The Best Italian Wedding Catering in Mount Ayr, IN

The Best Italian Wedding Catering in Mount Ayr, IN

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


13 Wedding Caterers in Mount Ayr, IN

Italian
Quick responder
The Food Truck Hub 
Rating: 4.8 (50 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Serves Mount Ayr, IN

The Food Truck Hub was founded in 2014 and has since expanded in scope and breadth. Our mission of creating memorable event experiences is fulfilled through our streamlined, one-stop-shop approach to simplify your event planning. We enjoy the creative process and finding the uniqueness in every occasion to give each event its own personality. Options are boundless - whether food trucks, carts, and beyond catering, our team can help create the right experience that you're looking to build.

Quick responder
Wooden Paddle Catering 
Rating: 4.7 (38 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Serves Mount Ayr, IN

Wooden Paddle Catering is Chicagoland's go-to for full-service wedding catering that's anything but ordinary. We roll up to your venue with mobile wood-fired brick ovens and cook everything fresh and live — wood-fired pizzas, chef-designed apps, desserts, and craft cocktails your guests will not stop talking about. We handle it all: professional staffing, full bar, rentals, setup, and teardown. Family-style, plated, or stations — you name it, we bring it. With 10+ years and 1,000+ events across Chicagoland, we've been to just about every venue in the suburbs. Serving the greater Chicago area within 50 miles of Lemont. 🔥

“From our first phone call with Wooden Paddle Catering, we knew we'd found our caterer. The team was responsive, accommodating, and genuinely excited to work with us on our big day. We did a pre-wedding tasting and loved it so much we didn't need to try any other restaurant. We decided to go with their 3 apps, 4 pizza, and beverage package, and they were totally flexible when we wanted to swap out the White Claw for High Noons. On the day of the wedding, their staff was incredible and kept everything running smoothly behind the scenes. The food was outstanding—the burrata toast, shrimp with polenta, and meatballs were standouts, and our guests couldn't stop talking about the signature cocktails we created together (Wooden Paddle Old Fashioned and Vodka Pomegranate). Since our wedding was at a loft, we wanted a rustic chic vibe and the food complemented the venue! We can't recommend Wooden Paddle Catering highly enough.”
Younga C., 7 days ago
Quick responder
SaveurFRESH Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (17 reviews)
  • Serves Mount Ayr, IN

A CULINARY JOURNEY TAILORED WITH UNIQUE VISION and CULINARY CREATION . With chic innovative vision emerging from diverse cultures specializing in superior meats fresh seafood and organic ingredients while influenced through distinctive heritages and cultural trends, Our Custom Catering brings you profound ethnic cuisine with superior taste impeccable service & atmosphere. Indulge your guests with a culinary journey that is as diverse as your imagination. Every event is full and complete offering beverage service alongside our meal offerings and our mission is to provide exceptional catering services that exceed our clients expectations

Awarded Best of Zola
“Saveur Fresh Catering was an absolute lifesaver for our wedding day. After our originally hired caterer cancelled on us last minute, Chef Chris and his team at Saveur Fresh stepped in and saved the day. Their communication was quick, streamlined, and courteous throughout the entire process. The quality of their work was outstanding, excellent, and truly top-notch. I will forever be so very grateful to Saveur Fresh and Chef Chris - they kept my wifes dream wedding alive when it seemed like it was going to be a disaster. Thanks to their incredible service and delicious food, our wedding day was perfect. I highly recommend Saveur Fresh Catering to any couple looking for an exceptional catering experience.”
Robert, a year ago
Quick responder
CK Catering 
Rating: 4.9 (16 reviews)
  • Starts at $36
  • Serves Mount Ayr, IN

CK Catering is a family-owned business in Benton Harbor, Michigan, with roots in the food and beverage industry since 1972. Our award-winning team is passionate about creating exceptional culinary experiences, customizing menus to match your vision. We offer a diverse range of acclaimed dishes—local, international, and dietary-friendly—to delight every guest. With various dinner service styles and a dedicated team to guide you, CK Catering is committed to making your special day truly unforgettable.

