The Best Italian Wedding Catering in Mayo, FL

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


29 Wedding Caterers in Mayo, FL

Italian
Quick responder
Taste Of The Robersons LLC 
Rating: 5.0 (37 reviews)
  • Starts at $1,500
  • Serves Mayo, FL

At Taste of the Robersons, we turn every event into an unforgettable experience. Led by Chef Robee, a full-time traveling celebrity chef, we bring world-class flavors to Georgia, Florida, Tennessee and beyond. From an intimate gathering or a grand celebration, we have custom menus for every occasion. With years of experience catering across the country, we take pride in our ingredients, delivering exceptional service and handling events of all sizes with precision and professionalism. We ensure every bite leaves a lasting impression because great food creates great memories!

Awarded Best of Zola
My husband and I had our wedding on 11/01/2025 and we absolutely adored Chef Robee and his wife! Jenifer was so communicable and understanding with all of my questions and the professionalism was phenomenal! Even when I had to adjust the menu to our budget Jenifer was understanding and so sweet with me! She made sure I had everything we needed and we had everything in order for the big day! The food itself was phenomenal and set up so incredibly! I am still getting compliments about the shrimp Chef Robee prepared for our wedding! Thank you again! I would recommend Taste of the Robersons to anyone and everyone who likes to eat good food!!
Alex N., 3 months ago
Quick responder
EL PAMPEANO STEAKHOUSE 
Rating: 5.0 (24 reviews)
  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves Mayo, FL
  • Offer

This is not just catering. This is a live fire experience your guests will never forget. At El Pampeano Steakhouse, we bring the authentic Argentine grill to your wedding, creating a one-of-a-kind experience centered around fire, flavor, and connection. Our team prepares everything fresh on-site over an open flame, turning your event into a true culinary show. We offer buffet and plated service with flexible packages, including appetizers, dessert tables, and custom options. Every detail is designed to make your celebration unforgettable. Limited dates available for 2026 and 2027. We recommend booking early to secure your wedding date.

Awarded Best of Zola
We first discovered El Pampeano Steakhouse through a wedding decorator and were blown away by their catering for our wedding in November 2024. Seeing them now on Zola reminded us of the wonderful experience we had, and we wanted to leave our review. Everything was flawless: the food was delicious, the service attentive and professional, and Leo, the grill master, and his wife Lore were always on top of every detail. They truly made our wedding even more special and memorable. We highly recommend El Pampeano Steakhouse to any couple looking for catering that combines amazing flavor, attentive service, and genuine dedication.
Laura & M., 8 months ago
Quick responder
Lakeland BBQ & Catering Company 
Rating: 5.0 (19 reviews)
  • Starts at $1
  • Serves Mayo, FL

Established in 2015, Lakeland BBQ has been proudly serving up authentic, slow-smoked barbecue with a passion for flavor and hospitality. What started as a love for great food and gathering people around the table has grown into a trusted catering company known throughout the region. Over the years, we’ve had the honor of catering countless meals — from intimate backyard celebrations to large-scale weddings, corporate events, and everything in between. Our team is committed to delivering delicious, high-quality BBQ with a friendly, down-to-earth approach that makes every event feel special.

Awarded Best of Zola
I was extremely please with Lakeland BBQ Company! I was given quite a few options for food as well as drinks and dinnerware. They were very affordable and had great customer service!
Ashlee, 3 years ago
Quick responder
Plan It To The T - Catering & Planning 
Rating: 5.0 (18 reviews)
  • Starts at $10,000
  • Serves Mayo, FL
  • Offer

Plan It To The T is a full-service event catering, bartending, planning, décor, day-of coordination, and floral design. Whether it’s an intimate celebration or a grand affair, we deliver elevated cuisine and polished design with warmth, professionalism, and heart. From custom floral arrangements to flawless event flow, our team ensures every detail is executed to perfection—so you can enjoy your moment. Rooted in creativity and committed to excellence, we’re not just here to plan your event—we’re here to make it memorable.

