The Best Restaurant & Brewery Wedding Venues in Shelter Island, NY

The Best Restaurant & Brewery Wedding Venues in Shelter Island, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


15 Wedding Venues in Shelter Island, NY

Restaurants, breweries
100-150 guests
Calissa Restaurant 

5.0

Water Mill, NY
  • Up to 400 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $10,000

Calissa is Mykonos in The Hamptons. Drawing on a decade of private dining experience in Manhattan and The Hamptons, our events team executes dynamic, unique and creative events with professionalism and care. Calissa’s outdoor dining spaces include the tented Garden, covered Terrace and open-air Meadow. Our more intimate indoor spaces are the Private Dining Room, Lounge, Bar, and Main Dining Room. We recommend utilizing either the two outdoor spaces or renting out Calissa in its entirety. Services Offered In addition to weddings, Calissa is available for bridal showers, engagement parties, rehearsal dinners, farewell brunches, and afterparties. Food comes first for us: we serve the same ingredients to private dining guests as are served to a la carte guests, sourced from family-run farms and local fishing boats. We are Slow Food certified and have won numerous awards for our commitment to sustainability.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Multiple event spaces
  • Wheelchair accessible
  • Provides event staff

Venue considerations

  • Venue feels large for events with small guest lists
  • No on-site guest accommodations
Calissa was amazing! We booked our wedding ceremony/reception and they were all so accommodating. The restaurant/venue is beautiful on its own, so we didn’t need much for flowers and decor. The food was delicious, our guests said that food kept coming and that’s exactly what we were looking for. And the service was excellent. Everyone was so attentive and friendly. From the planning of the day’s events, including the amazing band, to the food and the details, Calissa was amazing. Several of our guests said our wedding was the best ever! Dara and Kylie were amazing! Our day was perfect!
Anita S., 2 years ago
Quick responder
Moby's NY 

5.0

East Hampton, NY
  • Up to 250 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $30,000

Moby’s, situated in a lovingly restored 1880s home along the scenic stretch of Highway 27 leading to Montauk in East Hampton, beckons with its seasonal Italian cuisine, cocktails, and everlasting summertime enchantment. The restaurant offers a blend of indoor, outdoor, and patio dining experiences, providing a charming ambiance for culinary delights amidst historic allure. Amidst this charming backdrop, Moby's transforms into a versatile event venue, catering to gatherings of all sizes, from intimate dinners to grand affairs, Moby's offers a range of event spaces providing a seamless indoor-outdoor experience.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Has a glamorous vibe
  • Provides a dedicated team on-site
  • Flexible event spaces

Venue considerations

  • Not wheelchair accessible
  • Does not allow pets
  • On-site parking not available
Awarded Best of Zola
Where to begin? I had my heart set on Moby’s for our wedding long before I experienced their food, service, and ambience. Once we visited, it was an easy decision— the entire experience exceeded our expectations in every way; it was simply impeccable. Planning a wedding can be challenging, but John and the entire Moby’s team made the process effortless. The hospitality was truly incredible. There was never a no, instead a willingness to cater to our every desire and went above and beyond to ensure our vision came to life. From the stunning atmosphere to the exquisite food, everything was flawless. Our guests raved about the venue and the incredible food, making our special day even more memorable. The Moby’s team ensured everything ran smoothly, allowing us to fully enjoy our celebration. I highly recommend Moby’s for any event, and particularly for couples seeking a beautiful setting for their wedding with exceptional service.
Gab F., 8 months ago
GemHidden gem
Alimentari Beach Montauk 

5.0

Montauk, NY
  • Up to 135 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor
  • Starts at $5,000

Founded in 2021, Alimentari Beach originally an Italian market, opened its doors with the intention to build community around good quality food. With its success, the market has since evolved into a restaurant space. Still chasing that same ethos, Alimentari’s mission is to bring the community of Montauk together through good food, wine, and atmosphere.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Has a relaxed and casual vibe
  • Offers full-service amenities
  • Provides lighting and sound

Venue considerations

  • Not wheelchair accessible
  • No on-premises lodging options
  • On-site parking not available
We are so happy with the entire experience at Alimentari Beach MTK! The food, the drinks and the staff were exceptional. We would recommend to anyone and will certainly be back for more. Thank you again.
Paul F., 3 months ago
Quick responder
Jerry and The Mermaid 

5.0

Riverhead, NY
  • Up to 125 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $1,500
  • Offer

Jerry and the Mermaid is a waterfront restaurant venue in Riverhead, NY, ideal for After Parties, Rehearsal Dinners and Post Wedding Brunch events. This scenic setting is great for planning a relaxing lunch or a casual private dinner. A team of talented chefs is on board to deliver excellent culinary experiences. Their range of classics are created with a fresh, modern twist. Guests can enjoy their favorites in the comfort and style of this contemporary venue.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Offers convenient lodging options
  • Flexible event spaces
  • Full catering menu to choose from

