The Best Nut-free Wedding Caterers in Penfield, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


14 Wedding Caterers in Penfield, NY

Nut-free
Quick responder
Avenue29 Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (9 reviews)
  • Starts at $8,500
  • Serves Penfield, NY

At Avenue29 Catering, we specialize in full-service wedding experiences that go beyond the food. From your first consultation to the final plate served, our focus is simple: exceptional quality, seamless execution, and a menu your guests will remember. We design handcrafted menus built around bold flavors, fresh ingredients, and elevated presentation—whether you’re planning a classic reception, an outdoor celebration, or a fully customized event. Our team handles setup, service, and cleanup so you can stay present and enjoy your day.

We had a private wedding ceremony and got referred to Avenue29 as a caterer who would understand the specific details of what we wanted to make our food as magical as the rest of our day. When meeting with Nicholas we were thoroughly impressed by his calm and confident presence, his detailed questions and the vision he helped us co-create. We didn’t want a traditional buffet so he came up with a beautiful 4-corner display so each section could have their own semi-private food display. His attention to detail, professionalism and personality were nothing like we had experienced before. We had a beautiful tasting, he went over every line item with us thoroughly, and made sure it was the right package for our wedding. And the delivery on our wedding day was exactly what we’d imagined and more. Amazing food, service, presentation, and professionalism. We could not recommend Avenue29 enough! Nicholas and his team truly went above and beyond for us!
Jenna, 5 months ago
Quick responder
Maison D Events and Hospitality 
Rating: 5.0 (6 reviews)
  • Serves Penfield, NY
  • Offer

With over 15 years of experience Maison D is the premier catering and hospitality company you would ever need. We do everything from catering to event planning and everything in-between. We take your event to the next level and elevate it in every way possible

Maison D delivers an incredible experience from start to finish. Their professionalism, creativity, and attention to detail truly set them apart. Every element was thoughtfully planned and beautifully executed, creating an event that felt both elegant and effortless. The team was responsive, organized, and genuinely invested in making sure everything turned out perfectly. They took the time to understand the vision and brought it to life in a way that exceeded expectations. The final result was stunning and left our guests talking about it long after the event ended. If you’re looking for a company that combines luxury, style, and flawless execution, Maison D is the perfect choice. Highly recommended!
Elizabeth, 5 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Bon appetit exotics 
Rating: 5.0 (5 reviews)
  • Starts at $2,275
  • Serves Penfield, NY

My name is Don, the founder and creative mind behind Bon Appétit Exotics. What started as a genuine passion for cooking has grown into a business dedicated to bringing people together through flavorful, high-quality food. I created Bon Appétit Exotics to offer a unique catering and meal prep experience that blends bold, creative dishes with the comfort of familiar favorites. At Bon Appétit Exotics, I specialize in curating menus that stand out. From crowd-pleasing classics like wings, sliders, and homestyle sides to more elevated and diverse options, every dish is prepared with attention to detail and a focus on taste.

Bon Appétit Exotics made my wedding day feel nothing short of magical. Their team showed up with so much warmth, care, and intention that it felt like they were celebrating with us, not just serving us. Every detail was handled with such love, from the way they checked on my family to the way they anticipated needs I didn’t even know I had in the moment. And the food… phenomenal. Every dish was beautifully presented, full of flavor, and clearly crafted with care. Our guests are still talking about how delicious everything was. Bon Appétit Exotics didn’t just cater our wedding; they elevated it. I couldn’t have asked for a better team or a better dining experience on such an important day.
Daja Z., 4 months ago
Quick responder
Toss & Fire Wood-Fired Pizza 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Starts at $1,700
  • Serves Penfield, NY

Toss & Fire is an award winning wood-fired pizzeria and catering company in Central New York! We cater various events throughout the area with our wood-fired pizza trucks. We also operate two brick & mortar locations in Camillus and North Syracuse.

We used Toss & Fire’s mobile pizza truck for our wedding on 5/25/25 and they were a HUGE HIT. Honestly, the pizza was some of the best I’ve ever tasted. The crust was soft & chewy with a perfect balance of sauce, cheese & toppings. I live in Manhattan, and I’m genuinely struggling to find pizza half as good. Leading up to the wedding, the team at Toss & Fire were a dream to work with. The hardest part was deciding what to order off their menu, but they were incredibly flexible and we were able to craft the perfect order to the size and scale of our wedding. I’m a vegetarian and my husband is not, and we were both perfectly happy with our orders. We also wanted to accommodate our vegans & gluten free guests, and it couldn’t have been easier. The team informed us that they travel with GF crusts and vegan cheese, and could make any of our pizzas special for dietary restrictions. We even had an especially sensitive GF guest able to request having GF pizzas made first before the oven was shared with demon gluten. No one laughed or rolled their eyes, which is the minimum I was expecting. At our wedding, the food truck staff was exceptional. They called us (the bride & groom) up first, reminding us that the couple never eat at their own weddings, so we were to get first orders. I even saw them running specialty (vegan, etc) orders directly to tables. At the end of the night all the leftovers were boxed up and eagerly brought home by our guests! Their personal touch cannot be overstated. They travelled pretty far out of their way to be a part of our wedding, and were so tremendously grateful that they did. It’s two weeks later now, and I’m still dreaming about those pizzas.
Rebecca M., a year ago
Green Cart Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (2 reviews)
  • Starts at $52
  • Serves Penfield, NY

Green Cart Catering was founded on the desire to do two things: One, to provide healthy & ethical cuisine. And two, to provide event hosts, committed to healthy & ethical eating, the ability to stay true to their values while still providing their guests an outstanding culinary experience! Our 100% plant- based menus will impress everyone and leave no one wanting! Behind our great food is over 30 years’ experience in hospitality services. So, Green Cart Catering can provide you with not only great food, but complete event services, as well!

