The Best Historic Estate & Mansion Wedding Venues in Andover, NJ

The Best Historic Estate & Mansion Wedding Venues in Andover, NJ

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


6 Wedding Venues in Andover, NJ

Historic estates, mansions
150-200 guests
Quick responder
Mountainville Manor 

5.0

  • Up to 150 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $15,000

Mountainville Manor ensures that your wedding day is a merging of natural beauty and award winning, world class cuisine. The Victorian details and beautiful grounds offer a timeless backdrop for your special day, where you can say your vows in front of the charming gazebo. There is also an inside ceremony option, in our ballroom. Cocktail hour is enjoyed in the “home” part of the Manor with access to the wrap around porch and courtyard area with fire pit. The Manor provides two areas for a spectacular reception - an elegant setting with windows on several sides of the main ballroom to accommodate up to 150 guests or a tented reception on our lush landscaped grounds accommodating up to 250 guests. You may arrive four hours before your ceremony and get ready in our spacious bridal party suites. Hosting only one wedding a day, we pay special care and attention to every detail, making the wedding planning process stress-free and the event flawless for you and your guests.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Has a dance floor to dance the night away
  • Versatile for various event styles
  • All-inclusive venue packages

Venue considerations

  • Not for you if you are looking for something nontraditional
  • No on-site guest accommodations
Words cannot express what a fantastic job the management of Mountainville Manor did. If we even paused to think, there was staff ready to help. The food was AMAZING!! The service was even better! I heard so many positive comments from our guests! Their recommended florist and DJ were incredible! We had such a great time! If you are looking for a venue you won’t be disappointed!! Lauren and James were on top of every detail… they really cared that everything went as planned!! What a beautiful and well maintained venue!
Mia, 4 months ago
Quick responder
Crossed Keys Estate 

5.0

Andover, NJ
  • Up to 275 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $31,000

Crossed Keys Estate is a luxury wedding venue situated one hour outside of New York City in Andover, NJ. This lush property is nestled on 30+ acres of gardens, meadows, and old buildings that pay homage to its storied past. Brand new to the Estate is the Conservatory, a beautiful glass-enclosed building, that hosts the most magical cocktail hour! Crossed Keys Estate hosts weddings for 100 guests or more with a maximum of 275.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Accommodates more than 200 guests
  • Dressing room available
  • Provides event staff

Venue considerations

  • No free parking
  • Lighting and sound are not included
  • Venue feels large for events with small guest lists
Awarded Best of Zola
STOP WHAT YOU'RE DOING RIGHT NOW AND BOOK CROSSED KEYS ESTATE! Crossed Keys Estate goes above and beyond. From their menu customizations, bespoke floral installations, to the pristine grounds ... Crossed Keys HAS IT ALL. As a photographer, I simply know my couples are in such great hands at Crossed Keys and anytime I step foot on the property, I am BEYOND thrilled to see what they curate for our mutual clients. The stunning contemporary meets garden aesthetic of the property is one to remember as soon as you drive down the country lane and enter the property. This magnificent modern, luxurious Farmhouse keeps you guessing and you are WOWED beyond belief as you walk on site. The grounds are picture-perfect. Beautifully manicured. Truly, a bride's dream. Their service exceeds expectations. From the incredibly detailed floral installations, to custom culinary experiences! The team at Crossed Keys Estate brings your wedding day vision to LIFE. Katherine, Celso, Jessica, and Kyle ensure this is a sincerely memorable experience for you and your families for a lifetime … The team at Crossed Keys Estate creates a sincerely magical wedding day experience from the very first step to conclude an EPIC WEDDING CELEBRATION for you, your families, and best friends by your side for your EPIC bash!!
Michelle B., a year ago
Quick responder
Waterloo Village 

5.0

Stanhope, NJ
  • Up to 200 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $19,000

Featuring a working mill, blacksmith shop, active church, and several beautiful historic houses, Waterloo Village is a time capsule surrounded by an air of tranquil beauty. With its rich history, Waterloo Village is the perfect setting for weddings. Boasting two spectacular indoor event spaces—the newly-renovated meeting house and the rustic pavilion—in addition to its spacious outdoor compound, Waterloo has the resources and ambiance to make your special occasion a memorable success. As a remarkably well-preserved example of a 19th-Century canal town and the site of a 400-year-old Lenape Indian village, Waterloo Village is an incredibly valuable piece of New Jersey history. Waterloo is open to the public as part of Allamuchy Mountain State Park and home to many events and educational programs to teach and inform visitors about the past. When you choose Waterloo Village as the setting for your event, a portion of proceeds will go towards the preservation and restoration of the site.

