The Best Small Wedding Venues in Stillwater, NJ

The Best Small Wedding Venues in Stillwater, NJ

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


11 Wedding Venues in Stillwater, NJ

Beaches, waterfront settings
Up to 50 guests
Available on September 13, 2026
Quick responder
North Shore House 

5.0

Newton, NJ
  • Up to 175 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor

North Shore House offers the perfect combination of rustic appeal and modern amenities that have quickly made us a highly sought-after venue. We offer couples and their loved ones the opportunity to wed, celebrate, and stay with us for an entire unforgettable weekend, all while enjoying delicious food and luxe accommodations. With plenty of activities to keep you and your guests entertained, as well as 27 acres of pristine lakefront property to explore, you’ll spend every moment making incredible memories.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Full catering menu to choose from
  • Has a dance floor to dance the night away
  • Bridal suite on site

Venue considerations

  • No built-in audiovisual options
  • Not wheelchair accessible
  • Does not allow pets
Awarded Best of Zola
Where do we even begin?! North Shore House was a dream come true for our wedding. We only viewed 2 venues, this being the second, because as soon as we saw NSH we felt at home. Location: It felt like we were on vacation and not in New Jersey, it was so serene and special. Grounds were impeccable. Each season brings a different feel, even with a misty day it was striking with the flowers, antique gates, greenery, etc. Every time we visited off season there was some maintenance being done that just goes to show the love that gets put into it. The history behind the grounds was very interesting to us and we made sure to get a picture with their bar (originally imported from Brooklyn). They have beautifully decorated guest rooms with gorgeous bathrooms and a classy feel. They allowed us to pre-pick who would be given what room to avoid any drama. Our corner room was the newlywed suite and had the best view on the grounds, we felt so special! Service: NSH is a family owned business and they bring charm in everything they do. It was a pleasant surprise that throughout the process we met a new family member running different aspects - the kitchen/catering, grounds work, business/sales, etc! Throughout the experience (and especially day of) they would check in to make sure everything was to expectations. No wonder it felt like we were at home. We must call out that our day of coordinator, Samantha, was a literal dream to work with. She was light hearted, flexible, and felt like a friend helping you plan your day (without any of the drama that you might get working with family/friends :) professionalism was top notch). Special thanks to Eric as well that gave us the initial tour and supported our whole experience. Day Of: It was rainy and they waited until last minute to make the call if we would do outdoor ceremony. Thankfully it lightened up and they set up all the chairs within 30 mins of the start time so that the guests would not sit on soaking wet chairs. I loved how they met up with me (the bride) before the ceremony entrance which made me feel special. They had a bridal attendant Diana that was very friendly and brought us food, champagne, etc. Overall we are so happy we chose NSH to have our wedding. Everything had high attention to detail. The bride's father is a musician and has played hundreds of weddings and in general has high expectations - but he was very impressed with the grounds ("Spotless - you can tell they put in a lot of work") and the food ("This was real restaurant food, not wedding food"). Other family members continue to say how special of a wedding it was and how much they loved the historic Inn. It will always hold a special place in our heart - not only for our wedding, but for the first meeting of our parents, we reserved dinner there exactly 1 year from our date and enjoyed the ambiance, food, and service, getting us all so excited for the big day. Highly recommend this idea for other couples so you can picture what it will be like day of and get a different kind of tasting experience! We are very much looking forward to visiting for future anniversaries! Thank you so much again! - Holly & Ryan Hedderich
Holly L., 5 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Lake Mohawk Country Club 

5.0

Sparta, NJ
  • Up to 225 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $850

Located in Sparta, New Jersey, just 50 miles outside of New York City, Lake Mohawk is a private lake community that features magnificent homes, a Swiss Alpine styled village square, and an idealistic boardwalk that leads to a chalet–styled country club, beaches, and parks. The country club, boardwalk, and beach are all centrally located on beautifully landscaped property with breathtaking views of Lake Mohawk. The beach, located just off the boardwalk and steps away from the country club, makes for a perfect lakeside wedding ceremony, offering a picturesque backdrop and irresistible sunsets. If you would prefer, you can also exchange vows on our boardwalk, adorned with rustic lanterns and seasonal flowers. For winter weddings, we offer ceremonies in our spacious Grand Ballroom, with Palladian windows overlooking the magnificent Lake Mohawk. We invite you to come visit Lake Mohawk Country Club, and see for yourself the irresistible romantic charm.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Provides lighting and sound
  • Multiple event spaces
  • Bridal suite on site