Awarded Best of Zola
I hired Ty from Plan it to the T for my 40th Birthday theme party. From the beginning, Ty was very attentive to my vision for my party. She was organized and knew exactly how to execute my vision. She went above and beyond and even surprised me with a balloon arch. Plan it to the T also provided catering for my event and the food was amazing. My guests are still raving about the food and charcuterie. I would definitely hire Ty and her team again. If you’re looking for an event planner this team is for you.
Jaquita, 4 months ago
Quick responder
G&G Argentine Steakhouse 
Rating: 5.0 (11 reviews)
  • Starts at $2,899
  • Serves Mayo, FL

Make your event unforgettable with the authentic flavor of Argentina. GG Steakhouse offers live grill, buffet service, appetizers, and desserts. Perfect for weddings, birthdays, corporate events and more.

Awarded Best of Zola
G&G Argentine Steakhouse was an incredible choice for our wedding catering. From the beginning, they were very communicative and good people to work with. The quality of their work and value was exquisite - the food they provided was abundant and absolutely delicious. They helped make our wedding night a fantastic celebration. The service was very good and we are so grateful to the G&G team for everything they did to make our special day perfect. Thank you G&G Argentine Steakhouse!
Lisa C., 8 months ago
Quick responder
3 C's Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (10 reviews)
  • Starts at $500
  • Serves Mayo, FL
  • Offer

3 C's Catering provides reliable, professional and affordable catering in the greater Tampa, Florida and surrounding areas. We proudly incorporate our delicious, homemade, award-winning food and will develop a specific menu to fit your taste or budget. We cater all types of events: business meetings, conferences, weddings, church gatherings, and special events, so let us cater your next event and impress your guests.

Awarded Best of Zola
I have had the pleasure of using 3 C's Catering several times, for small events at my home, catered lunches all the way up to my daughter's wedding and my mother's celebration of life. And I have attended many events where 3 C's Catering was providing the food services. Everything is always perfect. The food is amazing! No matter what it is, from simple sandwiches, to top round of beef, everything is prepared deliciously. It's always fresh, hot and yummy! REAL mashed potatoes, tender meats, fresh everything. And the staff. so delightful. I attend a monthly lunch meeting, where they rotate the catering staff. 3 C's staff are the only ones who walk around the ballroom and collect plates from the attendees, and ensure that nothing else is needed. The other catering companies don't bother to pick up dishes or clear tables, they leave it for the guests to do. I will continue to use them any time I have an event, and will always recommend them to anyone having a function. When we had my mother's celebration of life for 100 people, and I saw the 3 C's staff walk in, I knew I didn't have to worry about anything to do with the food service. It was a relief knowing that they were there, and that I could have confidence that everything around the food would be perfect.
Lisa K J., a year ago
Quick responder
East Coast Catering & Events 
Rating: 5.0 (8 reviews)
  • Starts at $3,500
  • Serves Mayo, FL

East Coast Catering & Events is a wedding cuisine and events company located in St. Augustine, Fl. Serving Jacksonville, St. Augustine, Gainesville & Orlando. The chefs create seasonal menus that incorporate produce & artisan goods. Aside from fresh local food, late night snacks, sweet treats, the team assists couples in planning everything from custom food & beverage menus, event staffing and rentals.

Awarded Best of Zola
We hired East Coast Catering & Events for our wedding, and we couldn’t be happier with the entire experience! From the very first conversation, their team was professional, attentive, and truly committed to bringing our vision to life. They took the time to understand our preferences, offered thoughtful suggestions, and created a customized menu that our guests are still raving about! The food was absolutely incredible — beautifully presented, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. Every dish, from the hor dourves to the main dishes, was a hit. You could tell everything was made with care and top-quality ingredients. Beyond the food, the service was exceptional. The staff was friendly, organized, and made sure everything ran smoothly. They handled every detail with such grace and professionalism, which really helped us relax and enjoy our big day. If you're looking for a catering company that delivers both amazing food and top-notch service, we wholeheartedly recommend Chef Jonathan & East Coast Catering & Events. They helped make our wedding truly unforgettable!
Jenn A., 4 months ago
Quick responder
Pasta Chef Catering, LLC 
Rating: 3.7 (6 reviews)
  • Starts at $20
  • Serves Mayo, FL

Thank you for visiting Pasta Chef Catering. Pasta Chef Catering is a Tampa Bay-based catering company specializing in a high-quality catering experience for you and your guests to enjoy at a very affordable price. We have over 40 years of experience in the catering and food service industry. We offer cooked-to-order action stations as well as buffet and plated meal options. Our most popular action station is the Signature Pasta Bar. Our next popular station is the Taco & Nacho Bar. There are no hidden costs and no confusing or over priced menus to choose from.

