The Best American Wedding Caterers in New Albany, OH

The Best American Wedding Caterers in New Albany, OH

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


13 Wedding Caterers in New Albany, OH

American
Quick responder
Sweet Carrot 
Rating: 5.0 (6 reviews)
  • Starts at $20
  • Serves New Albany, OH

SAY I DO TO A WEDDING THATS UNIQUELY YOU! Ditch the boring buffet and dish up something different for your big day. Tell your love story your way while giving your guests an experience they won’t forget.

Awarded Best of Zola
“Working with Sweet Carrot for our wedding catering was an absolute pleasure. From our very first interaction, the team demonstrated a fantastic level of professionalism and kindness. They were incredible to work with, providing delicious food with thoughtful details for each course, and their staff went above and beyond - even bringing us food during our wedding photos and checking on us throughout the day to ensure we were taken care of. The quality of their work and value was exceptional, and our guests raved about how excellent the food was. We are so grateful to the Sweet Carrot team for helping make our special day even more perfect.”
Taylor A., 2 years ago
Quick responder
Together & Company 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Starts at $40
  • Serves New Albany, OH

Enjoy the moment with your whole heart and we'll plan it with ours. We take the time to get to know you and your unique vision and help you create a wedding menu that you and your guests will love. You deserve to have a team of passionate planners, designers and culinary experts pouring their hearts into your day. We value our partnerships with over 40 event venues all around Columbus, including our two exclusive downtown venues, High Line Car House and The Fives.

“We chose T&Co to cater our wedding in New Albany OH and could not have been happier with the service they delivered! We worked with Taylor on the planning. She was phenomenal - very responsive and pleasant to work with. She was willing to push back gently on our requests when her experience dictated it but she was never condescending or inflexible. We worked closely with her to build an almost completely custom menu with 3 different food stations. The menu ended up being a beautiful blend of different cuisines, with some items being requested by us and others coming off of the T&Co menu. Everything was utterly delicious and Chef Faye is incredible. I'm sure everything on their base menu is awesome and you probably can't go wrong with that, but their willingness to work on custom items is a huge plus. Although the pricing might be a bit steep, you'll be getting every penny of value that you pay for. I can't thank them enough and I can't recommend them enough either!”
Teresa & V., 3 years ago
Quick responder
Lex's Kitchen Catering 
Rating: 4.8 (4 reviews)
  • Starts at $16
  • Serves New Albany, OH

Creating Unforgettable Moments One Event At A Time With over 10 years of experience, we have been creating unique experiences. Our passion for not only great tasting food but for beautiful unique designs has pushed us to the top with God on the forefront of our business. We cater to people of all walks of life. One event is not like the other-we customize each menu for each client. We are the one stop shop for any & all events. I am also an event coordinator and Wedding Planner. We put love in everything we do. Comfort food for the soul with an upscale twist.

“Me and my wife were looking for an all inclusive caterer, its not a lot in Columbus. me and my wife were equally involved with planning our wedding and Lex was instrumental in meeting all of our needs. We had servers and buffet style reception with a self serve cocktail hour we had so many compliments on our wedding day. My Wife and I are from the south and wanted soul food at our wedding. Let me tell you everything was beyond delicious and Lex has a mac and cheese that is to die for and that glazed ham and fried chicken were at the top of our list. She made our wedding cake and gave us exactly what we wanted and it was moist and beautiful.”
Ken W., 9 months ago
Quick responder
To Go For Your Soul 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Starts at $3,750
  • Serves New Albany, OH

I am 27 years Old. I started “To Go For Your Soul” in 2020. I am passionate about cooking and have been cooking for 12 years now. I see food as art you can eat and it is a daily activity that is a necessity for us to live so why not make it as enjoyable as possible. Food for many of us is Community, Gathering, Celebration, & Relief. It is a very important part of any occasion especially in the world of weddings. In reality amongst all other tasks, it can be very stressful to plan an event and focus of feeding you and your guests.