Venue considerations

  • Not for you if you're looking for a sleek and contemporary space
  • Does not allow pets
  • Large venue, not ideal for small guest lists
We cannot say enough good things about LMCC! Thanks to LMCC our wedding day was everything we ever dreamed of and more. The staff at LMCC went above and beyond, making not only us feel comfortable and accommodated, but each and everyone of our guests as well. The staff's hard work and attention to detail was phenomenal. From planning the wedding to enjoying our wedding day, the staff was easy to work with, friendly, and dedicated to making our wedding day vision come to life. The food & drinks, venue/grounds, and overall experience for us and our guests was exceptional. Thanks to LMCC our wedding day was truly a dream come true. We highly recommend LMCC!!
Cait & R., 3 years ago
Quick responder
Bello Giorno Estate 

5.0

Belvidere, NJ
  • Up to 125 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor

Bello Giorno Estate is a modern interpretation of a romantic Italian villa in Tuscany. The grounds were inspired by and seek to emulate the villas of Tuscany's countryside. Situated alongside the scenic and historic Pequest river in Belvidere New Jersey, our Estate personifies an intimate natural elegance. Our grounds are carefully curated with a grand entrance gate, flowing gardens, and seasonal designs that provide the perfect accompaniment to our three outdoor ceremony spaces. Bello Giorno Estate also offers a separate 'Grooms Room' and Bridal Cottage for the wedding couple. Both spaces serve as the perfect place for your groomsmen and bridesmaids to privately enjoy pre-ceremony drinks and appetizers. Our riverside rock walls complement the outdoors and provide a place to sit quietly with your loved one and enjoy a specialty cocktail as you watch the river flow and native fauna pass by.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Full catering menu to choose from
  • Has a dance floor to dance the night away
  • Surrounded by beautiful vineyards

Venue considerations

  • Not for you if you prefer a more modern aesthetic
  • No on-site guest accommodations
  • Not for you if you are looking for something nontraditional
Awarded Best of Zola
My daughter got married there last year. The place is beautiful, food was incredible and the staff is amazing. They really did make it such a special day.
Michelle Pizzo, 10 months ago
Quick responder
Magnolia Streamside Resort 

5.0

Canadensis, PA
  • Up to 150 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor

Please visit our website to inquire directly! Wildflowers, barefoot dancing, nomadic tipi, gourmet dining under the stars, bohemian chic, hand-crafted touches and lots of pure wholesome LOVE… Welcome to Magnolia Streamside Resort, a gorgeous natural oasis for family and friends to celebrate your sacred union. From the chapel in our enchanted forest, to festivities on the courtyard surrounded by a gorgeous mountain stream, Magnolia is your perfect destination-wedding resort venue. We invite you to enjoy the privacy and exclusivity of the entire property for a wholesome wedding weekend experience.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Handles all cleanup logistics
  • Picturesque garden backdrop
  • Has a dance floor for celebration

Venue considerations

  • On-site parking not available
  • Not for you if you're looking for a sleek and contemporary space
  • Lighting and sound are not included
We didn’t go into our wedding with many clear ideas, but I had a clear “vibe” for the venue that I was looking for. We visited dozens of places and were about to give up when someone from a local restaurant told us to check out Magnolia. Thank god we did – I walked in and started tearing up. We didn’t have an appointment, but they gave us a tour anyway, and we fell in love. Although you can’t see it from the road, the moment you step inside Magnolia feels like you’ve entered a beautiful hidden forest glen. The only word we could think of to describe it, and the word we heard over and over from our guests, was “magical”. Everyone we met and worked with at Magnolia was great, but Cheyenne is truly amazing. By the end of the wedding day, it felt like we had gained a family member. She is so kind, thoughtful, creative, and fun. We called her with big problems and small questions and just curious thoughts, and each time she treated the conversation as the highest priority. She went out of her way to make sure our day was exactly how we pictured it, from finding us a local taco truck (and taste testing them for us!) to securing last minute umbrellas when the weather suddenly shifted. We called a lot of vendors, but after speaking with them, almost always ended up going with Cheyenne’s recommendation – we liked them best! And from food, to photography & videography, to music, we were happy with how everything turned out. Shout out to Love & Light, Mackey, and DJ Ruben! It did rain the day-of, but it only added to the beautiful scenery, the experience, and even the photos. The pavilion added plenty of cover for the majority of the night and Cheyenne coolly handled all wrinkles that appeared. We got married last year in June, and it’s taken a while to write this review, in part because it doesn’t quite feel like we can ever find the words to truly express our gratitude and appreciation for Cheyenne and Magnolia. Thank you for making our day feel as magical as we do when we’re together. Can’t wait to come back for our anniversary each year!
Darby and J., 4 months ago
The Settlers Inn 

