Wedding Cakes & Desserts in Oyster Bay, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads?

Bakers in Oyster Bay, NY

45 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in Oyster Bay, NY

Quick responder
MWDyes Sweets

5.0

Huntington, NY
  • Starts at $525
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY

I have been baking for 10+ years, and been in business for 5 years. What started off as a hobby turned into my greatest passion. I love bringing others vision to life through cake, I love the looks on my customer faces when thier dream cake comes into the room, this is my passion and I live what I do. I am here to make sure your special day goes as planned, and I am just grateful to be apart of making your day special.

Awarded Best of Zola
I recently placed an order with MWDyes, and it was by far the best decision I ever made. Not only was the cake beautiful, it was delicious. The vanilla buttercream is my favorite! My guest wanted seconds and I ate left overs at 12 am the next day because it was that good ! Place your orders today, you won’t regret it !
Faith G., 5 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Nita’s Pastries Inc

5.0

Hempstead, NY
  • Starts at $260

Based out of Hempstead, New York, Nita's Pastries Inc. is a custom cake bakery. We delights in providing cakes and sweet treats for weddings and other special events throughout Long Island. The talented baking team believes that Cakes should look great and taste even better, as reflected in their beautiful, tantalizing cakes. When working with Nita's Pastries Inc., couples can ensure that their cake will be crafted from high-quality ingredients. We are happy to provide custom design options so that to-be-weds can create a cake that's uniquely theirs. In addition to wedding cakes, Macaron towers, Cookies, Cupcakes and lots more.

I would recommend Nita’s pastries to any one for any occasion. They where so nice, easy to work with regardless of your budget, they work with you by providing you options. And what I liked most was that they where not too in my face. They provided me all my options and told me it’s all comes down to my decision( and you know what that means for a bride who hasn’t had that much luck making her own decisions) I felt included but they didn’t know they did that to me. Our experience was amazing. The cake was tasty that we had to use them again for my nieces baptism and we will continue to use them.
Anna & M., 2 years ago
Love, Li Cake

5.0

New Hyde Park, NY
  • Starts at $40

Just a 20 year old self-taught baker! Since starting my business at the age of 16, I continue to learn and grow in this industry, meeting and servicing the best clients in the Long Island and Queens area. From custom cakes to hot cocoa bombs, I work to make any occasion SWEET and memorable!

Our cake was BEAUTIFUL!!! She is such a joy to work with and made all of our dreams come true!!! On top of that it tasted delicious!! Our guests were raving about it! We will be recommending love li cake to all of our friends!!!
Maddie and R., 2 years ago
Dolce Bella Luxury Italian ices

5.0

Garden City, NY
  • Starts at $49,000

Hi my name is Brandyn, I am the owner and founder of Dolce Bella Luxury Italian Ices! We are a dairy-free, gluten-free, and vegan company with limited sugar-free and kosher options as well! We are a luxury Italian ice cart that proudly caters to the five bouroughs including the Hamptons and Montauk. Dolce Bella Luxury Italian ices does it all from birthdays to bridal and baby showers to weddings and backyard events, no event is too big nor too small!

We have had an amazing experience with Dolce Bella Luxury Italian Ices! They were prompt arrived before the scheduled time and the ices were the best Italian Ice I’ve ever had! The staff was so helpful and friendly and definitely will be booking again!
Antonia & B., 2 years ago
b.Kind Sweets
Massapequa, NY
  • Starts at $5

Treat yourself to something sweet today! Fresh breads and comfort treats. Your favorite donut and so much more! If you're looking for desserts or a cake for your next gathering, send us a message! Send us a message to get started! We're here 24/7. Stay well, friends. 🧿🖤🧿

Caked By Ellie
Roslyn, NY
  • Starts at $120

*** Please place order(s) a minimum of 5-6 weeks in advance due to limited availability.**** Inquiries are being taken for MARCH-MAY. *Inquiries may take approximately 2-3 weeks for a response * If it has been more than two weeks and you have not heard from me please kindly send me a DM.

Quick responder
Petite Fleur Cake

5.0

Woodside, NY
  • Starts at $700
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY

Petite Fleur Cake specializes in buttercream and sugar flower cakes. We are committed to treats that impress both the sight and the bite. To make your event extraordinary, we are only committed to using the finest quality ingredients. We are looking forward to serving you.

