What other Conneaut Lake vendors will I need?

Conneaut Lake Event Extras Conneaut Lake Officiants Conneaut Lake Bar Services & Beverages Conneaut Lake Cakes & Desserts Conneaut Lake Beauty Professionals Conneaut Lake Bands & DJs Conneaut Lake Wedding Planners Conneaut Lake Florists Conneaut Lake Videographers Conneaut Lake Photographers Conneaut Lake Venues

The Best 7 Southern Food Wedding Catering in Conneaut Lake, PA

Hidden gem

Cali's West Catering

5.0

Starts at $150
Serves Conneaut Lake, PA

The experience of Cali's West Catering spans decades. Renowned for our unparalleled service and extraordinary food, no Wedding is too small or too large for our professional staff. Cali's West Catering, in Erie, PA, is an affiliate of Calamari's Squid Row, which has been independently owned and operated by Jay & Marci Honard at 1317 State Street, since 1996. Established to meet the needs of our clientele, there is no doubt that we will make your event a memorable experience. We have catered thousands of Weddings, and pride ourselves on our accessibility, flexibility and ability to exceed the expectations of our guests.

“Using Cali’s was a great experience. They were knowledgeable and helpful in all areas. The food was delicious and we wouldn’t change a thing.”

Debbie, 7 months ago

Quick responder

Avenue29 Catering

5.0

Starts at $5,900
Serves Conneaut Lake, PA

Established in 2015, Avenue29 Catering is a full-service wedding catering company based in Williamsville, NY. As a two-time Taste of Buffalo award-winning company, we specialize in elevated, meat-forward menus and seamless event execution. We focus on high-value weddings of 100+ guests, delivering structured planning, professional staffing, and exceptional flavor. Our approach combines quality ingredients, generous portions, and smooth execution from tasting to final service. Also offering full bar services at exclusive pricing for wedding clients.

“We had a private wedding ceremony and got referred to Avenue29 as a caterer who would understand the specific details of what we wanted to make our food as magical as the rest of our day. When meeting with Nicholas we were thoroughly impressed by his calm and confident presence, his detailed questions and the vision he helped us co-create. We didn’t want a traditional buffet so he came up with a beautiful 4-corner display so each section could have their own semi-private food display. His attention to detail, professionalism and personality were nothing like we had experienced before. We had a beautiful tasting, he went over every line item with us thoroughly, and made sure it was the right package for our wedding. And the delivery on our wedding day was exactly what we’d imagined and more. Amazing food, service, presentation, and professionalism. We could not recommend Avenue29 enough! Nicholas and his team truly went above and beyond for us!”

Jenna, a month ago

Quick responder

Catering by Cable's

5.0

Starts at $4,100
Serves Conneaut Lake, PA
Offer

At Catering by Cable's, we specialize in providing exceptional full-service catering for weddings and special events. With over 20 years of experience in the catering industry, our team is dedicated to delivering superb hospitality and personalized menu planning that caters to your unique style.

“Catering by Cable's was an absolute delight to work with for our wedding. From the very first interaction, Kyrsta and the staff were friendly, open, and clear in their communication, making the planning process a breeze. Their attention to detail and fun, creative approach ensured our wedding day was smooth and seamless. The food they prepared was easily the best I've ever had at a wedding - absolutely delicious and prepared with great care, including accommodations for all known food allergies among our guests. Catering by Cable's was truly a joy to work with, and I would recommend them to any couple looking for an easy, stress-free catering experience for their special day.”

Stephanie, 22 days ago

Quick responder

Jessie’s catering kitchen

5.0

Starts at $2,500
Serves Conneaut Lake, PA

OUR CULINARY MISSION At Jessie's Catering Kitchen, our mission is to provide exceptional catering services that create memorable experiences. We focus on using high-quality ingredients and innovative recipes to delight every palate.

