Affordable Wedding Caterers in Cincinnatus, NY

Affordable Wedding Caterers in Cincinnatus, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


13 Wedding Caterers in Cincinnatus, NY

Up to $2,000
Available on July 18, 2026
Ba-Li Cravings Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $37 per person
  • Serves Cincinnatus, NY

Tal Cohen started her catering business, Ba-Li Cravings in 2014. But her love and passion for baking started when she was as young as 5. Tal would find herself exploring in the kitchen and baking on her own as a young child, and later volunteered to make all of the food and desserts for family gatherings. Tal always cooked and baked and found inspiration in the kitchen. She fell in love with the art of baking, cooking and crafting a different meal experience altogether. in 2015 Tal build her own com mercial kitchen, painted blue, and ever since that is where she can be found.

Tal is an angel and we adored working with her. She was so quick to answer any questions we had, even if that meant picking up the phone when we decided to call on a random Tuesday! Working with her was a breeze, but the food. Her freaking food!!! We are still getting comments about how delicious everything was, over a month later. Tal made sure to take care of my partner and I during the reception so we were able to eat, and we’ve heard so many couples say they missed their own food on their wedding day! She even packaged up to-to containers of everything for us to enjoy the next day. Tal helped us book our rentals too, so we had one less vendor to coordinate. I’m already trying to come up with ways to work with her again in the future. Thank you again, Tal!!
Kelly J., 2 years ago
Quick responder
Charlottes hospitality llc 
  • Starts at $1,800
  • Serves Cincinnatus, NY

We are a veteran/family owned catering bussiness! Catering services for your special day, and many other events! We are an off site catering company, as long as your venue allows you to bring your own caterer we will be there! We offer many different styles from plated meals buffet, family style, and the most unique is our Brazilian style! We accommodate any food allergy or restriction

TrendlineTrending
Glad Mouf 

5.0

  • Starts at $1,875
  • Serves Cincinnatus, NY

Glad Mouf BBQ – Unforgettable Flavor for Your Special Day At Glad Mouf BBQ, we believe every wedding deserves unforgettable food that brings people together. We specialize in craft barbecue with a gourmet twist, featuring the world’s most tender smoked oxtails, melt-in-your-mouth brisket, juicy smoked chicken, brisket tacos —all paired with our legendary sauces. We offer catering with a choice of station-style service with pre-portioned servings or a buffet. Enjoy a special rate of $50 per person for 100+ guests or $75 per person with a 50-guest minimum. Our customizable menu allows you to create the perfect meal for your wedding vision.

Our experience with Glad Mouf catering was fantastic from start to finish. Amir, the owner, had a fun and detailed communication style that made the planning process easy and enjoyable. His team was incredibly professional, delivering flavorful cuisine that wowed our guests. The menu options were unique and creative, and the pricing was very affordable, providing great value. Most importantly, they were punctual and easy to work with on the day of our wedding, ensuring everything ran smoothly so we could focus on celebrating our special day. We highly recommend Glad Mouf for any couple looking for a catering company that combines quality, creativity, and excellent customer service.
Arrielle, 4 months ago
Mise en Graze 

5.0

  • Serves Cincinnatus, NY

Mise en Graze is a luxury grazing company specializing in artfully curated boards and show-stopping grazing tables that elevate every celebration. With a focus on seasonal ingredients, elegant presentation, and personalized service, we bring The Art of Elevated Grazing to weddings, showers, engagement parties, and more. Founded by Lisa Valverde Mise en Graze was created to turn everyday entertaining into unforgettable experiences. From intimate gatherings to large-scale receptions, each table is a custom culinary centerpiece—designed to wow your guests and reflect your unique style.

Mise en Graze was an absolute dream to work with for our event needs. From the very first interaction, Lisa and her team showcased a visionary and collaborative communication style, truly partnering with us to create the most spectacular charcuterie display we've ever seen. Their attention to detail and artistry resulted in a culinary work of art that added so much magic to our evening. Lisa was able to take our initial brief and elevate it to a level we couldn't have imagined, delivering a final product that exceeded our wildest expectations. The Mise en Graze team were an absolute delight throughout the entire process, and we are so grateful for the role they played in making our event truly unforgettable.
Lavinia, a month ago
Green Cart Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $52
  • Serves Cincinnatus, NY

Green Cart Catering was founded on the desire to do two things: One, to provide healthy & ethical cuisine. And two, to provide event hosts, committed to healthy & ethical eating, the ability to stay true to their values while still providing their guests an outstanding culinary experience! Our 100% plant- based menus will impress everyone and leave no one wanting! Behind our great food is over 30 years’ experience in hospitality services. So, Green Cart Catering can provide you with not only great food, but complete event services, as well!

As a vendor of rental equipment, we've watched Green Cart Catering grow from the early days of the pandemic and mature into a well-managed off-premise caterer. From our vantage point we know the company is well-managed, organized, and committed to delivering great service.
David VanDenburgh, 6 months ago
Quick responder
Ginger Man Catering And Private Chef Service 
  • Starts at $1,700
  • Serves Cincinnatus, NY

Ginger Man Catering is a Glatt Kosher catering company in NYC formed by Chef Oren to offer custom Kosher catering and personalized service to our clients, while based in NYC, Chef Oren and his exemplary team will travel throughout New York City, Long Island, Hamptons, New Jersey and Connecticut area to create your specialized event in your home or at the venue of your choice. Ginger Man Kosher Catering NYC will work directly with you to ensure every detail of your events fulfills your expectations and results in a successful and pleasurable event.

