The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Nutley, NJ

We specialize in cakes and other sweets. Whether you are looking for a cake, a dessert table, or dessert favors we do it all! All of our desserts are made from scratch with the highest quality of ingredients.

Hi there! I’m Joey, the owner and cake artist behind Joeycakes Custom Cakes & Confections. First off, congratulations on your engagement! Planning a wedding is such an exciting adventure, and I’m honored to play a part in creating sweet memories for your big day. My journey into the world of cakes began with a love for baking that I nurtured into a career by attending culinary school, where I graduated in 2023. It was there that I discovered my passion for cake decorating. I quickly fell in love with the process of turning simple ingredients into edible works of art that not only taste amazing but also tell a story—your story.

With Big Day, Small Budget Cakes every couple can have a cake that brings cheer and warmth to their big day without sacrificing beauty, flavor, or your entire savings. You’ll be working directly with me, Allie, on creating the best cake for your budget. Whether it’s a simple cake for 25 guests or a large four-tier cake with embellishments, I have affordable options for you. You’re in good hands! I’ve baked and decorated cakes for over 10 years, and I’m still hooked! I began my journey training at ICE in New York City and worked at celebrated bakeries, including The Chocolate Room, Balthazar, and Billy’s Bakery.

David’s Custom Cakes is a specialty cake shop that will make your cake dreams come true! We will help you to design a beautiful, delicious work of art that will be the centerpiece of your event. Our experienced decorators specialize in buttercream and fondant designs and can create a stunning and creative cake that will suit your vision.

My Daughter's Cakes was founded in 2009 based on my desire to elevate the wedding cake experience for couples and their families. Our belief is that a wedding cake should be the most beautiful and delicious centerpiece of your reception, an artistic expression that plays an important role with your main meal. A long-remembered ‘wow factor’ for the eyes and taste buds for you and your guests.

We are a husband and wife team of pastry chefs who made our own chocolate favors for our wedding and got such good feedback. We offer handcrafted chocolates for favors, gifts and dessert displays. We have a background in fine dining restaurants and high end bakeries. We love the craft of making chocolates and bringing them to couples for their events.

Welcome to Tasty Glam Treats! As treat maker, I am truly passionate about adding a touch of sweetness and elegance to life's most special moments. Creating these treats is more than just a business for me—it's a therapeutic and joyful experience. I absolutely love the process of bringing creative ideas to life, from selecting the perfect colors and ribbons to ensuring every treat is as beautiful as it is delicious. It's truly a labor of love, and nothing brings me more joy than seeing the smiles on my clients' faces. Although I haven't had my business for as long as others I am dedicated to providing top-notch service for my customers.

A French-inspired cake studio and artisanal bakery creating handcrafted desserts for life’s most beautiful moments. ​ At Victoria’s Cake, we bring together the art of French baking and the elegance of custom dessert design. From delicate pastries made fresh daily to beautifully curated dessert tables, every creation is crafted with care, precision, and passion.

Mother Fudgers prides itself on making bite-sized fudge in a variety of flavors!... all served with a cheeky attitude! We've got typical flavors such as chocolate, vanilla, cookies & cream, and artisanal flavors such as birthday cake, lemon vanilla, and ube!

Hi, I’m MJ, founder of Toasty Polvo—where we reimagine and elevate Filipino polvoron for modern celebrations. Made with browned butter and crafted in small batches in Union, NJ, our rich, crumbly shortbread bites add a nostalgic yet elevated touch to your event. Perfect for wedding favors, dessert tables, or welcome bags, each piece brings comfort, culture, and joy. Women-owned and rooted in tradition, Toasty Polvo is proud to offer custom options to make your day even more special—one buttery bite at a time.

Butter Babe creates custom decorated sugar cookies for all occasions. We specialize in matching themes for anything from birthdays to bridal shower favors to custom cookie wedding seat place settings!

Hi, I’m Waleska, the heart and hands behind WC Sweet Treats Company. This business was born from love; love for creating beauty, celebrating life and most of all, love for my son. He’s been my greatest inspiration, reminding me every day that even the smallest moments deserve to feel magical. I believe life’s most precious moments deserve to be celebrated with warmth, intention, and a touch of magic. Creating isn’t just my job it’s my therapy, my joy, and my way of helping others feel celebrated, seen, and special. I’m here to help bring it to life with warmth, intention, and a whole lot of love Let’s create something unforgettable, together

Indulge in the artistry of Lady Caketh cakes for your every event. As a passionate cake artist, I transform cake into an art form. My cakes are more than just desserts; they are bespoke works of art tailored to your every event. Elevate your birthdays, weddings, dinner parties, grand openings, photoshoots, installations, brand marketing, exhibits and more. I would be honored to collaborate with you and add an extra layer of delight to your upcoming events through the art of cake.

I started Everything Just Baked because I no longer wanted to choose between a beautiful cake or a delicious cake! With Everything Just Baked we take pride in having both a masterpiece on the outside and inside. We specialize in custom cakes and would love to create a piece of art you will remember for the rest of your life!

We specialize in Custom Dessert Bar Displays and 100% Customizable Celebration Cakes. Dessert Ladies Events! From a masterpiece cake centerpiece, perfectly complimented by our coordinating bite sized desserts like our Signature Bien Tree Sculptures, to fully decorating the event space to create a transformative experience for your guests or employees, and even staffing for your special occasion to create a seamless party experience! Our full service, one stop shopping, Dessert Table displays can be customized for every theme and event including, anniversary milestones, promotional parties, open house features, weddings, showers and more!