Why you'll love this venue

  • All-inclusive venue packages
  • Dressing room available
  • Picturesque garden backdrop

Venue considerations

  • No on-site guest accommodations
  • Lighting and sound are not included
  • No free parking
Awarded Best of Zola
Waterloo Village is a truly magical venue, and we couldn’t be happier with our experience there. We first visited for a wedding and were immediately captivated by the rustic charm and historic atmosphere. After seeing how seamlessly everything ran that day, we knew it was the perfect place for our own wedding. The staff at Waterloo Village is outstanding—extremely friendly, helpful, and refreshingly low-pressure. They genuinely focus on making your day special without pushing you to spend beyond your budget. Their professionalism and warmth made the planning process enjoyable and stress-free. One of the highlights is their catering partner, JAM. Their commitment to farm-to-table dining is evident in every dish. Many of the ingredients are sourced fresh, some even from their urban garden, which adds a special touch. The food is not only fresh but absolutely delicious. If you’re looking for a beautiful venue with incredible staff and top-notch food, Waterloo Village is a fantastic choice!
Jordan G., 10 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Lake Mohawk Country Club 

5.0

Sparta, NJ
  • Up to 225 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $850

Located in Sparta, New Jersey, just 50 miles outside of New York City, Lake Mohawk is a private lake community that features magnificent homes, a Swiss Alpine styled village square, and an idealistic boardwalk that leads to a chalet–styled country club, beaches, and parks. The country club, boardwalk, and beach are all centrally located on beautifully landscaped property with breathtaking views of Lake Mohawk. The beach, located just off the boardwalk and steps away from the country club, makes for a perfect lakeside wedding ceremony, offering a picturesque backdrop and irresistible sunsets. If you would prefer, you can also exchange vows on our boardwalk, adorned with rustic lanterns and seasonal flowers. For winter weddings, we offer ceremonies in our spacious Grand Ballroom, with Palladian windows overlooking the magnificent Lake Mohawk. We invite you to come visit Lake Mohawk Country Club, and see for yourself the irresistible romantic charm.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Provides lighting and sound
  • Multiple event spaces
  • Bridal suite on site

Venue considerations

  • Not for you if you're looking for a sleek and contemporary space
  • Does not allow pets
  • Large venue, not ideal for small guest lists
We cannot say enough good things about LMCC! Thanks to LMCC our wedding day was everything we ever dreamed of and more. The staff at LMCC went above and beyond, making not only us feel comfortable and accommodated, but each and everyone of our guests as well. The staff's hard work and attention to detail was phenomenal. From planning the wedding to enjoying our wedding day, the staff was easy to work with, friendly, and dedicated to making our wedding day vision come to life. The food & drinks, venue/grounds, and overall experience for us and our guests was exceptional. Thanks to LMCC our wedding day was truly a dream come true. We highly recommend LMCC!!
Cait & R., 3 years ago
TrendlineTrending
Rutherfurd Hall 

5.0

Allamuchy, NJ
  • Up to 250 guests
  • Raw space
  • Outdoor & indoor
  • Starts at $800

Rutherfurd Hall is a historic Tudor style mansion build in 1904. The original woodwork, fireplaces, and grand stairs coupled with the amazing exterior views make for a beautiful backdrop for your wedding, bridal shower, party, or corporate event.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Raw space for complete customization
  • Private area for the wedding party
  • Flexible event spaces

