The Best Italian Wedding Catering in Milwaukee, WI

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


9 Wedding Caterers in Milwaukee, WI

Italian
Quick responder
Emerald City Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Starts at $930
  • Serves Milwaukee, WI

You want a celebration that feels warm, relaxed, and welcoming, where guests can gather around incredible food, feel taken care of, and still have plenty of energy left for the dance floor. You value comfort, connection, and personality over formality. Instead of the standard beef-or-chicken dinner, you’re looking for flavorful, homey comfort food — something that reflects you as a couple and gives your guests real choices through a curated buffet experience. Personalized service matters to you. You want a caterer who listens, guides you, communicates clearly, and keeps pricing transparent so planning feels exciting instead of overwhelming.

People talked about the food for MONTHS after our wedding. The details matter - they thought of things that had never even occured to me! As we were busy greeting our guests, Steve and Laurie made sure to set aside appetizer plates for my new husband and I. Everything was so delicious all of the apps were gone by the time we made it to our seats just to find two plates placed with care at the head table. At the end of the night, everything was neatly boxed up for us (yes, we got to keep our leftovers!) and they even made a separate container of our pig roast scraps for our dog! I recommend them to anyone for an all around wonderful experience that your guests will talk about long after the celebration day is over.
Sandra B., 5 months ago
Quick responder
Brim Cafe & Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
Milwaukee, WI
  • Starts at $5,000

Enjoy your wedding planning experience with a family-owned and operated cafe and catering company, serving the Southeastern Wisconsin area since 2014. Brim offers authentic and modern wedding catering solutions with a built-in event planner, Mediterranean gastronomy, and the charm of working with a couple directly who owns and operates Brim. From a private wedding tasting at their main cafe location to organized and seamless event planning, they will leave you and your guests filled to the brim with delicious food, cocktails, and dessert.

Brim Cafe and Catering was a pleasure to work with for our wedding. Their communication throughout the planning process was timely and professional, which made coordinating the catering logistics seamless. On the day of the event, their team executed the setup in a professional manner and the food they provided was excellent. The servers were courteous and attentive, ensuring our guests had a wonderful dining experience. We were very impressed with the quality of Brim's work and highly recommend them to any couple looking for an excellent wedding caterer.
Terry Bogues , a year ago
TrendlineTrending
Antigua Catering & Events 
Rating: 5.0 (6 reviews)
  • Starts at $1,000
  • Serves Milwaukee, WI

Life gets celebrated around food! Together, we can create a menu and setting that will reflect the love for you and your loved one. ​ At Antigua, we love what we do! And what better place to show our love for food and service than at your wedding. Let our award-winning team help you take care of the reception details so that you can enjoy your family and friends.

I can confidently say Antigua made our wedding day absolutely perfect. My wife and I knew we wanted food that was not only delicious but also unique and memorable. From the moment we sat down for our tasting, we knew Antigua was the right choice. First off, the food was next level. Seriously, people are still texting us about the empanadas and the cotija cheese mashed potatoes. It was this incredible mix of authentic Latin flavors with a sophisticated, modern twist. They worked with us to create a menu that matched our vibe perfectly. I mean, we’re talking about food that had my dad going back for seconds (and thirds) — and he’s usually super picky. But what really blew us away was how much the Antigua team cared. They weren’t just there to cater; they went above and beyond to make sure everything ran smoothly. The staff was so professional, friendly, and on top of it. It’s like they genuinely wanted us to have the best day ever, and they delivered. The setup was gorgeous. Their team transformed the venue into this warm, vibrant space that felt so us. They even helped us incorporate some personal touches — like a late-night churro station (game changer). If you’re looking for a catering team that feels more like family, Antigua is IT. They made our wedding feel like the best party Milwaukee has ever seen, and we couldn’t be happier. If I could give them 10 stars, I would. Antigua Catering, you guys crushed it. Thank you for everything! Ethan R. P.S The Chimi
Ethan R., a year ago
Quick responder
Hoffman House Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (26 reviews)
  • Starts at $1,645
  • Serves Milwaukee, WI

You’ve been dreaming of this day for a long time, crafting the perfect experience in your mind. The dress. The flowers. The ring. And, of course, the food. Each celebration is an opportunity for us to help couples bring their unique vision to life.

