The Best Vintage Wedding Videographers in Shelter Island, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


11 Wedding Videographers in Shelter Island, NY

Vintage
Quick responder
Press Record Co Camcorders 
Rating: 5.0 (81 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Vintage style
  • Starts at $645
  • Serves Shelter Island, NY
  • Offer

Imagine your wedding filmed by the people who know you best - your friends and family. With Press Record Co, we ship you our camcorders to capture every laugh, tear, and dance move, then you simply send it back to us to do the heavy lifting. We'll turn all your raw footage into a beautiful, nostalgic Modern Day Home Video® you'll actually love to rewatch. It's raw, real, and totally you.

Awarded Best of Zola
Truly a white-glove service! We decided to use Press Record Co for our wedding after deciding against a traditional videographer, and looking back, it was one of the best decisions we made. What makes Press Record Co so special is that it allowed us to experience our wedding day through the eyes of our friends and family. The candid moments, genuine reactions, and little memories that might have otherwise gone unnoticed ended up being some of our favorite parts of the final video. When we received our edited film, we were blown away. It perfectly captured the joy, emotion, and energy of the day in a way that felt authentic to us. We've already watched it multiple times and know it will be something we treasure for years to come. If you're on the fence about hiring a videographer or looking for a more personal and affordable option, we can't recommend Press Record Co enough. The entire team was fantastic, and we're so grateful to have these memories preserved in such a unique way.
Alyssa & M., 3 months ago
Quick responder
Made with Love Co. | Super 8 Videography 
Rating: 5.0 (9 reviews)
  • Vintage style
  • Starts at $2,350
  • Serves Shelter Island, NY

Made With Love Co. creates wedding films that feel like a love letter come to life. Super 8 brings a certain kind of magic—soft frames, bursts of light, and a dreamy rhythm that makes every laugh, kiss, and happy tear feel cinematic. It’s imperfect in the most beautiful way, capturing love stories with the same warmth and whimsy as the people living them. With Super 8, fleeting moments don’t just pass by—they become little time capsules, stitched together with heart and nostalgia.

Awarded Best of Zola
Sam truly exceeded our expectations and created a film we will cherish until the end of time. She made sure to capture every important moment of the day and compiled them all beautifully. She was easy to communicate with and would respond quickly. On the wedding day she made everything feel natural and had great vision for ideas to capture. I would recommend Made With Love Co. over and over again ti everyone! The final video was everything and more we could ever ask for. We are so grateful for her and her talent!
Lindsay P., 4 months ago
Rose Gold Films 
Rating: 5.0 (6 reviews)
  • Vintage style
  • Starts at $4,000
  • Serves Shelter Island, NY

I've been filming weddings for over 5 years now and to this day I love being behind the lens and getting creative with each unique wedding. Capturing lifelong memories, that you'd be able to playback with your family and friends for many more years to come!

Awarded Best of Zola
We are beyond thrilled with how our wedding footage turned out! We had Rose Gold Films for our welcome party, catamaran rehearsal day, ceremony, and reception. Every single moment was filmed so beautifully and authentically for lifelong memories. Our guests are so obsessed with the final product we watched it over and over again. From the start, communication was seamless. She really took the time to understand my vision and was incredibly patient and receptive to my (very Type A!) feedback during the editing process. I felt heard, supported, and most importantly..happy with the final result. She offered great suggestions and made adjustments with such care and professionalism, and I truly felt like she wanted it to be perfect for us. We’ll be reliving our favorite memories for years to come thanks to her talent. I can’t recommend Rose Gold Films enough!
Dena O., a year ago
TrendlineTrending
YouFilm Weddings 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Vintage style
  • Starts at $299
  • Serves Shelter Island, NY

A fun, candid alternative to traditional wedding videography. Your favorite people capture the laughs, happy tears, behind-the-scenes moments, and dance floor chaos on easy-to-use camcorders, and we turn it all into the wedding home movie you’ll watch for years to come. Add a nostalgic touch with our 35mm camera rentals — perfect for candid guest photos, behind-the-scenes moments, and flash-filled memories that feel straight out of a family photo album.

We chose YouFilm Weddings for our wedding and couldn't have been happier with the decision. From our first conversation, they responded quickly to every question we had, which made the planning process smooth and stress-free. On the day of the wedding, their fun video concept had our guests excited to participate and be part of the experience. They delivered our final video on time with a quick turnaround, and honestly, we've watched it so many times already. The video captures all the moments we wanted to relive from our special day and is something we'll cherish forever. We'd recommend YouFilm Weddings to any couple looking for videographers who are responsive, professional, and genuinely fun to work with.
Mary, 5 months ago
Quick responder
Velvet Letters Cinema Co 
Rating: 5.0 (25 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Vintage style
  • Starts at $4,200
  • Serves Shelter Island, NY for additional fees

My goal is to make film videography accessible and memorable for everyone who wants their special moments captured. After learning and teaching Super8 videography for my own elopement and micro-wedding 2 years ago, I wanted to develop my business to offer Super8 to all! I specialize in couples, elopements, and micro-weddings. My average pricing depends on the event type, duration, and details!