5.0

Hawley, PA
  • Up to 100 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor

Host your magical day at the most elegant wedding venue in the Poconos, The Settlers Inn. Our stunning bed and breakfast is the perfect backdrop for your special day. When you book one of our fantastic wedding packages, you can rest assured that we will work to exceed your expectations. From the ceremony to the reception, our dedicated staff will be there to help you in whatever way possible. When it’s time to plan your wedding in the Pocono Mountains, choose The Settlers Inn’s classic charm and outstanding service. Located on the Lackawaxen River the property boasts a beautiful garden.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Flexible event spaces
  • Bridal suite on site
  • Provides event staff

Venue considerations

  • Not for you if you are drawn to more unconventional venues
  • No free parking
  • Not wheelchair accessible
My husband and I were married at Settlers Inn this October and could not have picked a better venue! The ceremony and reception were held in the undercroft room, which is a beautifully decorated room with a cozy fireplace for guests to enjoy. Our wedding planner, Tammy was amazing and was available for last minute planning calls and quickly responded to emails. The staff at Settlers are very friendly and accommodating. Our guests were very impressed! We could not recommend Settlers more!
Marissa B., 2 years ago
Quick responder
Third & Company Lakeside 

5.0

Pine Bush, NY
  • Up to 130 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $2,500

Third + Company is the perfect lakeside Hudson Valley venue. We have an open air pergola in the bluestone lined courtyard perfect for ceremony. Let the guests enjoy both indoor & covered outdoor space for cocktail hour before making their way to the pavilion for the reception. A stunning venue for photography as you walk the bridges & trails to the island. Weather you choose buffet or a family style brunch or dinner our CIA trained culinary team will wow you and your guests in both flavor & presentation. Our in house service team led by our event planner & coordinators will ensure your planning & event will make memories that will last a lifetime. We look forward to meeting you soon! XX Third + Company

Why you'll love this venue

  • Has a dance floor for celebration
  • Wheelchair accessible
  • Both indoor and outdoor options

Venue considerations

  • Lighting and sound are not included
  • No on-site guest accommodations
We had an amazing experience working with Third & Company Lakeside for our wedding. Their communication was great and they were incredibly speedy in responding to all of our questions. The venue itself was beautiful, spacious, and cozy - the perfect setting for our special day. They attended to every need we had and provided excellent communication down to the smallest detail, really making us feel special. The staff went above and beyond to ensure our guests, vendors, and ourselves were all taken care of, and the food was absolutely amazing. They had so many options and all were so tasty!! We're so grateful to the entire team at Third & Company Lakeside for helping make our wedding day absolutely perfect and couldn’t recommend them more for someone else planning an event.
Olivia A., a month ago
Quick responder
W Hoboken 

5.0

Hoboken, NJ
  • Up to 209 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $35,000

With beautiful venues and a prime Hoboken location, our hotel offers the ideal setting for your wedding. Say your I dos in our stunning, light-filled Great Room venue, which accommodates up to 200 guests. Punctuated by Manhattan skyline views, Lulu's is an amazing venue for smaller events. Dance the night away under 19 foot ceilings with skylights, and dine on perfectly prepared cuisine. Thrill your guests with our stylish hotel accommodations and close proximity to NYC.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Has a glamorous vibe
  • Flexible event spaces
  • Offers convenient lodging options

Venue considerations

  • On-site parking not available
  • Not wheelchair accessible
  • Venue feels large for events with small guest lists
The hotel was beautiful the suite was a little pricey but worth it for a nice place to get ready as a bride
Sirena Aguiar, a year ago
Quick responder
Maritime Parc 

