The Best Sugar-Free Wedding Cake Bakeries in New Braunfels, TX

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


8 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in New Braunfels, TX

Sugar-free
Quick responder
Fire & Ice 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Serves New Braunfels, TX

Ryan & Jenn embarked on their journey in 2022 with Fire & Ice. With a combined experience of 22 years in serving their community, they have deep roots in Texas culture and a profound appreciation for its beauty. Fire & Ice is their endeavor to offer fellow Texans a delectable way to beat the heat with their irresistible sweet treats.

All of my guests were very happy we had a gelato cart at our wedding! It was perfect for our guests to cool off during this Texas heat! Jenn and Ryan are so lovely to work with and that gelato is so creamy and amazing! Thank you so much for being a part of our special day! Unforgettable!
Amy, a year ago
Quick responder
L’Atelier du Brigadeiro 
Rating: 5.0 (12 reviews)
  • Starts at $245
  • Serves New Braunfels, TX
  • Offer

L’Atelier du Brigadeiro creates handcrafted gourmet chocolates called Brigadeiros [Bree-gah-day-ro], Brazil’s most beloved chocolate confection. We specialize in luxury wedding favors, dessert tables, and artisan chocolate experiences. Each piece is handcrafted in small batches using premium ingredients and elegant presentation. Inspired by Brazilian tradition and elevated for modern celebrations, our mission is to create unforgettable moments and sweet memories for every couple and their guests.

I tasted the entire collection from L'Atelier du Brigadeiro and there’s literally not one flavor that disappoints. They’re divine — silky, perfectly balanced, and you can taste the difference. Rich chocolate, real fruit, nothing artificial or waxy. Just pure, luxurious bites. And the presentation? Couture-level. Each brigadeiro arrives like a little jewel in its own pleated cup. Even in Houston heat, our box showed up pristine — cold-packed, elegant, zero melted edges. We did a private tasting for the wedding and immediately placed our full order for the reception. Best decision we made. Three weeks post-wedding and I’m still getting texts: “WHO made those?!” If you want a dessert guests remember, photograph, and talk about long after the last dance — this is it. Worth every single penny. Book them before your date’s gone!
Anna R., 2 months ago
Asukar 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Starts at $750
  • Serves New Braunfels, TX

At Asukar, we believe every couple has a unique story, and we’re here to bring it to life through custom cakes and pastry bars. Thoughtfully designed and award-winning, our desserts are made to create unforgettable memories for your special day.

I cannot begin to put into words my thanks to Adesuwa for the incredible magical cake she made for our wedding! It was everything I dreamed of and more. I don't know how she did it - but she really incorporated everything I asked and hoped for. Not only that, but her expert guidance helped me along the way to make choices about a cake that would be truly meaningful to me in the long run, and not just look like every other cake out there that people are doing now. I'm so grateful for that. The way that she brought in color and the tropical fruit in the middle of WINTER to speak to our Brazilian and Mexican heritages is what brought it over the top for me. Adesuwa truly went above and beyond. Of course, all of that would have been beautiful on its own, but the taste and quality of the cake was to die for!!! Adesuwa is absolutely a master of her craft. Our guests were blown away! So many things go wrong during a wedding (and went wrong for us) and there were many disappointments for me. There were also many places I wish I would have been able to make more special / meaningful to our cultures, backgrounds and personal lives but weren't able to because of cost. Additionally, my entire Brazilian family weren't able to be there because of the high cost and challenge of flying here from the south of Brazil. So, to have this cake, we were able to bring more meaning and personal detail to our day, and it really means the world to me for so many reasons. Especially because the cake was paid for by my grandmother in Brazil, from whom I'm sure I got my obsession with cakes, and had a say in the design! To say thank you is not enough. I will tell everyone about Adesuwa's incredible work!
Gabriela L., a year ago
JAM’s Custom Cookies 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Starts at $1,500
  • Serves New Braunfels, TX

At JAM’s Custom Cookies, every cookie is designed to be as memorable as the celebration itself. I create handcrafted sugar cookies customized to match your wedding theme, colors, and aesthetic — perfect for elegant favors, dessert tables, bridal showers, and welcome events. Each order is made to order with attention to detail and artistry, turning simple cookies into edible keepsakes your guests will love.

JAM's Custom Cookies provided an outstanding and delicious contribution to our wedding day. Their communication was professional and fast, ensuring we received the cookies on time. The pre-wedding cookies they provided, which were placed in a gift bag for our guests, received rave reviews from everyone. The quality of their work was amazing, and I would definitely recommend JAM's Custom Cookies to anyone planning a wedding in the near future.
John A., 5 months ago