Quick responder
Roosters Weddings 
Rating: 5.0 (40 reviews)
  • Starts at $700
  • Serves New Albany, OH
  • Offer

Roosters Weddings delivers the fun, casual Roosters experience straight to your wedding! With 15 locations throughout Central Ohio, we’re known for our award-winning wings and friendly, energetic service. We offer a variety of affordable catering options for your rehearsal dinner, cocktail hour, reception, or late-night snack. Whether you want a simple drop-off, a staffed buffet, or our food truck serving hot, fresh food on-site—we’ll make it happen.

Awarded Best of Zola
“Roosters Catering was the perfect choice for our wedding day. The team was incredible - super friendly, professional, and efficient. The food was absolutely delicious, and we received so many compliments from our guests. The set up and tear down was quick and seamless, allowing us to fully enjoy the evening. I have already recommended Roosters to several of my engaged friends. Thank you Roosters for making our special day perfect!”
Kaitlyn M., a year ago
Quick responder
SaveurFRESH Catering 
Rating: 5.0 (17 reviews)
  • Serves New Albany, OH

A CULINARY JOURNEY TAILORED WITH UNIQUE VISION and CULINARY CREATION . With chic innovative vision emerging from diverse cultures specializing in superior meats fresh seafood and organic ingredients while influenced through distinctive heritages and cultural trends, Our Custom Catering brings you profound ethnic cuisine with superior taste impeccable service & atmosphere. Indulge your guests with a culinary journey that is as diverse as your imagination. Every event is full and complete offering beverage service alongside our meal offerings and our mission is to provide exceptional catering services that exceed our clients expectations

Awarded Best of Zola
“Saveur Fresh Catering was an absolute lifesaver for our wedding day. After our originally hired caterer cancelled on us last minute, Chef Chris and his team at Saveur Fresh stepped in and saved the day. Their communication was quick, streamlined, and courteous throughout the entire process. The quality of their work was outstanding, excellent, and truly top-notch. I will forever be so very grateful to Saveur Fresh and Chef Chris - they kept my wife's dream wedding alive when it seemed like it was going to be a disaster. Thanks to their incredible service and delicious food, our wedding day was perfect. I highly recommend Saveur Fresh Catering to any couple looking for an exceptional catering experience.”
Sebastian C., 2 years ago
Quick responder
Best Eats Catering Company 
Rating: 4.4 (7 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Starts at $18
  • Serves New Albany, OH
  • Offer

Personalized catering for weddings, open houses, birthdays, and corporate events, made with fresh local ingredients and a whole lot of heart. We are here to turn your vision into a reality. If you are ready please reach out to us

“From our first conversation, Best Eats Catering Company made us feel heard and supported every step of the way. The team was responsive to our questions and worked closely with our other vendors to keep everything running smoothly on the day of our wedding. What really impressed us was how the chef stayed in touch with everyone involved to ensure perfect timing. The food arrived hot and ready, and honestly, it tasted incredible. Our guests couldn't stop talking about the meals, and we felt like the whole experience was handled with real professionalism. We'd absolutely recommend Best Eats to any couple looking for caterers they can trust.”
Denise L., 18 days ago
Quick responder
Glad Mouf 
Rating: 5.0 (6 reviews)
  • Starts at $3,000
  • Serves New Albany, OH

Glad Mouf BBQ – Unforgettable Flavor for Your Special Day At Glad Mouf BBQ, we believe every wedding deserves unforgettable food that brings people together. We specialize in craft barbecue with a gourmet twist, featuring the world’s most tender smoked oxtails, melt-in-your-mouth brisket, juicy smoked chicken, brisket tacos —all paired with our legendary sauces. We offer catering with a choice of station-style service with pre-portioned servings or a buffet. Enjoy a special rate of $50 per person for 100+ guests or $75 per person with a 50-guest minimum. Our customizable menu allows you to create the perfect meal for your wedding vision.

