The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Old Lyme, CT

The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Old Lyme, CT

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads?


28 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in Old Lyme, CT

Quick responder
Sugar Crystles 

5.0

  • Starts at $4
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT

Sugar Crystles is a wedding confectionery company in New Milford, CT. This budding bakery is owned and run by me, Crystle, and I am industry professional with years of cake-making in my repertoire. Using my skills, I do my best to craft stunning wedding cakes and delectable desserts that will have you and your guests wanting more. I create a variety of desserts and cakes for any special occasion with various techniques. From icing-covered sugar cookies to a variety of desserts for a buffet, I do it all. I also specialize in gluten and dairy free. I will cater to any flavor or design of your choice. Cake tastings are also available

Sugar Crystles provided amazing desserts for our wedding day! Crystle's attention to detail was incredible - the desserts were beautifully presented and tasted absolutely delicious. The desserts were the highlight of our wedding, and our guests could not stop raving about them. Crystle's great communication throughout the planning process also made everything so easy. We were thrilled with the quality and value of Sugar Crystles' work, and we highly recommend them to any couple looking for incredible wedding desserts!
Hayda B and M., a month ago
Quick responder
Chocolate Rose Bakeshop 

5.0

  • Starts at $120
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT

Welcome. When I first started my story, it started out with me as a young adult and starting my adventure down the road of cake artistry. Then I dug a little deeper and gave thought to what probably sparked my interest in cake decorating. Chocolate Rose Bakeshop is Griswold, CT’s fav Custom & Special Occasion Cakeshop. Our creations may look too good to eat, but they taste too good NOT to! At Chocolate Rose we take pride in creating cakes that not only look too good to eat but taste too good NOT to!

Chocolate Rose Bakeshop was an absolute pleasure to work with for our wedding. From our very first interaction, their team was professional and personable, making the cake ordering process seamless. The final product was truly amazing - they captured the exact vision I had in mind and executed it with incredible detail. The wedding cake they created was the centerpiece of our reception and received endless compliments from our guests on both the beautiful design and delicious taste. Chocolate Rose Bakeshop went above and beyond to ensure our special day was perfect, and I would highly recommend them to any couple looking for a talented, reliable, and passionate bakery to bring their wedding cake dreams to life.
Courtney, 6 days ago
TrendlineTrending
Zest Fresh Pastry 

5.0

  • Starts at $3
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT

Our Pastry Chefs have over 15 years of experience creating custom cakes and desserts. We take pride in our desire to work with you step by step to create custom cakes, desserts, and favors. We aim to create the highest quality product by using as many local and seasonal ingredients as possible. We believe that through a delicious cake and an exquisite design your perfect result will be achieved.

For our wedding in July 2024 at the Inn at Mystic, neither my husband nor I were set on getting a cake. My mom insisted and we set out to search for a bakery. Zest Fresh Pastry came highly recommended by our venue and when we spoke with them, they said they bring a cake there pretty much every weekend (sometimes multiple times a weekend!) during wedding season. I wanted a simple two layer cake that we could have our florist add some flowers to. We also did a sheet cake as backup for the guests! Our guests raved about the cake and I'm so happy we ended up getting one. Would definitely recommend!
Molly M., 3 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Purposeful Cakes LLC 

5.0

  • Starts at $350
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT

My name is Elodia, and I’m a licensed boutique luxury cake artist who specializes in creating moist, buttercream cakes adorned with one-of-a-kind, meaningful designs for the most special people in life. And yes, my cakes taste as good as they look! All of my cakes are custom-made and uniquely designed for each customer.

I knew what I wanted my wedding cake to look like, but had such a hard time finding a baker who could execute my vision. My searched ended with Purposely Cakes. After sampling her cake flavors, I was sold! Every sample was moist, beautifully decorated and nicely packaged. Saying my experience was wonderful is an understatement! Elodia is not only extremely professional and polite, but also amazingly talented! Everyone opined how beautiful our cake was, and how great it tasted! I unreservedly recommend Purposeful Cakes for all your cake needs!
Tiffany, 3 years ago
Quick responder
JCakes 

