The Best Italian Wedding Catering in New Haven, NY

The Best Italian Wedding Catering in New Haven, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


10 Wedding Caterers in New Haven, NY

Italian
GemHidden gem
The Bearded Bear BBQ 
Rating: 4.9 (103 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves New Haven, NY

BBQ catering and food truck services for weddings, rehearsal dinners, corporate events, and celebrations. Catering packages starting at $28 per person with options for full food truck experience, we are way more than just BBQ!

“Amazing presentation and set up of catered events, always a pleasure to work with!”
Rachel, 3 days ago
Quick responder
Gance's Complete Catering 
Rating: 4.6 (19 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Starts at $3,900
  • Serves New Haven, NY

Gance’s Complete Catering — 75+ years of off‑premise expertise serving Greater Binghamton and beyond. Customized menus and professional service for corporate lunches, weddings, fundraisers, vending, disaster relief, and on‑site job catering. Drop‑off, staffed buffet, plated service, or emergency meal support. Experienced team handles setup, service, and breakdown with reliable logistics and dedicated coordination. Consistent quality for events of any size—so you can focus on your guests.

Quick responder
Avenue29 Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (10 reviews)
  • Starts at $8,500
  • Serves New Haven, NY

At Avenue29 Catering, we specialize in full-service wedding experiences that go beyond the food. From your first consultation to the final plate served, our focus is simple: exceptional quality, seamless execution, and a menu your guests will remember. We design handcrafted menus built around bold flavors, fresh ingredients, and elevated presentation—whether you’re planning a classic reception, an outdoor celebration, or a fully customized event. Our team handles setup, service, and cleanup so you can stay present and enjoy your day.

“Our food was incredible! Came out exactly as we were told, flavor was on point, sauces were home made, quality of meats were excellent, and all little details were attended to. They even took care of our gluten free guests by making grilled chicken instead of breaded just for 3 people so the could enjoy the meal as well. Everything including food, temperature, presentation, service, and clean up was outstanding from start to finish!”
Mike, 8 months ago
Quick responder
Bon appetit LLC 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Starts at $1,500
  • Serves New Haven, NY
  • Offer

Congragulations! You’ve found who you’re looking for right here! Lol. Hello, im Hannah. A chef with 16 years of cooking under my belt I enjoy cooking just about every menu to fit your needs. The most popular menu is a taco/nacho buffet. I also do a lot of pasta/salad bars and comfort food buffets. Please reach out with any questions.

“My husband and I ordered a full buffet for our wedding of 200 guests. I was absolutely thrilled with the service and loved the flavors and they attitude overall very happy.”
Jade, 22 days ago
Quick responder
Gola Osteria Restaurant & Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Starts at $1
  • Serves New Haven, NY

Gola Osteria is both a fine dining Italian restaurant and catering company. Tho we specialize in Italian cuisine we are able to accommodate most styles of food for catering. We offer one on one tastings to help you chose the perfect menu for your event.

“Kim is kind and very professional. Working with their team is easy and stress free.”
Ithaca Farmer's Market, 3 years ago
TrendlineTrending
Serendipity Catering 
  • Starts at $1,500
  • Serves New Haven, NY

Serendipity Catering is a full-service catering and event planning company based in Ithaca, NY. We focus on delivering exceptional service and perfectly detailed presentation for all of our weddings and events. Our culinary team is constantly creating and developing new ways to incorporate local and seasonal ingredients into our kitchen.

Quick responder
Lorrielle's 
Rating: 4.5 (11 reviews)
  • Starts at $2,500
  • Serves New Haven, NY for additional fees
  • Offer

At Lorrielle’s Catering & Events, we specialize in luxury private chef services, premier catering, and seamless event planning. We are dedicated to crafting elevated culinary experiences that range from intimate, multi-course fine dining to vibrant, sophisticated family-style feasts. Every menu is entirely bespoke, featuring bold flavor profiles and premium ingredients designed to delight the palate and spark conversation. We don't just feed guests; we bring a luxury restaurant experience directly to your venue, curating an unforgettable atmosphere where exceptional food meets meticulous execution.

“From our first call to the day of our wedding, Lorrielle's was always there when we needed them. They responded right away to every question and made planning feel simple and stress-free. The food was fresh and delicious, and their team thought through every detail from decorations to helping us find lodging for our guests. What really impressed us was their crew—there were enough people on staff to handle everything, even keeping the bathrooms spotless all night. When our photographer accidentally broke one of our flower arrangements, they cleaned it up instantly and turned the broken flowers into petals for our flower girl to toss. Working with Lorrielle's made our wedding day special, and we would recommend them to anyone looking for a caterer who truly cares.”
Chandra, 4 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Stuf'd 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Starts at $65
  • Serves New Haven, NY for additional fees

As a kid, Rebecca could be found in the kitchen cooking with either her Mom or Grandma. Traveling to Albany was always a treat, as her favorite dish to eat was Nan's French toast. While studying at NYU, Rebecca came up with the concept of STUF'D to fulfill the need for a savory French toast, as it was yet to be done. She decided to start the business as a food truck in 2016, as a way to keep her brand more mobile. Since then, we have evolved into a full-service catering company, offering a variety of sandwiches, sliders, and cocktail bites, and serving events that range from weddings and birthday parties to large-scale events!

Awarded Best of Zola
“Stuf'd really went the extra mile to make our wedding special. The team provided thorough, individualized attention every step of the way, allowing us to feel at ease knowing the food would be exactly what we were hoping for. They even came to view the space well in advance of the wedding to make sure the day would run smoothly. Our guests could not stop raving about the quality of food, which struck a perfect balance between casual and formal. We're very grateful to have worked with such a talented and dedicated catering team.”
Elaina & D., 2 years ago
Insatiable Eats Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Starts at $3,750
  • Serves New Haven, NY

Insatiable Eats has catered countless events and weddings in the Hamptons, Long Island and New York since 2005. We pride ourselves in providing the highest level of cuisine using both locally sourced and special imported ingredients. Whether casual or formal, intimate or grand, our team of professional service staff make sure no details go unnoticed.

“Insatiable eats, catered the most important event of my life! My Wedding.. Their staff was attentive, the owners were present and wanted our input, the fact my husbands a Chef, He felt that they understood his vision with the food and decor!!! My being a bride and not feeling nervous was an actual plus... I loved the whole experience and would recommend their services to any and everyone!!!”
Evelyne R., 5 years ago
Ginger Man Catering And Private Chef Service 
  • Starts at $1,700
  • Serves New Haven, NY

Ginger Man Catering is a Glatt Kosher catering company in NYC formed by Chef Oren to offer custom Kosher catering and personalized service to our clients, while based in NYC, Chef Oren and his exemplary team will travel throughout New York City, Long Island, Hamptons, New Jersey and Connecticut area to create your specialized event in your home or at the venue of your choice. Ginger Man Kosher Catering NYC will work directly with you to ensure every detail of your events fulfills your expectations and results in a successful and pleasurable event.