Awarded Best of Zola
“CK Catering can be characterized by exceptional food quality, meticulous service, and carefully curated culinary dishes. Our wedding venue has complete faith with the high level of service offered by CK Catering.”
Stonegate Manor V., 2 years ago
Quick responder
Fitoor Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (13 reviews)
  • Serves Mount Ayr, IN

As a leading catering company, we pride ourselves on crafting unforgettable dining experiences that elevate any occasion. Our team of skilled chefs meticulously curates a diverse menu, showcasing a fusion of global cuisines, using only the finest and freshest ingredients. Our dedicated staff ensures seamless execution, from personalized menu planning to flawless presentation, leaving you free to savor every moment of your special day.

Awarded Best of Zola
“Fitoor created an outstanding appetizer display for The Wedding Mastermind Event at Wildman BT and we could not have been more pleased. The apps were outstanding with delicious options for all dietary needs. We look forward to working with the Fitoor Catering team again soon!”
Michelle V., 8 months ago
Quick responder
Best Eats Catering Company 
Rating: 4.4 (7 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Starts at $18
  • Serves Mount Ayr, IN
  • Offer

Personalized catering for weddings, open houses, birthdays, and corporate events, made with fresh local ingredients and a whole lot of heart. We are here to turn your vision into a reality. If you are ready please reach out to us

“From our first conversation, Best Eats Catering Company made us feel heard and supported every step of the way. The team was responsive to our questions and worked closely with our other vendors to keep everything running smoothly on the day of our wedding. What really impressed us was how the chef stayed in touch with everyone involved to ensure perfect timing. The food arrived hot and ready, and honestly, it tasted incredible. Our guests couldn't stop talking about the meals, and we felt like the whole experience was handled with real professionalism. We'd absolutely recommend Best Eats to any couple looking for caterers they can trust.”
Denise L., a month ago
Quick responder
DIVINE TREATS & HEAVENLY EATS 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Starts at $7,500
  • Serves Mount Ayr, IN

I’m passionate about my work because I truly love bringing people together through food, hospitality, and beautiful experiences. There is something so meaningful about being a part of a wedding day and knowing that what we create helps make the celebration feel even more special. I take great pride in serving others, paying attention to the details, and creating memorable moments that couples and their guests will cherish long after the event is over.

“Divine Treats & Heavenly Eats were absolutely amazing!! The food was outstanding!!! The service and the staff were not only professional but also friendly, helpful, and soooo patient with us. I would highly recommend them to anyone and everyone for your event!!! Best decision we have made!”
Brenda H., 7 months ago
Quick responder
Untraditional Eats 
  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves Mount Ayr, IN
  • Offer

*For the rest of 2026, get a free events space for events up to 50 people! We have just moved into a restaurant with a small indoor area and a large private enclosed garden. This is best for bridal showers, wedding party breakfasts/lunch/dinners, elopements and other small meals surrounding your wedding day. Microweddings okay!* Untraditional Eats was founded by a globe-trotting hyper polyglot who speaks 7 languages. That unparalleled exposure to different cultures, cuisines and ways of cooking, as well as an unmatched cultural sensitivity, makes us exceptionally great at what we do.

Quick responder
Billy Bricks on Wheels 
Rating: 4.7 (92 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Starts at $850
  • Serves Mount Ayr, IN for additional fees

Family owned and operated since 2005, Billy Bricks on Wheels is one of IL’s fastest growing independent food truck business! With 7 brick-and-mortar stores, 6 mobile food truck units slinging authentic Neapolitan style pizza, pasta, salads, apps, and more made in a 900 degree wood fired oven, & a vintage 1958 Ford F350 Ice Cream bar truck/carts now serving up super premium ice cream! Welcome to the wood fired side, where we elevate traditional wedding catering into a unique and interactive experience for the entire wedding party. MANGIA!