Venue considerations

  • Does not allow pets
  • No on-site bridal suite
  • Not wheelchair accessible
Jerry works hard to make sure his customers are happy and well taken care of throughout the planning process and the event. Jerry and the Mermaid is my go to location when organizing outings for my school groups and fishing club. It is impressive that Jerry makes a point to speak to and check in on his customers during their dining experience.
Garrett, a month ago
Twin Fork Beer Co. Inc 

5.0

Riverhead, NY
  • Up to 125 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor

Behind every beer company... lies a story filled with inspiration, hope, and dedication. Such is true with the Twin Fork Beer Company and its twin brother founders, Dan and Pete Chekijian. Music was embraced in the Chekijian household, as a result of their father’s proud distinction of being a classically trained pianist. This love and respect for music later led to the use of the tuning fork as the iconic logo of the twin fork beer company. Specializing in many events such as rehearsal dinners, welcoming and farewell parties, engagement parties, and more. Each experience at Twin Fork Beer Co. is customized to each couple's needs, making us the perfect venue for you!

Why you'll love this venue

  • Pets can join the celebration
  • Has onsite accommodations
  • Both indoor and outdoor options

Venue considerations

  • No built-in audiovisual options
  • No on-site bridal suite
  • No free parking
We used Twin Forks for an engagement party and it was such a great experience! Savannah, the manager, was so easy to work with and accommodated all of our requests. She really went above and beyond to make the event special. The venue was perfect- so spacious and trendy with plenty of room for our large party. The drink and food package is the way to go and made the planning so easy and seamless. The prices were also very reasonable. The staff were so helpful and pleasant to deal with. I highly recommend booking your party at this venue!
Melissa D., 3 years ago
Stony Creek Brewery 

5.0

Branford, CT
  • Up to 140 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor

Situated in heart of Connecticut’s Branford, the Stony Creek Brewery offers a modern brewery venue for a fun-loving couple hoping to throw a laid back big day! Merging quality brews with delicious food and stunning design, it is no wonder that soon-to-be-wed couples see the Stony Creek Brewery as a stunning venue for their weddings! Imagine exchanging your vows on the adjoining dock with the glittering bay waters as a backdrop for your “I do’s.” The beautiful taproom boasts a unique atmosphere that is perfect for a relaxing reception.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Provides a dedicated team on-site
  • Provides lighting and sound
  • Both indoor and outdoor options

Venue considerations

  • No on-site guest accommodations
  • Not wheelchair accessible
  • No in-house catering options
Stony Creek Brewery was an absolute pleasure to work with for our wedding celebration. From the start, their communication style was easy and straightforward, making the planning process a breeze. Their indoor-outdoor space provided the perfect setting, with gorgeous views. We were able to kick off our wedding weekend with a wonderful welcome party in their private upstairs room the night before the big day. The space was perfect for our casual pizza, drinks, cannolis, and cupcakes - it set the tone for a fun and memorable celebration. We're so grateful to the Stony Creek team for helping make our wedding weekend truly special.
Anne-Levert, 8 months ago
Quick responder
Powder Ridge Mountain Park and Resort 

5.0

Middlefield, CT
  • Up to 200 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $129

Powder Ridge has plenty of indoor/outdoor space for your wedding. Our unique venue offers you the opportunity to have your ceremony at the Top of a Mountain. All your guests can travel to the top on our Ski Lift to get to the beautiful views of the property. If the Base of the Mountain is preferred, you may select to be next to our pond or by the outdoor fireplace. For your reception, our Rustic Lodge including two stone fireplaces, barn door along with bistro lighting is able to accommodate up to 180 people for dinner and dancing. New to the property, is our outdoor Pavilion, located next to the pond that can accommodate up to 200 people. Add on some firepits and lawn games for a fun and relaxing event. Choose our wedding package or customize your own to fit your need.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Allows pets
  • Provides setup and cleanup
  • Has onsite accommodations

Venue considerations

  • No in-house lighting and sound packages available
  • Venue feels large for events with small guest lists
Powder Ridge Mountain Park and Resort was an absolute dream venue for our wedding! From the moment we first reached out, Marla and the team were excellent communicators, always staying on top of every detail and being incredibly flexible as we planned our special day. The space was transformed from a restaurant and ski lodge into a lovely ceremony space and magical reception area. The decor outside our wedding space was decked out for Christmas, which went perfectly with our rustic winter theme and made our photographs look fantastic. Marla and Powder Ridge accommodated our every need and assembled our vision without a flaw. Not to mention, the food was absolutely delicious! We couldn't have asked for a better venue or team to bring our wedding to life.
Julia L., 2 months ago
Léon 1909 
Shelter Island Heights, NY
  • Up to 150 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $18,000

