The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Sarasota, FL

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


25 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in Sarasota, FL

Quick responder
KILWINS 
Rating: 5.0 (2 reviews)
Sarasota, FL
  • Starts at $25

Located in the heart of Siesta Village at seista key village Plaza! Serving hand-paddled Mackinac Island Fudge, copper-kettle caramels, hand-dipped chocolates, and Original Recipe Ice Cream just steps from world-famous Siesta Key Beach. Stop by to watch live confectionery crafting daily!

Working with Kilwins for our wedding desserts was an absolute pleasure—they stayed on top of every detail and addressed each request with genuine care. Guests couldn't stop raving about the dessert station, especially the caramel apples and pretzel sticks that brought back childhood memories for everyone. What impressed me most was their willingness to customize everything, from the main treats to personalized thank you chocolates for our guests. They work collaboratively to accommodate both your vision and budget, never making you feel rushed or limited. If you're planning a wedding, I'd highly recommend Kilwins; they transformed our dessert experience into something truly memorable and special.
Amy, 2 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Wonder Cake Creations 
Rating: 5.0 (2 reviews)
Sarasota, FL

    Baking and working with sugar has been a passion of Rocio’s from an early age — her gift of natural talent inherited from her mother. She has spent countless hours training with some of the best sugar artists in the world. Her main objective is to uniquely design each and every cake to help make your event a very special occasion.

    We were unsure of what combos would go together for a great cake, but Rocio made it easy and allowed us to try more if we didn’t love what we got. We opted for carrot cake and southern pecan, both with cream cheese frosting and it tasted INCREDIBLE! We got a navy cake with gold flecks and florals. Funniest part of the navy cake frosting was everyone’s mouths turning blue at the end of the night - so keep that in mind brides, you’ll be in for a laugh when you want a dark cake!
    Alexis S., 4 years ago
    Quick responder
    Lace Makes Cakes 
    Rating: 4.9 (14 reviews)
    ·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
    • Starts at $175
    • Serves Sarasota, FL

    Baking has been my passion since 6th grade- so much so that I left my corporate job behind to bake for love stories full time! I specialize in custom wedding cakes, interactive food bars, and an upcoming dessert trailer experience with full staffing starting this December. My mission? Making whatever desserts you've been dreaming of to ensure your big day is 100% you.

    We had such a great experience with Lace Makes Cakes for our elopement desserts. From the start, the owner was incredibly responsive and easy to work with, making the whole process feel seamless. We ordered a 9 inch heart shaped cake and 12 white rose cupcakes for 150 plus delivery, and the quality exceeded what we paid for. The cake was as delicious as it looked, and the cupcakes were stunning with their shimmer dust and pearl details. She even delivered everything to our Airbnb on Anna Maria Island, which meant one less thing to stress about on our special day. We would absolutely recommend Lace Makes Cakes to any couple looking for beautiful desserts without the headache.
    Kelsy, a month ago
    Quick responder
    StackD Cake Studio 
    Rating: 5.0 (11 reviews)
    • Starts at $400
    • Serves Sarasota, FL

    Nailah Browne, a native of St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands, first became interested in baking from her grandmother, who had a side business. Browne later completed the bakery program at Manatee Technical College. Browne and Selene Martinez met and became friends at IMG Academy, where Browne was the head baker and that's how StackD Cake Studio was born. At Stack’d Cake Studio, the customer directs how they want their cake built, from cake and size, to flavor of buttercream, filling and toppings.

    Awarded Best of Zola
    Nailah from StackD Cake Studio was an absolute dream to work with for our wedding desserts. From our very first interaction, they were attentive, communicative, and cordial, making the entire process a breeze. The cakes and desserts she created for us were not only delicious, but truly amazing, creative, and over the top. Their attention to detail was evident in every aspect, from the flavors to the beautiful design. The final products exceeded our wildest expectations and were the talk of the reception, and when I say the talk I mean that our guests were literally wanting more! Specially the Guava Posset!!! We are so grateful to StackD Cake Studio for helping make our special day even more wonderful.
    Kerem C., 2 years ago
    Quick responder
    Don Cannoli, LLC 
    Rating: 5.0 (90 reviews)
    ·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
    • Serves Sarasota, FL

    Premium cannoli, hand-piped by The Don himself! We make cannoli you can't refuse, featuring handmade shells imported from Sicily and fresh cannoli cream prepared for the day of your event. Our lavish cannoli concierge service is perfect for weddings, backyard birthdays, holiday parties, corporate events, and more!