Our food was perfect. Everyone was happy with the food and even though Mishele is the pasta chef she has such a good menu. We did a pasta dish and then a Spanish dish to celebrate my culture and it all was so yummy. Mishele was great to work with and she brought a great and very professional team with her. She was also so sweet and checked in on us during our wedding.
Ana S., 2 years ago
Chef Rocco Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (6 reviews)
  • Starts at $6,500
  • Serves Mayo, FL

Chef Rocco Catering is a luxury boutique caterer that allows you to completely customize your experience. Choose from our menu of options or schedule a call with us to discuss your vision for your wedding day. Your menu will be crafted around your favorite foods, theme, preferences, and any dietary requirements.

Chef Rocco and his entire team were absolutely incredible. From start to finish, the food was flawless, and we are so thankful we chose them for our wedding. Everything was beautifully prepared, perfectly timed, and tasted amazing. Our guests are still talking about the food. The mozzarella cart and the beignet bar were huge hits and truly elevated the entire experience. People were raving about how unique and delicious everything was, and it added such a fun and memorable element to the night. Chef Rocco and his team were professional, efficient, and clearly passionate about what they do. If you are looking for catering that will impress your guests and leave a lasting impression, Chef Rocco is the way to go. We could not be happier with our choice.
Brianna B., 3 months ago
Quick responder
Chef Lemaire, LLC 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Starts at $5,000
  • Serves Mayo, FL

Award-wining Chef Alain Lemaire is a native of Port-au-Prince, Haiti, where he first discovered his interest in cooking. That interest in food grew out of the need to feed himself what he wanted, and when he wanted it by watching his mother and grandmother in the kitchen, to full blown passion by the time he graduated. Chef Lemaire has featured on several TV shows: he was the host chef of the “Taste of Haiti” episode of the "Luda Can't Cook" series on Discovery+ with award winning rapper, actor, restauranteur Chris "Ludacris" Bridges. He is also a contestant of the Food Network's hit series, Fire Masters, Cutthroat Kitchen, and Chopped.

Awarded Best of Zola
We have been fortunate to work with chef Lemaire on several occasions. First at my wedding, my anniversary dinner and more recently at my sister destination wedding. Each of the experiences was beyond excellent! His menu choices are extensive. The dishes are delicious and creative. Chef lemaire is always professional , on time , work clean always leaves his kitchen spotless and relates well with the guests to the point where each time I'm hosting the guests always ask if he would be the Chef of the day. Most importantly, chef Lemaire truly strives to create the experience that the client wants starting from the tasting till the day of the event. Highest praise for Chef Lemaire and we look forward to working with him again and again.
Christlaine F., 2 years ago
Quick responder
Chef's Garden Catering & Events 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Starts at $2,500
  • Serves Mayo, FL

What do wedding bells make you dream of? An elaborate summer affair for hundreds... an intimate retreat for only your family and closest friends... or something in between? The Chef's Garden has helped create hundreds of weddings; however, because weddings are so uniquely personal, no one is a better expert on your wedding than you. Therefore, our first meeting will focus on YOU. Your tastes, style, vision, and values. In order for us to serve you at the highest level possible, we must build a foundation of trust, integrity, and respect, much like the union in which you are about to engage.

Awarded Best of Zola
Chef's Garden Catering & Events was a fantastic choice for our wedding catering. They were very accommodating, working closely with us to ensure they could meet our dietary restrictions. On the day of the wedding, they did a great job executing the meal service - the food was delicious and they worked seamlessly throughout the night to keep everything running smoothly. Our guests raved about the quality of the food and the overall catering experience. We're so glad we chose Chef's Garden Catering & Events to be part of our special day.
Kelsey B., a year ago
Puff 'n Stuff Catering & Events 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Serves Mayo, FL

Puff ‘n Stuff Catering has been repeatedly honored as caterer of the year nationally and locally in Orlando and Tampa, and we bring that level of excellence to every wedding we cater — no matter how large or small. When it comes to your wedding, your guests will remember a perfect blend of incredible food, gorgeous presentation, and stellar service. Our team has a heartfelt passion for helping create your extraordinary guest experience and the unique ability to create an outstanding event with a personalized menu and custom details. Together we’ll create the most amazing day of your lives, with the people you care about most!

