The Best Italian Wedding Catering in Athens, AL

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


3 Wedding Caterers in Athens, AL

Italian
Quick responder
Yae's Eats & Catering LLC 
Rating: 5.0 (33 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves Athens, AL

Yaes Eats is a family-driven catering and community outreach business committed to serving great food and giving back. We specialize in high-quality, affordable catering for weddings, events, and celebrations of all sizes. Beyond food, we’re passionate about supporting families in need through fundraisers, toy drives, and community giveaways. Everything we do is rooted in love, service, and making a positive impact—one plate and one family at a time.

Awarded Best of Zola
“Wedding food sometimes gets a bad reputation, for good reason I suppose. But I can say definitively that Anyae and team cooked the best wedding meal I’ve ever had - I REALLY loved our dinner. Beyond that, out of all of our vendors, they were consistently one of the only ones we didn’t have to stress over. Anyae is consistently responsive (despite my many, many tedious questions), and her flexibility and caring nature truly went above and beyond even our best expectations. Anyae was not just a caterer - she became a confidant and a friend. We found Anyae when we had to fire our original caterer for basically ghosting us and being wishy-washy with poor communication regarding our reception venue’s simple requirements regarding open flame. Anyae stepped in and saved the day, despite a relatively quick turnaround (for weddings at least). We were so impressed with her team’s professionalism and DANG GOOD FOOD. We’d hire them again in a heartbeat and will recommend them to all of our friends. Absolutely phenomenal experience. Cannot say enough good things. Thank you, Anyae, for everything. You are amazing.”
Lindsey, 2 years ago
Quick responder
Simply Sated By Tessa 
Rating: 4.5 (24 reviews)
  • Starts at $1,500
  • Serves Athens, AL

Award-winning wedding catering by Chef Tessa. With 23+ years of experience, Simply Sated offers fully customized menus, grazing tables, cakes, bartending, décor, rentals, and coordination—your one-stop shop for unforgettable weddings.

Awarded Best of Zola
“Tessa communicated with us through detailed emails that covered every detail, so we never had to guess what was happening. On the day of our anniversary celebration, the team arrived on time and was completely prepared with thoughtful touches like colorful posters to guide our guests to the coffee bar, and printed menu cards at each table. Beyond the food itself, those were added extras that made our day feel special and showed how much they cared about our celebration. The whole experience was professional, which is exactly what you want from a caterer. We would recommend Simply Sated By Tessa to any couple looking for a caterer they can trust.”
Joyce B., 2 days ago