The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Ithaca, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


11 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in Ithaca, NY

Kelly Banks Cakes 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Starts at $4
  • Serves Ithaca, NY

Culinary Institute of America graduate. Mom, wife, traveler, dreamer. Opened KBC in 2007. Only the best ingredients. I love being able to meet couples and start a relationship with them. I help personalize the wedding of their dreams, and execute it! I love what I do! Please text me for more info!!

We had an amazing experience with Kelly Banks Cakes from start to finish! From the perfect cake samples she made for us to try, to the beautiful setup on our wedding day, we were beyond impressed with her work. We chose a mini two-tier strawberry and cream cake along with a variety of cupcakes — chocolate mousse, coconut cream, and strawberry and cream — and our guests absolutely loved them all! Everything tasted incredible and looked exactly how we envisioned it. Kelly came and set everything up perfectly, and the display was stunning. We highly recommend her to anyone looking for delicious desserts and exceptional service for their wedding or special event!
Danielle P., 2 months ago
Sugar Mountain Bakery 
Rating: 5.0 (2 reviews)
  • Starts at $3
  • Serves Ithaca, NY

Sugar Mountain Bakery was first established in 1985 by my ever talented and lovely Grandma, from whom I learned all my skills and owe everything to. In 2021 I took over the business entirely and moved into our newly built bakery. I'm lucky to be right in the center of one of the best wedding locations in the US, the Finger Lakes! Working with the local wedding venues to provide couples their perfect desserts to match their perfect day is one of my favorite things about what I do.

Sugar Mountain Bakery was an absolute delight to work with for our wedding. Their communication was always timely, efficient and informative, which helped make the process of ordering our cake stress-free. The quality of their work was excellent - the cake was beautifully detailed and absolutely delicious. They even went above and beyond by dropping off the cake directly at our venue, saving us time and hassle on the big day. We highly recommend Sugar Mountain Bakery to any couple looking for exceptional cakes and desserts for their wedding.
Ali K., 9 months ago
Quick responder
The Gingersnap Bakery 
Rating: 4.8 (9 reviews)
  • Serves Ithaca, NY

The Gingersnap bakery is located in the business district of the village of Phoenix. We specialize in custom cakes and pastries. We love creating unique sweets that reflect the happiness of your celebration. We can pull inspiration from your wedding design elements as well as you as a couple!

Awarded Best of Zola
Chef Kelsie and the Gingersnap Bakery team are the best! Kelsie was quick to respond to our initial inquiry and set up a virtual meeting to discuss timeline, design, and cost. We showed her some Pinterest inspo pics and she drew a sketch on the spot. Then we picked out some cake and frosting flavors to sample, and she mailed them to our house (cake tasting and a movie was so fun!). She was always easy to reach and quick to respond. On the wedding day, she personally delivered the cake to our venue, and everything went without a hitch – in fact, we completely forgot about the cake until we walked into our ballroom to preview it during cocktail hour. The cake itself was absolutely beautiful and hit the brief perfectly; it was exactly what we wanted. It was an 8-inch single-tier token cake for the photo op, and the photos turned out great. Moreover, it was DELICIOUS! Perfect texture, just the right amount of sweet. We got their mocha flavor with chocolate ganache as our filling/frosting but asked for vanilla buttercream on the outside to match our white theme. We are so excited to eat the slices we are saving for our one-year anniversary!
Dasha T., a month ago
Quick responder
Por Suerte 
Rating: 5.0 (6 reviews)
  • Starts at $36
  • Serves Ithaca, NY

We make sweet AND savory fortune cookies that are fully customizable in every way. From the color and flavor, to the fortunes on the inside, these aren't your typical takeout afterthought. Think porcini mushroom with truffle salt, espresso, tutti frutti, and so many more flavors. We can also create a custom flavor just for you. We also stuff our cookies like cannolis, make fortune cookie ice cream sandwiches, and have different sized-cookies to really make a statement. We're based in Napa, CA but ship Nationwide and to Puerto Rico!

