The Best Small Wedding Venues in New Buffalo, MI

The Best Small Wedding Venues in New Buffalo, MI

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


4 Wedding Venues in New Buffalo, MI

Ballrooms, banquet halls
Up to 50 guests
Available on September 13, 2026
Quick responder
Port 393 

4.5

  • Up to 225 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $1,900

Port 393 is a luxury event space in Holland, MI. We have a customizable floor plan and even a rooftop where you and your guests can witness views of Lake Macatawa. Port 393 has a main level reception space with a full bar and catering kitchen, along with a second floor containing a cocktail hour area, full bar & garage door access to the sky view rooftop lounge. Port 393 has a list of catering partners for every event, within every price range making it easy to find amazing vendors! Port 393 is currently booking weddings on Thursday - Sunday. Port 393 has availability for showers, parties, rehearsal and so much more on weekdays as well! Our Offerings: 🥂 Exclusive use of the whole building for the whole day 🥂 Top-of-the-line audio & visual systems 🥂 In house rentals for your convenience 🥂 Access to our proprietary online Guest Portal! 🥂 On-site ceremonies (with 1 hour complimentary rehearsal time) 🥂 Two luxury built in bars 🥂Getting Ready Cove House

Why you'll love this venue

  • Has a dance floor to dance the night away
  • Both indoor and outdoor options
  • Multiple event spaces

Venue considerations

  • Venue feels large for events with small guest lists
  • No in-house lighting and sound packages available
  • Does not allow pets
We had our wedding at Port 393 on December 14, 2024, and it was an absolutely unforgettable experience. Chloe, our wedding planner, was incredibly attentive and had everything under control from start to finish. Her meticulous attention to detail allowed us to relax and truly enjoy our special day. Chloe was always easy to reach and guided us through every step of the planning process. On the day of the wedding, she made sure I had everything I needed and went above and beyond to make the day special. She even took care of loading up the car throughout the night, so we could focus on enjoying time with our family and each other. The decorations were stunning, and the entire venue looked beautiful. I highly recommend letting Port 393 handle all the details—they truly made our wedding everything we had hoped for and more. It was a fun and memorable day, thanks to their exceptional service.
Allie R., 5 months ago
Quick responder
19 North by Froehlich's 

5.0

Three Oaks, MI
  • Up to 350 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor
  • Starts at $35,000

Breathtaking floor to ceiling windows, refinished hardwood floors, handmade farm tables, gold charivari chairs, 8' tall chandelier, built-in custom bar, exposed brick and wood beams & private rooms for your bridal party. 19 North is a gorgeous 11,000 sqft venue located above Froehlich's charming Kitchen & Pantry restaurant. With the original wood floors and over 800 tin ceiling tiles still intact and beautifully restored, this space embodies a rustic opulence that offers couples the feel of a big city event in a quaint village. At the top of the grand staircase in the all-glass foyer, guests will find a tall corridor, flanked by two sets of massive, 12 foot turn-of-the-century doors, leading to a grand ballroom, complete with a show-stopping chandelier.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Has a dance floor for celebration
  • Full catering menu to choose from
  • Private area for the wedding party

Venue considerations

  • Not for you if you are drawn to more unconventional venues
  • Not wheelchair accessible
  • On-site parking not available
My fiancé and I discovered the hidden gem of 19 North by Froehlich's while initially visiting for a delightful breakfast at Froehlich's restaurant. We were thrilled to learn it doubles as a stunning wedding venue! From the grandeur of the 8-foot chandelier and star-like pendant lights to the vintage charm of the ornate tin ceiling tiles, this venue marries historical preservation with modern elegance. The impressive wooden doors promise an unforgettable ceremony entrance, complemented by antique lounge sets and a private entrance through a picturesque glass atrium, perfect for a cocktail hour. The photos I'm including are frames from a video I took during the tour and they simply do not do this beautiful space justice! As a Chicago couple seeking a beautiful wedding without the metropolitan price tag, we were thrilled by 19 North's proximity to Chicago and charming towns like Three Oaks, New Buffalo, and Michigan City. The all-inclusive experience, from the beautiful furnishings to the option of building a custom menu, means fewer details to manage and more time to enjoy the journey to our special day. There are also tons of walkable Airbnbs which will be great for us and our out-of-town guests. The array of options and pricing transparency for catering and staffing have been impressive, reflecting the venue's commitment to ease and excellence. Drew, our point of contact, embodies professionalism and attentiveness, answering every query quickly with patience and insight. For those on the market for a wedding venue that promises a seamless blend of historical allure and contemporary services, look no further. I wholeheartedly recommend scheduling a visit to 19 North by Froehlich's - a true embodiment of vintage elegance and an all-encompassing wedding experience. We eagerly await our wedding day at this enchanting venue and are confident it will create memories that we and our guests will cherish forever!
Layne L., a year ago
Quick responder
Barrelhouse The Venue 

5.0

Michigan City, IN
  • Up to 200 guests
  • Raw space
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $2,500

