What other Butlerville vendors will I need?

Butlerville Event Extras Butlerville Officiants Butlerville Bar Services & Beverages Butlerville Cakes & Desserts Butlerville Beauty Professionals Butlerville Bands & DJs Butlerville Wedding Planners Butlerville Florists Butlerville Videographers Butlerville Photographers Butlerville Venues

What other caterers are nearby?

American Louisville, KY caterers American Cincinnati, OH caterers

The Best 7 American Wedding Caterers in Butlerville, IN

7 Wedding Caterers in Butlerville, IN

American

Quick responder

Exline Eats

Rating: 5.0 (22 reviews)

·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews

Starts at $450
Serves Butlerville, IN

Exline Eats is a chef-owned gourmet caterer serving Louisville, Kentucky, and Southern Indiana. Let us support your next special occasion with thoughtfully-crafted, made-from-scratch culinary delights.

“My fiancé and I reached out to Exline Eats after my wedding planner absolutely raved about the recent experience she had working with them. After filling out the online inquiry form, Chef Ken reached out directly to offer a complimentary tasting. He was very responsive and accommodating on dates and times. At the tasting, Chef Ken prepared a fantastic spread- quite literally everything was our favorite! He chatted with us about the food, the services and was very transparent about pricing. It was truly a wonderful experience and we couldn’t be more excited to move forward with the next steps in booking with Chef Ken and his team for our wedding.”

Kennedy S., 2 months ago

Quick responder

Maison D Events and Hospitality

Rating: 5.0 (9 reviews)

Serves Butlerville, IN

With over 15 years of experience Maison D is the premier catering and hospitality company you would ever need. We do everything from catering to event planning and everything in-between. We take your event to the next level and elevate it in every way possible

“Maison D delivers an incredible experience from start to finish. Their professionalism, creativity, and attention to detail truly set them apart. Every element was thoughtfully planned and beautifully executed, creating an event that felt both elegant and effortless. The team was responsive, organized, and genuinely invested in making sure everything turned out perfectly. They took the time to understand the vision and brought it to life in a way that exceeded expectations. The final result was stunning and left our guests talking about it long after the event ended. If you’re looking for a company that combines luxury, style, and flawless execution, Maison D is the perfect choice. Highly recommended!”

Elizabeth, 5 months ago

Quick responder

Indy Fresh Catering

Rating: 5.0 (1 review)

Starts at $500
Serves Butlerville, IN

Owner Toby Nunley founded Indy Fresh Catering in 2013 to meet the growing demand for affordable, high-quality, full-service catering with diverse menu options. However, our journey began much earlier—in 2005. Since then, we’ve successfully catered over 300,000 events in Central Indiana, from corporate luncheons to weddings, conferences, private events, and more. Our experienced catering team knows that top-notch food and service are essential. We are committed to making your wedding day everything you’ve envisioned. You deserve the best, and we’re here to deliver. Let us handle the details, so you can focus on celebrating your special day.

“Indy Fresh Catering made our wedding day so much easier. Dara was incredible to work with—she responded quickly to every message and even followed up when we hadn't heard back, which showed how much she cared. On the big day, we didn't have to stress about food at all because everything ran smoothly. Our guests couldn't stop raving about the pizza, and several people said how easy and enjoyable dinner was. From start to finish, Dara and her team handled everything with such attention to detail that we could focus on celebrating with our loved ones. We'd absolutely recommend them to any couple looking for a caterer they can trust.”

Savanah T., a month ago

Quick responder

Sincere Catering

Rating: 5.0 (1 review)

Starts at $1,000
Serves Butlerville, IN

Welcome to the extraordinary tastes of Sincere Catering...a love letter paying homage to tradition and the evolution of cuisine! Sincere specializes in making your event day special by customizing your menu, preferences, and culinary options.

“Sincere Catering & Sincerely Yours Events was a cooperative, outstanding, and one-time communicable partner for our wedding. The quality of their work was top-tier and delicious - they gave me extra things I did not order as a gift, everything was on time, and I did not have to worry about the correct temperatures. I love the way they took their time, gave me options, and worked within my budget. The team was very easy to communicate with and never rushed me. I give Sincere Catering & Sincerely Yours Events a 10 out of 10 and highly recommend them.”

CARMEN, a year ago

Trending

Michaelis Events & Catering

Starts at $300
Serves Butlerville, IN

Welcome to Michaelis Events, where we specialize in turning your most ambitious visions into stylish, seamless realities. We believe that a truly great celebration is one where every element works in perfect harmony, which is why we’ve built a full-service experience that encompasses planning, catering, bar services, florals, and design—all under one creative roof. My team and I bring bold ideas and curated details to every event, ensuring that your day feels authentic, elevated, and entirely your own.

Hidden gem

Queen Q's Quisine Catering, LLC

Rating: 5.0 (5 reviews)

Starts at $100
Serves Butlerville, IN for additional fees

Queen Q’s Quisine has been proudly serving clients for over six years, bringing people together through the joy of food. We specialize in delicious Southern-inspired comfort foods and delectable homemade desserts, each dish handcrafted with love and care. Our passion is not only in the taste and quality of our cuisine, but also in the professionalism and warmth we bring to every event. At Queen Q’s Quisine, we believe food should nourish the soul, create lasting memories, and leave every guest feeling satisfied and cared for. No event is too large or small. We can't wait for you to "Taste the Love!"

“Q's Quisine Catering, LLC, delivered another great year of delicious food and set-up presentation for our company annual event. This was the 2nd year I requested Q's service and I'm glad I did. Q's worked around our short-notice and delivered a great experience for all in attendance. I look forward to working with Q's for other events in the very near future.”

Kenneth C., a year ago

Tuck-ins

Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)

Starts at $250
Serves Butlerville, IN for additional fees

Tuck-ins are a roastable, Inside-Out S’more on a stick, each containing a crunchy handmade graham cracker, covered in decadent chocolate, all inside a fluffy marshmallow! Tuck-ins® are available in Classic, Cookies & Cream, and Peanut Butter! Tuck-ins can be given out as favors with guests roasting them at home over a gas or electric stove. You can even have your own roasting station at your event with TerraFlame Fire Bowls available through Tuck-ins!