I ordered Por Suerte cookies as a gift for my pre-wedding parties (bridal shower) and they were a hit! The variety of flavors offered a great opportunity to have something for guests of all tastes. And it hadn’t been done before, which was fun for me. I loved working the vendor - incredibly professional, communicative, and thoughtful. Highly recommend!!!
Ana F., 24 days ago
Quick responder
Sweet Kee's Candies & Gifts 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Starts at $150
  • Serves Ithaca, NY

Sweet Kee's is a one-of-a-kind Hudson Valley, New York wedding favors & gifts business, servicing couples throughout New York State. We offer handcrafted, artisanal treats, including a variety of classic & specialty hard candies & lollipops that are perfect as candy or dessert table options, as gifts and favors. We also offer premium beverage infusion kits that allow your guests to create their own craft drink experience. Just add wine, liquor, or non-alcoholic beverages. Our other specialty food novelties include hot cocoa jars, small-batch fruit jams, and edible peppermint shot glasses. Shipping is available throughout New York State.

Awarded Best of Zola
Sweet Kee's was an absolute delight to work with! From our first interaction, she was professional, prompt, and incredibly helpful during communications. The lollipops were simply stunning and beautifully crafted. These were the most delicious, unique flavors we've ever tasted. In fact, I can say with confidence that these are the best lollipops I've ever had the pleasure of enjoying!! Thanks so much!
Kiana, 2 years ago
TrendlineTrending
Sweet Buckets 
Rating: 5.0 (5 reviews)
  • Starts at $300
  • Serves Ithaca, NY for additional fees

We began as a concession company providing cotton candy at sporting events. In the fall of 2021, we extended our brand by starting our own manufacturing plant. Sweet Buckets was born as an option for customers and businesses to purchase Cotton Candy and Gourmet popcorns direct from our company.

Awarded Best of Zola
We had our wedding reception at a brewery and wanted some easy to eat sweet and salty snacks. These popcorn flavors were delicious, they sent us flavors to try before we decided. We chose 4 flavors and they shipped them right to our house. The popcorn buckets had our cute custom labels which they designed for us and looked PERFECT! We had tons of compliments on the popcorn. We ordered plenty and people were grabbing them to take home at the end of the night. A perfect snack after a few beers. Theu were very fast with the samples and the order too!
Lyndsey C., 2 years ago
TrendlineTrending
BakerBitesCo 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Starts at $200
  • Serves Ithaca, NY for additional fees

Ready to impress your guests with our unique tasty treat? BakerBitesCo offers single serve fudge bites with customized labels to fit your perfect day. Wedding favors, bridesmaids gifts, wedding party gifts, etc. these can be used in any way to fit your needs. WHY YOU'LL LOVE US -We offer delicious unique seasonal flavors -We ship anywhere in the US -We can send a sampler box so you can taste all our flavors and pick your favorites. -Budget friendly at only $2/piece -Prepackaged, making our dessert ideal during COVID -We give a meal to a hungry child with every order We can't wait to make your day even more spectacular!

Best fudge I’ve ever had and the flavor varieties are amazing! I love that I can customize them for any occasion!
Linda, 6 years ago
Sarah & Simon Cake Design 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Starts at $1,500
  • Serves Ithaca, NY

Sarah & Simon Cake Design is a custom cake company based in Brooklyn. We specialize in unique and artful designs to create truly one-of-a-kind wedding and celebration cakes. Pulling from her background in fine art, Sarah approaches cake design from the standpoint of an artist to inform the way she composes and creates edible work. Her cakes are made entirely from scratch by a small team of professionals, using high quality ingredients and trusted recipes--each cake tastes as exquisitely delicious as it looks. Contact us for more information or to set up a consultation.

Seriously these people are artists. I'm a photographer and I love getting the chance to photograph their masterpieces!
Bethany Jones, 6 years ago

About wedding cakes & desserts in Ithaca, NY

What other Ithaca vendors will I need?

What other cakes and desserts are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?