The Basement Bakery
Price per serving
Starts at $3 per person.
Packages
Prices start at $350
Cake Tasting Boxes Available
You can sample 6 flavors of cakes from The Basement Bakery! Cake Tasting Boxes are $45 and can be picked up on the southside of Indy Near Greenwood Park Mall. Message me for more details!
About The Basement Bakery
The Basement Bakery
I am a home baker who specialized in decorated sugar cookies, cakes, and small desserts. I would love to help make your special day magical! I work a full time job and bake on the side with a dream of one day being able to open my own bakery!
What sets me apart from other bakers is my specialized decorated sugar cookies avaible in multiple flavors, colors and designs perfect to make your special day stand out! I have around 15 different flavors of cake perfect to be able to customize your wedding cake however you want it! I love to work with couples within their budgets to make their days special but within what is comfortable for them.
Services
Dessert types
- Cakes
- Candy and confections
- Cookies and macarons
- Cupcakes
- International desserts
- Mini desserts
- Pastries
- Pies
- Puddings and custards
- Novelties and other
Decor options
- Cake toppers
- Custom text
- Fruit topping
- Live flowers
Available customizations
- Cake filling
- Cake flavors
- Cake frosting
Services offered
- Bars & Buffets
- Consultations
- Delivery
- Dessert installations
- Service staff
- Setup
- Tastings
Dietary accommodations
- Sugar-free
- Vegan
The Basement Bakery packages
100 Guest Wedding
Price$350
Small 6" Standard Cut Cake $50 Two Kitchen Cakes- $300 - 108 servings - 2 Flavors
- 6" Cut Cake for couple
- Two Kitchen Cakes 54 servings each
Reviews
Write a review5.0 out of 5
10 reviews
- KG
Kaitlyn G.
Amazing Cake
Rachel was incredible to work with throughout the whole process. She made everything so easy for us and we couldn't be happier with how our wedding cake turned out! We went with her strawberry poptart and s'mores flavors and both were a huge hit. I sent her photos of my wedding bouquet and she truly brought it to life on the cake. I will absolutely look for any opportunity to purchase more cakes from her in the future!!
Rachel Overton•Jul 15, 2026Thank you for so much for choosing me to help make you day even more special! I look forward to working together again! Congrats!
- OH
Olivia H.
Wedding
Basement bakery was absolutely wonderful to work with. From numerous samples to endless emails, Rachel ensured she completed our vision for our wedding day. The cake and cupcakes were beautiful and so tasty! So grateful for her.
Rachel Overton•Jul 7, 2026I am so glad I could be apart of your special day! Congrats on your marriage and I wish you all the best!
- CC
Colette C.
Delicious, beautiful cupcakes and quality service
Rachel made us feel heard and supported throughout the entire planning process. She went above and beyond by working with us to accommodate vegan guests, and decorate the cupcakes exactly how we wanted. The quality of work was amazing, and the cupcakes were absolutely delicious. Honestly the best option by far compared to other bakeries we considered. She handled every request with such kindness and professionalism. We couldn't have asked for better desserts to celebrate with our loved ones, and the flavor options were to die for. Highly recommend The Basement Bakery to anyone looking for a bakery that won’t charge you an arm and a leg but will still give you gourmet desserts!!
Rachel Overton•Jun 8, 2026Thank you so muc for such kind words! Thank you for allowing me to be apart of your special day! Congrats again!
- KB
Kennedy B.
Amazing Job!
Basement Bakery did an amazing job! We had a beautifully decorated cutting cake that was so amazing. We had two kitchen cakes for the rest of the guests and every bite was so delish!! Thank you!!
Rachel Overton•Jun 9, 2026Thank you so much! I am so glad you liked your flavors! Congrats!
- AL
Angela L.
Service like Family
Rachel, the owner of the Basement Bakery was responsive and quick to reply to any and all of my questions or concerns. I initially bought cookies for my daughter's bridal shower, and they were so soft and delicious! I then reached out for a wedding cake. The cake she made and delivered to my daughter's wedding was delicious and quite stunning! Both very flavorful and moist. I would definitely use the Basement Bakery for all of my party needs, or just a batch of treats to have for myself!!
Explore other vendors serving Indianapolis, IN
- Beauty & The Braid
- Dogwood Lane Photography
- Aloha Erica Music - Acoustic Wedding Singer
- Sound Sensations Indy
- Styled & Snapped
- Beauty By Brigitte, LLC
- Team Wedding Day
- Higher Love Entertainment
- Madison Wren Photography
- Noah Comber Photography
- CC Photography
- The Ivy League Wedding Studio Invitations
Complete your dream team
- Indianapolis Venues
- Indianapolis Photographers
- Indianapolis Beauty Professionals
- Indianapolis Bands & DJs
- Indianapolis Florists
- Indianapolis Caterers
- Indianapolis Planners
- Indianapolis Videographers
- Indianapolis Bar Services & Beverages
- Indianapolis Officiants
- Indianapolis Event Extras
Other cakes & desserts in Indianapolis
- Tay’s Sweet Shop
- The Cupcake Cottage Bakery
- Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream + 1832 Brew Espresso Bar
- The Euphoria Sweets Lounge, LLC
- Jadin's Bakeshop
- Sweet Escape Cake Company