Affordable Wedding Caterers in Old Mystic, CT

Affordable Wedding Caterers in Old Mystic, CT

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


34 Wedding Caterers in Old Mystic, CT

Up to $2,000
Available on July 18, 2026
Quick responder
Kelli's Kitchen 

5.0

  • Starts at $85
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT

It is our mission at Kelli’s Kitchen to provide you with a wow factor through the elegance of our food, and the excellence of our service. Kelli has been cooking for over 20 years teaching her homeschooled children and their friends how to cook a wide array of culinary delights, from simple, tasteful appetizers to mouthwatering entrees. In that time, Kelli found her joy and artistic ability through food. That same creativity and hospitality is emanated through our food and staff to create a personalized, unforgettable experience at your event.

Awarded Best of Zola
We were so grateful for Kelli’s kitchen at our wedding! They did an amazing job making sure all of our wants were met. They helped with beyond catering and helped us keep on our reception schedule, cleaned up everything and we even paid a small fee and they broke down all the tables and chairs! We still get compliments on the food served and the service itself! Kelli’s kitchen helped us enjoy our wedding day a little extra with the delicious food and peace of mind!
Eve F., 10 months ago
Gourmet Galley Catering 

4.5

  • Serves Old Mystic, CT

We love weddings. We love them big and fancy or sweet and simple. We love brides who agonize over the size of their train, their pearls and their bouquets and we love brides who call up and say, “Let’s have a clambake at my dad’s beach house!” Celebrate everything—family reunions, birthdays, bridal and baby showers, anniversaries, retirement parties and just plain why-not? parties. Whether the whole clan is getting together for a long weekend or you’re having a sit down dinner for 20 just to honor some long and beautiful friendships, let us make the party that suits you.

Jen and her whole team at Gourmet Galley (GG) were amazing! My husband and I felt so taken care of throughout the planning process all the way through to our wedding day. Jen was always quick to communicate and was such a huge help to us from start to finish. She took all of our wants and needs into consideration and had our entire day planned out perfectly. We got a first taste of what GG could do during our tasting event, and we were blown away. We couldn't wait to experience it all again on our wedding day! On the day of the wedding, Jen and her team, along with our venue and florist, set up the entire wedding at the speed of light, and it all looked BEAUTIFUL. Jen took care of everything, and she helped make the day completely stress-free! The food was INCREDIBLE - We received so many compliments throughout the night from our families and friends about the food from cocktail hour, dinner, and dessert (wedding tip: always order the lobster rolls for your cocktail hour). GG had a designated person who made sure we were always fed and had something to drink (she was the sweetest!). I can't recommend GG enough. Jen really took care of us and helped everything move swiftly and smoothly, and the food was out of this world!
Kathleen C., 14 days ago
TrendlineTrending
SHMAYLEYS Mobile Events Bar 

5.0

  • Starts at $1,500
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT

Welcome to Shmayleys Mobile Events Bar, your all-inclusive event experience. We are your top choice for all-in-one event solutions. For a party & partnership to get excited about, inquire within. Event Planning: We specialize in creating memorable events. An inviting experience, bringing your celebration to life. Photo Booth: Capture your memories and all the fun in our photo booth! Dessert + Munchies: We offer an Ice Cream + Desserts Bar, alongside a Sweet and Savory Munchies Bar. Mobile Cocktail: From classic favorites to innovative creations, our bar adds sophistication and excitement to your event.

Awarded Best of Zola
We absolutely loved our experience with Shmayleys! We used their photo booth for our wedding and it was so much fun and such a hit with all our friends and family. The staff was so helpful from start to finish. They were all so pleasant to work with and really helped make our night extra fun :)
Vanessa R., 2 years ago
Quick responder
Emery's Catering 

4.4

  • Starts at $65
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT

With over 50 years of experience, Emery’s Catering has been a choice caterer for events throughout Rhode Island, Southeastern Massachusetts and Eastern Connecticut. From a small event of 10 or a celebration of 500, we are known to provide excellent service, delicious cuisine and a beautiful presentation. Call us, and we will undoubtedly prove to you that choosing Emery’s Catering is the first step in creating a successful and memorable event.

We were planning a Rhode Island wedding from out of state and went with Emery's for our caterer. We worked with Liz who was very helpful and always responded timely to my [many] questions and requests. They were very familiar with our venue and the other vendors that we used so they were able to make sure the night went smoothly and dinner was served timely. Liz set up my decorations exactly as I wanted (granted, there was not much) and the room looked beautiful. The staff and servers were excellent and extremely attentive to me and my husband all night. All of the guests were impressed by the food and overall had a great experience.
Megan P., 10 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Artisan Bites 

5.0

  • Starts at $250
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT

Locally curated, artfully designed Artisan Bites is a gourmet charcuterie company based in Rhode Island, offering grazing tables, corporate and private workshops, charcuterie boards and custom orders. We take pride in curating the finest selection of meats, cheeses, and accompaniments to create a memorable experience for any occasion.