Venue considerations

  • No all-inclusive dining options
  • Best for events with big guest lists
  • Dance floor not included
We had the pleasure of hosting our wedding at Rutherfurd Hall earlier this year, and we can't speak highly enough of the experience. From start to finish, everything was absolutely perfect. The venue itself is breathtaking—elegantly designed with gorgeous views, and it has an atmosphere that feels both luxurious and intimate. It was everything we dreamed of and more. Especially when we had a lot of challenges finding a venue for an Indian wedding to fit all your needs! A huge part of what made our day so unforgettable was the incredible service provided by the Director, Nick Serraino. From our very first meeting, Nick went above and beyond to ensure all your requests were accepted. He was incredibly kind, and always available to answer questions (which we had many of) or offer help! His professionalism and warm personality made the entire planning process smooth and stress-free. We can’t thank him and his team enough! If you’re looking for a venue that not only offers stunning surroundings but also a team that genuinely goes the extra mile to make your day perfect, look no further than Rutherfurd Hall. Our wedding is always a topic of fond memories at all other family gatherings! We will forever be grateful for the incredible experience and the kindness of Nick!
Pooja and M., 9 months ago
Quick responder
North Shore House 

5.0

Newton, NJ
  • Up to 175 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor

North Shore House offers the perfect combination of rustic appeal and modern amenities that have quickly made us a highly sought-after venue. We offer couples and their loved ones the opportunity to wed, celebrate, and stay with us for an entire unforgettable weekend, all while enjoying delicious food and luxe accommodations. With plenty of activities to keep you and your guests entertained, as well as 27 acres of pristine lakefront property to explore, you’ll spend every moment making incredible memories.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Full catering menu to choose from
  • Has a dance floor to dance the night away
  • Bridal suite on site

Venue considerations

  • No built-in audiovisual options
  • Not wheelchair accessible
  • Does not allow pets
Awarded Best of Zola
This is by far the most romantic, breath taking and incredible location for a wedding. My *now* husband, Todd, and I toured The North Shore house back in January 2025. We fell in love instantly and this was in the dead of winter where the trees were bare and the ground was frozen. We saw the pictures and I knew instantly that this venue would be stunning during the summer/fall time. I remember meeting the owner during that tour and how incredibly sweet she was. When the manager, Eric, gave us all the preliminary details, I began tearing up from excitement. “This is it,” I thought so I asked to have a moment with my fiancé to discuss, after nudging him under the table. When Eric left the room, I blurted out instantly, “This is it! We found it! I want it!” Todd agreed and so began the planning stages with Emma, our events coordinator. Emma is beyond prepared and brilliant. She asked us so many important questions and made the planning process easy. She was super detailed, super knowledgeable and clearly an expert in wedding planning. Her recommendations were always the best choices and she was incredibly responsive throughout. I cannot express to you how incredible she is and how much I recommend working with Emma. She’s lovely, brilliant, and made the entire journey less stressful. The day of our wedding, there were some unforeseen things that came up but Emma took care of everything. She was always direct, communicative and respectful. She thought of things way before we could anticipate the need. A small example of this was our extra flowers. We had flowers lined down the aisle during the ceremony. She asked if she could repurpose them during the reception once the ceremony concluded. We said yes. She immediately repurposed them as decoration by the bar and made the area more beautiful. Now, the venue and inn itself. All my guests voiced how stunning the venue is from the ceremony location outdoor by the lake, to the reception space with the polished wood, and each individual room. My guests are telling me they felt like they escaped the hustle and bustle of the metropolitan area to a completely new country on a mountain top by the lake. Everyone felt the romantic setting come to life. The best part? We had the entire place to ourselves since they only do 1 wedding per day, so your guests can walk the grounds without interrupting another ceremony. Let’s talk food! I will quote a friend of mine who ran up to me on the dance floor yelling, “OMG. THIS IS BY FAR THE BEST STEAK IVE EVER HAD AT A WEDDING!!!” People are raving to us constantly about the food. The lobster station was a hit! The hanger steak was by far the most loved dish. Every single selection was delicious. I loved how incredibly accommodating they are with allergies and dietary restriction. I’m gluten free, so anything I was given was made sure to be gluten free. Even the staff knew this so they alerted me what wasn’t gluten free so that I knew. The North Shore House makes your wedding dream come true; ours truly was the perfect day with the perfect weather and the perfect food.
Vanessa R S., 14 days ago

Location flexible? Discover venues near Andover, NJ

About wedding venues in Andover, NJ

Why Is Andover Perfect for Your New Jersey Wedding?