5.0

  • Serves Old Lyme, CT

JCakes is an award-winning custom cake bakery, located in North Branford, Connecticut, specializing in gourmet wedding cakes and cupcakes. JCakes turns scrumptious ingredients into stunning works of art in three steps: 1) Cake- JCakes begins with a freshly baked, moist cake 2) Filling- The cake is then filled with homemade, hand whipped fillings (nothing comes pre-made from a tub). 3) Frosting- Cakes are frosted with your choice of flavored French buttercreams or rich chocolate ganache, or expertly covered in rolled fondant

J Cakes made our wedding cake experience absolutely delightful. Communication with them was effortless, and they offered a fantastic variety of delicious flavors to choose from. The delivery was fast, easy, and completely stress-free. The cake itself was not only beautiful but also incredibly tasty, impressing all our guests. Highly recommend J Cakes for any special occasion!
Imani D., 3 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Bella Confections 

5.0

  • Starts at $36
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT

"Bake The World A Better Place." Bella Confections main goal is to create that excitement from childhood when your birthday cake was brought out. I focus on incredible flavors, textures, and designs all made from scratch, by hand, by me- I am a one-woman business. I make sure that nothing less than the best thing you've ever tasted gets delivered to you. Priding myself on communication, I work closely with my clients. Nothing makes me happier than a kid screaming "The Cake Lady Is Here!" through the screen door! ***Custom orders only- please inquire with date/time/location/# of servings needed***

Working with Lauren at Bella Confections for our wedding cake was an absolute dream! The cake tasting experience was delightful, with a selection of cupcake flavors hand-delivered to our home. We ultimately chose the strawberry cake with pineapple whip frosting, and it was a huge hit with our guests! Lauren made the entire process so easy and enjoyable. I highly recommend hiring her for your wedding cake; you won't be disappointed!
Kayla M., a month ago
Quick responder
Storeybook Cakes, LLC 

5.0

  • Starts at $800
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT

*** PLEASE NOTE THAT WHILE I AM HAPPY TO TRANSPORT MY CAKES ANYWHERE IN NY + NEW ENGLAND, MY DELIVERY FEES ARE $1.45 PER ROUND-TRIP MILE, SO PLEASE TAKE THIS INTO ACCOUNT WHEN CONSIDERING YOUR WEDDING CAKE BUDGET. THANK YOU! Storeybook Cakes is a one-woman business based out of Oxford, CT. Owner Lynn Storey creates bespoke luxury wedding cakes that range in style from classic minimalist decor to rustic buttercream textures, colorful florals and sleek modern fondant designs. Lynn will capture your vision and create a beautiful, delicious and memorable piece of edible art to honor you & your partner on your special day!

Awarded Best of Zola
Lynn was so sweet and wonderful to work with!! She created a beautiful pressed florals wedding cake for our recent wedding. Lynn was even able to make the cake gluten free and it was very tasty! We also ordered gourmet cupcakes and our guests loved them! Lynn was patient and communicative and created both visually stunning and scrumptious desserts! We were thrilled! Highly recommend!
Lauren S., 3 months ago
Quick responder
Brent Bakes 

5.0

  • Starts at $800
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT for additional fees

Woman-owned small business. Carol, the baker behind Brent Bakes, loves baking and creating wedding cakes that is perfect for the big day! Brent Bakes specializes in uniquely flavored and equally stunning sweets. We custom make delicious cakes, cupcakes, and so much more!

Awarded Best of Zola
Carol brought my cake dreams to life! She was super communicative throughout the entire process and truly cared about my vision. The cake tasting process was seamless and all of the cake flavors I tasted were extraordinary. My husband who doesn’t even like cake was obsessed with how light and airy the cake was and flavorful the frosting and fillings were. We had a stunning 2-tier mini tall cake and 48 cupcakes and all were executed with such care. The cupcakes were so moist and flavorful and the same with the cake. I’ve never seen the cake at a wedding disappear so fast, my guests loved it all. The design was better than I even imagined and I’m so grateful for Carol and all the care she put into giving me the most special cake and cupcakes. She is a true artist, in flavor and design! And I work in the culinary industry, my standards are super super high. You won’t regret working with Carol for your wedding.
Eva P., 3 months ago
Quick responder
Sweet Buckets 

5.0

  • Starts at $300
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT for additional fees

We began as a concession company providing cotton candy at sporting events. In the fall of 2021, we extended our brand by starting our own manufacturing plant. Sweet Buckets was born as an option for customers and businesses to purchase Cotton Candy and Gourmet popcorns direct from our company.

