The Best 6 Italian Wedding Catering in New Castle, AL

Quick responder

Simply Sated By Tessa

Rating: 4.5 (27 reviews)

Starts at $1,500
Serves New Castle, AL

Award-winning wedding catering by Chef Tessa. With 23+ years of experience, Simply Sated offers fully customized menus, grazing tables, cakes, bartending, décor, rentals, and coordination—your one-stop shop for unforgettable weddings.

“Newly weds here, Ms.Tessa was really nice on our menu. If there was something that we didn't want in the menu or wanted to change or take something from the menu or services, she'll take it out with no hesitation. We asked for servers and a coordinator. We had her make steak smothered with mushroom and onion gravy, garlic herb chicken, mixed veggies, mashed potatoes, mac and cheese and dinner rolls. Drink we picked with water, sweet tea and flavor fruit water. The Mac and cheese was the favorite for everyone along side with sweet tea. Unfortunately we didn't try the chicken, we were too full to say. The steak with the gravy was okay to say. The mix veggies were actually on the spicy side, we weren't aware of that. The carrots in it was a little undercooked, really hard in the center. Loved the servers, they were lovely. The Coordinator however was a little something. Within less than a month of the wedding, Ms. Tessa introduced her to us. Immediately almost every day, she would ask us question after question. Our stress skyrocketed ever since we met the Coordinator, to the point my mother had to step in to say that we can talk after I'm off of work. She is nice, she's helped with putting stuff together for the binder, talked to each of the vendors, helped with getting the wedding together and even helped cleaned up afterwards. Honestly, it would've been better and less stressful if we had met her maybe 3 months ahead of time. Overall, they did an awesome job, each and every one of them. Thank you all for your hard work. 3”

T&L, 3 days ago

Quick responder

Grace’s Place

Rating: 4.0 (4 reviews)

Starts at $2,000
Serves New Castle, AL

At Grace’s Place & Catering, we believe love is best celebrated with great food, warm hospitality, and personal touches that make your day unforgettable. Based in Leesburg, GA, we offer full-service catering for weddings across Georgia and surrounding areas—serving everything from elegant plated dinners to Southern-style buffets, brunch spreads, and late-night bites

“We used Grace's Place for our wedding catering and couldn't be happier with the service they provided. From the beginning, Hannah was incredibly responsive, prompt, and clear in all of our communications as we planned the menu and logistics. On the day of the wedding, the catering staff were fabulous - they were so sweet and even asked if our dog needed a plate for dinner! The quality of the food was excellent, and we especially loved the twice baked potatoes and mac and cheese. The ladies knew exactly what to do and made the whole catering process a breeze. We are so grateful to Grace's Place for helping make our special day a success!”

Madison H., a year ago

Quick responder

Bon appetit LLC

Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)

Starts at $1,500
Serves New Castle, AL
Offer

Congragulations! You’ve found who you’re looking for right here! Lol. Hello, im Hannah. A chef with 16 years of cooking under my belt I enjoy cooking just about every menu to fit your needs. The most popular menu is a taco/nacho buffet. I also do a lot of pasta/salad bars and comfort food buffets. Please reach out with any questions.

“My husband and I ordered a full buffet for our wedding of 200 guests. I was absolutely thrilled with the service and loved the flavors and they attitude overall very happy.”

Jade, a month ago

Quick responder

Yae's Eats & Catering LLC

Rating: 5.0 (33 reviews)

·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews

Starts at $2,000
Serves New Castle, AL for additional fees

Yaes Eats is a family-driven catering and community outreach business committed to serving great food and giving back. We specialize in high-quality, affordable catering for weddings, events, and celebrations of all sizes. Beyond food, we’re passionate about supporting families in need through fundraisers, toy drives, and community giveaways. Everything we do is rooted in love, service, and making a positive impact—one plate and one family at a time.

“We had an amazing experience with Yae’s Eats & Catering LLC for our wedding! From start to finish, they were communicative, flexible, and made everything feel so seamless. The food was absolutely incredible—everything from the drinks and appetizers to the main courses was delicious. Our guests loved the stuffed mushrooms and meatballs, and the Tuscan chicken and Salisbury steak with gravy were a huge hit. The mac and cheese, corn casserole, and collard greens were amazing and truly felt like authentic soul food! The bar service was fantastic as well—the margaritas were a favorite! A special thank you to Chef Anyae and her team for their hard work and for creating such a memorable experience for us and our guests. Highly recommend!”

Bria C., 7 months ago

Eight Eleven Catering

Rating: 5.0 (1 review)

Serves New Castle, AL

Welcome to Eight Eleven Catering. We are a Chef owned and operated premier catering company offering our services in Birmingham Alabama and the surrounding areas. With both casual and sophisticated food options we are able to cater an expansive array of affairs. From extravagant weddings to intimate dinners, our head chef Lamar Lockett work closely with you to ensure your vision is brought to life.

“Had the change to work with Lamar and Eight Eleven Catering last year. One Word AMAZING!!! The food, the service, the staff...AMAZING!”

LIV Creative Solutions, 5 years ago

Hidden gem

Chef Rockie Bree Cajun & Southern Personal Chef Luxury Dining Experiences

Rating: 5.0 (2 reviews)

Starts at $3,000
Serves New Castle, AL for additional fees

I’m a traveling Private Chef servicing Florida & Alabama. I specialize in Southern Cajun Cuisine and a multitude of other cuisine. Chef RockieBree is my passion. I’m a BS Johnson & Wales University Graduate in Culinary & Food Service Management

“She simply brought the experience with her amazing food! My family and friends were so impressed and still 3 weeks still bragging about how the food was so delicious. I recommend her over and over for weddings or even dinner for a private chef within the Florida area”

Tiffany H., 3 years ago

The Best Italian Wedding Catering in New Castle, AL

The Best Italian Wedding Catering in New Castle, AL

Location flexible? Discover caterers near New Castle, AL

Meal services for wedding caterers in New Castle, AL

Breakfast/brunch

Buffet

Dessert service

About wedding caterers in New Castle, AL

What other New Castle vendors will I need?

What other caterers are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?

Wedding Bands & DJs near New Castle, AL

Wedding Planners near New Castle, AL

Wedding Videographers near New Castle, AL

Wedding Photographers near New Castle, AL

Wedding Cakes & Desserts near New Castle, AL

Wedding Beauty Professionals near New Castle, AL

Wedding Florists near New Castle, AL

Wedding Venues near New Castle, AL

Wedding Bar Services & Beverages near New Castle, AL