Andover, NJ offers distinctive English gardens, historic barns and scenic mountain backdrops just one hour from NYC. You'll fall in love with countryside estates like Crossed Keys and Perona Farms where centuries-old architecture meets modern amenities. The venue diversity here means you can plan anything from an intimate gathering to a grand celebration with ease. Most properties feature both elegant indoor halls and outdoor ceremony spaces that photographers love for capturing those perfect wedding moments.

What Makes Andover Wedding Venues Stand Out?

Andover venues boast architectural elements you won't find elsewhere in NJ. Crossed Keys Estate features stunning glass-enclosed conservatories while Perona Farms celebrates five generations of family ownership. Bear Brook Valley gives you that perfect blend of industrial and countryside aesthetics. Most properties span over 20 acres with multiple ceremony locations to choose from. You'll appreciate that venues typically host just one wedding per day, giving you exclusive property access and dedicated coordination teams who know every inch of the venue and have solid relationships with local vendors.

How Much Does an Andover Wedding Typically Cost?

Wedding costs in Andover follow premium New Jersey pricing with venue costs averaging $9982 which represents about 17% of your total wedding budget for 150 guests. This aligns nicely with the national benchmark range of $6500 to $12000. Total wedding budget expectations by guest count:

  • Small wedding (50 guests): $26049
  • 100 guests: $43227
  • 150 guests: $59371
  • 200 guests: $73794
  • 250 guests: $88216
  • Large wedding (300 guests): $102638

Which Andover Wedding Services Take the Biggest Slice of Your Budget?

ServiceAverage Cost% of Total (150 guests)
Venue$9,982.5717%
Florists$8,133.9414%
Catering$7,986.0613%
Bar Services$6,388.8411%
Photographers$5,900.8110%
Planners$4,806.428%
Videographers$4,213.387%
Bands and DJs$2,464.804%
Cakes and desserts$998.262%
Hair & Makeup$468.001%

What Are the Most Sought-After Venues in Andover, NJ?

Crossed Keys Estate spans over 20 acres of beautifully landscaped English gardens with a glass-enclosed Conservatory that's perfect for your cocktail hour. You can host ceremonies for up to 275 guests and enjoy the property exclusively since they maintain a one-wedding-per-day policy. Perona Farms has been creating wedding magic since 1917 with five generations of the same family guiding its legacy. You'll love choosing from multiple event spaces across their property including The Barn with its charming exposed wooden beams. They comfortably accommodate up to 275 guests for your celebration. Bear Brook Valley delivers that perfect blend of countryside elegance and industrial charm set against a vineyard backdrop with water views. Their approach to wedding planning is comprehensive with staff handling everything from initial planning through final execution so you can relax and enjoy your special day.

When Should You Book Your Andover Wedding Venue?

Most couples secure their Andover venue about 13 months (386 days) before their wedding date with November being the peak inquiry month. You'll want to book 14-16 months ahead for those popular early spring and fall weddings due to high demand. Winter weddings offer you more flexibility with 10-12 month booking windows if you're planning on a shorter timeline.

Are There Fully Accessible Venue Options in Andover, NJ?

Crossed Keys Estate provides full ADA compliance with wheelchair-accessible pathways throughout their gardens and accessible restrooms for all your guests. The Loft at Jack's Barn located just 11 miles from Andover features a specialized wheelchair lift designed specifically for wedding accessibility. Perona Farms offers handicap-accessible paths connecting all venue spaces including their beautiful outdoor ceremony sites so everyone can participate in your special day.

Which Andover Venues Offer Outstanding Culinary Experiences?

Perona Farms stands as one of Northern New Jersey's premiere wedding locations with packages for every budget. You'll appreciate their excellent locally-sourced cuisine that guests consistently rave about. Crossed Keys Estate receives exceptional praise for both cocktail offerings and main courses with guests impressed by the variety taste and presentation. Bear Brook Valley delivers high-quality food with attentive service making it an excellent choice if culinary excellence is high on your priority list for your wedding day.

