The Best Italian Wedding Catering in Carlisle, OH

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


8 Wedding Caterers in Carlisle, OH

Italian
TrendlineTrending
Grace Well Catering 
Rating: 4.6 (5 reviews)
  • Starts at $500
  • Serves Carlisle, OH

Hi! My name is Angie Walls and I am the owner of Grace Well Catering. I have been catering for over 15 years to family, friends and church. I decided in May of 2023 to pursue my dream of being a full time caterer after being laid off from my full time job. I have always loved to cook and was told by many people that I would be an amazing caterer. I took the leap and haven't looked back. My love language is feeding people delicious affordable food. I would love to get some bookings as a traveling chef as well. Thank you for checking out my listing!

“Grace Well Catering made our wedding day feel stress-free from start to finish. Angie and her team were responsive, professional, and easy to work with throughout the planning process. They handled both our cocktail hour grazing table and pasta bar dinner flawlessly—the grazing table was such a showstopper that guests are still talking about it weeks later. The pasta bar ran like clockwork with plenty of delicious options for everyone to enjoy. For the quality and creativity they brought to the table, the value we got was unbeatable. We'd absolutely recommend Grace Well Catering to any couple looking for caterers who will make their guests feel taken care of without breaking the bank.”
Samantha G., 3 months ago
Quick responder
Best Eats Catering Company 
Rating: 4.4 (7 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Starts at $18
  • Serves Carlisle, OH
  • Offer

Personalized catering for weddings, open houses, birthdays, and corporate events, made with fresh local ingredients and a whole lot of heart. We are here to turn your vision into a reality. If you are ready please reach out to us

“From our first conversation, Best Eats Catering Company made us feel heard and supported every step of the way. The team was responsive to our questions and worked closely with our other vendors to keep everything running smoothly on the day of our wedding. What really impressed us was how the chef stayed in touch with everyone involved to ensure perfect timing. The food arrived hot and ready, and honestly, it tasted incredible. Our guests couldn't stop talking about the meals, and we felt like the whole experience was handled with real professionalism. We'd absolutely recommend Best Eats to any couple looking for caterers they can trust.”
Denise L., 4 days ago
Quick responder
Bon appetit LLC 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Starts at $1,500
  • Serves Carlisle, OH
  • Offer

Congragulations! You’ve found who you’re looking for right here! Lol. Hello, im Hannah. A chef with 16 years of cooking under my belt I enjoy cooking just about every menu to fit your needs. The most popular menu is a taco/nacho buffet. I also do a lot of pasta/salad bars and comfort food buffets. Please reach out with any questions.

“From the moment we reached out to Later Tater LLC, their communication was excellent. They were extremely friendly and professional, and worked closely with us to ensure our wedding day catering was perfect. The food they provided was all locally sourced and incredibly fresh, and their grazing tables were beautifully presented. The entire team was highly proficient, and they seamlessly executed the catering and desserts for our special day. We couldn't have been happier with their services, and would highly recommend Later Tater LLC to any couple planning their wedding.”
Angel, a year ago
Quick responder
Chef's Choice Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Serves Carlisle, OH

Thank You for considering Chef’s Choice Catering for Your Event! Chef’s Choice Catering has proudly served the Greater Cincinnati and Northern Kentucky area since 1995. We have encountered great success with our clients largely because of our wide variety of menu and dining options, our ability to create customized menus, and because of our courteous and professional sales and service staff. Chef’s Choice Catering offers diversified menus that specialize in casual themed platters and grill out buffets, to upscale plated and served rehearsal dinners and wedding receptions that rival any caterer in the area.

“Chef's Choice Catering was a fantastic choice for our wedding. Their communication was excellent, with a quick response time to all of our questions and requests. The quality of their work was great, and our guests raved about the delicious food. The bartenders and servers were also a pleasure to work with, making sure our event ran smoothly. We were thrilled with the service provided by Chef's Choice Catering and would highly recommend them to any couple planning their special day.”
Megan K., a year ago
Quick responder
Street Provisions with Chef James 
Rating: 4.8 (23 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Starts at $70
  • Serves Carlisle, OH for additional fees

Street Provisions creates food experiences that bring people together. Our seasonal, chef-driven menus are designed to make your celebration feel warm, memorable, and full of flavor. Whether it’s a wedding, rehearsal dinner, or an intimate gathering, we make sure your guests feel cared for and connected through every bite. It’s the kind of food that turns a meal into something everyone remembers.

“Chef James is professional, knowledgeable, and masterfully skilled at his craft! We chose him for our wedding and we plus all of our guests thought it was the best food we’ve ever had at a wedding. He is fairly priced and does all the dishes top notch! We highly highly recommend, the food was our highlight and that was important to us!”
Catherine L., 8 days ago
Quick responder
Sincere Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Starts at $1,000
  • Serves Carlisle, OH for additional fees

Welcome to the extraordinary tastes of Sincere Catering...a love letter paying homage to tradition and the evolution of cuisine! Sincere specializes in making your event day special by customizing your menu, preferences, and culinary options.

“Sincere Catering & Sincerely Yours Events was a cooperative, outstanding, and one-time communicable partner for our wedding. The quality of their work was top-tier and delicious - they gave me extra things I did not order as a gift, everything was on time, and I did not have to worry about the correct temperatures. I love the way they took their time, gave me options, and worked within my budget. The team was very easy to communicate with and never rushed me. I give Sincere Catering & Sincerely Yours Events a 10 out of 10 and highly recommend them.”
CARMEN, a year ago
Rose & Brie Charcuterie 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Starts at $75
  • Serves Carlisle, OH for additional fees

Hi, I’m Marian—mom of two, creative soul, and the heart behind Rose & Brie Charcuterie. I started this business with a simple mission: to bring people together around beautiful, delicious food without the stress. At Rose & Brie, we believe that food should be both a feast for the eyes and the heart. Every board is crafted with care, intention, and a whole lot of love. Making gatherings more beautiful (and more delicious!) is what drives me every day.

“Marian is an extremely talented and professional caterer, and you will be missing out if you don't book her for your wedding! She worked with us to make sure every detail was perfect for the big day, and she brought the most stunning spread of food I have ever seen. Our guests were floored and very happy with the variety, quality, and abundance of the food available. It really elevated the event!”
Marissa C., 6 months ago