puyallup Mama Stortini's location. We generally serve the following areas: Puyallup, Tacoma, Lakewood, Auburn, Bonney Lake, Enumclaw, Buckley, Gig Harbor, Poulsbo, Seattle, Kent, Renton, Fife, Sea-Tac, Dupont, and other surrounding areas.
We can provide individual Gluten-Free, Vegetarian, and limited Vegan options as needed.
Right after reserving your venue, your caterer is the next big stop! To ensure you will have the services needed for your event, we recommend booking as soon as possible after you have chosen your venue. Please be aware that some venues have a closed catering list, so please be sure Mama Stortini's Catering is able to serve you and your guests at your venue.
Yes, delivery is an option for any event type! Being able to deliver to your event is solely dependent on the discretion of the venue. Some venues require full-service, or fully staffed events, where delivery is not an option. Should Mama Stortini's be able to deliver to your venue, the standard fee is $35.00 within a 15-mile radius of the area code 98372. The fee increases based on location of venue outside of the 15-mile radius.
Mama Stortini's Catering is happy to offer cake cutting services at no additional charge!
Yes, our event minimum is $3,000.00 in food and beverage (both alcoholic and/or non-alcoholic options) for all weddings, involving staffed offsite events. Minimums vary for Fireside Room rentals, delivery, or pick-up options.

Explore other vendors serving Puyallup, WA

Complete your dream team

Other caterers in Puyallup

Other wedding services nearby