“We had an incredible experience working with Glad Mouf for our wedding catering. From start to finish, their team was responsive and made the planning process feel effortless. The food they served was absolutely delicious—our guests couldn't stop talking about it—and the staff was genuinely kind and attentive throughout the entire event. What really stood out was how easy they were to work with; they listened to what we wanted and made it happen without any stress. The quality of their work combined with their warm personalities made them feel less like vendors and more like friends helping us celebrate. We'd recommend Glad Mouf to anyone looking for caterers who care about both the food and the experience.”
Brittany A., a month ago
Quick responder
SocietySip 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Starts at $2
  • Serves New Albany, OH

As a family-focused, full-service catering and bartending company with over 10 years of experience, we’re passionate about helping you create an event that feels effortless and unforgettable. From intimate gatherings to large celebrations, we offer full-service catering, convenient drop-off catering, and professional bartending services, including a mocktail-only. Our team is committed to making every guest feel welcome with outstanding food, drinks, and genuine hospitality. We can’t wait to be part of your special day!

“We did the lemonade - dirty soda - mocktail package for my son’s graduation everything was great ! She made custom drink signs and straws for him , very efficient and good communication. Reasonable pricing”
Kimberly S., 3 months ago
Quick responder
Bon appetit LLC 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Starts at $1,500
  • Serves New Albany, OH
  • Offer

Congragulations! You’ve found who you’re looking for right here! Lol. Hello, im Hannah. A chef with 16 years of cooking under my belt I enjoy cooking just about every menu to fit your needs. The most popular menu is a taco/nacho buffet. I also do a lot of pasta/salad bars and comfort food buffets. Please reach out with any questions.

“From the moment we reached out to Later Tater LLC, their communication was excellent. They were extremely friendly and professional, and worked closely with us to ensure our wedding day catering was perfect. The food they provided was all locally sourced and incredibly fresh, and their grazing tables were beautifully presented. The entire team was highly proficient, and they seamlessly executed the catering and desserts for our special day. We couldn't have been happier with their services, and would highly recommend Later Tater LLC to any couple planning their wedding.”
Angel, a year ago
L.A. Catering 
  • Starts at $1
  • Serves New Albany, OH

L.A. Catering is a proud division of Lifecare Alliance that has served the local community with outstanding nutrition and health programs since 1898. All profits from L.A. Catering are invested back into your community through Lifecare Alliance programs and services to support older adults, medically challenged and disabled individuals in Central Ohio. This means that birthday parties, boxed lunches, cookouts, graduations, holiday parties, reunions and weddings catered by L.A. Catering help your community!

Chemical X Inc 
  • Starts at $750
  • Serves New Albany, OH

At Chemical X, we serve up cocktails with intention, delicious dinners that hits the spot, thorough planning & anything else you might need for your big day! Chemical X also offers non-denominational wedding ceremony officiant services. Our owner/operator, Elizabeth, 30, has been in the service industry for over a decade, finding her true calling as a Bartender when she migrated to Cleveland in 2015. She has competed in various cocktail competitions, became a Tales of The Cocktail alumni, acquired her TIPs, ServSafe & Bar Smarts certificates & opened Chemical X, a one stop shop for all your event needs!

Tuck-ins 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Starts at $250
  • Serves New Albany, OH for additional fees

Tuck-ins are a roastable, Inside-Out S’more on a stick, each containing a crunchy handmade graham cracker, covered in decadent chocolate, all inside a fluffy marshmallow! Tuck-ins® are available in Classic, Cookies & Cream, and Peanut Butter! Tuck-ins can be given out as favors with guests roasting them at home over a gas or electric stove. You can even have your own roasting station at your event with TerraFlame Fire Bowls available through Tuck-ins!

Awarded Best of Zola
“We arranged to have the Tuck-ins team come to our wedding to set up a table with small fire stations and Tuck-ins so that our guests could roast their own s'mores as a fun, interactive dessert. All of my guests loved them and they were also able to take some home if they wanted to save one for later. Additionally, working with the Tuck-ins team was great; they're very responsive and were even able to customize the labels on the Tuck-ins to have our names and wedding date on them. It was truly a unique part of our wedding and I think everyone enjoyed it. Highly recommend!”
Kyra, 5 years ago

About wedding caterers in New Albany, OH

What other New Albany vendors will I need?

What other wedding services are nearby?