The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Old Lyme, CT

The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Old Lyme, CT

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


13 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in Old Lyme, CT

Up to $158
Quick responder
Chocolate Rose Bakeshop 

5.0

  • Starts at $120
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT

Welcome. When I first started my story, it started out with me as a young adult and starting my adventure down the road of cake artistry. Then I dug a little deeper and gave thought to what probably sparked my interest in cake decorating. Chocolate Rose Bakeshop is Griswold, CT’s fav Custom & Special Occasion Cakeshop. Our creations may look too good to eat, but they taste too good NOT to! At Chocolate Rose we take pride in creating cakes that not only look too good to eat but taste too good NOT to!

Awarded Best of Zola
I highly recommend Chocolate Rose Bake Shop for your wedding cake or cupcakes for any event. Erin was highly responsive and decorated our cake just as we had described. Our cake, as well as the cupcakes, tasted amazing and we couldn't be happier. Thanks for all your hard work Erin!
Leah L., 6 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Zest Fresh Pastry 

5.0

  • Starts at $3
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT

Our Pastry Chefs have over 15 years of experience creating custom cakes and desserts. We take pride in our desire to work with you step by step to create custom cakes, desserts, and favors. We aim to create the highest quality product by using as many local and seasonal ingredients as possible. We believe that through a delicious cake and an exquisite design your perfect result will be achieved.

For our wedding in July 2024 at the Inn at Mystic, neither my husband nor I were set on getting a cake. My mom insisted and we set out to search for a bakery. Zest Fresh Pastry came highly recommended by our venue and when we spoke with them, they said they bring a cake there pretty much every weekend (sometimes multiple times a weekend!) during wedding season. I wanted a simple two layer cake that we could have our florist add some flowers to. We also did a sheet cake as backup for the guests! Our guests raved about the cake and I'm so happy we ended up getting one. Would definitely recommend!
Molly M., a year ago
Quick responder
Sugar Crystles 

5.0

  • Starts at $4
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT

Sugar Crystles is a wedding confectionery company in New Milford, CT. This budding bakery is owned and run by me, Crystle, and I am industry professional with years of cake-making in my repertoire. Using my skills, I do my best to craft stunning wedding cakes and delectable desserts that will have you and your guests wanting more. I create a variety of desserts and cakes for any special occasion with various techniques. From icing-covered sugar cookies to a variety of desserts for a buffet, I do it all. I also specialize in gluten and dairy free. I will cater to any flavor or design of your choice. Cake tastings are also available

Awarded Best of Zola
Our heart-shaped red velvet cake with cheesecake cream was everything we dreamed of and more! Crystles was able to take our inspiration and not only deliver it, but completely exceed our expectations. The cake was a true masterpiece — stunning to look at and absolutely heavenly to taste. The rich red velvet with the creamy cheesecake filling had everyone raving, and we’re still dreaming about it. We’re so grateful for the love, detail, and artistry she poured into creating such a beautiful (and delicious!) centerpiece for our wedding day.
Mimi P., 2 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Bella Confections 

5.0

  • Starts at $36
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT

"Bake The World A Better Place." Bella Confections main goal is to create that excitement from childhood when your birthday cake was brought out. I focus on incredible flavors, textures, and designs all made from scratch, by hand, by me- I am a one-woman business. I make sure that nothing less than the best thing you've ever tasted gets delivered to you. Priding myself on communication, I work closely with my clients. Nothing makes me happier than a kid screaming "The Cake Lady Is Here!" through the screen door! ***Custom orders only- please inquire with date/time/location/# of servings needed***

Lauren did a fantastic job on our cake. She did 3 different flavors per layer and included fillings in 2 of the layers. It was everything that I wanted, we included our own cake stand and figurine, but she put it all together to match exactly what I wanted. We received so many compliments on how good the cake was. Definitely would recommend, she was very professional and she went out of her way to come all the way to Massachusetts to drop off the cake testing samples. Thank you Lauren!!
Candace W., a year ago
Wright's Dairy Farm and Bakery 

5.0

  • Starts at $4
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT

Nestled in northern Rhode Island, Wright's Dairy Farm and Bakery is a fifth-generation, woman-owned business, that has been providing customers with fresh, high-quality desserts since 1914. We know wedding planning can be overwhelming, but there's no reason to stress the dessert - let us take care of it for you! From traditional tiered wedding cakes, to mini pastry dessert bars, we've got it covered. We thrive on creating a unique and enjoyable experience for each and every couple, ensuring that your vision comes to life! Reach out to us directly on our website!

