Tay’s Sweet Shop

About Tay’s Sweet Shop

Tay’s Sweet Shop

Baker/ Owner

Bringing my passion to life, I specialize in made-from-scratch desserts. I’m a home-based Vendor in Noblesville, IN where small businesses are the heart of our community! I opened in 2017 as part time and took it on full time during the pandemic, after having my daughter.

I strive to make each cake unique to each couple. I only take a very limited number of Wedding cakes per weekend focus on each order. Everything is made from scratch, including any edible decor! Not only do I deliver a high-quality product, but deliver a memorable experience to match any wedding style or theme!

Best of Zola 2024


Dessert types

  • Cakes
  • Candy and confections
  • Cookies and macarons
  • Cupcakes
  • Donuts
  • Mini desserts
  • Pastries
  • Pies
  • Puddings and custards

Decor options

  • Cake toppers
  • Custom text
  • Fruit topping
  • Live flowers
  • Sugar flowers

Available customizations

  • Cake filling
  • Cake flavors
  • Cake frosting

Services offered

  • Bars & Buffets
  • Consultations
  • Delivery
  • Dessert installations
  • Setup
  • Tastings

Dietary accommodations

  • Dairy-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Kosher
  • Nut-free
  • Sugar-free
  • Vegan
  • Vegetarian


Write a review

4.6 (11 reviews)

  • Does not Follow through

    Verified review
    Avri P2 months ago

    If I could give zero stars I would. Taylor was super responsive at first but after sending her money it became difficult to get a response from her. Taylor told me to pay her 50 to order a tasting box and then I could place a wedding cake order after deciding on flavors. When I sent the money for the tasting box to her she informed me she would send the tasting box the same week. However, she never sent it. It has been nearly two months and she still has not sent the tasting box. I’ve inquired with her about it multiple times and each time she says she is sending the tasting box out the next day, but she never does. I recently asked her for a refund. She said she would send me a refund but she has not sent that either. I understand people have busy lives, I just wish I could have gotten more realistic timelines from Taylor instead of false promises. I would have totally understood if she was honest about when she was actually available to create and send the tasting box instead of telling me she would send it then never following through. I would not recommend.

  • Amazing service

    Verified review
    Krista 4 months ago

    Taylor provides exceptional service and products. I have used her for my personal wedding cake/cupcakes and my brother/SIL couples shower and each time she exceeded expectations. For my wedding cake specifically she jumped in during the unprecedented time that COVID was and did so with such professionalism and grace that made the cake ordering process one less thing to worry about during that time. The cakes and cupcakes are absolutely delicious as well! Highly recommend!

  • Delicious cake, Wonderful baker!!

    Verified review
    Marrissa4 months ago

    Taylor was such a joy to hire for our wedding cake! She made samples for us as we couldn’t do an in person cake tasting, was easy to communicate with and so personable! She made my cake exactly how I imagined it and it was delicious! When I realized I couldn’t save my cake top for my anniversary, she put it in her calendar for the next year to make us an exact replica for us to enjoy! She is such a delight and makes the best sweets! Highly recommended!!

  • Easily Recommended

    Verified review
    Hannah Meacham4 months ago

    Taylor from Tay's Sweet Shop did an amazing job with our cake! It was easy to communicate with her. The cake she made for us was absolutely beautiful and tasted amazing!