In summer 2022, Valerie Mnuchin and her father Robert Mnuchin debuted Léon, their first independent restaurant located on Shelter Island. Named after Valerie’s paternal grandfather, whose affinity for romantic European adventures and seaside destinations inform the restaurant’s setting, Léon is an inviting homage to the past with warm, natural materials and nods to unfussy, countryside French and Italian fare. A wood-burning hearth at the heart of the restaurant serves as its anchor, inspiring a Provençal-style menu showcasing regional ingredients. Now Open Seven Days a Week 5-10 pm Chef: Mason Lindahl Sous Chef: Armond Joseph General Manager: Chris Clark

Why you'll love this venue

  • Has a dance floor for celebration
  • Handles all cleanup logistics
  • All-inclusive venue packages

Venue considerations

  • No on-site bridal suite
  • No on-site guest accommodations
  • Does not allow pets
Quick responder
Navy Beach Restaurant 
Montauk, NY
  • Up to 175 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $5,000

Montauk’s favorite beachfront restaurant, Navy Beach serves casual coastal cuisine in a laid back, family-friendly setting. Positioned on a 200-foot private beach, the restaurant offers prime seating on the sand and some of the best sunsets in the Hamptons. Boaters are welcome to anchor in the protected waters of Fort Pond Bay (41° 02′ 45.11″N, -71° 57′ 44.88″W), which was once occupied by the US Navy, and where two Navy piers are still part of the water landscape. As Montauk’s favorite beachfront restaurant, Navy Beach is available to host a myriad of events indoors– in our waterview bar and dining room–and outdoors, on our 200-foot private beach.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Has a dance floor for celebration
  • Provides a dedicated team on-site
  • Has a relaxed and casual vibe

Venue considerations

  • No on-site guest accommodations
  • Not wheelchair accessible
  • Does not allow pets
Montauk Yacht Club 
Montauk, NY
  • Up to 500 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $38,500

Located on a private lakefront in the hamlet of Montauk, Montauk Yacht Club offers a timeless backdrop for your wedding and related events. Our indoor and outdoor venues are ideal for celebrations both big and small, from casual to black-tie. In addition to rooms, suites, and cottages, Montauk Yacht Club offers a luxurious bridal suite, perfect for getting ready for all the festivities.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Offers full-service amenities
  • Provides event staff
  • Has a dance floor for celebration

Venue considerations

  • Not for you if you are looking for something nontraditional
  • No built-in audiovisual options
  • Venue feels large for events with small guest lists
East End Venue 
Riverhead, NY
  • Up to 200 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor

Nestled in Long Island’s beautiful east end, The East End Venue at the Residence Inn Long Island East End is the perfect place to celebrate with friends and family. From corporate events, fundraisers, communions, anniversaries, and weddings, experienced staff and newly built facilities are ready to welcome you, and those you love, to an event you’ll always remember. Our team is experienced in every aspect to coordinate and execute seamless events.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Provides lighting and sound
  • Has a sophisticated vibe
  • Has a dance floor to dance the night away

Venue considerations

  • Not for you if you are drawn to more unconventional venues
  • On-site parking not available
  • Not wheelchair accessible
Quick responder
The Marina At American Wharf 
Norwich, CT
  • Up to 250 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Outdoor
  • Starts at $7,000

Nestled in the heart of Norwich, CT, our marina is not just a boating haven, but a vibrant hub for diverse events. From member-exclusive gatherings to public festivities, we host a myriad of experiences. Looking to create your own special moment? Our picturesque setting is perfect for any event, be it a cozy engagement party or a dream wedding.

Why you'll love this venue

  • All-inclusive venue packages
  • Promotes a party atmosphere
  • Provides catering services

Venue considerations

  • No on-premises lodging options
  • Not wheelchair accessible
  • Does not provide event staff
The Charlestown Rathskeller 
Charlestown, RI
  • Up to 300 guests
  • Select services
  • Outdoor

The Charlestown Rathskeller started out as a speakeasy in a different time, and has grown into something entirely unique since then. Nestled in the woods of Charlestown since 1933, the Rathskeller is one of the most memorable dining and entertainment destinations in Southern New England. We serve deliciously grilled steaks, local seafood, burgers and sandwiches in our meticulously restored dining room and tavern, beautiful outdoor patio, and at our indoor and outdoor bars. Just across the restaurant’s backyard sits our rustic outdoor music and entertainment venue. Down Back, our summer stage, backyard bar and burger shack surround a roaring bonfire on cool summer nights. Guests from all over New England descend on the Charlestown Rathskeller for concerts featuring some of the best party, pop, rock and country cover acts in the region. With tasty food and beverages, plus backyard games like horseshoes, cornhole and bocce, guests can enjoy a whole day or night at the Rathskeller.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Space for a large guest list
  • Provides lighting and sound
  • Provides a dedicated team on-site

Venue considerations

  • Not wheelchair accessible
  • Venue feels large for events with small guest lists
  • No on-premises lodging options
Quick responder
Insignia 
Smithtown, NY
  • Up to 250 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Indoor & outdoor

At Insignia, every wedding is a wonderful creation that’s as refreshingly different as your love together. Our elegant, modern décor both indoors and out is a beautiful departure from typical wedding halls. Combining the look and feel of a Hamptons-style mansion with a chic, upscale Manhattan restaurant, it sets the stage for a truly memorable experience.

