The Couple
Natalie and Anthony were lucky enough to be introduced by a mutual friend in 2015 (thanks, Nichole!). They met one fateful night in Santa Cruz, when Nichole accidentally made plans with both of them, and suggested that they all hang out together. By this time, Natalie and Anthony had already heard countless stories about the other person. Needless to say, when they finally met, it felt like they had known each other for years. Although there is still some controversy over "who texted first" to set up their first date (Natalie totally texted first), they started seeing each other shortly after that night.
Nearly 4 years later, their engagement was just as special. Anthony proposed on February 23, 2019 on a beach in Santa Cruz, just miles away from where they first met. Nichole and her husband, Joe, were there to help with the engagement surprise.