Affordable Wedding Caterers in New Palestine, IN

Affordable Wedding Caterers in New Palestine, IN

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


8 Wedding Caterers in New Palestine, IN

Up to $2,000
Available on July 18, 2026
GemHidden gem
Charcuterie Cones & Cups Mobile Cart 

5.0

  • Starts at $250
  • Serves New Palestine, IN

We’re Kelly & Leanne – Besties, Foodies, and Party Enthusiasts! After 30+ years of friendship and a shared obsession with hosting unforgettable events, we turned a fun wedding idea into a crowd-pleasing creation: our Charcuterie Mobile Cart. Think grab-and-go gourmet that’s as cute as it is delicious! From bridal showers to backyard “I do’s,” our cart adds style, flavor, and a little wow-factor to every celebration. Based in Pendleton, Indiana, we proudly serve surrounding counties—one bite-sized masterpiece at a time.

I cannot say enough about how incredible Characutie Cones and Cups made my bridal shower! From the moment they arrived, they took the experience to a whole new level. Their mobile cart is not only adorable but also packed with the most delicious and beautifully presented treats. They offered a variety of options that were perfect for our guests, making it a fun and interactive experience. The food was fresh, flavorful, and catered to every dietary need, which made everyone feel included. Every detail was thoughtfully put together, and the team was so professional and personable, ensuring everything ran smoothly. Characutie Cones and Cups truly made my bridal shower special and memorable. Their service was top-notch, and I received so many compliments from friends and family about the unique and delicious experience they provided. I wholeheartedly recommend them for any event – they exceeded every expectation! Thank you, Characutie Cones and Cups, for making my bridal shower unforgettable!
Madison M., 15 days ago
Quick responder
Indy Anna's Catering, Inc. 
  • Serves New Palestine, IN

Indy Anna's Catering is a family owned business that was founded by Anne Kirk in 1974 making us one of the oldest caterers in the Indianapolis area. Anne started out by using recipes that have been handed down through the generations. Today, Anne's daughter, Judi Kirk Sims, continues our tradition of excellence by using these time-tested recipes and is always finding new and innovative ways to expand upon them in order to provide the highest quality food and service in the business. We pay particular attention to every last detail, whether it is for a once in a lifetime wedding reception or for that all-important business luncheon.

TrendlineTrending
Jonathan Byrd’s Catering 
  • Starts at $500
  • Serves New Palestine, IN

The Byrd Family has been feeding central Indiana residents for nearly 70 years. It all started in 1952 with a family run custard shop called the Custard Kitchen. After additional family ventures, and years dreaming of his own place, Jonathan finally opened his own flagship location in Greenwood, Indiana. Since its inception in 1988, Jonathan Byrd’s has served millions of meals, while also delivering its experience to dozens of partner locations throughout the Indianapolis Metropolitan area through its extensive catering operation.

First Class Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $30
  • Serves New Palestine, IN

First Class Catering was founded on a simple principle - that the crux of every event - big or small, formal or casual- is great food. As the son of lifetime restaurateurs, Caleb Blackerby came home from college with a business degree and a great love of food. Using the kitchen at Blackerby’s Hangar 5 for over seven years, hundreds of weddings, thousands of corporate events - The First Class Catering team has refined a seamless service style that will make every event a success.

We booked First Class Catering for our food and bartender for our wedding. The food was delicious and the drinks were great! I would definitely recommend them for any wedding. The price was really not bad for why we got and having both food and bartending services.
Danni H., 2 years ago
Bauer Flavor Factory Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $100
  • Serves New Palestine, IN

Bauer Flavor Factory Catering is a family-owned business fueled by a love for food and creativity. We’re passionate about making every event special by crafting delicious, custom menus just for you. Whether it’s a wedding, party, or celebration, we’ll work with you to create a personalized and unforgettable food experience that fits your style, taste, and vision.

From our first conversation with the team at Bauer Flavor Factory Catering, we were impressed by their fast, dependable, and easy-going communication style. They were incredibly reliable throughout the entire planning process, working with us to create a flexible menu full of amazing, high-quality food options. The Bauer team went above and beyond, even helping with the setup on the day of our wedding. Their attention to detail and willingness to customize the menu to our specific preferences made them an invaluable partner in making our special day perfect. We would highly recommend Bauer Flavor Factory Catering to any couple looking for a stress-free, delicious catering experience.
Jay, a month ago
TrendlineTrending
Tuck-ins 

5.0

  • Starts at $250
  • Serves New Palestine, IN for additional fees

Tuck-ins are a roastable, Inside-Out S’more on a stick, each containing a crunchy handmade graham cracker, covered in decadent chocolate, all inside a fluffy marshmallow! Tuck-ins® are available in Classic, Cookies & Cream, and Peanut Butter! Tuck-ins can be given out as favors with guests roasting them at home over a gas or electric stove. You can even have your own roasting station at your event with TerraFlame Fire Bowls available through Tuck-ins!

Awarded Best of Zola
Such a fun, innovative, and different experience to enhance your big day. Delicious flavors and the ability to customize/personalize is great for couples. Excellent customer service and responsiveness too!
Julia Spieler, 4 years ago

Location flexible? Discover caterers near New Palestine, IN

About wedding caterers in New Palestine, IN

What types of caterers are in New Palestine, IN?

What other New Palestine vendors will I need?

What other caterers are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?