Awarded Best of Zola
Ashley is the best! Iv used her for many events and her work is always top notch. Highly recommend!! The presentation is always so beautiful and her communication is 10/10.
Tory R., a year ago
Quick responder
Bellissimo Boards Mobile Charcuterie Bar 

5.0

  • Starts at $1
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT

We are a mobile charcuterie bar that is the perfect addition to your wedding! Give your guests the interactive experience of creating their charcuterie board to enjoy at your wedding. Pick from a custom list of ingredients that you would like guests to choose from at your event, and leave the rest to us! We handle all setup, cleaning, and delivery, so you can worry about your special day.

Awarded Best of Zola
Sara at Bellissimo Boards goes above and beyond to create beautiful charcuterie boards for any occasion. She brings my requests and visions to life with every order. She is super responsive and easy to work with. I would recommend Bellissimo boards for any occasion, big or small.
Jessica Alvarnas , a year ago
TrendlineTrending
La Mila Catering & Events 

5.0

  • Starts at $75
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT

Starting their careers in the restaurant and food industry, Elie & Heidi Hanna decided to utilize their unique experiences and create their own vision of a full service event company. La Mila is named after their daughter, Milana, who provides them with limitless inspiration and motivation.

Awarded Best of Zola
As a classically trained chef, I hope my review of La Mila inspires anyone doing their “homework” to earn an A — for themselves, especially their guests. I’ve been to many weddings, and the food served is often an edible afterthought. How many times, when leaving a wedding, were you asked, “What did you think about the food?” — and you replied with shrugged shoulders, “Eh, it was okay.” That is not the case with La Mila. A huge shoutout and thank you to Sandy, who was able to pull together a phenomenal menu all in a very timely timeline. Sandy was honest, upfront, and available around our busy work schedule. The day before and the day of, Sandy was there to help with setup — from the big asks, like helping move furniture, to the small tasks—like lighting lanterns and ensuring no glass of champagne for our toast was served empty! Given our wedding took place at our home, we thoroughly appreciated Sandy staying late to clean the kitchen, empty overflowing garbage, and make sure our home was not a war zone when we woke up the next morning! Elie’s execution of our menu was stellar. As a classically trained chef, I was thoroughly impressed by the well-run machine Elie could create within our garage, the makeshift kitchen for the event. It rained on our wedding day, and we were blessed with a beautiful, vivid rainbow—right before dinner service. This blessing brought all our guests outside for 30 minutes—right before dinner. A major wrench in the moment-by-moment timeline. I know how this, for many chefs, can be a disruptive, unexpected delay—but Elie did not miss a beat. All of our guests raved about the food—notably friends who I graduated with from the Culinary Institute of America. One thing I learned in culinary school is that you “eat with your eyes first.” Simply put, Heidi’s presentation skills are on point! Her attention to detail in creating beautiful food displays, notably for our cocktail hour, showed the care, thought and love we wanted our guests to feel. Sandy, Elie, and Heidi may be the stars of La Mila’s show—but the success of our wedding would not have been possible without their hard-working and friendly staff. One of the elements that sold us on choosing La Mila, was their well-stocked arsenal of kitchen equipment they brought on site. (Most caterers require you rent equipment separately, which is not only more expensive, but introduces a whole new dimension of moving parts.) La Mila was also able to include chinaware, silverware, and the majority of our glassware! They even included soft drinks, water, condiments, cocktail napkins, etc. — all of this, and they still came in under what we were quoted by other caterers. Thank you, Sandy, Elie, Heidi, and the entire La Mila Catering & Events team, for making our wedding day what it was. Your talent, professionalism, and experience were felt by everyone who took part in our special day.
Jordan R. S., 8 months ago
Quick responder
Emily's Catering Group 

5.0

  • Serves Old Mystic, CT

Emily's Catering Group is a full-service catering and event planning company. The creative team and gourmet chefs work individually with you to create a customized menu matching your preferences and tastes. They will design distinctive party themes with visually stunning presentation to match your wedding style. ECG specializes in creating delectable, flavorful cuisine using the highest quality of fresh and seasonal ingredients. The event production team plans custom invitations, wedding cakes, décor, entertainment and everything in between. The personalized care at ECG is unmatched and will exceed the expectations of you and your guests.