    Such a Fun Addition to Our Wedding!! My mom surprise booked Don Cannoli for our wedding and I am SO happy she did because WOW, our guests absolutely loved him!! He walked around the reception dancing, handing out cannolis, and just making everyone happy. It was so fun watching people react to him, and he brought such a great energy to the night. It wasn’t just dessert, it was genuinely part of the entertainment! And most importantly... the cannolis were SOOOOO GOOD. We didn’t have a traditional wedding cake, so having Don Cannoli was such a perfect and unique way to add another dessert option while also giving our guests a fun experience. I would 100% recommend him, especially if you’re like us and want something a little different from the typical wedding dessert or even a a fun addition to your wedding! Delicious cannolis AND an entertaining guy walking around your reception handing them out?? What more could you want!!! So AWESOME
    Justine, 16 days ago
    TrendlineTrending
    Kakes By Kiersten 
    Rating: 5.0 (9 reviews)
    • Starts at $7
    • Serves Sarasota, FL

    Kakes by Kiersten specializes in custom orders of wedding cakes, cupcakes, dessert bars, and more. The team is delighted to take even the most creative orders, creating authentic reflections of couples and their personalities. The bakery also provides other treats, such as desserts for pre-wedding parties, showers, and groom cakes. Couples can avail of delivery and set-up services, taking some of the wedding day organization pressure off their shoulders. Interested couples can book a consultation, and cake-testing kits are available for couples who would like to explore their options for flavors and cake types.

    Awarded Best of Zola
    Kiersten was an absolute joy to work with for our wedding. Her communication was quick, helpful, knowledgeable, and professional throughout the entire process. I have a lot of food restrictions and Kiersten was more than willing to work with me to fully customize our wedding cake so that I would be able to eat it. She was so accommodating and willing to work with our preferences to make sure that we got exactly what we wanted and she exceeded our expectations! The quality of her work is beautiful and delicious. We got cake pops, cupcakes, and our wedding cake. Best German chocolate cake ever BTW - our guests agreed!!! If you're on the fence, just know that I am SO happy I came across Kakes by Kiersten. I highly, HIGHLY recommend to any couple planning their wedding or anyone planning any event. I will hands down be using her in the future.
    Carrie, 2 years ago
    Quick responder
    Lakay Cakes 
    Rating: 5.0 (8 reviews)
    ·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
    • Starts at $18
    • Serves Sarasota, FL

    Hi, I’m Joyce from Lakay Cakes Bakery. I have been in business over 9 years and have many years of baking experience. My company was started by making liquor infused desserts. Which branched out to other desserts as well as a catering company.

    Awarded Best of Zola
    Lakay Cakes is literally THE BEST company for any of your desert needs. They did my wedding cake on Nov10th and not only did the cake turn out how we envisioned but it was also delicious. Even after a month later our guests talks about how nice the cake was and how tasty it was. I truly enjoyed it & the customer service was amazing. Very respectful, responsive & reliable. Everyone knows how busy a bride and groom can get and they made the cake process so easy for us. Thank you again!!
    Alexia A., 9 months ago
    TrendlineTrending
    Seventeen and co 
    Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
    • Starts at $300
    • Serves Sarasota, FL

    Seventeen and Co is a Central Florida 3x Award Winning Wedding Cake shop located in Orlando, FL. Founded by the talented baker Saisha, this professional aims to bring a smile to your face with her creations. Since she was younger, Saisha's favorite pastime growing up was always baking. She loves adapting her childhood recipes from Germany and Southern Texas roots to create her delicious treats. No matter if you need a simple sponge cake or an extravagant multi-tiered design, Seventeen and Co can make it. Each cake made by Seventeen and Co is crafted with love, detail and freshest ingredients possible. Reach out to Saisha for more info

