Tay’s Sweet Shop

Packages

About Tay’s Sweet Shop

Tay’s Sweet Shop

Baker/ Owner

Bringing my passion to life, I specialize in made-from-scratch desserts. I’m a home-based Vendor in Noblesville, IN where small businesses are the heart of our community! I opened in 2017 as part time and took it on full time during the pandemic, after having my daughter.

I strive to make each cake unique to each couple. I only take a very limited number of Wedding cakes per weekend to be able to focus on each order. Everything is made from scratch, including any edible decor! Not only do I deliver a high-quality product, but deliver a memorable experience to match any wedding style or theme!

Best of Zola 2024

Services

Dessert types

  • Cakes
  • Candy and confections
  • Cookies and macarons
  • Cupcakes
  • Donuts
  • Mini desserts
  • Pastries
  • Pies
  • Puddings and custards

Decor options

  • Cake toppers
  • Custom text
  • Fruit topping
  • Live flowers

Available customizations

  • Cake filling
  • Cake flavors
  • Cake frosting

Services offered

  • Bars & Buffets
  • Consultations
  • Delivery
  • Dessert installations
  • Setup
  • Tastings

Dietary accommodations

  • Dairy-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Kosher
  • Nut-free
  • Sugar-free
  • Vegan
  • Vegetarian

Tay’s Sweet Shop packages

Intimate Package: up to 40 Guests

Price$205

Description

This package is recommends for small, intimate weddings with 40 or less guests. *Delivery not included in price

What’s included
  • Small Cake for Cutting
  • 4 Dozen Cupcakes

Package 1: Up to 70 Guests

Price$430

Description

This package is for weddings with 70 guests or less. *Delivery/Setup not included in price

What’s included
  • Two Tier Cake
  • 4 Dozen Cupcakes
  • 4 Dozen Cake Pops

Package 2: 75-100 Guests

Price$680

Description

For weddings with a guest count between 75-100 **Delivery/Setup not included in price.

What’s included
  • Two Tier Cake
  • 5 Dozen Cupcakes
  • 5 Dozen Mini Cheesecakes
  • 2 Dozen Cake Pops

Package 3: 100-150 Guests

Price$1,050

Description

For weddings with 100-150 guests *Delivery/Setup not included in price.

What’s included
  • Three Tier Cake
  • 7 Dozen Cupcakes
  • 5 Dozen Cake Pops
  • 4 Dozen Brownies

Reviews

Write a review

4.5 out of 5

27 reviews

Write a review

  • Wedding cake

    •Verified review•Incentivized review
    •Hailly W.•Dec 7

    Tay's Sweet Shop was an absolute delight to work with for our wedding. From the very first interaction, their communication was prompt, friendly, and professional. The quality of their work was amazing - the wedding cake and desserts they provided were a true crowd pleaser and looked absolutely beautiful. The sweet element they added to our special day was truly memorable, and our guests are still raving about how delicious everything was. We couldn't have asked for a better vendor to bring our wedding vision to life. Highly recommend Tay's Sweet Shop to any couple planning their big day!

  • Last Minute Request

    •Verified review
    •Teri•Nov 19, 2025

    We hired Tay’s Sweet Shop very last minute and was so thankful that they were able to accommodate! We had a simple two-tier cake as well as five dozen cupcakes. The guests raved about how moist and flavorful the cupcake cupcakes were. The cake was for us and the wedding party only. If you’re looking for a bakery, I recommend working with Taylor. She was very sweet and was able to answer all my crazy questions. I was very impressed with her ability to squeeze us in last minute!

  • Perfect Wedding Desserts

    •Verified review
    •Macy•Nov 18, 2025

    We hired Tays Sweet Shop to create our wedding cake and desserts. From day one until wedding day, we had the most perfect experience. The tasting box was filled with so many options, it was hard to choose from. The flavors we chose (lemon with raspberry filling) was the most amazing combination, recommended by the owner herself. Wedding day came and Taylor exceeded our expectations for our cake and desserts! She was truly an amazing person to work with and communication was always on point! I highly recommended using this bakery for your special day!

  • Great Taste, Not so great communication

    •Verified review
    •Meghan K.•Nov 8, 2025

    I worked with Tay from Tay’s Sweet Shop for my wedding. Early communication was great and she answered all of my questions. One thing I didn’t fully think through at booking was that having a contract was optional — in hindsight, that should have been a standard part of the process. Two days before the wedding, Tay let me know she wouldn’t be able to deliver or set up the desserts due to a death in the family. I understand that emergencies happen, and we were able to arrange for someone local to pick them up. However, we had paid a 100 delivery/set-up fee that we did not receive. When I requested the refund, she told me it would process in 5–7 days due to her business setup, but it has now been well past that and the refund still has not been issued. After that, communication stopped. The cutting cake was beautiful and tasted amazing. The other desserts tasted good as well, but they looked rushed and not quite wedding-quality. I do want to be fair and acknowledge that this may have been related to the sudden circumstances she was dealing with that week. Still, the overall result did not match what I paid for. I also wish I had looked at more reviews beforehand, including on her Google page (listed under a different business name), because it seems others have experienced similar communication and follow-through issues. Overall, while the flavors were great and I empathize with the situation, the lack of consistent communication, the delay in the refund with no follow-up, and the uneven presentation made the experience disappointing.

Preferred vendors of Tay’s Sweet Shop

Quick responder
Venue
Mill Top Banquet & Conference Center

5.0 (5)

Noblesville, IN
Venue
Laurel Hall
Venue
White Willow Farms

Explore other vendors serving Noblesville, IN

Complete your dream team

Other cakes & desserts in Noblesville

Other wedding services nearby