Awarded Best of Zola
Emily's Catering Group is the best! Rick is an incredible chef and visionary for a good party! Our guests couldn't stop raving about the BLT station, cocktail hour spread, and the dinner itself. Several guests commented on how nice it was so have salads served immediately upon sitting down. These little details are what set ECG apart. Everything went so smoothly - from our initial call with Rick, to our tasting with our parents, and all of the communications in between with Cheryl - Emily's Catering Group is so professional and thorough. We were able to focus on having fun and enjoying our guests - it was obvious that that they could handle any situations that came their way, even in an outdoor cook tent at a family home! Would give even more than 5 stars if we could!
Kristen F., 8 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Glad Mouf 

5.0

  • Starts at $1,875
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT

Glad Mouf BBQ – Unforgettable Flavor for Your Special Day At Glad Mouf BBQ, we believe every wedding deserves unforgettable food that brings people together. We specialize in craft barbecue with a gourmet twist, featuring the world’s most tender smoked oxtails, melt-in-your-mouth brisket, juicy smoked chicken, brisket tacos —all paired with our legendary sauces. We offer catering with a choice of station-style service with pre-portioned servings or a buffet. Enjoy a special rate of $50 per person for 100+ guests or $75 per person with a 50-guest minimum. Our customizable menu allows you to create the perfect meal for your wedding vision.

We hired Glad Mouf to cater our holiday party, serving 100 guests.From start to finish, their team was professional, organized, and accommodating. The booking process was seamless, and he worked with us to create a custom menu that fit our theme. We chose a mix of passed appetizers, and a plated dinner. The oxtails and were incredibly tender, and the brisket was a huge hit! On the day of the event, the catering team arrived early, set up beautifully, and ensured everything ran smoothly. Not only was the food delicious,the pricing was fair for the quality, and there were no unexpected costs. Overall,Glad Mouf exceeded our expectations, and we highly recommend them for ANY special event. We'll definitely be using them again for future gatherings!
Corey, 4 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Big Green Truck Pizza 

5.0

  • Starts at $1,300
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT

Welcome to Big Green Truck Pizza! For more than 20 years, we have delighted customers all over Connecticut with delicious pizza served in an attractive, fun atmosphere. Our specially outfitted trucks are genuine antiques equipped with wood-fired brick ovens, tables, and all the ingredients needed to bring a buffet of New Haven pizza to your backyard. We pride ourselves on the quality, variety, and convenience of our pizza, and specialize in bringing a fun, professional atmosphere to every occasion.

We had an incredible experience with Big Green Truck Pizza at our Wedding Welcome Event! Renting their pizza truck was one of the best decisions we made. The entire process was smooth and enjoyable from start to finish. The team from Big Green Truck Pizza was professional, friendly, and exceptionally accommodating. They arrived on time and set up efficiently, bringing their signature charm and enthusiasm that immediately engaged our guests. The smell of their delicious pizzas filled the air, setting the perfect tone for a fun and relaxed event. The variety of pizzas they offered was fantastic, with something to please every palate. Each slice was made with high-quality ingredients and cooked to perfection—crispy crusts, flavorful toppings, and mouthwatering cheese. The salad and gelato included made it a no brainer for us! We were looking forward to espresso and cappuccino but I don’t think they brought it to our event. But no one noticed because our guests couldn’t stop raving about how amazing the food was! They even brought gluten free crusts and made them dairy free for my MIL. The unique experience of having a pizza truck added a fun, interactive element to our event that everyone enjoyed. Big Green Truck Pizza truly elevated our welcome event, and we couldn’t be happier with their service. A huge thank you to the team for helping us kick off our wedding weekend celebrations!
Mr & M., 10 months ago
TrendlineTrending
RGKkitchen 

5.0

  • Starts at $1,500
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT

We are Stephen and Rae! We met as teenagers in 2007 and married in 2012. We originally started college together in PA when Stephen encouraged me to pursue me passion in cooking. We moved to MA for me to attend Le Cordon Bleu while Stephen studied law. We settled here permanently after graduation. In 2020 I started RGKkitchen. Working together came naturally and quickly took off. Our most popular areas are Cape Cod, Boston, Newport/Middletown, & Narragansett. We service all of RI, the MA coast, and down to Mystic, CT. We typically travel within 80 miles of 02748 but do go further for some events. We're happy to accommodate if we can!