“Jessie’s Catering Kitchen delivered an absolute dream experience for our wedding day. From start to finish, everything felt like a true fairytale — elegant, seamless, and beyond anything we could have imagined. Their team was incredibly professional, punctual, and organized. Every detail was executed with perfection, allowing us to fully relax and enjoy our day without any stress. The setup was stunning and gave our reception a beautiful, castle-like elegance that truly wowed our guests. The food was exceptional — flavorful, beautifully presented, and prepared with such care. Our guests are still talking about it! The staff was attentive, kind, and always one step ahead, making sure everything ran smoothly throughout the entire event. What stood out most was their dedication to excellence. Jessie’s Catering Kitchen didn’t just provide a service — they created an unforgettable experience filled with elegance, warmth, and magic. If you’re looking for a reliable, professional, and high-quality caterer who will truly elevate your wedding day, this is the team to book.”

Erica D., 6 days ago

Quick responder

Glad Mouf

5.0

Starts at $3,000
Serves Conneaut Lake, PA

Glad Mouf BBQ – Unforgettable Flavor for Your Special Day At Glad Mouf BBQ, we believe every wedding deserves unforgettable food that brings people together. We specialize in craft barbecue with a gourmet twist, featuring the world’s most tender smoked oxtails, melt-in-your-mouth brisket, juicy smoked chicken, brisket tacos —all paired with our legendary sauces. We offer catering with a choice of station-style service with pre-portioned servings or a buffet. Enjoy a special rate of $50 per person for 100+ guests or $75 per person with a 50-guest minimum. Our customizable menu allows you to create the perfect meal for your wedding vision.

“I recently had the pleasure of working with Glad Mouf for catering my wedding, and I am so glad I did! From the very beginning, their communication was seamless and professional. They listened carefully to all my needs and provided thoughtful suggestions that made the entire process stress-free. The team at Glad Mouf truly went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect for my special day. The food was absolutely incredible! The oxtail was tender and flavorful, cooked to perfection with a rich, savory sauce that had just the right amount of seasoning. Every bite was melt-in-your-mouth delicious. The crab fried rice was another standout—packed with juicy crab meat and a delicious combination of flavors. It was the perfect balance of savory and just the right amount of richness. I’ve had many versions of crab fried rice, but this one was top-tier. As for the overall experience, the quality and value of their work were exceptional. The portions were generous, and the food was served fresh and hot, even though they were catering to a large crowd. Our guests couldn't stop talking about how amazing the food was. Glad Mouf’s dedication to their craft really shone through, and they contributed to making my wedding day even more memorable. If you’re looking for top-notch BBQ and seafood, I highly recommend Glad Mouf. They will elevate any event with their great food and excellent service!”

Sakinah P., a year ago

Quick responder

Old Souls Catering

Starts at $5,000
Serves Conneaut Lake, PA

Growing up in Wyoming County, the heart of New York’s dairy & farming industry, Josh has a real appreciation for fresh food products. His family’s restaurants and their farms sparked a passion for carefully choosing sources of food. Josh’s dedication to sourcing and using the best fresh and local products is evident in his cooking. Josh went to culinary school at Johnson & Wales University in North Miami. He took the skills he learned from working in his family and other local restaurants and continued to develop them at J&W. After culinary school, Josh came back to Western New York and opened a catering business.

Quick responder

The Smoking Bar

5.0

Starts at $500
Serves Conneaut Lake, PA for additional fees

At The Smoking Bar, we pride ourselves on crafting unique and flavorful cocktails and food that elevate your drinking experience. Our journey began with a passion for mixology and cooking, and we continue to innovate and inspire with every drink and dish we serve.

“The Smoking Bar was an amazing wedding caterer for our special day. From the start, they made the process of planning our menu easy and enjoyable. They were very helpful in guiding us through all the decisions and offered a delicious tasting so we could sample the quality of their food. On the day of the wedding, they arrived on time and their communication was outstanding throughout the entire process. The staff was incredibly professional, and we had no issues whatsoever with this vendor. The food they served was absolutely delicious, using the freshest and highest quality ingredients. It tasted far better than any other catering we had tried. We are so grateful to The Smoking Bar for helping make our wedding day perfect.”

Nicole T., 6 months ago