Tay’s Sweet Shop

Packages

About Tay’s Sweet Shop

Tay’s Sweet Shop

Baker/ Owner

Bringing my passion to life, I specialize in made-from-scratch desserts. I’m a home-based Vendor in Noblesville, IN where small businesses are the heart of our community! I opened in 2017 as part time and took it on full time during the pandemic, after having my daughter.

I strive to make each cake unique to each couple. I only take a very limited number of Wedding cakes per weekend to be able to focus on each order. Everything is made from scratch, including any edible decor! Not only do I deliver a high-quality product, but deliver a memorable experience to match any wedding style or theme!

Best of Zola 2024

Services

Dessert types

  • Cakes
  • Cookies and macarons
  • Cupcakes
  • Donuts
  • Mini desserts
  • Pastries
  • Pies
  • Puddings and custards

Decor options

  • Cake toppers
  • Custom text
  • Fruit topping
  • Live flowers

Available customizations

  • Cake filling
  • Cake flavors
  • Cake frosting

Services offered

  • Bars & Buffets
  • Delivery
  • Dessert installations
  • Setup
  • Tastings

Dietary accommodations

  • Dairy-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Kosher
  • Nut-free
  • Sugar-free
  • Vegan
  • Vegetarian

Tay’s Sweet Shop packages

Intimate Package: up to 40 Guests

Price$250

Description

This package is recommends for small, intimate weddings with 40 or less guests. *Delivery not included in price

What’s included
  • Small Cake for Cutting
  • 4 Dozen Cupcakes

Package 1: Up to 70 Guests

Price$450

Description

This package is for weddings with 75 guests or less. *Delivery/Setup not included in price

What’s included
  • Two Tier Cake
  • 4 Dozen Cupcakes
  • 4 Dozen Cake Pops

Package 2: Up to 100 Guests

Price$680

Description

For weddings with a guest count up to 100 **Delivery/Setup not included in price.

What’s included
  • Two Tier Cake
  • 5 Dozen Cupcakes
  • 5 Dozen Cake Pops
  • 2 Dozen Mini Cheesecakes

Package 3: Up to 150 Guests

Price$1,050

Description

For weddings with up to 150 guests *Delivery/Setup not included in price.

What’s included
  • Three Tier Cake
  • 7 Dozen Cupcakes
  • 5 Dozen Cake Pops
  • 4 Dozen Brownie Bites

Reviews

Write a review
Rating: 4.5

4.5 out of 5

35 reviews

  • ES

    Emmaleigh S.

    Rating: 5
    •Jun 30, 2026

    Yummy cake !

    We were thrilled with Tay's Sweet Shop from start to finish. Their communication was fast and kind throughout the entire planning process, which made everything feel smooth and stress-free. When we had a delivery mix-up, Tay quickly worked through the confusion and got everything sorted without any drama. On the day of our wedding, there was another event happening in the main building that we hadn't realized, but she adapted on the fly and made sure our desserts arrived exactly where they needed to be. The quality of their work was absolutely delightful, and our guests couldn't stop raving about the cakes and treats. We'd recommend Tay's Sweet Shop to any couple looking for someone who truly cares about making their day special.

  • MM

    Mya M.

    Rating: 5
    •Jun 29, 2026

    Wedding Couple

    Tay’s Sweet Shop was a perfect addition to our magical day. We decided to go with one of her cake and dessert packages. It included a three tiered cake, cookies, cupcakes, and cake pops! Our cake was perfect! The desserts were a huge hit. So many guest complimented the different flavors as well as the taste. She is so easy and sweet to work with. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND!

  • S

    Savannah

    Rating: 5
    •Jun 27, 2026

    6/20 Wedding Cake

    We absolutely loved our wedding cake! We chose a two-tier cake with two different flavors, and both were incredible. The cake was so moist, delicious, and received so many compliments from our guests. From the tasting to pickup, the entire process was simple and stress-free. Communication was always quick and easy, and the cake turned out exactly how I had envisioned it. It was not only beautiful but tasted just as amazing as it looked. We couldn't have been happier with our experience and would highly recommend them to any couple looking for a wedding cake!

  • K

    Kristen

    Rating: 5
    •May 18, 2026

    10/10 Experience

    Taylor was responsive and made sure every detail matched our vision perfectly, taking the time to understand exactly what we wanted for our big day. When our cake arrived on the wedding day, it turned out fantastic. The flavors were delicious and it looked absolutely stunning. If you're looking for a dessert vendor, we would 100% recommend Tay's Sweet Shop without hesitation.

  • DD

    Danielle D.

    Rating: 5
    •Apr 29, 2026

    So good!!

    Super great cake!! We got a lemon cake with raspberry filling and it was so good! Moist and tasty, good frosting, and we got a design on the cake that Taylor did such a great job with. Communication was fast, and she was always super nice. With our tasting take home samples, we got quite a few different cake, filling, and frosting flavors to mix and match as we wanted, which was nice. Overall would definitely recommend!

    Taylor Engle•Apr 29, 2026

    Thank you! I’m so glad you enjoyed the cakes! I was honored to be apart of your big day! Congratulations again 🫶🏼

Preferred vendors of Tay’s Sweet Shop

Quick responder
Venue
Mill Top Banquet & Conference Center
Rating: 5.0 (5 reviews)
Noblesville, IN
Venue
Laurel Hall
Venue
White Willow Farms
Arcadia, IN
Keto, Sugar free, Gluten Free, Vegan, Vegetarian, Peanut/Tree Nut Free, Dye Allergen
With any deposits, tasting is complimentary. Tasting prior to booking is $50 for pickup or $62 for shipped. This price does not come off of the final booking.
Delivery fee is determined on delivery location. Setup fee is based on the amount of items in your order, which will help determine the amount of time needed for setup.
Just let us know how many servings you’ll need and we will give you the most accurate cake size!
All cake designs are custom to fit the needs of the couple on their special day.
If you prefer an alternative to cake, don't hesitate to ask! I am more than willing to be accommodating to all needs and requests.
Wedding Cancellation : —If you are cancelling your order with 60+ days before the due date, the NON-REFUNDABLE RETAINER (50% of total order) will not be refunded. You will receive refund of the balance remaining after the retainer. — If you are cancelling your order with 40-60 days before the due date, the NON-REFUNDABLE RETAINER (50% of total order) will not be refunded. You will receive a 50% refund of the balance remaining after the retainer. — If you are cancelling your wedding date within 35 days of the due date, the NON-REFUNDABLE RETAINER will not be refunded. You will receive a 25% refund on the balance remaining after the retainer.
I send contracts to all couples who book the date!

Explore other vendors serving Noblesville, IN

Complete your dream team

Other cakes & desserts in Noblesville

Other wedding services nearby