What other Lilly vendors will I need?

Lilly Event Extras Lilly Officiants Lilly Bar Services & Beverages Lilly Cakes & Desserts Lilly Beauty Professionals Lilly Bands & DJs Lilly Wedding Planners Lilly Florists Lilly Videographers Lilly Photographers Lilly Venues

What other caterers are nearby?

Italian Frederick, MD caterers Italian Lancaster, PA caterers Italian Harrisburg, PA caterers Italian York, PA caterers

The Best 8 Italian Wedding Catering in Lilly, PA

8 Wedding Caterers in Lilly, PA

Italian

Flair of Country Catering & Event Planning

5.0

Starts at $2,000
Serves Lilly, PA

Flair of Country is Waking Up Your Taste Buds! We aren’t your “typical” caterers. Flair of Country was established with the intentions of changing the culinary palette of our clients. Our menus offer a variety of different options; whether a formal dinner for your wedding or a cookout for a family reunion in your backyard – we have the menu for you. Our concept revolves around always providing fresh food for our clients. Our mobile kitchens allow us to cook all of our catered meals in a kitchen and serve every meal straight out of the oven regardless of where your event takes us. This is where Flair of Country stands out above the rest.

“Flair of Country catered our wedding in 2015. While we went simple with BBQ, mac & cheese, and other fan favorites from their menu, we had more compliments and happy guests because of the food than anything else. The hardest decision you will have to make is which items to cut because they're all SO GOOD! From a buffet style to plated dinners, we've been lucky to encounter FOC at many of our friends' weddings and other events in the last 7 years also. Since our wedding, we've utilized FOC for their event space and catering for our other important events, i.e. baby shower, first birthdays, holiday meals, etc. The professionalism and commitment to client satisfaction are of utmost importance and it fully shows in every aspect of their operation. You will truly be missing out if you go with any other caterer!”

Alicia R., 4 years ago

Quick responder

Luongo Barbecue

5.0

Starts at $1,800
Serves Lilly, PA

Preparing and serving slow smoked, expertly prepared Texas barbecue and rustic Italian inspired dishes is the greatest joy in my life. There are no short cuts in barbecue and that's what I love about it. We started Luongo Barbecue to glorify the Lord and grow the Kingdom of God. We use the business as a means to feed and serve our community. After spending 30 years in Texas we have relocated to central Pennsylvania to begin working with family on the next chapter of Luongo Barbecue. Winners of "Best in Show" and "Best Entrée" at Taste of Western Lancaster County 2025 for our brisket, pulled pork and peach cobbler!

“Luongo Barbecue was an absolute dream to work with for our wedding. From the very first interaction, their communication was professional and timely. The quality of their work and overall value was simply fantastic - they went above and beyond to ensure our special day was perfect. The service was excellent; they set up on time, their clean-up was seamless, and their interaction with the guests respectful and uplifting. We absolutely cannot recommend Luongo Barbecue enough. The food was over the top delicious, their staff was incredibly polite and engaging, and they even went out of their way to help our guests get to-go containers. They were the perfect catering partner for our wedding. No need to even think twice about having them cater your special event!”

Tracy, 4 months ago

Quick responder

Marinades Grill

5.0

Starts at $3,500
Serves Lilly, PA

Hello! Marinades travels and we cook on-site with a food truck and grills. Fresh right to the table! Every event we do it custom to fit your menu and budget. We set up, serve and stay to clean up. We have bartenders as well and a mobile beverage cart if you wish for cocktails, mocktails or coffee bar. Only the freshest ingredients are used and we have many references to we provide what we promise. We also specialize in special eating requests such as Gluten free, Vegan, etc.

“Marinades Grill provided us with excellent, clear communication throughout the entire process of planning our wedding. Their team, especially Julie, demonstrated the highest quality of work and a great work ethic. Everything they delivered was even better than promised - the quantity and quality of the food was superb. Julie was incredibly understanding of our needs and requests, and she went above and beyond to achieve greatness. Her delivery was on time and the services provided were exceptional. I will absolutely use Marinades Grill for any future events, and I highly recommend them for any event.”

Jennifer S., 3 months ago

Trending

Vow & Vine LLC

Starts at $420
Serves Lilly, PA

Vow & Vine LLC was created from a lifelong passion for cooking, designing, and bringing ideas to life by hand. What began as a love for creating-whether in the kitchen or through carefully curated details-grew into something much greater: a business built on intention, creativity, and connection. My aesthetic and vision were shaped early on through a deep connection to alternative music and the culture surrounding it. That influence is woven into Vow & Vine's signature style-dark, romantic, and visually striking. It allows us to create experiences that feel unique and personal, especially for those who don't resonate with traditional events.

Quick responder

BISSOU

4.3

Starts at $4,500
Serves Lilly, PA for additional fees

Our innovative presentation will redefine your perception of indulgence, combining sumptuous amenities and top tier dining options to create an impeccable experience tailored to your personal taste. Our culinary acumen with proficiency in contemporary cooking and commitment to sourcing the highest quality ingredient. With the service ranging from meal prep for individual and daily need, personal chef services for your intimate dinner, to gastronomic delight up to silver spoon class matrimonial soirees. Our team is well verse in every aspect of the event and will undoubtedly delivery top notch services.

“We had our wedding ceremony during Covid and we didn’t want to do the courthouse so we had a small ceremony at home with brunch catered by Bissou it was a great experience and my guest were happy with all the food choices especially with the omelette bar I would definitely book again.”

Suprena, 2 years ago

Trending

Basilico Boards Charcuterie & Catering

5.0

Serves Lilly, PA for additional fees

My name is Jozay and I'm the owner of Basilico Boards Charcuterie & Catering. I'm a wife, mama & multi-business owner; Pennsylvania born and raised! Basilico Boards was created out of my love for food, my years of experience in the industry, including owning a pizzeria alongside my husband for five years, and wanting to connect & serve people throughout Central Pennsylvania.

“Basicilo Boards provided us with a gorgeous charcuterie spread for our wedding reception- complete with plates shaped like our initials! It was an adorable touch. I truly only saw pictures of the spread (and I was the bride!) By the time cocktail hour was over, the guests had gobbled up the huge table of goodies. I will recommend Basicilo Boards forever!”

Mary & Z., 4 years ago

Quick responder

The Smoking Bar

5.0

Starts at $500
Serves Lilly, PA for additional fees

At The Smoking Bar, we pride ourselves on crafting unique and flavorful cocktails and food that elevate your drinking experience. Our journey began with a passion for mixology and cooking, and we continue to innovate and inspire with every drink and dish we serve.

“The Smoking Bar was an amazing wedding caterer for our special day. From the start, they made the process of planning our menu easy and enjoyable. They were very helpful in guiding us through all the decisions and offered a delicious tasting so we could sample the quality of their food. On the day of the wedding, they arrived on time and their communication was outstanding throughout the entire process. The staff was incredibly professional, and we had no issues whatsoever with this vendor. The food they served was absolutely delicious, using the freshest and highest quality ingredients. It tasted far better than any other catering we had tried. We are so grateful to The Smoking Bar for helping make our wedding day perfect.”

Nicole T., 6 months ago

Firestone’s Tavern and Catering

Starts at $35
Serves Lilly, PA

With more than 20 years experience in the food service industry, Firestone's Culinary Tavern is excited to expand our presence into off site catering. Firestone’s is known for offering remarkable food, and impeccable service. We pride ourselves on creating menus that implement regional, American, and international culinary traditions, with ingredients that are fresh, seasonal, and locally produced, ensuring the highest quality food we can offer. Not only do we provide delicious food, but we offer full service catering, and event services to meet your events specific needs.