Awarded Best of Zola
““ Billy Bricks catered our wedding on Saturday May 18, 2024 and we could not have had a better experience! From the moment I contacted them Craig & his team answered every and all questions quickly and put me at ease every step of the way. The day of the wedding they were nothing short of professional! All the food was made on time and it was DELICIOUS! All 160ish of our guests had nothing but great things to say about the food. In fact, it was talked about for the rest of the night! They all kept saying it was the best food they've had at a wedding ever. If you're looking for something fun and unique for any of your events I could not recommend Billy Bricks on Wheels enough! I look forward to working with them for ANY event I plan moving forward. Thank you again Billy Bricks for everything!!””
Jessica N., 2 years ago
Quick responder
Maison Cuisine 
Rating: 4.9 (13 reviews)
  • Starts at $5,000
  • Serves Mount Ayr, IN for additional fees

Maison Cuisine is an eco-conscious, full-service catering & event planning company, specializing in corporate events, weddings and other social gatherings. From black tie weddings to the annual company picnic, Maison Cuisine caters to your every need. As a full-service caterer, we understand what makes an event unforgettable. Maison Cuisine starts each dish with the highest quality ingredients. We use locally grown fruits and vegetables, when seasonally available – some coming from urban Westside farms. We offer natural meats & poultry, in addition to freshly prepared baked goods.

Awarded Best of Zola
“Maison Cuisine provided impeccable service and delicious food at our wedding! They were a preferred vendor at our venue, and when we were planning the wedding, I could see why. They were very easy to work with and knew the venue and our other vendors extremely well. They were pretty much perfect on the wedding day. We did a buffet with a plated salad brought to guests when they arrived at their seats. We had some guests with dietary restrictions, and they would bring special plates to those guests. The servers were very nice and efficient. We got so many compliments on the food and service! (Attached photos by Audrey Simper)”
Christopher S., 5 days ago
Quick responder
Elegante Cuisine 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Starts at $5,625
  • Serves Mount Ayr, IN for additional fees

At Eleganté Cuisine, our sole goal is to ensure the complete satisfaction and happiness of our customers. Through our meticulous attention to detail, quality, execution and presentation, we always strive to exceed expectations by placing the utmost emphasis on the wants and needs of our clientele.

Awarded Best of Zola
“Elegante Cuisine is one of the higher end catering companies in the area, so this was a splurge for us, but one that we do not regret. Good food and good music are two of the biggest factors in the guest experience, so it was worth it to us. Our tasting was awesome; their menu options are extensive but all the dishes seemed to be executed perfectly. They had catered at our venue many times, and seemed highly competent. During and since the wedding, many of our friends and family have raved to us that it was the best food they’ve had at a wedding. Our entrees were the chicken asiago and the stuffed peppers (sooo good!). On the wedding day, Elegante staff took great care of us, even making sure we had hot, full plates and an assortment of our cocktail hour hors d'oeuvres ready when we entered the reception space. We worked with Trisha, who at times did not respond very effectively or efficiently to our questions/concerns/requests, but overall we are very happy with the services we received and us and all the guests were certainly well fed.”
Megan, 3 years ago
TrendlineTrending
To Go For Your Soul 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Starts at $3,750
  • Serves Mount Ayr, IN for additional fees

I am 27 years Old. I started “To Go For Your Soul” in 2020. I am passionate about cooking and have been cooking for 12 years now. I see food as art you can eat and it is a daily activity that is a necessity for us to live so why not make it as enjoyable as possible. Food for many of us is Community, Gathering, Celebration, & Relief. It is a very important part of any occasion especially in the world of weddings. In reality amongst all other tasks, it can be very stressful to plan an event and focus of feeding you and your guests.

Quick responder
Sincere Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Starts at $1,000
  • Serves Mount Ayr, IN for additional fees

Welcome to the extraordinary tastes of Sincere Catering...a love letter paying homage to tradition and the evolution of cuisine! Sincere specializes in making your event day special by customizing your menu, preferences, and culinary options.

“Sincere Catering & Sincerely Yours Events was a cooperative, outstanding, and one-time communicable partner for our wedding. The quality of their work was top-tier and delicious - they gave me extra things I did not order as a gift, everything was on time, and I did not have to worry about the correct temperatures. I love the way they took their time, gave me options, and worked within my budget. The team was very easy to communicate with and never rushed me. I give Sincere Catering & Sincerely Yours Events a 10 out of 10 and highly recommend them.”
CARMEN, a year ago