What other Tyler vendors will I need?

Tyler Event Extras Tyler Officiants Tyler Bar Services & Beverages Tyler Cakes & Desserts Tyler Beauty Professionals Tyler Bands & DJs Tyler Wedding Planners Tyler Florists Tyler Videographers Tyler Photographers Tyler Venues

What other caterers are nearby?

Italian Sioux Falls, SD caterers

The Best 5 Italian Wedding Catering in Tyler, MN

Quick responder

Green Mill Catering & Bar Service

Rating: 5.0 (10 reviews)

Starts at $50
Serves Tyler, MN

It starts with a complimentary tasting and ends with an incredible dinner and a VERY happy couple. Our staff is ready with everything you need: linens, napkins, china, glassware, coffee, etc. and complete set up & tear down. We can even bring the bar!

“The Green Mill team was a pleasure to work with for our wedding! The food was delicious and the service was incredible. Sarah and Katie were so gracious during the planning portion and answered ALL our questions which made it a breeze! Several high marks from our guests as well! Highly recommend Green Mill for your next event.”

Katie J., a year ago

Quick responder

This Little Piggy Catering

Rating: 5.0 (6 reviews)

Starts at $40
Serves Tyler, MN

Established in 1979, our legendary catering has been enjoyed by thousands of wedding couples and their treasured guests. Proudly family owned and operated, This Little Piggy is a favorite for weddings and events throughout Minnesota and Western WI.

“Five Stars Isn’t Enough! We hired little piggy catering for our wedding just this past Saturday on August 9th and they absolutely blew us away. The food was phenomenal—every dish was bursting with flavor, beautifully presented, and had our guests raving all night. But what truly set them apart was their exceptional staff. Every single person was kind, courteous, and genuinely attentive in a way that felt so personal. One moment that really stuck with me: I had my hands full and one of their team members noticed—without hesitation, they offered to carry my plate to my table. It was such a small gesture, but it spoke volumes about their commitment to service and care. They didn’t just cater our wedding—they elevated it. If you’re looking for a catering company that delivers incredible food and treats your event like it’s their own, look no further.”

Alexis A., 8 months ago

Quick responder

Apples 2 Apples Catering

Rating: 5.0 (1 review)

Starts at $10
Serves Tyler, MN

Available at our many exclusive venues, Apples 2 Apples Catering offers an ethical farm to table catering concept using healthy ingredients fresh from local farms across Minnesota and Wisconsin. The menu offers organic, grass fed, free range, and sustainable options, served in an eco-friendly manner. We also specialize in serving those with dietary restrictions such as gluten and dairy intolerance, as well as vegetarian and vegan needs.

“Apple 2 Apples catering is the best all around catering Company with the best food, best prices, and best service.”

Michael, 2 years ago

Quick responder

HI5 BBQ

Rating: 5.0 (1 review)

Starts at $1,000
Serves Tyler, MN

Our passion for great BBQ goes back over 25 years. After attending a few weddings catered by other BBQ companies, we realized something — we could do it better. That’s when HI5 BBQ was born. We make everything fresh to order for each event — nothing reheated, nothing made in bulk. We believe that a wedding is one of the most important days of your life, and the food should reflect that. The BBQ should be outstanding, the service top-notch, and your vendor should be as passionate about your day as you are.

“Had Hi5 BBQ provide a great assortment of meats and sides. Corn pudding was a real hit. Chopped brisket was demolished and the pulled chicken and pork were a wonderful addition. Fresh food delivered with care. Thank you. All the sides were amazing”

Jody R., 5 months ago

Roll'n Pin Catering

Starts at $2,000
Serves Tyler, MN for additional fees

Our Promise: • Absolutely delicious meals • Flexible online event personalization planner • Transparent ‘honest’ pricing & policies • Outstanding communication & organization. INCLUDED: • Quickly-moving, attended buffet(s) (plated/served available) • High-quality, disposable tableware (‘real’ china available) • Free local delivery (within 150 miles available).