Cakes by Karol

Price per serving

Starts at $10 per person.

About Cakes by Karol

Cakes by Karol

Luxury Wedding Cakes & Desserts

Cakes by Karol are known for our stunning, unique and award-winning cakes and fancies, as well as our diverse range of “made from your imagination” specialty cakes for weddings, anniversaries, bridal & baby showers, baptisms, graduations, birthdays, retirements, holidays, corporate events and any other occasion conceivable.

We pride ourselves in creating every order from the ground up using only the freshest and best ingredients. Our reputation amongst local businesses, wedding chapels, caterers, restaurants, hotels, guest houses, and florists is beyond compare. So whether you are looking for something classical or a whimsical masterpiece tailored directly from your imagination, ‘Cakes by Karol’ would love to create your treat that tastes as delicious as it appears

Services

Dessert types

  • Cakes
  • Cookies and macarons
  • Cupcakes
  • Ice cream and frozen desserts
  • Mini desserts
  • Pies
  • Novelties and other

Decor options

  • 3D sugar work
  • Fruit topping
  • Live flowers
  • Sugar flowers

Available customizations

  • Cake filling
  • Cake flavors
  • Cake frosting

Services offered

  • Consultations
  • Delivery
  • Setup
  • Tastings

Dietary accommodations

  • Dairy-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Vegetarian

Reviews

Write a review
Rating: 5.0

5.0 out of 5

1 review

  • DR

    Daniel R.

    Rating: 5
    •May 31, 2025

    Delicious, Creative, and So Easy to Work With!

    Working with Cakes by Karol was an absolute delight from start to finish. She was incredibly responsive and patient, answering all of our questions and offering thoughtful recommendations on flavor combinations that would complement each other perfectly. We had a very specific cake inspiration we found online, and Karol took that exact vision and transformed it into a beautiful cake that not only matched our wedding aesthetic but also reflected our personalities. It was truly the perfect centerpiece for our celebration. One of the highlights was the cake tasting process—even though we weren’t local, Karol shipped the cake layers, fillings, and frostings to us so we could sample and mix flavors at home. It was so much fun (and so tasty!) to experiment with all the delicious combinations before making our final choice. On the big day, our guests couldn’t stop raving about how incredible the cake was—some even joked about trying to bribe others for extra slices! That kind of reaction says it all. If you want a cake that’s as delicious as it is beautiful, and a vendor who’s easy to communicate with and truly cares, Cakes by Karol is the one to call.

Real wedding inspiration featuring Cakes by Karol

Show all photos
We recommend booking your date as soon as you have it selected. Since we do book up fairly quickly. Even if you can’t decide on final cake design, you can still reserve the date, and then we can finalize your details as we get closer to the big date.
We require a 50% non refundable deposit to book your wedding day and price, a contract needs to be sign when your order, Balance needs to be paid in full 30 days before the event day. All requests for cancellation must be made in writing.
The cake must be paid for in full no later than 30 days prior to delivery of your cake.
Each cake is designed and decorated differently and the charge is based on the amount of time involved in the decoration like sugar flowers, specialty flavors, special shapes etc. Please contact us for your specific cake inquire if you have a picture email it. Each cake tier can be a different cake and filling flavor with same icing if you would like to have more than one flavor in your cake.
Fondant is a sweet sugar dough consistency looks very smooth like porcelain, can be tinted any color. Choosing to have your cake covered in Fondant is like icing your cake twice, first there is the layer of Buttercream then the fondant.
e do offer tastings for weddings cakes for more than 30 people by appointment only. We offer a sampler platter PICK UP for a take home or we will deliver to your hotel if we're closed, cost is $20.00 includes 10 different cake flavors with 10 fillings and 4 icing separated to mix and match flavors.
Most appointments are made during business hours, Tuesday through Friday, Saturday we are busy finishing and delivering the cakes. We try to accommodate everyone, so please contact us and we will make every effort to work with in your schedule.
Changes can be made 30 days before the event date.
Of course you can! We are often asked to recreate design that our costumers have seen elsewhere.
There is actually no cost saving when creating a cake with fake and real tiers in it, because of the time consuming is the same as decorating a real cake.
Yes, if you have a budget please let us know and we can work with you to design something within your budget as long as your budget is reasonable.
All of our cakes are custom made and we only take a limited amount of cakes a week. If you cancel your order you may loose your deposit. Or we may issue you a credit for another order to be use within 6 months. It will be to our discretion.
Two tiers ROUND: The Smallest serves 20-25 people or bigger tiers for up to 60 servings - Two Tiers Square: The smallest serves 35-40 people or bigger for up to 90 servings - Three tiers Round: The smallest serves 50 people or bigger tiers for up to 100 servings - Carve 2D, 3D Shaped Cakes: 20 servings Minimum order.
Our serving size are based on 1 1/2” by 3 1/2" slices, if you would like bigger slices you have to order a bigger cake.
Yes, you can pick up at our store front during business hours.

Explore other vendors serving Key West, FL

Complete your dream team

Other cakes & desserts in Key West

Other wedding services nearby