Why Is Andover Perfect for Your New Jersey Wedding?

Andover, NJ offers distinctive English gardens, historic barns and scenic mountain backdrops just one hour from NYC. You'll fall in love with countryside estates like Crossed Keys and Perona Farms where centuries-old architecture meets modern amenities. The venue diversity here means you can plan anything from an intimate gathering to a grand celebration with ease. Most properties feature both elegant indoor halls and outdoor ceremony spaces that photographers love for capturing those perfect wedding moments.

What Makes Andover Wedding Venues Stand Out?

Andover venues boast architectural elements you won't find elsewhere in NJ. Crossed Keys Estate features stunning glass-enclosed conservatories while Perona Farms celebrates five generations of family ownership. Bear Brook Valley gives you that perfect blend of industrial and countryside aesthetics. Most properties span over 20 acres with multiple ceremony locations to choose from. You'll appreciate that venues typically host just one wedding per day, giving you exclusive property access and dedicated coordination teams who know every inch of the venue and have solid relationships with local vendors.

How Much Does an Andover Wedding Typically Cost?

Wedding costs in Andover follow premium New Jersey pricing with venue costs averaging $9982 which represents about 17% of your total wedding budget for 150 guests. This aligns nicely with the national benchmark range of $6500 to $12000. Total wedding budget expectations by guest count:

  • Small wedding (50 guests): $26049
  • 100 guests: $43227
  • 150 guests: $59371
  • 200 guests: $73794
  • 250 guests: $88216
  • Large wedding (300 guests): $102638

Which Andover Wedding Services Take the Biggest Slice of Your Budget?

ServiceAverage Cost% of Total (150 guests)
Venue$9,982.5717%
Florists$8,133.9414%
Catering$7,986.0613%
Bar Services$6,388.8411%
Photographers$5,900.8110%
Planners$4,806.428%
Videographers$4,213.387%
Bands and DJs$2,464.804%
Cakes and desserts$998.262%
Hair & Makeup$468.001%

What Are the Most Sought-After Venues in Andover, NJ?

Crossed Keys Estate spans over 20 acres of beautifully landscaped English gardens with a glass-enclosed Conservatory that's perfect for your cocktail hour. You can host ceremonies for up to 275 guests and enjoy the property exclusively since they maintain a one-wedding-per-day policy. Perona Farms has been creating wedding magic since 1917 with five generations of the same family guiding its legacy. You'll love choosing from multiple event spaces across their property including The Barn with its charming exposed wooden beams. They comfortably accommodate up to 275 guests for your celebration. Bear Brook Valley delivers that perfect blend of countryside elegance and industrial charm set against a vineyard backdrop with water views. Their approach to wedding planning is comprehensive with staff handling everything from initial planning through final execution so you can relax and enjoy your special day.

When Should You Book Your Andover Wedding Venue?

Most couples secure their Andover venue about 13 months (386 days) before their wedding date with November being the peak inquiry month. You'll want to book 14-16 months ahead for those popular early spring and fall weddings due to high demand. Winter weddings offer you more flexibility with 10-12 month booking windows if you're planning on a shorter timeline.

Are There Fully Accessible Venue Options in Andover, NJ?

Crossed Keys Estate provides full ADA compliance with wheelchair-accessible pathways throughout their gardens and accessible restrooms for all your guests. The Loft at Jack's Barn located just 11 miles from Andover features a specialized wheelchair lift designed specifically for wedding accessibility. Perona Farms offers handicap-accessible paths connecting all venue spaces including their beautiful outdoor ceremony sites so everyone can participate in your special day.

Which Andover Venues Offer Outstanding Culinary Experiences?

Perona Farms stands as one of Northern New Jersey's premiere wedding locations with packages for every budget. You'll appreciate their excellent locally-sourced cuisine that guests consistently rave about. Crossed Keys Estate receives exceptional praise for both cocktail offerings and main courses with guests impressed by the variety taste and presentation. Bear Brook Valley delivers high-quality food with attentive service making it an excellent choice if culinary excellence is high on your priority list for your wedding day.

What types of wedding venues are in Andover, NJ?

What other Andover vendors will I need?

What other wedding venues are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?