5.0

Jersey City, NJ
  • Up to 300 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $10,000

Maritime Parc is a contemporary wedding venue located at the marina in Liberty State Park, boasting views of the New York City Skyline, the Statue of Liberty, and Ellis Island. It opened its doors in 2009 and is well known for offering an upscale dining experience by Executive Chef-Owner Chris Siversen with cuisines ranging from a modern take on seafood to familiar American favorites, all using the freshest locally sourced ingredients. Guests can mingle outside on our wraparound terraces on both the second and third floors, while soaking in the amazing waterfront views. The Sky Room exudes a sleek and modern aesthetic with fabric-wrapped illuminated ceiling panels. The Aviary is an expansive room with a 22-foot vaulted exposed beam ceiling and large windows for ample natural light. Maritime Parc’s attentive staff is dedicated to making your experience flawless and seamless. From planning to day-of coordination, this team of professionals has you covered.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Space for a large guest list
  • Pets can join the celebration
  • Full catering menu to choose from

Venue considerations

  • No on-premises lodging options
  • Not for you if you are drawn to more unconventional venues
  • No free parking
We knew we wanted to host our wedding in Jersey City so our guests could enjoy the skyline and the water views. After viewing multiple venues, we landed on Maritime Parc for 7/20/24 and it was the best decision we made. Our wedding planning ran smoothly because we worked with Maritime’s team. Working with Priscila, the sales manager, was like working with family. She was available whenever I needed her which made getting answers to questions quick and easy. She went above and beyond her role. This venue offers a classy food tasting and cake tasting at their restaurant. Even though they host weddings every weekend, they made us feel that ours was very special and important. We appreciated working with Alexis on our timelines and floor-plan. She was very organized and thought of all the little things that we never would have!! Our day of Captains and Bridal Attendant, Marc, Rita and Patricia were the best!! Always there when we needed them and so so kind. My family members raved about their helpfulness. The entire staff at Maritime (servers, bartenders, valet, etc) were professional and attentive. It is rare to have such good and consistent service at a wedding. Lastly… the FOOD. What other wedding venue serves Scallops over braised short ribs?? None! Choose Maritime for a stress free wedding year!
Tina S., 4 months ago
The Eldred Preserve 
Eldred, NY
  • Up to 100 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor

At The Eldred Preserve, located in the heart of the picturesque Catskill Mountains, you’ll find flexible indoor and outdoor spaces that are perfect for weddings, corporate retreats, employee appreciation events, client appreciation events, baby showers, family or school reunions, bar/bat mitzvah celebrations + more. Each unique space can be scaled and decorated to suit any small- to medium-sized event or party (from 50 to 100 people), and our team will work with you throughout each step of the planning process to ensure your event offers the memorable luxury that guests will immediately recognize as second-to-none. Delicious and flexible catering options are available as well, thanks to the talents of Chef John Botti, a graduate of the renowned Culinary Institute of America, Middletown native, and chef-owner of John’s Harvest Inn for 30 years. Chef Botti and his team are always happy to create a custom menu or suggest alternative selections to meet the dietary needs of your guests.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Wheelchair accessible
  • Has a chic vibe
  • Unique barn setting

Venue considerations

  • Does not allow pets
  • Not for you if you prefer a more modern aesthetic
  • Not for you if you are drawn to more unconventional venues
Quick responder
Smooth Sailing Celebrations 
Weehawken, NJ
  • Up to 1200 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor

We have 45 private luxury yachts sailing from NY & NJ. They are ideal for private events of 12 to 1,200 guests. We appeal to the couple who is looking for something unique, festive & classy. We are definitely not cookie-cutter. You and your guests will enjoy dining, dancing, sightseeing and celebrating while sailing on the Hudson Harbor. Our wedding packages include a number of amenities, which differ from boat to boat.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Has a dance floor for celebration
  • Designed for grand celebrations
  • Bridal suite on site

Venue considerations

  • Large venue, not ideal for small guest lists
  • Does not allow pets
  • Not wheelchair accessible

Location flexible? Discover venues near Stillwater, NJ

About wedding venues in Stillwater, NJ

Why Choose New Jersey for Your Wedding Day?

