The Best Italian Wedding Catering in Eagle Bay, NY

The Best Italian Wedding Catering in Eagle Bay, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


5 Wedding Caterers in Eagle Bay, NY

Italian
GemHidden gem
The Bearded Bear BBQ 
Rating: 4.9 (103 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves Eagle Bay, NY for additional fees

BBQ catering and food truck services for weddings, rehearsal dinners, corporate events, and celebrations. Catering packages starting at $28 per person with options for full food truck experience, we are way more than just BBQ!

“The Bearded Bear Catering does an amazing job! They have a great menu to choose from - whether you're looking for a full catered BBQ meal (the cornbread casserole is amazing!!), or a charcuterie display - they can do it all. They are very versatile too, depending on the type of event you are hosting. They can cater upscale weddings or informal events with their food truck. Their team is reliable and professional. Highly recommend!”
Bethany S., 2 days ago
Quick responder
Grace & Faith BBQ 
Rating: 5.0 (12 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Starts at $1,000
  • Serves Eagle Bay, NY for additional fees

Grace & Faith BBQ is a Premier Craft BBQ Catering Company that provides a great environment & of course a mouth watering experience filled with tons of Fresh Smoked BBQ. At Grace & Faith BBQ we focus on creating an unforgettable experience for the couple and your guest. We offer everything from our delicious Authentic Southern BBQ to American favorites and Latin dishes. Our Pit Master, Originally from NC has more then 10 years experience in the BBQ and Catering industry.

“HI hired Grace & Faith for my wedding. Their food was fantastic! I highly recommend using them for all your parties and affairs. Professional, experienced and most importantly they delivered as promised. My guest enjoyed the food.”
Kim E., 2 years ago
Quick responder
Lorrielle's 
Rating: 4.5 (11 reviews)
  • Starts at $2,500
  • Serves Eagle Bay, NY for additional fees
  • Offer

At Lorrielle’s Catering & Events, we specialize in luxury private chef services, premier catering, and seamless event planning. We are dedicated to crafting elevated culinary experiences that range from intimate, multi-course fine dining to vibrant, sophisticated family-style feasts. Every menu is entirely bespoke, featuring bold flavor profiles and premium ingredients designed to delight the palate and spark conversation. We don't just feed guests; we bring a luxury restaurant experience directly to your venue, curating an unforgettable atmosphere where exceptional food meets meticulous execution.

“From our first call to the day of our wedding, Lorrielle's was always there when we needed them. They responded right away to every question and made planning feel simple and stress-free. The food was fresh and delicious, and their team thought through every detail from decorations to helping us find lodging for our guests. What really impressed us was their crew—there were enough people on staff to handle everything, even keeping the bathrooms spotless all night. When our photographer accidentally broke one of our flower arrangements, they cleaned it up instantly and turned the broken flowers into petals for our flower girl to toss. Working with Lorrielle's made our wedding day special, and we would recommend them to anyone looking for a caterer who truly cares.”
Chandra, 4 months ago
Mangia and Enjoy! 
  • Starts at $25,000
  • Serves Eagle Bay, NY for additional fees

Chef Sarah Chianese is an accomplished, award-winning chef & Wedding Industry Professional creating unique & memorable boutique wedding experiences for over a decade. She & her exceptional team at Mangia and Enjoy! provide the most flavorful, heart-warming, healthy and beautifully presented meals for you & your loved ones using local, organic & seasonal ingredients in a creative way - your experience, your palette's pleasure, and alway made with love! Local, organic, seasonal, farm fresh and full of Flavor! Mangia and Enjoy! has been featured in: Bridal Guide, Wedding Chicks, She Finds, Catersource, Dances With Her & more. WIPA, ICA & NACE.