Quick responder
Stuf'd 

5.0

  • Starts at $65
  • Serves Cincinnatus, NY for additional fees

As a kid, Rebecca could be found in the kitchen cooking with either her Mom or Grandma. Traveling to Albany was always a treat, as her favorite dish to eat was Nan's French toast. While studying at NYU, Rebecca came up with the concept of STUF'D to fulfill the need for a savory French toast, as it was yet to be done. She decided to start the business as a food truck in 2016, as a way to keep her brand more mobile. Since then, we have evolved into a full-service catering company, offering a variety of sandwiches, sliders, and cocktail bites, and serving events that range from weddings and birthday parties to large-scale events!

There are so many great things to say about Rebecca and the entire crew at Stuf’d. Stuf’d catered our wedding in Highland, NY, and they were absolutely amazing. First and foremost, the food was delicious—our guests couldn’t stop raving about it and loved the wide variety of sliders and appetizers. The entire team at our wedding was incredibly friendly, helpful, and even joined us on the dance floor — such a blast! From day one, Rebecca was the most communicative, thorough, and responsive vendor I worked with. As a bride with a full plate, that level of support was beyond appreciated. She answered all of my questions, accommodated a few changes to the menu, and was truly a delight to work with from start to finish. I highly recommend Rebecca and the entire crew at Stuf’d for any of your catering needs. Many, many thanks!
Jaclyn, 2 months ago
TrendlineTrending
JOLAS KITCHEN (AUTHENTIC AFRICAN FOOD) 

5.0

  • Starts at $1,250
  • Serves Cincinnatus, NY for additional fees

We pamper your tastebuds with authentic African Foods. To us, it’s more than just food, it’s a brand. It’s THE JOLAS KITCHEN BRAND. We have created a brand, with some amazing loyalty. Our aim is to take you back to the streets of Lagos with the Jolasjollof, and if you have never been to Lagos you can enjoy what the Nigerian party Jollof tastes like. It’s cooked with parboiled rice in a mixture of carefully selected peppers to give you that authentic taste of Nigerian Jollof. Looking forward to bringing our flavors to your next event!

Jolas Kitchen catered at our wedding on December 27th. I cannot say enough good things about Chef Jola, she was so communicative, and made excellent recommendations and suggestions, which was so helpful to me as a first time bride who had never planned such a large event before. We were absolutely blown away by the presentation, and the care and attentiveness of chef Jola and her team. I have never worked with such thoughtful and kind caterers, they really thought of everything and made the night such a wonderful and stress free experience for us. The food was absolutely amazing and our guests could not stop talking about how much they loved everything, from the Beef Suya (my personal favorite) to the Cole Slaw, to the Jollof and Meat Pies, and the Puff Puff. A lot of brides don’t eat much on their wedding day, but I cleaned my whole plate and even took some home with me. Highly recommend!
Kylie K., 6 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Tuck-ins 

5.0

  • Starts at $250
  • Serves Cincinnatus, NY for additional fees

Tuck-ins are a roastable, Inside-Out S’more on a stick, each containing a crunchy handmade graham cracker, covered in decadent chocolate, all inside a fluffy marshmallow! Tuck-ins® are available in Classic, Cookies & Cream, and Peanut Butter! Tuck-ins can be given out as favors with guests roasting them at home over a gas or electric stove. You can even have your own roasting station at your event with TerraFlame Fire Bowls available through Tuck-ins!

Awarded Best of Zola
We ordered Tuck Ins to put in our wedding guest gift bags at the hotel. Tuck Ins was easy to work with, delivered in a timely manner, and all of our guests loved having something delicious and made by a local Philly company. If we were to get married again, I think we would include Tuck Ins at the dessert table and let the guests roast them at the reception. Would highly recommend!
Caroline, 4 years ago
Farmer x Baker 

5.0

  • Starts at $25
  • Serves Cincinnatus, NY for additional fees

Farmer x Baker is a woman-owned, organic, seasonal, people-focused food business. We are a collective of passionate chefs and creative minds. Our mission is to connect people with nature through food.

Awarded Best of Zola
Jen from Farmer x Baker went above and beyond to make my wedding day a success! I had never eaten her food before so I was taking a leap of faith in booking her, but it was one of the best decisions during the planning process. Jen helped to save the day when the reception space had to be moved indoors, and she also kept the space clean and brought me and my husband our plates of food personally. Everyone raved about the food at our wedding, and having Jen there to help was an added bonus of booking Farmer x Baker. I can’t thank her enough for her hand in making our wedding amazing!
Rachel H., 2 years ago

Location flexible? Discover caterers near Cincinnatus, NY

About wedding caterers in Cincinnatus, NY

What types of caterers are in Cincinnatus, NY?

What other Cincinnatus vendors will I need?

What other caterers are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?