The Best Italian Wedding Catering in New Brighton, MN

The Best Italian Wedding Catering in New Brighton, MN

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


8 Wedding Caterers in New Brighton, MN

Italian
Quick responder
Green Mill Catering & Bar Service 
Rating: 5.0 (10 reviews)
  • Starts at $50
  • Serves New Brighton, MN

It starts with a complimentary tasting and ends with an incredible dinner and a VERY happy couple. Our staff is ready with everything you need: linens, napkins, china, glassware, coffee, etc. and complete set up & tear down. We can even bring the bar!

Awarded Best of Zola
“The Green Mill team was a pleasure to work with for our wedding! The food was delicious and the service was incredible. Sarah and Katie were so gracious during the planning portion and answered ALL our questions which made it a breeze! Several high marks from our guests as well! Highly recommend Green Mill for your next event.”
Katie J., 2 years ago
Quick responder
CRAVE Catering 
Rating: 4.9 (39 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Starts at $4,000
  • Serves New Brighton, MN

Established in the Twin Cities, minority-owned, and a division of Kaskaid Hospitality, we at CRAVE Catering pride ourselves on our genuine passion for the food and beverage industry and desire to provide an elevated and unparalleled dining experience for all guests. Kaskaid Hospitality is behind the restaurant concepts CRAVE American Kitchen and Sushi, Brit’s Pub, Union Rooftop, The Butcher’s Tale, Burger Burger, BLVD, a wellness company Nuleev, and our exclusive event center – Quincy Hall.

Awarded Best of Zola
“From the moment we started planning, CRAVE Catering made the whole process stress-free with quick responses to every question we had. Their team pulled off a flawless event that tasted incredible, and what really stood out was how thoughtful they were throughout the day. They boxed up meals for our entertainment before they performed, and when they noticed I was too busy managing things to eat, they made me a plate without me even asking. It was clear they know exactly what they're doing—we didn't have to worry about a single detail. CRAVE Catering turned our wedding day into something truly special, and we can't recommend them enough.”
Karen P., 4 months ago
Quick responder
This Little Piggy Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (9 reviews)
  • Starts at $40
  • Serves New Brighton, MN

Established in 1979, our legendary catering has been enjoyed by thousands of wedding couples and their treasured guests. Proudly family owned and operated, This Little Piggy is a favorite for weddings and events throughout Minnesota and Western WI.

Awarded Best of Zola
“Working with This Little Piggy Catering was such a great choice for our wedding day. Mallory made the entire planning process smooth and stress-free with her professional guidance, never making us feel rushed or uncertain about decisions. The food was delicious, and her team paid close attention to every detail to ensure everything was executed perfectly. What really stood out was how approachable and supportive the staff were throughout the day—they genuinely seemed to care about making our event special. From start to finish, This Little Piggy Catering delivered exactly what we needed, and we'd recommend them to any couple looking for a caterer who gets the job done right.”
Mackenzie J., 3 months ago
Quick responder
Apples 2 Apples Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Starts at $10
  • Serves New Brighton, MN

Available at our many exclusive venues, Apples 2 Apples Catering offers an ethical farm to table catering concept using healthy ingredients fresh from local farms across Minnesota and Wisconsin. The menu offers organic, grass fed, free range, and sustainable options, served in an eco-friendly manner. We also specialize in serving those with dietary restrictions such as gluten and dairy intolerance, as well as vegetarian and vegan needs.

“Apple 2 Apples catering is the best all around catering Company with the best food, best prices, and best service.”
Michael, 2 years ago
River Valley Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Serves New Brighton, MN

We proudly serve the Twin Cities Metro area, as well as the Greater St. Croix Valley in Western Wisconsin. With nearly 30 years in the catering business, we have the experience you want for your event. Don’t hesitate to contact us with any questions you may have about our services.

“Bry and the whole team at River Valley went above and beyond! The communication was so stellar leading up to the big day and it really helped put our minds at ease knowing we could always reach out to Bry and get such a quick reply! The food was spectacular, people are still talking about those mashed potatoes! The servers were all very friendly and did a spectacular job taking care of us and our guests. River Valley is a phenomenal, professional, and delicious catering company for weddings or any large event!”
Julia C., 2 years ago
Wandering Charcuterie 
  • Starts at $156
  • Serves New Brighton, MN

Beautifying the ordinary. That is what Charcuterie is to us. Your wedding is a magical moment that brings all your favorite people together. When you hire Wandering Charcuterie, you are guaranteed an elevated, full-service experience for both you and your guests. We are into the details, making sure everything is just as you envision. So when you have 100 things to do for your special day and you want someone you can count on, let Wandering Charcuterie take feeding your guests, off your plate.

Local Effort 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Serves New Brighton, MN

Local Effort specializes in personal and event cooking, with an emphasis on local ingredients. We provide plated, coursed meals akin to a restaurant experience, more casual family-style meals, and appetizer-focused cocktail party service, all with the same ingredient-obsessed quality.

“Local Effort has been a part of several smaller events I have hosted as well as a large family reunion. The food is delicious, creative and presented beautifully. Weston worked with me to develop a menu that would fit each event I have hosted and Catherine makes the most delicious treats.”
Stefanie K., 3 years ago
Broders' Catering & Hospitality 
Rating: 5.0 (5 reviews)
  • Starts at $120
  • Serves New Brighton, MN

Family-owned & operated since 1982, Broders' Catering & Hospitality brings over 40 years of experience in Italian cuisine, warm service, and unforgettable celebrations. As an extension of the beloved Broders' Restaurants in Minneapolis, we offer full-service catering that blends old-world tradition with modern hospitality. From intimate dinners to grand receptions, our team provides curated menus rooted in regional Italian flavors, seasonal ingredients and thoughtful presentation. We believe in hospitality that feels like home and proudly support love in all its forms.

“Broders' Catering was a wonderful choice for our wedding. The catering specialist was clear, thoughtful, and professional throughout the entire process. The food they provided was delicious, authentic, and served in good portions. Their drop-off catering service helped eliminate stress during an already busy time, and the plating and presentation of the dishes made it easy for us to serve right away with little to no preparation. The food was not only delicious, but also well-priced for the quality - we even had leftovers! We highly recommend Broders' Catering for any special event.”
Frank P., 2 years ago

About wedding caterers in New Brighton, MN

What other New Brighton vendors will I need?

What other caterers are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?