Awarded Best of Zola
Karen is excellent all around. She’s a great baker and skilled designer. My husband and picked the Earl grey flavor cake for our wedding and it was a major hit! The design was also beautiful with drape-like folds, gold foil and sugar flowers. She was very easy to work with and also helped me stay within budget. I highly recommend her!
Iris, 6 months ago
Quick responder
Cakes by Magda

5.0

Glendale, NY
  • Starts at $500
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY

Hi! Privately I am a mom of a 4 year old girl and a wife, on the business side aside from being a bookkeeper for a construction company I also love Coordinating business for mom. I love planning for not only weddings but all other events for my mom too. I get excited about every single lead and I invest all of my time to answer and help out our customer. Looking forward to working with you! <3

Awarded Best of Zola
Her cake was incredible! I would highly recommend her to anyone.
Julio Olvera, 10 months ago
Whimsical Splendor

5.0

Ronkonkoma, NY
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY

I’ve been in the cake making business for over 8 years. It’s something I absolutely love doing. I enjoy working closely with my clients and listening to all their wants and needs to make the perfect desserts for their special day.

Highly recommend. Angela is very easy to work with and brought our dream wedding cake to life.
Ashley V., 3 years ago
Brent Bakes

5.0

Staten Island, NY
  • Starts at $800
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY

Woman-owned small business. Carol, the baker behind Brent Bakes, loves baking and creating wedding cakes that is perfect for the big day! Brent Bakes specializes in uniquely flavored and equally stunning sweets. We custom make delicious cakes, cupcakes, and so much more!

Awarded Best of Zola
Your bakery search is OVER because we couldn't recommend Brent Bakes more for your special moments! Their team is super responsive and they go above and beyond for their clients. As beautiful as their products look, they taste even better. You won't be disappointed!
EVENTFULLNYC, 4 months ago
GemHidden gem
Cake Hero

5.0

Brooklyn, NY
  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY

Based in Brooklyn, self taught sugar artist Melissa Torres knows that there’s nothing like a gorgeous and delicious treat to take your party to the next level! With a commitment to using organic, fair trade ingredients, Cake Hero confections are beautiful and delicious delights that you can feel good about. Your purchase of a Cake Hero cake means that together, we are a force for good in our business and purchasing practices. We extend this way of thinking to our packaging, and use recycled boxes and paper whenever possible. Melissa’s unique take on cake has caught the eye of Vogue, New York Magazine, and many stylish events in NYC & beyond.

True story -- when people first came up to the reception area from the separate space where we held cocktail hour to find their seat at our wedding, everyone immediately rushed to see Melissa's beautiful cake. I have photos of a huge crowd gathered around the cake, everyone's phone was out taking pictures as if this was a celebrity sighting or something! People literally had to be told several times to get to their seats because they were literally in awe of the amazing cake. The cake also tasted incredibly delicious, and the buttercream frosting was a huge hit. Melissa really goes out of her way to create incredibly intricate and magical designs and it's something we will remember for the rest of our lives! Her and her husband also delivered the cake to our venue directly and even got in touch directly with our venue contact weeks in advance to coordinate. They were super organized and knew just how to handle everything. Plus she uses all fair trade ingredients so you will actually be contributing to sustainable agriculture.
Jen and S., 4 years ago
GemHidden gem
Baked in Color

5.0

Scarsdale, NY
  • Starts at $150
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY

Baked in Color launched in 2016, a female owned and operated company, and we have been providing SMILES ever since. Why eat a boring cookie when you can have one Baked in Color!?! Our desserts are the perfect compliment to weddings, one of life's most happy occasions.

Awarded Best of Zola
This company is amazing! We had just 11 days to plan our wedding and Julie and the crew worked with us and turned around a custom order for wedding "favors" in just six days! Here is what we sent to Julie when we received the cookies: "Received the cookies - they are beyond perfect! You and your team did an amazing job! And we’ve already sampled a few :) Couldn’t be happier with your company. I can’t believe you were able to turn this around so quickly! Thank you for the cookies and the love!"
Catherine S., 2 years ago

Location flexible? Discover bakers near Oyster Bay, NY

About wedding cakes & desserts in Oyster Bay, NY

How much do wedding cakes usually cost in Oyster Bay, NY?

Wedding cake packages start at $490 and run up to $575 per person in Oyster Bay, NY.

Do bakers in Oyster Bay, NY offer cakes for special diets?

They do! 30 offer Gluten-free desserts, and 20 offer Vegan options.8 offer Sugar-free options.

What are the most popular cake and dessert options in Oyster Bay, NY?

The most popular wedding cake vendors in Oyster Bay, NY are Avas Cakes LLC, Sweet Buckets and Little Treats and Cakes by Janna, LLC.

What other Oyster Bay vendors will I need?

What other cakes and desserts are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?