    I am honored to express my sincere gratitude for your exceptional service. We recently organized a surprise birthday celebration for our department head, and Seventeen & Co. exceeded our expectations. Given the short notice, I opted for a classic favorite to ensure simplicity. Saisha, with her attentiveness to my wishes, transformed the vanilla cake into a delectable creation infused with banana flavoring. The versatility of your offerings made the selection process challenging, but Seventeen & Co.’s creative expertise proved why she’s the best. Upon its arrival, the cake was adorned with guava filling on half, adding an unexpected touch of elegance. Your attention to detail and artistic flair left us astounded. I am now delighted to be a valued customer of Seventeen & Co. Thank you for sharing your culinary expertise with us.
    WoodSprings S., 4 months ago
    GemHidden gem
    Sisterly Sweets 
    Rating: 5.0 (2 reviews)
    • Starts at $10
    • Serves Sarasota, FL

    Sisterly Sweets is a sister owned gourmet cookie business based in SWFL, created by sisters Meddy & Maria. What started with a love for baking has grown into creating elevated cookie experiences for weddings and special events. From beautifully displayed gourmet cookies to our Cookies & Milk and Cookies & Ice Cream experiences, we love bringing something fun, memorable, and a little different to every celebration. Everything can be customized to fit your wedding and vision. Our goal is simple: amazing cookies, beautiful presentation, and an experience your guests will remember.

    We had such a great experience with Sisterly Sweets! The cookies were absolutely delicious and everyone loved them. Meddy and Maria were so sweet, professional, and easy to work with. Everything looked beautiful and was set up perfectly. I would definitely recommend Sisterly Sweets to anyone looking for something special and different for their wedding and or event!
    Lazaro, 4 days ago
    TrendlineTrending
    Unique Sweets Supply 
    Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
    • Starts at $84
    • Serves Sarasota, FL

    Unique Sweets Supply takes pride in making an extra effort to substitute the best food-based non-chemical ingredients for making our Gluten Free, Dairy Free and Vegan Cake and dessert options. The shorter the ingredient list that can be easily read, the better making of as close to the all-natural, gluten-free, egg-free, and vegan cake and dessert options as possible. We can also make Organic Vegan Cakes for you upon request.

    Unique Sweets was the perfect pick for our wedding day! My husband and I wanted a small, dairy free, Neapolitan cake just for us and Unique Sweets delivered! The tasting went smoothly and the cake itself was delicious, so much so my husband wants to order again just for fun haha Communication was seamless and delivery was spot on, early even! And I was in Fort Pierce. Overall a great experience I would recommend to everyone who needs a wedding cake in the area!
    Victoria W., 7 months ago
    Quick responder
    Happiness 101 
    Rating: 5.0 (17 reviews)
    • Starts at $100
    • Serves Sarasota, FL for additional fees

    Happiness 101 creates custom cakes, cupcakes, cake pops, dessert shooters and bundts in 101 baked from scratch flavor options. I believe taste and appearance are equally important when it comes to cake. I also believe the wedding cake and desserts are one of the most important components of a wedding reception. Many guests say "I'm here for the cake!" in jest, but there is definitely some truth behind that statement.

    Awarded Best of Zola
    Working with Happiness 101 was such a joy from start to finish. Andrea was consistently responsive and kind throughout the entire planning process, making sure to understand exactly what we wanted for our big day. She brought our vision to life with delicious desserts that looked as good as they tasted, and the presentation was absolutely flawless. What really stood out was how thoughtful she was about every detail and how accommodating she proved to be when we needed adjustments. Andrea's support and willingness to listen made us feel heard and cared for, which meant so much during the wedding planning journey. We couldn't have asked for a better dessert partner and would recommend Happiness 101 to any couple looking to make their celebration sweet.
    Nathan and J., 25 days ago
    Quick responder
    That Cannoli Guy - Jacksonville, FL 
    Rating: 5.0 (6 reviews)
    ·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
    • Serves Sarasota, FL for additional fees
    • Offer

    That Cannoli Guy was founded in 2024 because someone had to step in and save the cannoli from sad, pre-filled dessert tables. We specialize in fresh, made-to-order cannoli filled live at your event with crispy shells, rich cannoli cream, and toppings your guests can’t stop watching (or eating). It’s part dessert, part show, and 100% crowd-pleaser. We bring big Italian energy and real cannoli, done the right way 🤌

