Windy City Cookies

Price per serving

Starts at $4 per person.

About Windy City Cookies

Windy City Cookies

Custom Sugar Cookies

Hello future brides! I'm Audrey O'Shanna, owner and operator of Windy City Cookies. I specialize in custom sugar cookies. From favors to bachelorette parties, showers, and every event in-between. I love taking your vision and bringing it to life in the most delicious way! Fun fact about me, I took 1st place in the pastry division at "The Chicago's Best Baker" competition in 2018!

All orders are made to order with love and as much detail as I would put into cookies for my own event. Every cookie comes individually packaged and heat sealed for ultimate freshness. Packaging is just as important to me as my cookies. Presentation is so important! After all you eat with your eyes first.


Dessert types

  • Cookies and macarons

Decor options

  • Custom text

Services offered

  • Consultations

Dietary accommodations

  • Nut-free


Write a review

5.0 (2 reviews)

  • Owner of Smallcakes Cupcakery in Western Springs

    Verified review
    Jennifer Lentine3 years ago

    We had Windy City Cookies make these beautiful cookies for a graduation party. They were the perfect graduation theme cookies , and I asked her to individually wrap them with for me. They were beautiful—everyone loved them! I heard from reliable sources that they tasted delicious, too. Sadly, I did not have any of the cookies for myself. Hopefully next time!

  • Bridal Shower Cookies

    Verified review
    Bridget & Russell3 years ago

    Having sampled Audrey’s cookies before at other parties, I knew that she’d create something beautiful and delicious for our bridal shower. I was able to fill out a simple online form, and then did a quick phone consult to discuss our themes. Audrey delivered on several amazingly detailed designs, each individually wrapped, almost too pretty to eat! But these are definitely cookies that SHOULD be eaten, as they’re soft and delectable!