New Jersey gives you four distinct regions with unique wedding settings and styles to match any vision. September tops the charts for wedding inquiries here, so you'll want to plan ahead if you're eyeing a date during peak season. The varied landscapes mean you can find everything from waterfront elegance to historic charm without traveling far.

What Types of Wedding Venues Can You Find in New Jersey?

The venue scene in New Jersey covers just about every style imaginable. Luxury estates like Park Chateau in East Brunswick offer stunning French-inspired architecture with gorgeous European gardens that make for incredible photo backdrops. If water views are your thing, places like Liberty House showcase breathtaking NYC skyline panoramas right alongside the water. History buffs fall in love with venues like Pleasantdale Chateau in West Orange with its historic grounds and Mediterranean gardens. Modern couples gravitate toward industrial spaces such as The Art Factory in Paterson where contemporary design meets character and uniqueness.

How Much Should You Budget for a New Jersey Wedding?

Wedding venues in New Jersey typically run between $8,600 and $10,600, which falls right in line with the national range of $6,500-$12,000. Your overall costs will scale with your guest count. A 50-person celebration averages around $25,059 while stepping up to 100 guests pushes that to $41,588. Mid-sized weddings with 150 guests come in around $57,123 and larger gatherings of 200 reach about $71,002. Going bigger? Expect to invest around $84,881 for 250 guests or $98,761 for 300 guests. These figures help you set realistic expectations as you start planning.

Which Budget Categories Matter Most for New Jersey Celebrations?

Knowing where your money typically goes helps you allocate your budget effectively. Venues take the biggest slice at about 17% of your total budget or $9,599 for a 150-guest wedding. Florals follow at 14% costing around $7,821 while catering represents 13% at approximately $7,679. Bar services run about $6,143 or 11% of your budget. Photography investments average $5,674 (10%) with planning services at $4,622 (8%). Videography accounts for 7% at $4,051 and entertainment like bands or DJs takes 4% at $2,370. Sweet treats like cakes and desserts are surprisingly affordable at just $960 (2%) with hair and makeup coming in at $450 (1%).

ServiceAverage Cost% of Total (150 guests)
Venue$9,59917%
Florists$7,82114%
Catering$7,67913%
Bar Services$6,14311%
Photographers$5,67410%
Planners$4,6228%
Videographers$4,0517%
Bands and DJs$2,3704%
Cakes and desserts$9602%
Hair & Makeup$4501%

Where Can You Find Exceptional Culinary Experiences in New Jersey?

The Manor in West Orange houses one of America's most acclaimed kitchens with multiple ballroom options to match your party size. You'll love Liberty House in Jersey City where farm-to-table cuisine comes with those incredible NYC skyline views we mentioned earlier. Hudson House brings Italian influence through Executive Chef Matteo Limoli's creative menu designs. The Rockleigh adjusts their menus seasonally and can customize dishes to match your personal tastes. Food quality varies dramatically between venues so tastings are essential.

What Options Exist for Accessible Wedding Venues in New Jersey?

The Rockleigh can accommodate massive celebrations with up to 850 guests while offering both grand ballrooms and beautiful outdoor garden settings. Bridgewater Manor features elegant chandeliers a grand staircase and beautifully maintained grounds that photograph wonderfully. Always reach out directly to venues about specific accessibility features you need. Most have wheelchair ramps and accessible restrooms but details matter when creating an inclusive celebration for all your guests.

How Can New Jersey Venues Accommodate Remote Guests?

Crystal Springs Resort in Sussex County offers virtual tours that can be adapted for remote guest experiences. Liberty House and Hudson House provide scenic settings that work perfectly with advanced audiovisual systems to bring your ceremony to distant loved ones. Bonnet Island Estate offers unique backdrops that videographers can capture creatively for those who can't attend in person. More venues now offer hybrid options after the pandemic changed how we think about celebrations.

What Makes Your New Jersey Wedding Uniquely Yours?

You'll find your perfect match in New Jersey whether you're drawn to waterfront venues with Manhattan skyline backdrops historic estates with classical architectural details or modern spaces with industrial charm. The state's diverse regions offer venues across many price points and styles. Your wedding should reflect who you are as a couple and New Jersey's venue landscape gives you plenty of options to create that personalized celebration regardless of your budget or aesthetic preferences.

What types of wedding venues are in Stillwater, NJ?

What other Stillwater vendors will I need?

What other wedding venues are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?