My Sugar Wishes


Price per serving

Starts at $5 per person.


About My Sugar Wishes

My Sugar Wishes

Cake Artist/Owner

My Sugar Wishes is an award winning cake studio that creates unique designs to reflect the personal style of the bride and groom. Bring us details about your wedding and we'll create the perfect cake for your celebration. The magic begins with the complimentary cake tasting and design consultation where we listen to your vision and answer all your questions. This includes sampling freshly made cakes and savory buttercreams that will excite your tastebuds. On the big day we will carefully deliver your cake to be picture perfect!!

"Connie was absolutely fabulous to work with. Our cake turned out beautiful and better than I imagined. My husband and I went to the tasting knowing we wanted one flavor, but then with all the flavors tasting so good, we had a different flavor for each tier, which made it a lot of fun. Our guests kept telling us how delicious the cake was. Connie is the absolute sweetest and easiest person to work with and is extremely talented I highly recommend My Sugar Wishes!" Sarah C., October 18, 2021

Best of Zola 2025
Best of Zola 2024

Services

Dessert types

  • Cakes
  • Cupcakes
  • Mini desserts

Decor options

  • Cake toppers
  • Custom text
  • Fruit topping
  • Live flowers
  • Sugar flowers

Available customizations

  • Cake filling
  • Cake flavors
  • Cake frosting

Services offered

  • Consultations
  • Delivery
  • Setup
  • Tastings

Dietary accommodations

  • Dairy-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Nut-free
  • Vegan
  • Vegetarian

Reviews

Write a review

4.9 out of 5

28 reviews

Write a review
  • Best tasting Cake!!!

    Verified review
    Heather M.Oct 20

    My Sugar Wishes was an absolute dream to work with for our wedding cake and desserts. From our first consultation, the owner was a quick responder, easy to work with, and had a very laid-back communication style that put us at ease. We had been looking forward to their cake for over a year, and it did not disappoint - it was absolutely delicious! The quality of their work and value was exceptional. From the initial consultation to the wedding day, we appreciated everything they did to ensure our desserts were perfect. We would highly recommend My Sugar Wishes to any couple planning their wedding.

  • Eye appealing but not as expected

    Verified review
    Kish J.Oct 12

    We are deeply disappointed with how our wedding cakes turned out. We ordered two cakes—one for the bride and one for the groom. During our final tasting, we specifically requested that the bride's cake be made less sweet. Unfortunately, on our wedding day, we received the exact opposite: the bride's cake was overwhelmingly sweet, even sweeter than before. Multiple guests commented on how overly sugary it was, and most of the cake ended up being thrown away uneaten. This was not only a waste of a significant amount of money, but also a letdown on what should have been a perfect day. When we brought this to the vendor's attention, their response left us feeling unheard and undervalued as customers. It's frustrating that our clear instructions were not only ignored but seemingly reversed. While the groom's German chocolate cake was excellent and guests devoured every slice, this only added to our disappointment. We had paid considerably more for the bride's cake, expecting it to be the centerpiece dessert, yet it was the less expensive groom's cake that everyone enjoyed. The contrast between what we paid for and what we received feels incredibly unfair. We expected better attention to detail and customer service, especially for such an important occasion.

    Response from vendorOct 19, 2025
    Dear Kish, Thank you for your review. I’m glad to hear you enjoyed the chocolate groom’s cake! I wish the lightly sweetened watermelon flavored wedding cake was more enjoyable. This unique flavor was a fun cake to make, and I can understand your disappointment if it didn’t match your expectations. I always aim to deliver a great experience, and am heartbroken when I don’t meet a client’s desires. As you can see in other reviews, My Sugar Wishes is known for taking ownership and caring deeply about our customers. I can’t fix the past but please accept my sincerest apologies. I will definitely use this feedback moving forward.
  • Wedding cake

    Verified review
    Colleen E.Jun 27, 2025

    My husband and I were thrilled with the service and quality of the cake from My Sugar Wishes. From the beginning, their communication was great - they were responsive, professional, and listened closely to our preferences. On the day of the wedding, the cake was absolutely beautiful and delicious. The presentation was elegant and the flavors were fantastic. Our guests raved about how tasty everything was. We were so pleased with the value and would highly recommend My Sugar Wishes to any couple planning their wedding.

  • Amazing and delicious

    Verified review
    Brian N.Jun 21, 2025

    My Sugar Wishes provided the most delicious and beautifully decorated wedding cake for our special day. Connie was extremely professional and delivered everything on time. The cake was not only visually stunning, but tasted absolutely incredible and were very reasonably priced. We couldn't have been happier with the service and quality from My Sugar Wishes. Thank you so much Connie for helping to make our wedding day perfect!