Working with Rae, Stephen and their team was so much fun from start to finish. We had a wonderful tasting where they made us feel right at home (fell in *love* with the food) and then did everything they could do to make our day perfect. We had a LOT of pivots to make (hellllllo, rainy day) and they both handled everything flawlessly and went above & beyond with everything. We would work with them again and again, truly great people and very, very talented. Our guests loved everything and couldn't say enough good things. You will absolutely not regret working with these guys – we felt so grateful to have linked with them!
Shae, 5 months ago
Quick responder
Old World Pizza Truck 

5.0

  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT

We started Old World Pizza Truck with our beloved old '42 Chevy, built and designed with a passion for entertaining and food in mind. Our fleet consists of four international diesel trucks, ready to serve both local and long range parties all across Connecticut, parts of New York, and Massachusetts. All trucks have basically the same equipment including powerful sound systems for those of you that like music at your affairs. They all are self sufficient with onboard generators, coolers, freezers and running water. No matter which truck is sent, the total experience is the same- great food, great music, lots of fun and unsurpassed service!

We were so pleased with the service we received from Old World Pizza Truck for our wedding. From the very first interaction, their team was kind, understanding, and incredibly flexible with all of our requests. They were easy to work with, affordable, and provided unforgettable food that our guests are still raving about. The pizza and other menu items were of the highest quality, and the staff was friendly and attentive throughout the entire event. They were even able to accommodate our last-minute timing changes without any issues. We can confidently say that Old World Pizza Truck is the best pizza truck on the planet, and we would highly recommend them to any couple looking for a unique and delicious catering option for their wedding day.
Ryan R., 5 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Carmela Marie 

5.0

  • Starts at $1
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT

Connecticut caterer serving throughout the state including New Haven, West Haven, Hartford, Litchfield, West Hartford counties as well as on-site. We offer several menu options to choose from including food choices for soy, nuts, gluten, kiwi, fruit, and dairy allergies. Vegetarian and keto options are available.

Carmela Marie was an absolute delight to work with for our wedding catering. From the very first call, their team was incredibly responsive, caring, and attentive to all of our questions and requests. We felt like we were part of their family throughout the entire planning process. On the day of the wedding, the owners themselves came to help and made sure to check in on us regularly to ensure everything was going smoothly. The food was absolutely delicious and their staff was professional and friendly. We could not have asked for a better catering experience - Carmela Marie truly helped make our wedding day perfect.
Savannah D., 9 months ago
Quick responder
Ginger Man Catering And Private Chef Service 
  • Starts at $1,700
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT

Ginger Man Catering is a Glatt Kosher catering company in NYC formed by Chef Oren to offer custom Kosher catering and personalized service to our clients, while based in NYC, Chef Oren and his exemplary team will travel throughout New York City, Long Island, Hamptons, New Jersey and Connecticut area to create your specialized event in your home or at the venue of your choice. Ginger Man Kosher Catering NYC will work directly with you to ensure every detail of your events fulfills your expectations and results in a successful and pleasurable event.

Seasonal Catering 
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT

We’re sorry we cannot contact you directly through the Zola site. They have recently moved to a mandatory pay-to-talk-to-client system. We would be happy to talk to you about your upcoming wedding. Please get in touch with us directly via our website, Thank you! A family-operated Farm to Table small business known for quality food and service. Our expert mixologists provide exceptional craft cocktails, local beer, and even local wines for you to enjoy with our fully licensed and insured bar services. We have personalized wedding experiences for couples on local farms, mansions, rustic barns, warehouses, theaters, and even backyards!

Quick responder
Sips on the Hudson Mobile Bar and Mini Pancakes 

5.0

  • Starts at $500
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT for additional fees

Indulge in the Mobile Bar and Dessert Experience. We specialize in Handcrafted Cocktails and delicious made-to-order Mini Pancakes. Our minis are the perfect Wedding add-on for cocktail hour or the night cap. We use local ingredients for our Cocktails and our services can be combined or separated upon request. Packages can be customized to fit your needs. Contact us for affordable pricing.

This company is absolutely Amazing in every aspect. My guests loved their cocktails and flapjacks. From the moment they got to the venue you their high energy and good vibes showed. The owner even made unexpected mocktails for the kids and refused to charge me. The trailer is adorable and they are affordable. I highly recommend them to anyone.
Jennifer C., a year ago
Quick responder
Sara’s Event Services 

5.0

  • Starts at $150
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT for additional fees
  • Offer

Cooking and creating meals for others has been my passion for as long as I can remember. My dream began watching food network instead of cartoons as a small child and finding myself inspired to pursue a career in culinary arts. I’ve worked for years in hospitality and now I get share my love of cooking on a more personal level, creating custom meals for families and friends to enjoy together. I love food because it connects people and helps create memories that will last a lifetime. I look forward to bringing my passion, creativity, and years of experience to your next special event or celebration.

