Love Story Cakes

Price per serving

Starts at $3 per person.

About Love Story Cakes

Katie McVay

Owner and Operator

Hello I’m Katie! Owner and operator of Love Story Cakes! I have a Bachelors Degree in Baking and Pastry Arts from Johnson and Wales University and I’ve been in the business for over 16 years. I love to make delicious desserts and edible works of art. I’m very passionate and strive to have everything I make be the best it can be for your wedding day!

Customizable is a big thing that sets us apart! We offer several different cake, filling, and icing selections that can be mixed and matched to make your perfect combination! We also offer cake stand rentals and cake and dessert staging. We know wedding planning can be extremely stressful so we strive to make the ordering process easy and fun! We would be so honored to be a part of your special day!

Best of Zola 2024


Dessert types

  • Cakes
  • Cookies and macarons
  • Cupcakes
  • Mini desserts
  • Novelties and other

Decor options

  • Cake toppers
  • Custom text
  • Live flowers
  • Sugar flowers

Available customizations

  • Cake filling
  • Cake flavors
  • Cake frosting

Services offered

  • Consultations
  • Delivery
  • Setup
  • Tastings

Dietary accommodations

  • Vegetarian


Write a review

5.0 (3 reviews)

  • Absolutely Delicious!

    Verified review
    Mallerlyn V4 months ago

    Everything from setting up our tasting to the delivery of the cake was amazing! Katie was always flexible which made everything so much easier. We got the strawberry and chocolate cake and they were hitters! At the end of the night we only had 4 slices left! Our cake looked so beautiful the day of, i really couldn’t have had asked for anything better!

  • Excellent Cake!

    Verified review
    Michael Borell6 months ago

    We loved our wedding cake from Love Story Cakes! Katie was the best to work with - from planning stages or choosing wedding cake fillings, we had an easy time saying yes for her to make our unique wedding birch cake a reality! She was so helpful, the cake tasted and looked amazing and all in all I'd recommend to anyone in need of a wedding cake!

  • 5 stars!!!!

    Verified review
    Gretta Hellmuth2 years ago

    Could not recommend Love Story Cakes enough! Katie is so great to work with.