Awarded Best of Zola
We had our wedding reception at a brewery and wanted some easy to eat sweet and salty snacks. These popcorn flavors were delicious, they sent us flavors to try before we decided. We chose 4 flavors and they shipped them right to our house. The popcorn buckets had our cute custom labels which they designed for us and looked PERFECT! We had tons of compliments on the popcorn. We ordered plenty and people were grabbing them to take home at the end of the night. A perfect snack after a few beers. Theu were very fast with the samples and the order too!
Lyndsey C., 5 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Perfectly Styled & Sweet LLC 

5.0

  • Starts at $700
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT for additional fees

Perfectly Styled & Sweet is a custom cake shop located in NJ. We specialize in wedding and celebration cakes. We have been featured in several publications including the notable Brides Magazine and Munaluchi Bride Magazine. We have also created custom orders for celebrities, such as Marc Anthony and Coco Austin. Our passion for our work has also allowed us the opportunity to appear on such shows as Despierta America. Our purpose is to create one-of-a-kind masterpieces and everlasting memories for our clients.

Perfectly Styled & Sweet was an absolute joy to work with for our wedding cake and desserts. From our first meeting, the owner was extremely responsive, direct in her recommendations, and made the whole process calm and stress-free. She took the time to understand our vision, even using pictures of my grandparent's cake and details of my dress as inspiration to perfectly capture what we wanted. Throughout the planning process, she was accommodating to our requests, attentive to every detail we provided, and made sure the final products felt personalized to us as a couple. The end result not only looked beautiful but tasted delicious too. I would highly recommend Perfectly Styled & Sweet for their clear communication, dedication to truly understanding their clients, and talent creating elegant, customized desserts that make your wedding feel that much more special.
Carissa B., 3 months ago
TrendlineTrending
BakerBitesCo 

5.0

  • Starts at $200
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT for additional fees

Ready to impress your guests with our unique tasty treat? BakerBitesCo offers single serve fudge bites with customized labels to fit your perfect day. Wedding favors, bridesmaids gifts, wedding party gifts, etc. these can be used in any way to fit your needs. WHY YOU'LL LOVE US -We offer delicious unique seasonal flavors -We ship anywhere in the US -We can send a sampler box so you can taste all our flavors and pick your favorites. -Budget friendly at only $2/piece -Prepackaged, making our dessert ideal during COVID -We give a meal to a hungry child with every order We can't wait to make your day even more spectacular!

Best fudge I’ve ever had and the flavor varieties are amazing! I love that I can customize them for any occasion!
Linda, 4 years ago
GemHidden gem
Spiced & Iced 

5.0

  • Starts at $180
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT

Spiced & Iced was established in 2021 focusing on uniquely personalized, highly decorative sugar cookies for weddings, engagement parties, bridal showers, and bachelorette parties. Perfect for thank you favors to your guests / bridal party, or even a special touch to your dessert table. Custom cookies to fit any theme and create a moment to last a lifetime!

Awarded Best of Zola
We received so many compliments from our guests on our cookie favors!! Everyone told us how delicious they were, and they stayed fresh for days after the wedding too. Michelle was a dream to work with and gave us a few different ideas based upon the inspiration we gave her. The cookies were beautifully decorated, and also packaged with a bag and cute bow for easy placement at our tables. She also assured us her cookie recipe is allergen friendly which gave us so much peace of mind with a few peanut allergies at our wedding. We can’t recommend Michelle enough!!
Alicia K., 2 years ago

Location flexible? Discover cakes & desserts near Old Lyme, CT

About wedding cakes & desserts in Old Lyme, CT

How much do wedding cakes usually cost in Old Lyme, CT?

Wedding cake packages start at $250 and run up to $350 per person in Old Lyme, CT.

Do bakers in Old Lyme, CT offer cakes for special diets?

They do! 21 offer Gluten-free desserts, and 15 offer Vegan options.8 offer Sugar-free options.

What are the most popular cake and dessert options in Old Lyme, CT?

The most popular wedding cake vendors in Old Lyme, CT are Perfectly Styled & Sweet LLC, Eat More Cake Llc and Sweet Buckets.

What other Old Lyme vendors will I need?

What other cakes and desserts are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?