    Had That Cannoli Guy come out for a Friendsgiving at my place. Easy, smooth setup and great energy. When Anthony walked out, I’ve never seen so many phones come out at once. The cannoli were legit. People were raving about them all night and going back for more. Simple, fun, and a solid addition to the party. Would definitely book again.
    Adam, 8 months ago
    TrendlineTrending
    Sweet Buckets 
    Rating: 5.0 (5 reviews)
    • Starts at $300
    • Serves Sarasota, FL for additional fees

    We began as a concession company providing cotton candy at sporting events. In the fall of 2021, we extended our brand by starting our own manufacturing plant. Sweet Buckets was born as an option for customers and businesses to purchase Cotton Candy and Gourmet popcorns direct from our company.

    Awarded Best of Zola
    We had our wedding reception at a brewery and wanted some easy to eat sweet and salty snacks. These popcorn flavors were delicious, they sent us flavors to try before we decided. We chose 4 flavors and they shipped them right to our house. The popcorn buckets had our cute custom labels which they designed for us and looked PERFECT! We had tons of compliments on the popcorn. We ordered plenty and people were grabbing them to take home at the end of the night. A perfect snack after a few beers. Theu were very fast with the samples and the order too!
    Lyndsey C., 2 years ago
    Quick responder
    Sweet Homemade Treats by Shawna and Ashley 
    Rating: 3.7 (3 reviews)
    • Starts at $5
    • Serves Sarasota, FL for additional fees

    From decadent wedding cakes, perfectly designed for your special day, to birthday cakes bursting with flavor tailored to your loved ones, we take pride in every detail. Not only do we specialize in cakes for weddings, birthdays, and showers, but our offerings extend to a wide array of other delicious sweets that are perfect for any occasion. Whether you're looking for mouthwatering cookies, rich brownies, or luscious pastries, we have something to satisfy every sweet tooth.

    Sweet Homemade Treats by Shawna and Ashley provided excellent service and delicious desserts for our wedding. Their communication was fast, easy-going, and in-depth, making the planning process a breeze. The quality of their work was fantastic and provided great value - they were able to create our dream cupcakes within our budget. Our guests raved about the taste and presentation of the desserts, and we were thrilled with the final result. We highly recommend Sweet Homemade Treats for any couple looking for a skilled, affordable, and personable cakes and desserts vendor.
    AB, a year ago
    TrendlineTrending
    BakerBitesCo 
    Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
    • Starts at $200
    • Serves Sarasota, FL for additional fees

    Ready to impress your guests with our unique tasty treat? BakerBitesCo offers single serve fudge bites with customized labels to fit your perfect day. Wedding favors, bridesmaids gifts, wedding party gifts, etc. these can be used in any way to fit your needs. WHY YOU'LL LOVE US -We offer delicious unique seasonal flavors -We ship anywhere in the US -We can send a sampler box so you can taste all our flavors and pick your favorites. -Budget friendly at only $2/piece -Prepackaged, making our dessert ideal during COVID -We give a meal to a hungry child with every order We can't wait to make your day even more spectacular!

    Best fudge I’ve ever had and the flavor varieties are amazing! I love that I can customize them for any occasion!
    Linda, 6 years ago
    Jac’s Snacks 
    Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
    • Serves Sarasota, FL

    What started as a simple idea while planning my own wedding quickly turned into a passion. I realized there was a gap in the market for interactive, elegant, and beautifully styled dessert and drink options that didn’t feel like just another buffet table. I wanted something more intimate, more thoughtful something that made our guests say “wow.” That’s how Jac’s Snacks was born. Every cart is customized to fit your aesthetic, and every detail is handled with care from setup to breakdown so you can focus on the magic of your day. Serving Southwest Florida and beyond, we bring style, charm, and sweet moments to weddings big and small.

    From donuts to drinks, Jaccs Snacks always delivers. They showed up to our Naples Girls Walk Club 1-Year Anniversary with the cutest (and yummiest) donuts, and then totally switched gears and served major vibes as bartenders at our Flirt Club event. Talk about versatile! Whether they’re bringing the sugar or shaking the cocktails, this crew is professional, fun, and seriously makes every event better. I can’t imagine hosting something without them now, and honestly? I don’t want to. Highly recommend for anyone looking to level up their event with good energy, great service, and unforgettable treats.
    Tereza, a year ago