Why you'll love this venue

  • Has a glamorous vibe
  • Provides setup and cleanup
  • Flexible event spaces

Venue considerations

  • Not wheelchair accessible
  • No free parking
  • Does not allow pets

Location flexible? Discover venues near Shelter Island, NY

About wedding venues in Shelter Island, NY

Why is New York the Perfect Wedding Destination?

New York gives you incredible variety for your special day, from Manhattan's iconic skyline to the charming countryside of Upstate. You can enjoy timeless elegance at The Plaza Hotel with its grand ballrooms overlooking Central Park, or take in breathtaking panoramic views of Manhattan at Tribeca Rooftop. Brooklyn offers photography-friendly industrial-chic spaces like The Foundry with its character-filled exposed brick and factory windows. Head Upstate and you'll find City Winery Hudson Valley where your celebration unfolds against the backdrop of a working vineyard with mountain views that change beautifully with each season. April sees the most wedding inquiries in New York, showing just how many couples are drawn to the region during spring's beautiful blooming season.

What's the Reality of Wedding Costs in New York?

Expect to pay more for your New York wedding than the national average of $6,500-$12,000 for venues alone. New York venues typically cost around $16,709 which makes up about 22% of your total wedding budget. Your overall costs will vary based on how many guests you're hosting:

Guest CountTotal Wedding Budget
50 guests (small wedding)$32,316
100 guests$54,844
150 guests$76,011
200 guests$94,911
250 guests$113,810
300 guests (large wedding)$132,709

Your other major expenses will include catering at $13,367 (18%), bar services running $10,694 (14%), florals at $8,177 (11%), planners costing $6,044 (8%), photography at $5,119 (7%), videography at $4,622 (6%), entertainment at $2,298 (3%), cake and desserts at $1,067 (1%), and hair and makeup averaging $550 (1%).

How Do NYC Wedding Venues Compare to Upstate Locations?

NYC venues offer you urban sophistication with distinctive skyline views. At Tribeca Rooftop + 360° you'll enjoy floor-to-ceiling windows showcasing Manhattan panoramas while The Plaza presents opulent ballrooms featuring chandeliers ornate molding and gold accents. The 620 Loft & Garden gives you a stunning rooftop terrace overlooking St. Patrick's Cathedral and Fifth Avenue.

Upstate venues surround you with natural beauty and historic architecture. City Winery Hudson Valley welcomes you to a renovated factory featuring vaulted ceilings stone walls and vineyard views. You can host up to 350 guests here and customize your outdoor ceremony areas to create exactly the atmosphere you're dreaming of.

Which New York Venues Offer Outstanding Culinary Experiences?

You can treat your guests to Two Michelin star cuisine at Manhatta perched 60 floors high in the Financial District where Executive Chef Justin Bogle creates memorable dishes like hamachi and black truffle dumplings. The River Cafe in Brooklyn serves Michelin-starred cuisine featuring Hudson Valley foie gras and Nantucket Bay scallops with Brooklyn Bridge views right outside your window. For a farm-to-table experience Blue Hill at Stone Barns in Westchester County offers cuisine sourced directly from their on-site farm with their HayLoft space accommodating anywhere from 40 to 260 guests.

Where Can You Find Accessible Wedding Venues in New York?

For couples prioritizing accessibility 620 Loft & Garden offers customizable settings that can work with various needs though you'll want to confirm specific features during your planning. Prospect Park Boathouse and Central Park Conservatory Garden provide accessible options with proper pathways for all your guests. Always ask about specific accommodations like wheelchair ramps elevators and accessible restrooms when you're researching potential venues to ensure everyone can fully participate in your celebration.

How Can Guests Participate Remotely at New York Weddings?

Historic Manhattan venues can make remote guests feel included by incorporating virtual tours during ceremony breaks while Midtown Loft & Terrace supports interactive platforms that go beyond simple passive streaming. You might consider venues in Chelsea or SoHo that can enhance those famous skyline views with live streaming that includes interactive elements like virtual photobooths live chats or virtual toasts. These features help create genuine engagement for participants joining your special day from afar.

What types of wedding venues are in Shelter Island, NY?

What other Shelter Island vendors will I need?

What other wedding venues are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?