Sara's Event Services was a fantastic catering choice for our office event. From our first interaction, the team was prompt, friendly, and professional in their communication. On the day of, they arrived on time and with great attention to detail, ensuring the entire event ran smoothly. The food they served was delicious, and their friendly attitude helped create a special and memorable experience for us and all our guests. We highly recommend Sara's Event Services to anyone looking for a top-notch catering team to make their event perfect.
Elise, 3 months ago
Quick responder
Ben's Raclette 

5.0

  • Starts at $1,499
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT for additional fees

Transport your guests to the Alps with Ben's Raclette! Since 2023, Ben Piscopo has specialized in serving crispy, gooey Alpine cheese scraped onto fresh baguette with seasonal accompaniments right in front of guests. Ben was raised in New England’s snowy mountains with a deep appreciation of Alpine cuisine. After visiting his grandmother’s birthplace in Switzerland, he sought to capture the essence of visiting the Alps through a decadent food experience. He makes sure that every bite of raclette is a true taste of the Alps. En Guete! (Bon appétit!)

I recently hired Ben's Raclette to serve at my engagement party at my home, and I couldn't be happier with the experience! Ben was super responsive and detail-oriented from the start, which made me feel confident that everything would go smoothly. And it did! The raclette was a huge hit with my guests - the freshly melted cheese on baguette was so delicious, and the honey version was a surprise favorite. I loved that Ben's Raclette offered a unique and interactive experience that added to the fun and celebratory atmosphere of the party. I would definitely hire Ben again for a similar gathering - he's professional, reliable, and serves up amazing food! :)
Diane B., 2 months ago
Quick responder
Mill Creek Catering & Events 
  • Starts at $75
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT for additional fees

Mill Creek Catering & Events is a premiere, full-service, off-premise caterer & event coordinator specializing in elegant, boutique weddings with a personalized touch. We are known for our inspirational, one of a kind events in spectacular locations with unsurpassed service. We help you to plan unique, seasonal menus designed to fit your vision and personal style, including cultural and ethnic trends. Our focus is on sustainability, and when possible, we use locally sourced ingredients. Our culinary team can accommodate an array of dietary needs.

Quick responder
Wing It On Wheels 
  • Starts at $1,200
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT for additional fees

Every wing experience at WIO starts with fresh, never-frozen, all natural chicken wings free of hormones and steroids. Once ordered, we cook your wings fresh and crispy then give them a toss in our award-winning flavors

Greekin' Out 

5.0

  • Starts at $1,000
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT

DID YOU SAY PARTY? We'll bring the ouzo! “What does real Greek food taste like?” People ask us this all the time. Here’s what we like to tell them: Real, authentic, close-your-eyes-and-you’re-there Greek food tastes like the salty air drifting off the Aegean Sea. Like oregano plucked from your mother’s garden. Like the sunrise over the Acropolis. Sound like something you’d like to taste more often? Get in touch - we’ll bring enough for everyone.

We hired Greekin’ Out for our wedding and could not have had a better experience. Not only was the food to die for but Sarah and Niko were absolutely incredible to work with. They were all the things you need and want from a vendor, responsive, accommodating, sincere, very reasonably priced and reliable. One of the biggest compliments we got on our wedding was the food and how friendly they were to all of our guests.
Felicia and S., 4 years ago
Charcu Catery 

5.0

  • Starts at $39
  • Serves Old Mystic, CT

At Charcu, we specialize in creating a unique social and culinary experience that is sure to give both you and your guests a sense of indulgence, elegance, and overall enjoyment. We work with every couple to create customized Charcuterie Grazing Tablescapes that are guaranteed to be show-stoppers -- truly edible art. Each Tablescape is unique, featuring hand selected locally sourced charcuterie, cheeses, artisanal bread, as well as fresh seasonal produce. So -- gather your friends and family and pick your favorite drink, as our style of catering naturally invites socializing and conversation until the last bite is enjoyed!

Charcu Catery stole the show at my Bridal shower! You expect delicious food and service from your caterer, but rarely do you see one that becomes the talking point and centerpiece of the event. I didn't know what to expect from the term "edible art" but seeing is believing. A caterer and service unlike any I have used in the past. Charcu gave me an unbelievable culinary experience and one I will not forget!
Morgan T., 4 years ago

Location flexible? Discover caterers near Old Mystic, CT

About wedding caterers in Old Mystic, CT

What types of caterers are in Old Mystic, CT?

What other Old Mystic vendors will I need?

What other caterers are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?