Welcome For the past 2 years, Cake + Flourish has been making hand-crafted delights the old-fashioned way: from scratch, in small batches, and with the finest ingredients and techniques. We offer custom tiered cakes, cupcakes, iced sugar cookies, and a host of other pastries, seasonal treats, and more.

88 Degrees Chocolate is a New Jersey-based boutique chocolatier specializing in handcrafted Belgian chocolate favors, bonbon collections, and personalized edible gifts for weddings, showers, and special celebrations. We create elegant chocolate pieces designed to match your event theme, colors, and vision. From custom place cards to luxury favor boxes, every detail is made to impress your guests and create unforgettable moments.

Bovella’s Pastry Shoppe, a staple of the Westfield NJ community, has maintained a standard of excellence in culinary artistry for over 60 years. Bovella’s, long considered one of the premiere bakeries in the Tri-State area, has flourished behind an outstanding crew of chefs, bakers, and personnel. Ralph Bencivenga, owner and operator, was a Westfield High School student when he began his tenure at the bakery for founder Michael Bove. Bovella’s is no longer simply a bakery. It is now a destination… a place to sit and enjoy a coffee, espresso, or dessert after an evening at one of Westfield’s 100+ eateries.

Welcome to Off The Wall Donuts, where we make every celebration a little sweeter with our custom designed, handcrafted Donut Walls & Displays. Owned and operated by John and Kate Emmets, our company embodies a perfect blend of fun, elegance, and classic charm. Each and every donut wall is a testament to our commitment to creativity and style, and results in a delightful experience for our clients and their guests. Whether it's a wedding, birthday party, corporate event, or any special occasion, our hand-created donut walls are designed to elevate each event and satisfy our client and their guests' sweet cravings.

One visit to Glaze Donuts will have you convinced that our team members are practically magicians! And it’s the highest-quality ingredients that make our donut varieties so delectable. Taste the freshest fruit, milk, and flour, and all the love, with every mouth-watering bite! Our small team crafts thousands of unique and delicious donuts by hand every day!

Welcome to Chic Sugars, where your sweetest ideas come to life! We are a custom cake and treats boutique dedicated to turning your special moments into delicious masterpieces. We offer a wide variety of flavors, and our Google reviews are filled with customers sharing not only how beautiful our cakes are, but how delicious they taste.

I’m Tara Barbera-Brown, owner of the Sugar Stylist! I have been working in the hospitality business since I was 18 years old and have always loved sweets, whether it be baking for my family and friends, creating a candy bar for a special event or just sharing my secret stash of fun dip with my nieces and nephews at various family events. I recently turned my love for all things sugar into a business of my own and I am so grateful for all of the support we have received so far. I am so happy to be sharing my passion with you and appreciate the opportunity to create something special for the happiest moments of your lives! ​

Babka Bailout began as a way to help a friend struggling to make rent and feed her family during the pandemic. When founder/owner Michal Prevor learned about a fellow mom’s desperation, she immediately opened her heart, rolled up her sleeves and began baking towards a brighter future. Michal’s “babka fundraiser” facebook post quickly covered her friend Carmen’s expenses and soon evolved into Babka Bailout - a booming babka business committed to changing the world one babka at a time.

Traveling cake decorator who also does work international. Master baker and owner of Rum Cake Lab. Specializing in Jamaican rum cake but also bakes other products and flavors. It’s my passion. Business grew tremendously after i opened in 2019. Had to expand after only 6 months of being in business. Looking forward to working with couples who fell in love !

I Smell Icing’s Lead Decorator, Kelly Dubé is a sweets enthusiast and avid creative cake builder. She first got her start in cake-making when learning the tricks of the trade from her great aunt at a young age. Kelly is dedicated to seeing your cake idea come to life.

Stuff by SJ launched as a virtual bakeshop making custom cakes, baked goods & chocolate treats using social media as the primary conduit to interact with our customers. Because of the overwhelming support of our community and high demand for our goods, we were able to grow & open our first brick & mortar location in 2022. We strive to connect with the community providing homemade, artisan baked goods specifically designed for each client. ​

We are a boutique confectionery operating out of Livingston, NJ. We love our community, take pride in our creations, and value our customers. We offer free delivery, shipping, and curb-side pick-up. All purchases can be made 100% online. ..

Premium cannoli, hand-piped by The Don himself! We make cannoli you can't refuse, featuring handmade shells imported from Sicily and fresh cannoli cream prepared for the day of your event. Our lavish cannoli concierge service is perfect for weddings, backyard birthdays, holiday parties, corporate events, and more!

At Vici Design, we believe your wedding cake should be more than just a dessert. It's a reflection of your unique love story, a centerpiece that adds a touch of elegance and sweetness to your celebration.

Chocolate Carousel is a family owned and operated bakery and dessert shop located in Wall, NJ. We are proud to partner with some of the finest wedding venues and caterers in the state. Chocolate Carousel is widely known as a leader in the wedding industry having received numerous local and national awards for its work and philanthropy. Chocolate Carousel is known for its beautiful cake creations, creative design concepts, exceptional customer service and quality of product. Chocolate Carousel also offers, custom cookies, favors, groom’s cakes and many more desserts for your shower, rehearsal dinner, wedding and more!