Bethel Bakery

Price per serving

Starts at $4 per person.

About Bethel Bakery

Bethel Bakery

Wedding Department

Bethel Bakery has the right ingredients to make your wedding celebration a truly remarkable affair. During your intimate, at-home consultation, our talented, educated staff will guide you through a step-by-step, full-service planning experience. Together, we will whip up a recipe for an extraordinary custom wedding cake that fits your unique taste, style, and budget.

In an era driven by convenience and competition from mega-markets and chain stores, Bethel Bakery has endured because it is far more than a retailer of baked goods - it is a memorable destination experience and a nostalgic reminder of the charms of independent bakeries that were once a part of the fabric of every community.

Best of Zola 2026

Services

Dessert types

  • Cakes
  • Cookies and macarons
  • Cupcakes
  • Donuts
  • Mini desserts

Decor options

  • Custom text
  • Sugar flowers

Available customizations

  • Cake filling
  • Cake flavors

Services offered

  • Consultations
  • Delivery
  • Setup
  • Tastings

Dietary accommodations

  • Nut-free
  • Vegetarian

Reviews

Write a review

5.0 out of 5

14 reviews

  • RL

    Rachel L.

    •Nov 28, 2025

    Love Bethel Bakery!

    My husband and I opted for a small cake for ourselves and we got the cutest cake from Bethel Bakery! We ordered the heart shaped cake that had "Just Married" written on it. Super easy to order online.

  • BR

    Brittany R.

    •Nov 16, 2025

    Great experience

    Our cake and cupcakes for guests turned out perfectly! Would highly recommend

  • BJ

    Brittany J.

    •Oct 6, 2025

    Cupcakes

    Bethel Bakery provided the cupcakes for our wedding and they were absolutely delicious. The communication with them was okay, but they set up a beautiful display for the desserts that really impressed our guests. The cupcakes themselves were excellent - moist, flavorful, and beautifully decorated. While the communication could have been a bit better, the quality of their work and the value they provided was top-notch. We were very happy with Bethel Bakery's contribution to making our special day memorable.

  • OS

    Olivia S.

    •Sep 19, 2025

    Bethel Bakery Wedding Cake Review

    Bethel Bakery was an absolute pleasure to work with for our wedding cake. From the very first interaction, their communication was punctual, attentive, and genuinely helpful as we navigated all the options. The final cake they created was not only beautiful with the decorations we requested, but it tasted absolutely delicious and has stayed fresh even days later. We were thrilled with the quality and value of their work - the cake was both high-quality and affordable, which was exactly what we were looking for. We would happily recommend Bethel Bakery to any couple planning their wedding. They truly helped make our special day even more perfect!

  • KA

    K. A.

    •Incentivized review
    •Jul 18, 2025

    Bethel Bakery is amazing!

    Bethel Bakery was a wonderful choice for our wedding cake. From the very beginning, their communication was prompt, and they were always available to answer our questions and provide great advice. The quality of their work was truly professional - the design on our cake was beautiful, and the tasting process was smooth and enjoyable. They worked seamlessly with our other vendors, accommodated all of our requests, and ensured timely delivery on the big day. We are thrilled with how everything turned out and highly recommend Bethel Bakery to any couple planning their wedding.

Real wedding inspiration featuring Bethel Bakery

Show all photos

Explore other vendors serving Bethel Park, PA

Complete your dream team

Other cakes & desserts in Bethel Park

Other wedding services nearby