The Best Italian Wedding Catering in Lilly, PA

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


10 Wedding Caterers in Lilly, PA

Italian
TrendlineTrending
Flair of Country Catering & Event Planning 
Rating: 5.0 (2 reviews)
  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves Lilly, PA

Flair of Country is Waking Up Your Taste Buds! We aren’t your “typical” caterers. Flair of Country was established with the intentions of changing the culinary palette of our clients. Our menus offer a variety of different options; whether a formal dinner for your wedding or a cookout for a family reunion in your backyard – we have the menu for you. Our concept revolves around always providing fresh food for our clients. Our mobile kitchens allow us to cook all of our catered meals in a kitchen and serve every meal straight out of the oven regardless of where your event takes us. This is where Flair of Country stands out above the rest.

Awarded Best of Zola
Corey, Mindi & the team at Flair of Country are a personal favorite of mine. Obviously, their food is second to none. Absolutely delicious, but they shine in areas that people don't think about when hiring a caterer. Organization, making sure they've got everything in place to serve a great meal, clean up, great attitudes, and presentation. I'm a fellow wedding professional and the team at Flair of Country are in line, or better than the professionalism and food quality of a five-star resort.
Alex Nepa, 5 years ago
Quick responder
Luongo Barbecue 
Rating: 4.9 (39 reviews)
  • Starts at $3,500
  • Serves Lilly, PA

Restaurant now open in Middletown offering tastings! Preparing and serving slow smoked, expertly prepared Texas barbecue and rustic Italian inspired dishes is the greatest joy in my life. There are no short cuts in barbecue and that's what I love about it. We started Luongo Barbecue to glorify the Lord and grow the Kingdom of God. We use the business as a means to feed and serve our community. After spending 30 years in Texas we have relocated to central Pennsylvania to begin working with family on the next chapter of Luongo Barbecue. Winners of "Best in Show" and "Best Entrée" at Taste of Western Lancaster County 2025 for our brisket.

Awarded Best of Zola
From our first conversation with Luongo Barbecue, we knew we had found the right caterer. They responded to every question quickly and answered our calls with genuine excitement about our wedding day. On the big day, the team showed up ready to work and treated our guests like family. Our friends and family couldn't stop raving about the food—people told us it was the best barbecue they'd ever had at a wedding. The quality and flavor of everything they prepared was outstanding, and we'd absolutely hire them again for any future event. If you're looking for caterers who care about making your day special, Luongo Barbecue is the answer.
Katie J., 3 months ago
Quick responder
Maison D Events and Hospitality 
Rating: 5.0 (9 reviews)
  • Serves Lilly, PA

With over 15 years of experience Maison D is the premier catering and hospitality company you would ever need. We do everything from catering to event planning and everything in-between. We take your event to the next level and elevate it in every way possible

Maison D Events & Hospitality exceeded every expectation we had! From the very beginning, their team was professional, responsive, organized, and truly passionate about making our event unforgettable. The food was absolutely incredible — beautifully presented, full of flavor, and our guests are still talking about it days later. What really stood out was the attention to detail and the level of care they put into every part of the experience. They made everything feel seamless and stress-free, allowing us to actually enjoy our special day. The staff was friendly, attentive, and went above and beyond to ensure every guest felt taken care of. Whether you’re planning a wedding, corporate event, private dinner, or celebration, I cannot recommend Maison D Events & Hospitality enough. Their creativity, professionalism, and hospitality are unmatched. We will definitely be using them again for future events!
Michelle and A., 3 months ago
Quick responder
Marinades Grill Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (8 reviews)
  • Starts at $4,000
  • Serves Lilly, PA
  • Offer

Firstly, congratulations 🥂 💍 We at Marinades Grill Catering specialize in scratch made comfort foods, sourcing fresh, quality ingredients as locally as possible. With a diverse selection of homestyle options as well as more sophisticated choices, you’re free to create a menu that’s uniquely and deliciously your own. From trays of crowd pleasing appetizers all the way to decadent desserts, the meal will be sure to delight every guest. Since the main entrees are prepared on site, you can be sure that your meal will be served hot, fresh, and right on time. We encourage plenty of options and customization for you and your guests at every event.

