Calla Lily Cakery

Price per serving

Starts at $6 per person.

Packages

Prices start at $150

About Calla Lily Cakery

Calla Lily Cakery

At Calla Lily Cakery we create custom wedding cakes, cookies, and dessert tables with endless flavor and design possibilities. Everything is made from scratch using high quality ingredients. We offer delivery and setup throughout Ohio so your desserts arrive beautiful and celebration ready.

We believe your desserts should feel just as special as your wedding day. Every order is thoughtfully customized from flavors to decorations with creativity, flexibility, and attention to detail to ensure your desserts are memorable, and uniquely yours.

Services

Dessert types

  • Cakes
  • Candy and confections
  • Cookies and macarons
  • Cupcakes
  • International desserts
  • Mini desserts
  • Pastries
  • Pies
  • Puddings and custards
  • Novelties and other

Decor options

  • 3D sugar work
  • Custom text
  • Fruit topping
  • Live flowers
  • Sugar flowers

Available customizations

  • Cake filling
  • Cake flavors
  • Cake frosting

Services offered

  • Consultations
  • Delivery
  • Dessert installations
  • Setup
  • Tastings

Dietary accommodations

  • Dairy-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Sugar-free
  • Vegan
  • Vegetarian

Calla Lily Cakery packages

Intimate Two Tier Wedding Cake

Price$600

Description

This custom two tier wedding cake serves up to 40 guests and is perfect for your ceremony cutting while also serving your wedding party. Each cake is crafted from scratch using premium ingredients and fully customized to match your wedding style. Final pricing may vary based on flavor selections, fillings, and design detail.

What’s included
  • Custom 2-tier cake, flavors & design consult

Classic Three Tier Wedding Cake

Price$950

Description

This timeless three tier wedding cake serves up to 100 guests and is thoughtfully designed to complement your wedding aesthetic. Each cake is crafted from scratch using premium ingredients and fully customized to reflect your color palette and overall vision. Final pricing may vary based on flavor selection, intricate detailing, and specialty finishes.

What’s included
  • Custom 3-tier cake, flavors & design consult

Dessert Spread

Price$1,200

Description

A stunning, fully customized dessert table featuring a curated assortment of sweets, designed to wow your guests and elevate your wedding reception. Each table is tailored to your color palette, theme, and flavor preferences. Serves up to 150 guests. Final pricing varies based on dessert selections, flavors, and design complexity.

What’s included
  • Assorted desserts (~3–4 per guest)
  • Custom flavor selection
  • Menu consultation & planning

Custom Cake & Dessert Spread

Price$1,800

Description

A curated combination of a 1-2 tier custom wedding cake and coordinated desserts, designed to create a visually stunning focal point for your reception. Serves up to 150 guests. Final pricing varies based on dessert selections, flavors, and design complexity.

What’s included
  • Custom 1–2 tier wedding cake
  • Assorted desserts (~3–4 per guest)
  • Flavor consultation & menu planning

Reviews

Write a review

5.0 out of 5

4 reviews

Write a review

  • Professional and tasty!

    •Verified review
    •Ron W.•Mar 22

    I had the pleasure of officiating a wedding where this vendor provided the cake and desserts, and I was seriously impressed. The cake looked absolutely phenomenal—beautifully designed and a true centerpiece for the reception. Throughout the night, I kept hearing guests rave about how incredible it tasted. It’s one thing for a cake to look amazing, but to also have everyone talking about how good it is really says a lot. From a vendor perspective, everything appeared seamless and professional, which makes a big difference on such an important day. I would absolutely recommend them to any couple looking for both stunning presentation and amazing flavor!

  • 5 Star Experience

    •Verified review
    •Amiah G.•Mar 16

    We ordered a tiered wedding cake and a full dessert table for about 200 guests, and the entire experience was absolutely incredible. From start to finish, everything was handled professionally and with so much care. The cake and desserts were not only beautiful but also incredibly fresh and delicious. You could really tell everything was made with high-quality ingredients and attention to detail. We received so many compliments from our guests about how good everything tasted. She also delivered everything and personally set up the entire dessert table, which took a huge amount of stress off our plate on the wedding day. Everything looked perfect and was arranged beautifully. Honestly, 15/10 experience. If you're looking for someone for a wedding or event, I can't recommend her enough!

  • A cake we'll never forget!

    •Verified review
    •Brinley•Feb 2, 2026

    Calla Lily Cakery was an absolute dream to work with! From our first conversation to our wedding day Calla was professional, responsive & truly listened to our vision. Our cake was not only stunning but hands down one of the best tasting cakes we’ve ever had. Guests are still talking about it! We couldn’t have asked for a better experience and highly recommend Calla Lily Cakery to any couple looking for a beautiful, custom wedding cake.

    Response from vendor•Mar 16, 2026
    Thank you so much for your sweet words! It truly means so much to hear that you had such a wonderful experience. I loved working with you and bringing your vision to life. Knowing that you and your guests enjoyed the cake and are still talking about it is the best compliment I could receive. Thank you for trusting Calla Lily Cakery to be part of your special day. Wishing you both a lifetime filled with love, happiness, and many sweet moments together!

  • 5 Star Bakery

    •Verified review
    •Anthony•Feb 2, 2026

    Calla Lily Cakery provided an amazing and elegant experience for our wedding desserts. Their communication was fast, clear, and fun from start to finish. They made sure everything was delivered and set up on time, and our guests raved about the beautiful and delicious dessert table they created. The cake and other sweets were not only visually stunning, but tasted incredible too. We couldn't have been happier with Calla Lily Cakery and highly recommend them to any couple planning their wedding.

    Response from vendor•Mar 16, 2026
    Thank you so much for your kind words! It was truly an honor to be part of your special day. I’m so glad you and your guests enjoyed the desserts and that everything looked and tasted just as you hoped. Creating beautiful and delicious dessert tables for weddings is something I absolutely love, so hearing feedback like this means the world to me. Thank you for trusting Calla Lily Cakery to be a part of your celebration, and I wish you both a lifetime of happiness together!

Explore other vendors serving Lima, OH

Complete your dream team

Other cakes & desserts in Lima

Other wedding services nearby