We had such a wonderful experience with Puff & Stuff! The staff member assigned to take care of us throughout the day was phenomenal. We truly felt so looked after the entire time and somehow were never hungry—no small feat on a wedding day. The food itself was fantastic and we received so many compliments from guests about how good everything tasted. The service was just as impressive as the food, and the team made everything feel effortless for us. Highly recommend them if you want delicious food and a team that genuinely takes care of the couple throughout the day.
Aleia E., a month ago
Quick responder
Ez Eats 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Starts at $750
  • Serves Mayo, FL

Welcome! Our focus when dining with Ez Eats is to deliver an unforgettable food experience. Everyone who dines with us is considered a guest, not a client. We bring the fun, a vibe, and most importantly, amazingly delicious food!

From the moment we first spoke with the team at Ez Eats, their communication was clear and they listened intently to all of our requests for our wedding day. The food they provided was truly magnificent - delicious, savory, and absolutely delightful. The servers were very kind and mindful of all our guests, ensuring everyone was well taken care of throughout the evening. We couldn't have asked for a better catering experience to make our special day even more perfect.
James B., a year ago
Quick responder
River City Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Serves Mayo, FL

Engagement Parties, Rehearsal Dinners, Weddings, Showers, Birthdays, Anniversary, Company Parties, Civic Functions, Barbecues and Celebration of Life are just a few types of functions we cater to. You are limited only by your imagination and with our varied selection of menus, we have a taste for everyone. River City Catering can also tailor a menu for you and assist with any dietary requirements you might have in mind.

River City Catering was AMAZING to work with! We opted for their blossom package and couldn't have been happier with our decision! The food was delicious and Kayleigh was such a gem to work with! Kayleigh was so friendly and gave such clear communication, especially regarding our various allergy/dietary accommodations for our guests. Our tasting consultation was such an enjoyable experience and did an amazing job with helping to add a personal touch to our menu. Everyone raved about the delicious dinner (especially the scalloped potatoes) and we couldn't have been happier to work with RCC for our wedding!
Mairead O., a year ago
Quick responder
Simply Sated By Tessa 
Rating: 5.0 (16 reviews)
  • Starts at $1,500
  • Serves Mayo, FL for additional fees

Award-winning wedding catering by Chef Tessa. With 23+ years of experience, Simply Sated offers fully customized menus, grazing tables, cakes, bartending, décor, rentals, and coordination—your one-stop shop for unforgettable weddings.

Awarded Best of Zola
Everything about my experience was amazing, Chef Tessa was very quick to respond to me during the months leading up to my wedding. Was very helpful in the process of deciding what food I was choosing and how much as well! The food was phenomenal, we got the lasagna and roast beef and I highly recommend these, every single guest LOVED it and lots of people got seconds. We had a seated meal and the waiters were amazing as well, they all came to check on us several times, refilling drinks, bringing more food and were so friendly. Would totally recommend to book her and would book again for any other event!
Haley F., 10 months ago
Quick responder
Bauer Flavor Factory Catering 
Rating: 2.6 (5 reviews)
  • Starts at $100
  • Serves Mayo, FL for additional fees

Bauer Flavor Factory Catering is a family-owned business fueled by a love for food and creativity. We’re passionate about making every event special by crafting delicious, custom menus just for you. Whether it’s a wedding, party, or celebration, we’ll work with you to create a personalized and unforgettable food experience that fits your style, taste, and vision.