Awarded Best of Zola
Kayla was absolutely fantastic to work with! She was timely in responding to any questions we had, and made it easy to plan our dinner. The on-site tasting experience was a nice added bonus to allow our families to try our wedding food before the day of. We would absolutely recommend Hoffman House if you are looking for quality service and amazing food!
Elsa U., 7 months ago
Quick responder
SaveurFRESH Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (16 reviews)
  • Serves Milwaukee, WI
  • Offer

A CULINARY JOURNEY TAILORED WITH UNIQUE VISION and CULINARY CREATION . With chic innovative vision emerging from diverse cultures specializing in superior meats fresh seafood and organic ingredients while influenced through distinctive heritages and cultural trends, Our Custom Catering brings you profound ethnic cuisine with superior taste impeccable service & atmosphere. Indulge your guests with a culinary journey that is as diverse as your imagination. Every event is full and complete offering beverage service alongside our meal offerings and our mission is to provide exceptional catering services that exceed our clients expectations

Awarded Best of Zola
SaveurFRESH Catering was an outstanding choice for our wedding day. Their communication throughout the planning process was excellent and prompt, making the catering logistics a breeze. On the day of, Chef Christopher and his staff were truly exceptional and professional, all while providing our guests with a comfortable, not uptight atmosphere. The food and service was outstanding - they went above and beyond to create the most elegant displays and ensure our special day was perfect. We could not have asked for a better catering experience.
Blaine, 6 months ago
Quick responder
Maison D Events and Hospitality 
Rating: 5.0 (5 reviews)
  • Starts at $150
  • Serves Milwaukee, WI
  • Offer

With over 15 years of experience Maison D is the premier catering and hospitality company you would ever need. We do everything from catering to event planning and everything in-between. We take your event to the next level and elevate it in every way possible

Maison D delivers an incredible experience from start to finish. Their professionalism, creativity, and attention to detail truly set them apart. Every element was thoughtfully planned and beautifully executed, creating an event that felt both elegant and effortless. The team was responsive, organized, and genuinely invested in making sure everything turned out perfectly. They took the time to understand the vision and brought it to life in a way that exceeded expectations. The final result was stunning and left our guests talking about it long after the event ended. If you’re looking for a company that combines luxury, style, and flawless execution, Maison D is the perfect choice. Highly recommended!
Elizabeth, 3 months ago
Quick responder
Elegante Cuisine 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Starts at $5,625
  • Serves Milwaukee, WI for additional fees

At Eleganté Cuisine, our sole goal is to ensure the complete satisfaction and happiness of our customers. Through our meticulous attention to detail, quality, execution and presentation, we always strive to exceed expectations by placing the utmost emphasis on the wants and needs of our clientele.

Awarded Best of Zola
Elegante Cuisine is one of the higher end catering companies in the area, so this was a splurge for us, but one that we do not regret. Good food and good music are two of the biggest factors in the guest experience, so it was worth it to us. Our tasting was awesome; their menu options are extensive but all the dishes seemed to be executed perfectly. They had catered at our venue many times, and seemed highly competent. During and since the wedding, many of our friends and family have raved to us that it was the best food they’ve had at a wedding. Our entrees were the chicken asiago and the stuffed peppers (sooo good!). On the wedding day, Elegante staff took great care of us, even making sure we had hot, full plates and an assortment of our cocktail hour hors d'oeuvres ready when we entered the reception space. We worked with Trisha, who at times did not respond very effectively or efficiently to our questions/concerns/requests, but overall we are very happy with the services we received and us and all the guests were certainly well fed.
Megan, 3 years ago