What other Elroy vendors will I need?

Elroy Event Extras Elroy Officiants Elroy Bar Services & Beverages Elroy Cakes & Desserts Elroy Beauty Professionals Elroy Bands & DJs Elroy Wedding Planners Elroy Florists Elroy Videographers Elroy Photographers Elroy Venues

What other caterers are nearby?

Italian Madison, WI caterers Italian Appleton, WI caterers Italian Oshkosh, WI caterers

The Best 7 Italian Wedding Catering in Elroy, WI

Quick responder

KFS CATERING

5.0

Starts at $1,200
Serves Elroy, WI
Offer

KFS catering bring the best in Personal,Corporate and Full-Service Event Catering with phenomenal food, customer care, and attention to detail. Experienced in large events as well as smaller gatherings, they are true experienced professionals.

“KFS Catering was an outstanding choice for our wedding catering. Their communication throughout the planning process was excellent, and they were incredibly responsive to all of our questions and requests. On the day of the event, their service was great - the food was delicious and beautifully presented, and the staff was attentive and professional. We received so many compliments from our guests on the quality of the catering. KFS truly went above and beyond to ensure our special day was perfect. We couldn't have asked for a better catering experience.”

Tom and M., a year ago

Trending

Hangry Dave's Carnivore Catering & Herbivore Grazing

5.0

Serves Elroy, WI

If I were to ask you to tell me about the best steak you've ever had, what would you tell me? Would you describe the flavor? The texture? How juicy it was? Or, would you tell me about the experience, who was with you, or how it made you feel? These are the most important questions when it comes to food. We ask you these questions so we can craft the perfect flavors, AND experience for you and your guests. Food is love. Love feels good. Let's make your event delicious, enjoyable and completely unforgettable.

“From the moment we first reached out to Hangry Dave's Carnivore Catering & Herbivore Grazing, we were impressed by their honest and respectful communication style. They exceeded our expectations in every way, handling every aspect of the catering seamlessly. The price was exactly as promised, the food was exceptional, and the staff was incredibly professional and courteous. We were blown away by their service, and I would 100% recommend Hangry Dave's to any couple planning their wedding. In fact, I have already personally recommended them to several friends and family members - you will not be disappointed!”

Jeff, a year ago

Quick responder

Two Hearts Catering

Serves Elroy, WI
Offer

At Two Hearts we're more than just a catering company- we're a family driven business passionate about bringing people together over delicious food. As Italian Americans food is in our DNA. We believe that sharing a meal is about connection, love and community. Our team led by CEO Lisa is dedicated to crafting customized menus that exceeds expectations. whether it's a corporate event, wedding, or special celebration, we're committed to delivering exceptional service, fresh ingredients, and a dash of heart.

Quick responder

Martha Kelly Catering Services

Starts at $900
Serves Elroy, WI

We are a family owned-operating business from Mercer Wi. My family and I moved up to the Northwoods From Chicago almost 8 years ago. I ran a local deli for about six years. With over thirty years in the food industry, I ( Martha Kelly) started our catering business with my husband and three sons almost four years ago.

Twisted Radish

Starts at $10,000
Serves Elroy, WI

Twisted Radish has a deep respect for food and we treat it with care. The whole idea of being a catering company is that nothing goes to waste--ever. The Twisted Radish team is made up of a variety of minds from various walks of life that have been joined together by the common interest of good food that is good for you. We have decided to share our food and philosophy with others. We focus on organic, local, and seasonally inspired menus. In addition to being vital to agriculture, choosing seasonal and locally sourced foods is also the most flavorful way to eat.

Quick responder

This Little Piggy Catering

5.0

Starts at $40
Serves Elroy, WI for additional fees

Established in 1979, our legendary catering has been enjoyed by thousands of wedding couples and their treasured guests. Proudly family owned and operated, This Little Piggy is a favorite for weddings and events throughout Minnesota and Western WI.

“We had a wonderful experience working with This Little Piggy Catering for our wedding on 8/15/20. Our food was fabulous. People have been talking about it for months especially the mac and cheese! The staff was wonderful to work with the day of our wedding as well. Would definitely recommend!”

Johannah, 5 years ago

Northwoods Catering of Wisconsin, LLC

1.0

Starts at $7,000
Serves Elroy, WI

At Northwoods Catering, we offer a refined, boutique experience where every detail is tailored to you. We’re not bargain caterers — our chef-led team prepares exceptional cuisine on-site, never delivered in warming boxes, ensuring each dish is served fresh and flawless. From private consultations to custom menus, every step is personal, elevated, and rooted in your story. We take on only select events to maintain the highest standards of care. On your special day, expect exquisite food, expert service, and the quiet confidence of knowing it’s all in capable hands.