Specialty Jewelry Insurance Vs. Protection Plans: What Do I Need?

Want to know the difference between a protection plan and jewelry insurance? Learn what coverage is right for you to keep your wedding rings and other jewelry safe and secure.

By Jewelers Mutual

wedding ring insurance
Photo by Unsplash

Sponsored Content. We may earn compensation if you click the links or buttons below.

As you investigate the various ways to protect your engagement ring, wedding ring, or other jewelry, you may be questioning your options. Whether through your jeweler, friend, family member, or your own online research, you likely came up with a couple of considerations: a protection plan and jewelry insurance.

Spoiler alert: They are not the same.

You want to wear your jewelry without worry, knowing you’re covered if something happens. Both a protection plan and jewelry insurance are great to have, but it’s important to understand how the coverages differ.

Let’s go over some of the things that set protection plans apart from specialty jewelry insurance so you can make a confident decision about how best to protect your special pieces.

What does a typical protection plan cover?

  • Protection plans may be purchased from your jeweler at the same time as the jewelry purchase and typically covers your jewelry from damage caused by normal wear. This may include damage like a worn prong or a thinning band.
  • You may be able to purchase a protection plan for various time periods, such as 1-year, 3-years, 5-years, or even lifetime. When your plan expires and you want further coverage, you would need to purchase a new plan.
  • Protection plans typically do not include loss or theft.

What does jewelry insurance cover?

  • A stand-alone policy from a specialty jewelry insurer like the Jewelers Mutual Group may be mentioned by your jeweler as an option to consider but is the coverage you would purchase directly through the insurer, not with your jeweler.
  • Specialized jewelry insurance includes more comprehensive coverage to protect your jewelry from perils such as loss, theft, damage, and mysterious disappearance.
  • Accidents like cracking your stone on the edge of a table, leaving your ring on a beach towel, or just not having a clue where you left your necklace would all be covered with jewelry insurance.
  • Jewelry insurance policies typically are 12-month renewable policies with the premium paid annually.

Couldn't I purchase both?

Jewelry owners may purchase both a protection plan for routine maintenance along with a jewelry insurance policy for comprehensive coverage that extends beyond the protection plan coverage for maximum protection.

Remember to check with your jeweler for any complimentary services they may provide to keep your ring and other jewelry sparkling like new. Whether you have a protection plan, insurance or both, it’s recommended you visit your jeweler at least twice a year for a professional cleaning and inspection. Your jeweler will be able to examine your ring with an expert eye to ensure it’s in good condition.

For more information about specialty jewelry insurance from Jewelers Mutual, visit: JewelersMutual.com

jeweler's mutual logo
About Jewelers Mutual

Your jewelry reflects who you are and represents your life’s special moments and memories. It deserves protection from jewelry insurance experts.

Jewelers Mutual Insurance Group is the only insurer in North America solely dedicated to jewelry and only jewelry for over 100 years. No matter what pieces you insure, you’ll have the extra level of protection that comes from specialty jewelry insurance to wear your jewelry without worry.

Get started

Up next for you

Close up of female hand with engagement ring holding male hand across her chest

Complete Guide to Engagement Ring Insurance

Q & A

Engagement ring insurance is an easy way to achieve peace of mind and keep your jewelry safe. How much does it cost? Do you need it? And, if so, where can you find the best policy? We've got the answers.

gold wedding band and three diamond eternity wedding bands on a white sequined fabric

A Guide to Wedding Rings

Q & A

From how much you should expect to spend on a wedding ring to tips for how to choose the right one for you, check out this guide on wedding ring styles, types, and materials.

where you can wear your engagment rings

Where You Can (and Can't) Wear Your Engagement Ring

Q & A

Diamond experts share all the places you can wear your engagement ring and where you shouldn't wear your ring. Plus, tips for keeping your engagement ring like new.

Find even more wedding ideas, inspo, tips, and tricks

We’ve got wedding planning advice on everything from save the dates to wedding cakes.