The Best Italian Wedding Catering in Whatley, AL

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


8 Wedding Caterers in Whatley, AL

Italian
Quick responder
Yae's Eats & Catering LLC 

5.0

  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves Whatley, AL
  • Offer

Yaes Eats is a family-driven catering and community outreach business committed to serving great food and giving back. We specialize in high-quality, affordable catering for weddings, events, and celebrations of all sizes. Beyond food, we’re passionate about supporting families in need through fundraisers, toy drives, and community giveaways. Everything we do is rooted in love, service, and making a positive impact—one plate and one family at a time.

Awarded Best of Zola
Anyae catered our winter wedding at Juliette's Chapel in Dahlonega and did an amazing job! We selected some of her Italian entrees and everyone was delighted with the food. The cheesecake bites in particular were a big hit! We were very pleased with her professionalism throughout the entire process and can heartily recommend her!
Thomas M., a year ago
Quick responder
Simply Sated By Tessa 

5.0

  • Starts at $1,500
  • Serves Whatley, AL

Award-winning wedding catering by Chef Tessa. With 23+ years of experience, Simply Sated offers fully customized menus, grazing tables, cakes, bartending, décor, rentals, and coordination—your one-stop shop for unforgettable weddings.

Awarded Best of Zola
Everything about my experience was amazing, Chef Tessa was very quick to respond to me during the months leading up to my wedding. Was very helpful in the process of deciding what food I was choosing and how much as well! The food was phenomenal, we got the lasagna and roast beef and I highly recommend these, every single guest LOVED it and lots of people got seconds. We had a seated meal and the waiters were amazing as well, they all came to check on us several times, refilling drinks, bringing more food and were so friendly. Would totally recommend to book her and would book again for any other event!
Haley F., 10 months ago
Quick responder
Pensacola Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $1,600
  • Serves Whatley, AL

As a Certified Sommelier, Ian Whitcomb worked hand in hand with his chef mentors for over 15 years, creating menus that stood apart from the rest. Respecting minimalism and purity in ingredients, his relationships with local farmers and ranchers keeps his focus on beginning each dish with what the season has to offer. Stacy Whitcomb has spent over a decade in event planning and is not intimidated by outside of the box thinking when it comes to simple, yet elegant desserts. Whether it be Bay Laurel Crème Brulée or Satsuma & Thai Basil Sorbet, she always brings the symphony to a crescendo.

Awarded Best of Zola
I had the opportunity to sample the food from Pensacola catering at an event they were having. everything was set up nicely and the food was fabulous. All of the food was served at the right temperature. The steak was tender, juicy and seasoned very well. The homemade chips were crispy light in with just a right amount of salt. You can really taste the quality of the ingredients used in the entire set up. I would definitely hire them for future events.
Robin, 10 months ago
Quick responder
Chef Mike Newhall LLC 

5.0

  • Serves Whatley, AL
  • Offer

Chef Mike Newhall is a chef-driven catering professional known for creating fully customized events built around each client — not pre-set packages. Every menu is designed from the ground up based on your vision, guest count, service style, and budget. Whether it’s an intimate gathering or a full-scale wedding, the focus stays the same: deliver quality food, smooth execution, and a stress-free experience. With a hands-on approach and a background in high-demand service environments, Chef Mike is known for being adaptable, detail-oriented, and able to handle challenges in real time. Clients trust him to take control of the food and service

We had an amazing experience with Chef Mike Newhall LLC from start to finish. Mike was incredibly responsive and stayed on top of every detail leading up to our wedding day. When rain was in the forecast, he reached out proactively to let us know he'd already seen it coming and had a plan. He rented two large tents for us so our guests could stay comfortable and enjoy the celebration without worry. His team showed real dedication to making our day special, and the food was delicious. We highly recommend Chef Mike Newhall LLC to any couple looking for a caterer who truly cares about their customers.
Cami H., 6 days ago
GemHidden gem
Sweet Leaf Catering & Food Truck 

5.0

  • Starts at $1,200
  • Serves Whatley, AL for additional fees

I have been Catering, Planning & Coordinating both large & small Weddings & Events for over 22 years. I started in our family owned restaurant at a young age, waiting tables & learning to cook. I then learned the business side of a restaurant and ventured out in catering. I put all of my energy, passion & love into making sure each event is special and custom to my clients desires. We pull out all the stops to make sure you event is perfect, customizable & a forever memory! We take care & pride into all we do, providing exceptional food, customer and guest services.

I would highly recommend this catering service. Susan catered, decorated, set up, and directed me daughter’s wedding. I was able to relax and enjoy the celebration. Everything was perfect. Susan was so helpful and certainly did all we asked.
Patty M., 4 years ago
Southern Flavor Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $500
  • Serves Whatley, AL for additional fees

Southern Flavor Catering and Events prides ourselves on bringing our clients culinary visions to life. With over 15 years experience in catering, we've made it a point to put customer service at the top of our list and ensure our clients needs are put first. We always provide the freshest ingredients, and will help you have a menu that fits your budget. We can even help with signature cocktails or wine pairings for your unique menu! We work hard to make your Wedding/Event as special, and delicious, as possible!

We love working with Paige, Dwayne, and their staff because the food is always made from scratch and they will go above and beyond to ensure that their clients are happy with their experience. From the first class tasting event to leaving their wedding with midnight snacks, Southern Flavor goes the extra mile for each event,
After The Proposal, 4 years ago