Marinades Grill Catering made planning our wedding so easy from start to finish. Their team stayed in touch throughout the process, answered our questions right away, and handled all the details without us having to worry. The food was delicious and looked beautiful on every plate, plus the pricing was fair and transparent. Our guests couldn't stop talking about the quality of the meals, and honestly, we felt like we got so much value for what we paid. They took care of everything so smoothly that we didn't have to stress about a single thing on our wedding day. We'll definitely use Marinades Grill Catering for any event we host in the future.
Krystle, 3 months ago
Quick responder
Vow & Vine LLC 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Starts at $3,500
  • Serves Lilly, PA
  • Offer

Vow & Vine LLC was created from a lifelong passion for cooking, designing, and bringing ideas to life by hand. What began as a love for creating-whether in the kitchen or through carefully curated details-grew into something much greater: a business built on intention, creativity, and connection. My aesthetic and vision were shaped early on through a deep connection to alternative music and the culture surrounding it. That influence is woven into Vow & Vine's signature style-dark, romantic, and visually striking. It allows us to create experiences that feel unique and personal, especially for those who don't resonate with traditional events.

Kelsey and her team did an incredible job catering for the bridal shower that I was hosting! She took the time to construct a menu with me that fit the Sunday dinner vibe with an elegant “something blue before I do” theme. The food was absolutely delicious, the presentation was gorgeous. The service incredible. She kept everything full and ready for second helpings. The little details that she added made it all the better. The effort she put in to the theme was so impressive. Small blue bows on the champagne flutes, cups that match the theme. I could feel the love she has for her job and the dedication she has to please her customers. I will definitely be using Vow and Vine in the future!
Tama Z., a month ago
Quick responder
Common Plea Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Serves Lilly, PA

Your dedicated planner stays with you from the first conversation through the final toast. No handoffs, no dropped details. Our menu covers everything from elegant plated dinners to stations and buffets, with full bar service and tastings included. Dietary restrictions handled without making anyone feel like an afterthought. During cocktail hour, hors d'oeuvres and a cocktail are waiting after photos. We time your meal so it is never cold and send you home with cookies from your Pittsburgh cookie table.

The plated filet at our wedding was hands down the best I have ever had. Cooked perfectly, every single plate. Our guests are still talking about it months later. Common Plea truly delivered a fine dining experience on one of the most important nights of our lives.
Nick, 2 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Black Radish Kitchen 
Rating: 5.0 (7 reviews)
  • Starts at $1
  • Serves Lilly, PA for additional fees

Black Radish Kitchen is a women owned and operated boutique catering company. We are vegetable forward, queer-eyed, and locally focused. We cater events of all sizes and shapes; we customize to meet your vision and palate, working cohesively with all your vendors to ensure the most seamless, lovely, and rad celebration possible. Our cuisine is diverse and can accommodate nearly any type of dietary preference or restriction.

Awarded Best of Zola
After a caterer debacle forced me to cancel my caterer only a few weeks before my wedding, Black Radish jumped in and was absolutely fantastic. Given they only had a few weeks to prepare and we were changing details up to the day before the wedding, I expected a few mishaps with the catering the day of. There were none. The food was excellent and everyone was raving about the food even after the wedding. I also cannot say enough good things about the staff. They were friendly, professional, and far exceeded my expectations. Everything went seamlessly and I cannot recommend them enough.
Claire T., 3 years ago
TrendlineTrending
The Smoking Bar 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Starts at $500
  • Serves Lilly, PA for additional fees

At The Smoking Bar, we pride ourselves on crafting unique and flavorful cocktails and food that elevate your drinking experience. Our journey began with a passion for mixology and cooking, and we continue to innovate and inspire with every drink and dish we serve.

The staff is amazing! Attention to detail is a something that stood out the most of all. The food was not only tasty but visually appealing as well. Kudos to the owner Briyonna, servers, and bar staff. We had an amazing time at my niece's wedding. I can't wait to hire them for our next event.
Chelsea G., 10 months ago
Basilico Boards Charcuterie & Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (5 reviews)
  • Serves Lilly, PA for additional fees

My name is Jozay and I'm the owner of Basilico Boards Charcuterie & Catering. I'm a wife, mama & multi-business owner; Pennsylvania born and raised! Basilico Boards was created out of my love for food, my years of experience in the industry, including owning a pizzeria alongside my husband for five years, and wanting to connect & serve people throughout Central Pennsylvania.

Awarded Best of Zola
I had Basilico Boards for my vow renewal and Jozay went above and beyond. She has a great eye for detail in everything she does. She is extremely responsive to messages and great ideas for anything you are questioning. I will recommend this business to everyone I know and I will continue to use them in the future other parties.
Stefanie D., 5 years ago

About wedding caterers in Lilly, PA

What other Lilly vendors will I need?

What other caterers are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?