Tay’s Sweet Shop
Packages
About Tay’s Sweet Shop
Tay’s Sweet Shop
Bringing my passion to life, I specialize in made-from-scratch desserts. I’m a home-based Vendor in Noblesville, IN where small businesses are the heart of our community! I opened in 2017 as part time and took it on full time during the pandemic, after having my daughter.
I strive to make each cake unique to each couple. I only take a very limited number of Wedding cakes per weekend to be able to focus on each order. Everything is made from scratch, including any edible decor! Not only do I deliver a high-quality product, but deliver a memorable experience to match any wedding style or theme!
Services
Dessert types
- Cakes
- Cookies and macarons
- Cupcakes
- Donuts
- Mini desserts
- Pastries
- Pies
- Puddings and custards
Decor options
- Cake toppers
- Custom text
- Fruit topping
- Live flowers
Available customizations
- Cake filling
- Cake flavors
- Cake frosting
Services offered
- Bars & Buffets
- Delivery
- Dessert installations
- Setup
- Tastings
Dietary accommodations
- Dairy-free
- Gluten-free
- Kosher
- Nut-free
- Sugar-free
- Vegan
- Vegetarian
Tay’s Sweet Shop packages
Intimate Package: up to 40 Guests
Price$250
This package is recommends for small, intimate weddings with 40 or less guests. *Delivery not included in price
- Small Cake for Cutting
- 4 Dozen Cupcakes
Package 1: Up to 70 Guests
Price$450
This package is for weddings with 75 guests or less. *Delivery/Setup not included in price
- Two Tier Cake
- 4 Dozen Cupcakes
- 4 Dozen Cake Pops
Package 2: Up to 100 Guests
Price$680
For weddings with a guest count up to 100 **Delivery/Setup not included in price.
- Two Tier Cake
- 5 Dozen Cupcakes
- 5 Dozen Cake Pops
- 2 Dozen Mini Cheesecakes
Package 3: Up to 150 Guests
Price$1,050
For weddings with up to 150 guests *Delivery/Setup not included in price.
- Three Tier Cake
- 7 Dozen Cupcakes
- 5 Dozen Cake Pops
- 4 Dozen Mini Brownies
Reviews
Write a review4.5 out of 5
32 reviews
- K
Kristen
10/10 Experience
Taylor was responsive and made sure every detail matched our vision perfectly, taking the time to understand exactly what we wanted for our big day. When our cake arrived on the wedding day, it turned out fantastic. The flavors were delicious and it looked absolutely stunning. If you're looking for a dessert vendor, we would 100% recommend Tay's Sweet Shop without hesitation.
- DD
Danielle D.
So good!!
Super great cake!! We got a lemon cake with raspberry filling and it was so good! Moist and tasty, good frosting, and we got a design on the cake that Taylor did such a great job with. Communication was fast, and she was always super nice. With our tasting take home samples, we got quite a few different cake, filling, and frosting flavors to mix and match as we wanted, which was nice. Overall would definitely recommend!
Taylor Engle•Apr 29, 2026Thank you! I’m so glad you enjoyed the cakes! I was honored to be apart of your big day! Congratulations again 🫶🏼
- M
Mallory
Exceeded Every Expectation
Tay's Sweet Shop was an absolute pleasure to work with for our wedding. From the very beginning, she was friendly, responsive, and incredibly helpful as we navigated designing the perfect cake and desserts for our special day. The final result was not only absolutely beautiful, but also some of the most delicious cake and desserts we've ever had. Tay's Sweet Shop truly went above and beyond to make our wedding desserts truly exceptional, and we would highly recommend them to any couple looking for a talented, professional, and wonderful vendor to work with.
Taylor Engle•Apr 29, 2026I was honored to create your wedding day desserts! Congratulations again! 🫶🏼
- EN
Emily N.
Disappointed
Taylor knew from the beginning that it would be a longer commute and a Saturday brunch wedding. I paid extra for delivery and set up. When I messaged a month out to confirm the wedding, Taylor said she needed to deliver on Friday night and asked if she could use fridge space at our venue. No fridge space was written into our contract but I checked anyways. Nope. She proceeded to call my hotel to try and deliver there. She didn't really explain the plan but the general gist was that I'd have to deliver the cake to my venue the morning of my wedding and set it up. The hotel said no. So she paid a courier to get the cake there. This courier showed up like 10 minutes before the ceremony was supposed to start, told my coordinator that she wasn't part of the bakery and didn't know how to set up and left. The cake itself was still frozen when we tried to eat it and fairly flavorless. It was difficult to cut. It was better that night when it'd be unfrozen. Most of the cake was uneaten. It was not money well spent.
Taylor Engle•Jan 26, 2026Hi Emily! I’m sorry your expectations weren’t met and this put the coordinator in a bind on your big day! This is not how I want my business to be represented or believed to be. I can assure you that all my delivery drivers are under a contract with my business and not outsourced/random couriers. All my contracted deliver drivers know how to set up and fix any cake/dessert issues if needed. I’m not sure what had occurred as I was told everything went smoothly. I will be speaking with this individual. When communicating, I did let you know the week of that your cake would be delivered the morning of- before the start of the event. I’m not sure how the cake could’ve been frozen, as I put it together that morning prior to it being delivered. I apologize that it wasn’t up to your standards. Please email me to discuss further! I truly hope your wedding turned out beautifully and congratulations again!
- SF
Sara F.
Wonderful cakes and wonderful communication
We had Taylor do cake and cupcakes for our wedding, communication was great and cake got rave reviews! We also had her do a semi-last minute cupcakes for my dad's retirement party and they were perfect :)
Preferred vendors of Tay’s Sweet Shop
Explore other vendors serving Noblesville, IN
- The Faux Bouquets
- Carlos Bustos | Lido Video
- Summer & Co Bridal LLC
- Rama Photo Video
- the little flower co.
- DJ Lisa Blayde
- Kira Trinh Photography
- A Beautiful Day Event Flowers & Decor
- Ring Of Music
- Satcher Productions
- Bupp Woodworks and Designs - Flower Preservation
- Hillary Hutchinson Photo Co.
Complete your dream team
- Noblesville Venues
- Noblesville Photographers
- Noblesville Beauty Professionals
- Noblesville Bands & DJs
- Noblesville Florists
- Noblesville Caterers
- Noblesville Planners
- Noblesville Videographers
- Noblesville Bar Services & Beverages
- Noblesville Officiants
- Noblesville Event Extras