I cannot put it words enough how incredible this was. Not only is John one of the most responsive vendors I had contacted, he was one of the most helpful. Chef Marisa’s food is a work of art. Finding a way to bring my carnivore family into my to vegetarian/vegan new family was smooth sailing with GCC. Everyone under the sun was happy. John was also so attentive to me as a bride on my big day that I made sure I got to enjoy the fruits of my choices. Thank you GCC.
Daryan C., 3 years ago
Quick responder
Old Souls Catering 
  • Starts at $5,000
  • Serves Penfield, NY

Growing up in Wyoming County, the heart of New York’s dairy & farming industry, Josh has a real appreciation for fresh food products. His family’s restaurants and their farms sparked a passion for carefully choosing sources of food. Josh’s dedication to sourcing and using the best fresh and local products is evident in his cooking. Josh went to culinary school at Johnson & Wales University in North Miami. He took the skills he learned from working in his family and other local restaurants and continued to develop them at J&W. After culinary school, Josh came back to Western New York and opened a catering business.

TrendlineTrending
Distinguish Catering 
  • Starts at $6,000
  • Serves Penfield, NY

Distinguish Catering is a luxury boutique, farm-to-table catering company specializing in elevated wedding experiences, offering a refined fusion of Afro Soul Food and international cuisines. We distinguish every celebration with a deep appreciation for cultural diversity. Our culinary approach draws inspiration from the vibrant flavors of Afro Soul Food thoughtfully infused with global influences to create dynamic memorable dishes. Each plate is crafted with premium, farm-fresh ingredients and presented with intention, offering guests immersive, sensory-driven experiences that transform every event into an unforgettable culinary journey.

Quick responder
Nasrin's Kitchen 
Rating: 5.0 (2 reviews)
  • Starts at $1,000
  • Serves Penfield, NY for additional fees
  • Offer

Nasrin's Kitchen started with a simple idea — sharing the recipes I grew up with in Iran with the people of New York. What began as small batches of homemade jams and torshi during the pandemic has grown into one of NYC's most celebrated Persian catering kitchens, featured in The New York Times, Vogue, Forbes, and The New Yorker. We specialize in authentic Persian cuisine — saffron-infused rice, tender kababs, slow-cooked stews, and handmade breads — prepared with the same love and care as a home-cooked meal.

Working with Nasrin's Kitchen was an absolute pleasure from start to finish. Their communication was clear and straightforward throughout the planning process, making it easy to coordinate all the details for our wedding day. They arrived on time and executed everything with genuine professionalism—the food was delicious and the service team was attentive without being intrusive. From the first consultation to the final plate served, they treated our event with real care and attention. I'd confidently recommend them to any couple looking for a caterer who delivers both exceptional food and reliable service.
Wahida b., 2 months ago
Insatiable Eats Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Starts at $3,750
  • Serves Penfield, NY

Insatiable Eats has catered countless events and weddings in the Hamptons, Long Island and New York since 2005. We pride ourselves in providing the highest level of cuisine using both locally sourced and special imported ingredients. Whether casual or formal, intimate or grand, our team of professional service staff make sure no details go unnoticed.

Insatiable eats, catered the most important event of my life! My Wedding.. Their staff was attentive, the owners were present and wanted our input, the fact my husbands a Chef, He felt that they understood his vision with the food and decor!!! My being a bride and not feeling nervous was an actual plus... I loved the whole experience and would recommend their services to any and everyone!!!
Evelyne R., 4 years ago
GemHidden gem
Brigs Sweet Shop 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Starts at $4,000
  • Serves Penfield, NY for additional fees

Add a touch elegance, class, and photo op opportunity to your wedding with our ice cream bike cart! Our ice bike is equipped to serve from 100 guests up to thousands. We take care of all the details you only need to choose the ice cream flavors and we do the rest! Bikes can be decorated with flowers, balloons and messages! Ice cream cups are also customizable to include names/ messages and theme!

Brigs Sweet Shop cater our wedding and baby shower, they were the highlight of the night! The ice cream is freshly made and for both occasions Priscilla made special flavors that were a mix between our favorite desserts we’ll never forget, so thank you Priscilla for contributing on making both days unforgettable. We also cater items for our dessert table and the macarons are the best I ever eaten! We made a point to have them on every special occasion from small to big! Lucy and John
Lucy F., 3 years ago

About wedding caterers in Penfield, NY

What other Penfield vendors will I need?

What other caterers are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?