From our first conversation with the team at Bauer Flavor Factory Catering, we were impressed by their fast, dependable, and easy-going communication style. They were incredibly reliable throughout the entire planning process, working with us to create a flexible menu full of amazing, high-quality food options. The Bauer team went above and beyond, even helping with the setup on the day of our wedding. Their attention to detail and willingness to customize the menu to our specific preferences made them an invaluable partner in making our special day perfect. We would highly recommend Bauer Flavor Factory Catering to any couple looking for a stress-free, delicious catering experience.
Jay, a year ago
Quick responder
Côte & Flame 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Starts at $1,100
  • Serves Mayo, FL for additional fees

Côte & Flame is a luxury wedding catering service in Tampa specializing in elegant receptions, rehearsal dinners, and intimate celebrations. Our chef-driven menus feature seasonal ingredients sourced from trusted local farms and brands, and are prepared fresh on-site for true restaurant-quality flavor. From refined plated dinners to sophisticated buffet-style receptions, every detail is customized to reflect your vision and create an unforgettable dining experience on your wedding day.

From the very first phone call, Côte & Flame demonstrated a professional, fast, and friendly communication style that put us at ease throughout the wedding planning process. On the day of the event, their team delivered delicious food that was beautifully plated, creating an amazing atmosphere for our guests. The catering was exceptional, and they worked quickly and efficiently to clean up afterwards, allowing us to fully enjoy our special day. We couldn't have asked for a better catering experience - Côte & Flame truly went above and beyond to make our wedding reception a huge success.
Jenna, 2 months ago
That's Amore / FULL Italian menu + WOOD-fired Pizza 
Rating: 5.0 (5 reviews)
  • Starts at $1,700
  • Serves Mayo, FL

Contact us by email: Ciao AT pizzeriathatsamore com. That's Amore WOOD-fired PIZZA and Pasta Catering, straight from the heartlands of South of Italy! We use an authentic, hand-built brick oven, fueled only by wood, to bring you a bite of Italian tradition you can't resist! Our wood-fired pizza & pasta journey started in the kitchen of Chef Giuseppe’s mother and grandmother. Our experience goes from catering for Formula 1 & Miami Open at Hard Rock Stadium to Indy500! So wherever you have 50 guests or 500 we can manage it! We are a preferred catering vendor at Ever After Farm Wedding Venue

Have you always wanted to impress your friends and neighbors? How about having this Italian-made Beauty pull in your driveway to create a piece of Italy for you, your family or your party guests? Family owned mobile pizza oven That’s Amore! Absolutely phenomenal and delicious menu!
R.P.C., 2 years ago
The Grazing Sisters LLC 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Starts at $500
  • Serves Mayo, FL

We’re two sisters with a shared love for hospitality, celebration, and unforgettable food experiences. The Grazing Sisters was born from our passion for creating beautiful, curated charcuterie displays that bring people together. Whether it’s an intimate bridal shower or a grand wedding celebration, we put our hearts into every detail—from the freshest ingredients to the artful presentation. We love what we do because we get to be part of life’s most special moments, helping couples celebrate with flavor, beauty, and joy.

From the moment we reached out to The Grazing Sisters, I knew we were in good hands. We were worried because we had a lot of dietary restrictions, but they truly put us at ease and delivered! The mobile charcuterie cart had such a great variety, freshness, and the presentation of the food was top-tier. They were so accommodating to our needs! As a mother, you want everything to be perfect for your daughter’s big day, and The Grazing Sisters delivered that and more. I can’t thank them enough for being such a special part of our celebration. If you’re considering them for your event, don’t hesitate—they’re truly the best.
Nocilia P., a year ago
GemHidden gem
inGenious Elegance Cuisines 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves Mayo, FL for additional fees

"A Taste of Art. A Touch of Grace" In a world where flavor meets finesse, inGenious Elegance rises to impress. Each plate, a canvas-each bite, a song, Where locally sourced dreams belong. We cater with heart, with detail divine, Infusing soul into every brine. From dietary needs to lavish displays, We sculpt your vision in gourmet ways. More than a meal-it's a moment, a muse, An experience designed for you to choose. Let us craft your table, elegant and rare- Because brilliance is best when it's served with care. Book your moment. Taste the extraordinary

inGenious Elegance Cuisines was a pleasure to work with for our wedding. They were open, diligent, and highly responsive throughout the entire planning process. The quality of their work was exceptional, with a clear focus on high attention to detail. They paid close attention to the small details in order to make a big impact, and the food not only looked and tasted delicious, but you could tell the love and passion that went into every dish. inGenious Elegance Cuisines is wonderful to work with, and we highly recommend them to any couple planning their special day.
Seth P., a year ago