Constructed in 1871 by Bavarian immigrant Philip H. Zorn Jr., Barrelhouse The Venue resides on the historic Zorn campus. As an annex to the brewery, Barrelhouse The Venue would manufacture beer barrels to house fresh beer prior to distribution around Northwest Indiana. Though unoccupied now, the original ice-house, brew-house, and malting building still stand across the street, a reminder of the dream Philip Zorn brought with him to America.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Versatile for various event styles
  • Wheelchair accessible
  • Dressing room available

Venue considerations

  • Not for you if you are drawn to more unconventional venues
  • Does not allow pets
  • No built-in audiovisual options
Our wedding at Barrelhouse the Venue was perfect. Everything went exactly as we had hoped. It’s such an interesting historic building and Michigan City is a great place to visit.
Samantha S., 8 months ago
Uptown Social - Michigan City, Indiana 

5.0

Michigan City, IN
  • Up to 300 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $7,000

Located in the Michigan City's Uptown Arts District surrounded by history sits this 150+ year old church. It was fully renovated in 2020 while keeping the charm of old architecture. We offer an experience that merges the past and the present through modern comfort and historical luxury. All eyes will be focused on you as you enter our beautiful ballroom. As you begin your magical journey down our center aisle, you will meet the love of your life, where the two of you will vow your love to one another. Exiting the ballroom as a newly married couple, you’ll begin your new life in celebration with your guests during cocktail hour in our lounge & historic courtyard. Once returning to the cathedral ballroom, you will enter into your gorgeous, fully transformed dinner and reception space. This is your night!

Why you'll love this venue

  • Space for a large guest list
  • Bridal suite on site
  • Provides lighting and sound

Venue considerations

  • Large venue, not ideal for small guest lists
  • No free parking
  • Not for you if you are drawn to more unconventional venues
From a vendors perspective, Uptown Social is top notch. Jeremy and Judy and the entire staff are some of the best in the business to work with!
Audrey, 3 years ago

Location flexible? Discover venues near New Buffalo, MI

About wedding venues in New Buffalo, MI

New Buffalo offers couples stunning wedding backdrops that combine Michigan's beautiful lakeside settings with small-town charm. You'll find a variety of venues where you can say "I do" along Lake Michigan's shores or among elegant vineyard estates that capture the region's natural beauty while providing an intimate atmosphere for your special day.

What's the Average Cost of New Buffalo MI Wedding Venues?

Wedding venues in New Buffalo cost about $7,743 on average, fitting nicely within the national range of $6,500 to $12,000. Your costs will typically scale with your guest count; smaller gatherings of around 50 guests run about $6,930 while medium-sized weddings of 100-150 guests range from $7,000 to $8,000. Larger celebrations hosting 200-300 guests will push your venue budget to $8,000-$8,470. The good news? You'll spend proportionally less on your venue in New Buffalo at just 17% of your total wedding budget compared to the national average of 25%.

When Should You Book Your New Buffalo Venue?

October sees the most venue inquiries in New Buffalo, with couples typically securing their location 14 months (445 days) before walking down the aisle. You'll want to plan even further ahead for those coveted Saturday dates during summer months. New Buffalo has become quite popular as a destination wedding location so premium dates get snapped up quickly by couples looking to take advantage of the area's scenic beauty and relaxed atmosphere.

What Are New Buffalo's Most Distinctive Wedding Venues?

New Buffalo's venue options cater to virtually every wedding style you might envision. The Woodlands Course at Whittaker gives you serene golf course scenery that can accommodate up to 300 guests with plenty of outdoor ceremony spots. Journeyman Distillery offers that perfect blend of industrial charm with elegant touches that creates a truly unique celebration space. Tabor Hill Winery & Restaurant surrounds you with picturesque vineyard views ideal for rustic yet sophisticated celebrations. Etre Farms delivers authentic countryside charm for couples dreaming of a genuine farm wedding experience with natural beauty all around.

What Additional Costs Should You Budget For?

Your venue is just the beginning of creating your perfect New Buffalo wedding day. Beyond the $7,743 average venue rental which takes up 17% of your budget, you'll need to plan for catering at around $6,194 (14%) and bar services averaging $4,955 (11%). Photography will run about $4,083 (9%) while florals typically cost $5,631 (13%). Other essentials include videography at $3,815 (9%) planning services at $2,534 (6%) entertainment ranging around $1,337 (3%) cake and desserts at $859 (2%) and hair and makeup averaging $396 (1%).

ServiceAverage Cost% of Total Budget
Venue$7,74317%
Catering$6,19414%
Bar Services$4,95511%
Photography$4,0839%
Florals$5,63113%
Videography$3,8159%
Planning$2,5346%
Band/DJ$1,3373%
Cake/Desserts$8592%
Hair & Makeup$3961%

How Can You Find Accessible Venues in New Buffalo?

Accessible venue options are available throughout New Buffalo to ensure all your guests can celebrate comfortably. The Woodlands Course at Whittaker features accessible paths throughout the grounds making it easier for guests with mobility concerns. Journeyman Distillery's industrial setting typically includes wheelchair accessibility in its modern design. When you're touring potential venues, be sure to ask specific questions about ramps elevators and accessible restrooms so you can feel confident that everyone on your guest list will have a wonderful experience at your celebration.

What types of wedding venues are in New Buffalo, MI?

What other New Buffalo vendors will I need?

What other wedding venues are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?