From the moment we reached out to Wright's Dairy Farm and Bakery, their communication was quick, easy, and simple to work with. The quality of their work was stunning - the two-tier sweetheart cake and sheet cakes they created for our wedding were not only delicious, but had so many options for us to choose from to fit our vision. Our guests raved about the cakes, constantly asking where we had gotten them. We were thrilled with the final product and how it contributed to making our special day even more perfect.
Morgan, 3 months ago
Quick responder
Celebrated 

5.0

  • Starts at $100
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT

Celebrated is a vegan and allergy friendly bake shop in Richmond, RI. We serve pastries and coffee for takeout. We specialize in custom order desserts for special occasions with a focus on weddings, serving all of Rhode Island, Massachusetts and Connecticut. We cater to all your special event dessert needs, with a focus on full-service wedding dessert tables. From visualizing and baking to delivery and setup, we take care of it all!

Awarded Best of Zola
Becky was amazing to work with. She created our Wedding cutting cake as well as our dessert table. Everything was AMAZING. My husband is Celiac and everything was SO good. Thanks Becky!!
Stephanie, a year ago
Sweet Confessions 

4.8

  • Starts at $50
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT for additional fees

Baking to me isn’t just a job, it’s a hobby. What I love most is being part of such a meaningful day. Your wedding cake isn’t just dessert—it’s a moment. It’s the centerpiece of your reception, the sweet bite shared as newlyweds, and a memory captured in photos for a lifetime.

To Adrienne (Owner Of Sweet Confessions), I just wanted to take a moment to extend my deepest appreciation and gratitude for the exceptional experiences I’ve had with your company. From the quality of your baked goods to the care and consistency in your service, everything you do speaks of passion, dedication, and genuine craftsmanship. Your creations not only taste amazing but carry a kind of warmth and joy that makes every bite memorable. Whether it’s for a special occasion or simply to treat myself, Sweet Confessions has become my go-to — and I’m always confident that whatever I order will exceed expectations. Thank you for the love you pour into your work. It truly shows — and it’s deeply appreciated. Looking forward to many more sweet moments with you! With gratitude, Tykwell!
Tykwell W., 3 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Eat More Cake Llc 

5.0

  • Starts at $5
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT for additional fees

Our small batch boutique style bakery brings taste and design together to make your day special. Custom desserts made to highlight the couples vision is what we do best. We can create any dessert spread you desire! Everything is made by hand including our french macarons, cake and cupcake fillings (no jelly here!), and ganaches. We don't buy pre made batters, crusts, fillings or anything else.

Make Eat More Cake your first and last stop for any all baked goods! Eat more cake services many of our clients getting married at our venue. All have had only wonderful things to say!
Stone Garden, 4 years ago
Sweet Jules Treats 

5.0

  • Starts at $90
  • Serves Old Lyme, CT for additional fees

Julia Lentini, owner of Sweet Jules Treats, creates custom works of desserts and cakes for all special occasions. Our highest priority is that your desserts taste just as wonderful as they look, using the highest quality ingredients. I decided to take my passion for baking to the next level by creating my own baking business. Turning my passion into a full time business has been such a blessing for me and I am loving every part of it. Overall, I cannot thank my customers enough for the support they give and the love they give through each and every text, call or message. Each and every event is treated like my own!

Jules was so accommodating and was willing to work with us on our Golf themed engagement party. She made the cutest cupcakes and a beautiful small cake topper that everyone thoroughly enjoyed at the party. THANK YOU JULES!
Kristina H., 3 years ago

Location flexible? Discover cakes & desserts near Old Lyme, CT