Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop

Price per serving

Starts at $3 per person.

About Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop

Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop

Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop has been baking and creating masterpiece wedding cakes for over 40 years and we look forward to working with you! Our cakes are known for incredible texture and flavor and the delicious flavors are the result of a combination of baking mastery and passion that is simply unsurpassed. We use only the highest quality ingredients, recipes, and baking practices resulting in exceptionally delicious and moist cakes.

Aggie’s has received countless industry awards for our incredible cakes! We strive to make your entire wedding cake experience easy and stress-free, and we look forward to providing you with the wedding cake of your dreams! For more information, email us at (personal information protected by Zola) or schedule a consultation here: (personal information protected by Zola)

Services

Dessert types

  • Cakes
  • Cookies and macarons
  • Cupcakes
  • Donuts
  • Mini desserts
  • Pies

Decor options

  • 3D sugar work
  • Custom text
  • Fruit topping
  • Sugar flowers

Available customizations

  • Cake filling
  • Cake flavors
  • Cake frosting

Services offered

  • Consultations
  • Delivery
  • Setup
  • Tastings

Reviews

Write a review
Rating: 4.7

4.7 out of 5

11 reviews

  • MH

    Marie H.

    Rating: 5
    •Incentivized review
    •Feb 16, 2026

    Delicious and Easy!

    Working with Aggie's was delicious, easy, and so reliable! Their desserts are incredible, and everything about working with them was amazing from start to finish. We would repeat our orders with them in a heartbeat!

  • TR

    Taylor R.

    Rating: 4
    •Oct 13, 2025

    Honest review

    Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop was a mixed leading up to our wedding day. The communication style from the owners was rude, rushed, and slow at times, which caused some minor hiccups that were partly my own fault for not reading everything carefully before confirming (wedding brain). However, the end result was absolutely worth it - the two beautiful 3-tiered cakes they created were simply gorgeous, decadent, and had everyone at our wedding raving about the incredible taste. Despite the less-than-ideal communication, Aggie's Bakery delivered on the quality and value of their work, creating cakes that were truly the highlight of our dessert table.

  • A

    Alyssa

    Rating: 5
    •Incentivized review
    •Aug 10, 2025

    Perfect couple’s cake!

    Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop was a pleasure to work with for our wedding! Their communication was direct and clear over phone and email. They brought our vision of a small couple’s cake to life! It had buttercream frosting with raspberry filling, which was so delicious. Highly recommend!

  • AG

    Alondra G.

    Rating: 5
    •Incentivized review
    •Jul 29, 2025

    Sleeping Beauty Wedding Cake

    Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop was an excellent choice for our wedding cakes and desserts. Rachel, the person we did the consultation with, was incredibly helpful and guided us through the entire process. Her expertise made the experience so smooth and enjoyable. The quality of their work is amazing, and the value is very affordable, especially considering how delicious the cake tasting was. While I don't have any specific examples to share from our wedding, I highly recommend at least doing a consultation with Aggie's if you are getting married in the Milwaukee or Waukesha area. They will not disappoint!

  • SG

    Stephanie and G.

    Rating: 5
    •Jul 28, 2025

    Bride and Groom

    Amazing desserts, thank you so much for being such a great vendor! The cheesecakes are to die for!

Preferred vendors of Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop

Venue
Rustic Manor 1848
Rating: 4.7 (3 reviews)
Hartland, WI
Starts at $3,000
Venue
The Gage
Milwaukee, WI

Real wedding inspiration featuring Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop

Show all photos
1. We use only the highest quality ingredients, recipes, and baking practices resulting in exceptionally delicious and moist cakes! 2. Aggie's has been baking and creating masterpiece wedding cakes for almost 40 years. All of our staff members are exceptionally talented and highly trained. 3. It is our passion and our main priority to create a beautiful and delicious wedding cake for you!
Our clients typically book 6 – 18 months in advance with the summer months from June – October being the most popular. Based on our reputation and portfolio of previous work, our dates do fill up early, so you should book your consultation as soon as possible.
You can start by searching our website/the internet for any design ideas. The most important part is setting up a consultation here: https://www.aggiesbakery.com/schedule-a-consultation/ so you can taste our product, design a cake, and get a detailed quote. While most of our customers do book with us after our consultations, you are not required to do so if you are not comfortable at that time.
Aggie’s offers many different cakes and dessert options for your wedding including these options: Tiered Cakes Cheesecakes Sheet cakes (kitchen cakes) Groom's Cakes Table cakes Cupcakes Mini Pastries Small 4″ Pies and 2″ Pies Sweets Tables Donuts Cookies
Tiered cakes start at $3.50 a serving and sheet cakes start at $1.50 a serving. We offer three different sized cupcakes ranging from $1 - $3 each and a wide variety of mini pastries that range from $12 - $15 per dozen. For more information/specifics, send us an email!

Explore other vendors serving West Allis, WI

Complete your dream team

Other cakes & desserts in West Allis

Other wedding services nearby