Awarded Best of Zola
I have worked with Kiley several times in the wedding industry. Her creative spark isn’t just in the super8 filming. She has assisted me as a wedding coordinator, as well as my colleagues in florals. She has perfect attention to detail, a flare for design, and is always keeping up on event trends. She is professional and wonderful to work with. Her customer service shines as she is so good at making her clients feel at ease, since she is just super sweet and generally fun to be around.
Nikki H., 2 years ago
GemHidden gem
American Rose Films 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Vintage style
  • Starts at $12,000
  • Serves Shelter Island, NY for additional fees

American Rose Films is a motion picture wedding studio led by Justin and Steph, partners in life and work. Based in Connecticut and traveling widely, they are drawn to the art of noticing. Their films, made primarily using 16mm & Super 8mm analog film, capture the texture and feeling of a day as it unfolds. Each frame is exposed to light & developed through a chemical process. The result is a wedding film that feels like a memory.

Awarded Best of Zola
Easy to work with, create beautiful videos, include the unique super 8 film. All around awesome!
Kristen Beck, 5 years ago
TrendlineTrending
Vinty Media 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Vintage style
  • Starts at $1,200
  • Serves Shelter Island, NY for additional fees

VINTY is a brand new cinematic & vintage mixed-media company founded by Parris and Randolph — a newlywed couple now proudly operating out of Raleigh-Durham, NC. After meeting over a decade ago in New York, our story has always been one of artistry, love, and timeless moments. We capture events and everyday beauty using vintage and traditional formats like: * 2000's (Y2K) Camcorders * 90's Camcorders * Super 8 film * Polaroid-style Film photography * 360 Virtual Reality Video * 4k Cinematic HD * & More.

Awarded Best of Zola
We brought VINTY in to handle all the vintage coverage for one of our couples, and they were incredible to work with from start to finish. Their communication was effortless — relaxed, genuine, and always honest — which made collaborating on a busy wedding day feel easy.
David R., 10 months ago
Newlywed Films 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Vintage style
  • Serves Shelter Island, NY for additional fees

Your wedding won’t feel like a highlight reel while you’re living it. It will be a blur of people you love, conversations, nerves, laughter, music, and little moments you may not even notice until later. Newlywed Films creates wedding films that bring all of that back. We pair beautiful, cinematic imagery with real audio, candid moments, and nostalgic, archival-inspired textures to create something that feels less like a recap of the day and more like a memory of actually being there. Based in Philadelphia and available for weddings wherever your story takes you.

Quick responder
Wedding Love Film Retro Wedding Films. 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Vintage style
  • Starts at $850
  • Serves Shelter Island, NY for additional fees
  • Offer

Hi, I’m Anthony with Wedding Love Film. I create nostalgic, retro-inspired wedding films featuring Digital Super 8, 1930s–1970s film-inspired looks, and 1990s/early-2000s camcorder vibes. Every package includes both a highlight and full-length wedding film—no need to purchase them separately. You get the fun retro look while preserving the full story of your day. Send me your rough timeline, including coverage start/end, ceremony, and reception times, and I’ll recommend the most affordable package that fits your wedding.

Working with Wedding Love Film and Anthony Hagen was honestly one of the best decisions we made for our wedding. From the very first conversation, Anthony really took the time to get to know us—not just what we wanted in a wedding film, but who we are as a couple. He listened, understood our vision, and made us feel completely comfortable the entire time. The Super 8 film he created for us is beyond anything we could have imagined. Using vintage cinema lenses and a Super 8 film camera, Anthony brought such a timeless, authentic feel to our wedding video. It’s like stepping back in time, and every little moment—our laughter, the way we looked at each other, the energy of the day—was captured perfectly. Watching it takes us right back to that incredible day, and we get teary-eyed every time. Anthony is more than just a filmmaker; he’s a storyteller who truly cares. If you want someone who will listen to you, understand your vision, and create something that feels authentic to your love story, Wedding Love Film is the way to go. Thank you, Anthony, for giving us a film that we’ll cherish forever!
Anna T., 2 years ago
Super Joy 
Rating: 5.0 (2 reviews)
  • Vintage style
  • Starts at $1,750
  • Serves Shelter Island, NY

Super Joy specializes in analog wedding videography, which means we capture your big day on glorious Super 8 film. After an initial chat and some check-ins along the way, I'll show up on your wedding day with my cameras and enough film to capture every tender and goofy moment (and everything in between). I take a fly-on-the-wall approach, which basically means you won't get anything staged from me. Think vintage home movies on a cinematic level.

My husband and I were over the moon when we received our wedding film from Super Joy! We didn't know exactly what to expect as neither of us were super familiar with Super 8 film (pun intended), but the results were outstanding. It turns out everything looks better on film! It doesn't hurt that Finley is also such a sweetheart and made everything so seamless and easy for us.
Kim, 2 years ago
TwentyTen Productions 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Vintage style
  • Starts at $1,000
  • Serves Shelter Island, NY for additional fees

My name is Travis and TwentyTen Productions is my filmmaking and videography production company. I know what it takes to move people through filmmaking, how to capture not only the image of the day, but the feelings and emotions. You won't just see your wedding film, you'll feel it. I don't bother with gimmicks and tricks. I'm not trying to be the next big thing. I just have a passion for storytelling through film and I have found that weddings have some of the most beautiful stories in the world. I want to tell your story.

We worked with Travis at a wedding recently and he was super easy going yet very professional. His work is top notch and we highly recommend his company.
DJKO_YO, 3 years ago